This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

This Essay Compares Today's Society, Specifically Since The Birth Of The Patriot Act, To That Of Orwell's 1984.

1001 words - 4 pages

The new programs implemented by President Bush in order to protect Americans and discourage terrorist behavior have made evident the similarities between modern American society and Orwellian socialism as described in 1984. The Patriot Act has been the most significant of these post-9/11 measures. Americans' fear of economic decline and terrorist activity has allowed the government nearly free reign to disrupt the delicate system of checks and balances, expand their powers of surveillance and to declare war.
With the swift enactment of the Patriot Act, the government took the first significant step towards an Orwellian society. On October 6th, 2001 assistant Attorney General Viet Dinh proposed an act that would make sweeping changes to over 15 different statutes (EFF1); allow for an extreme expansion of surveillance of the American public (ACLU 3), increase the authority of the executive branch (Herman 4), and a grant of never before seen war powers. Originally, many congressmen were weary of such a bill, but after Attorney General Ashcroft warned that "terrorist attacks are imminent" and that Congress would be blamed if the bill was not passed immediately the bill was passed within a week (Center for National Security Studies 2). By the 12th of October both houses of Congress had passed nearly identical, unchanged versions of the bill. Bush maintains, however, that the programs were based on "the latest intelligence and how best to protect our country (Gerstenzang A3)."While Savage claims that The Act's
objective is to "lower the wall between intelligence gathering and criminal investigations (Savage A16)," the EFF disagrees, saying that there is "no evidence that our previous civil liberties posed barrier to effective tracking or prosecution of terrorists (EFF 2)" The
Patriot Act, like 1984's MiniTrue, has a name designed to gloss over the project's true meaning. In 1984, MiniTrue's objective is, ironically, to conceal the truth, replacing news stories with ones more positive to the party (Orwell 128). They take no concern to cover-up their lies, simply creating or erasing people like Comrade Ogilvy and expect the people to accept their lies (Orwell 42). Similarly, the "Patriot" Act actually denies Americans of many rights true "patriots" would have fought for. The Act has found a way to deny us of four amendments from possibly the most "patriotic" document we have; The Constitution (Herman 1) (US Constitution).
Surveillance measures have been the hardest pill to swallow of the Patriot Act's many upsetting directives. Through spy projects like TIPS, complex networks of government informants have been established with easy access to private homes. These "informants" will include postal workers, utility technicians and even your "cable guy" (ACLU 2). Similar to the "thought police" and the zealous citizens of Oceania in 1984, everyone around the common citizen seems to be watching, waiting for a neighbor to expose himself as a criminal by the...

Find Another Essay On This essay compares today's society, specifically since the birth of the Patriot Act, to that of Orwell's 1984.

Events that Led up to the Creation of the Patriot Act

2784 words - 12 pages The Patriot Act was created in the year of 2001, the same year that the tragic day, 9.11, occurred. On September 11th, 2001, 19 terrorists working for Al-Qaeda hijacked four planes, and caused this day to be forever remembered in the history of the United States. At 8:46 AM on September 11th, the first hijacked plane (American Airlines Flight 11) crashed into the North Tower of the World Trade Center. Specifically, it crashed into the 93-99th

"The Case Against the US Patriot Act"- This essay explores the effects of the US Patriot Act on our Constitutional Rights

1293 words - 5 pages The Case Against the USA Patriot Act"There is nothing to fear, but fear itself." This famous quote, spoken by Franklin Roosevelt, serves as a reminder to people everywhere that fear should not guide our actions, nor should they influence our lives. On September 11th, 2001, the American public saw the face of fear and stood bravely in its shadow, its shadow which covered New York City and Washington DC. Shortly thereafter, President George W

This is a review and examination of Orwell's Homage to Catalonia. It concerns the Spanish Civil war, specifically from the side of the POUM

1044 words - 4 pages , this book is quite funny in places as Orwell makes light of the glaring inadequacies of the Spanish at the most perilous times. Orwell compared his time at the front to that of a mock opera, yet he found his time at the front line to be one of the most meaningful experiences of his life. Orwell's beautiful prose and the thoroughness of this account made Homage to Catalonia a joy to read.Perhaps the most important aspect that Orwell relates

Common Threads in George Orwell's 1984 and Today's Society

1562 words - 6 pages Common Threads in George Orwell's 1984 and Today's Society "Big Brother is Watching You"(Orwell 5). This simple phrase has become the cornerstone of the conspiracy theorists dialog. George Orwell may have writing a cautionary novel with 1984, but there is little possibility that he could have foreseen how close to reality his novel would truly become. In the past 50 years, the world has become a much more dangerous place. Along with

The Traits of Society in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984)

595 words - 2 pages ; Fortunately, a fine line exists between the free, democratic society under which we live, and the closed-minded, totalitarian regime that fictionally existed here. Today's people are much more intelligent, free-minded, and aware of their surroundings to fall victim to such a terrible, controlling trap. We like to maintain that assumption, anyway; we must believe it to continue with our daily activities and lives. Fortunately for us, that's the way it is, and Orwell's novel was just fiction, which we can put down at any time, look around and feel assured that we are free and safe. Unless, we really are being watched?  

A Watership Down by Richard Adams. This essay compares the functions of the rabbits to those functions of our society, making it more than a children's story

674 words - 3 pages rabbits do not really care or realize when a rabbit is missing. This highlights the horrifying point that in modern society, we are caught up in all of the motion around us. In our busy lives, we sometimes ignore the quality of life and forget to show our care for those important to us. The Cowslip rabbits are so caught up in luxury that they are missing the joy and search for freedom in their lives. The rabbits in the Nuthanger Farm are in

This essay compares the Egyptian architecture, with that of the Olmecs, an early civilization in Central America

1828 words - 7 pages Lorenzo and Veracruz were constructed using basalt columns. Basalt, as we know since we use it ourselves, is an igneous rock, which is definitely not capable of withstanding the test of time. Their earliest tool was using fire to mould wood, but they abandoned this because it was unpredictable and unreliable.Our building projects are community events, even a source of revenue in our economy. Some people are very attached to the idea that only slaves

This is about Birth... Description of the modern birth process as on that is ritualistic and shaped by a technological society

1466 words - 6 pages In the ethnography, Birth as an American Rite of Passage, Robbie E. Davis-Floyd describes the modern birth process as one that is ritualistic and shaped by a technological society. Davis-Floyd argues that childbirth is a natural process that does not need to be controlled and manipulated by technology. In this work, Davis-Floyd interviewed one hundred middle class white women, who had access to, what she terms the technocratic model. The

This essay discusses the origin of the Young Offenders Act and compares it with the Juvenille Delinquents act, which was the first version of the modern Young Offenders act. (Canada)

2218 words - 9 pages attempt to deal with the youths that belong in this category, Canada put into place the Young Offenders Act; a statute that holds youths aged twelve to seventeen responsible for their actions. This Act is intended, like the adult criminal justice system, to punish the guilty, protect society, and deter future criminal behaviour from occurring.The Young Offenders Act did not actually come into effect until 1984, two years after it was originally passed

This essay is about the effects of art on modern society and compares the rise of capitalism with the rise of individuality and creativity expressed in art

510 words - 2 pages Olympics and Odyssey of the Minds programs. Despite the push by the school committee for the reimbursement money to be spent on the Project fair the city insisted that the money would only be spent on "high growth communities."Although maybe not fully intended, this phrase "high growth communities" has many underlying meanings and can be taken in different contexts. Often when cities are putting special efforts into "cleaning up" a neighborhood or

1984 vs today's society - EHS AP language - Essay

529 words - 3 pages see are often targeted specifically towards us based on what we have said in a text or email or searched on the internet even once. There are also several ways that the government spies on us in our everyday live/s. Much like the telescreens in 1984, our phones act as a way for the National Security Agency (NSA) to monitor us on a daily basis. Also, anywhere you go in public you will see a security camera of some kind. This allows constant

Similar Essays

This Essay Describes The Patriot Act I In Terms Of Control And Compares Today's Reality To That Of Geroge Orwell's 1984

1084 words - 5 pages government has asked its citizens to accept the "loose at best (Herman 2)" ties between the two.With the establishment of the Patriot Act came the furthering of America's desensitization to government intrusion. This numbing of American society, although not yet to the extent of 1984, has increased exponentially in the last year. If notice is not taken, our society could become much like Orwell's in the near future.

Comparing Society Today With That Of The World In George Orwell's "1984"

1273 words - 5 pages John David Frodsham (1985) points out that to study George Orwell's 1984 is to note: "1984 will always remain as a menacing possibility" (p. 139). George Orwell, in his futuristic novel, 1984, incites the imagination of the reader to compare society today with that of the world in the novel. The totalitarian society depicted by Orwell did not achieve its power and authority only through violence, real or threatened, but through the isolation of

A Feared Patriot This Is An Essay About The Usa Patriot Act And Some Of Its Potential Problems

326 words - 2 pages In this world that we live in, violence is often the answer to any question. The USA PATRIOT Act is an effort by the United States to "level the playing field" with terrorists. However, in their zeal to enable themselves to fight terrorism, the leaders of this country have opened wide the door that leads to government power abuse.The USA PATRIOT Act allows the government to monitor people believed to be terrorists very closely. However, this

T His Essay Is About George Orwell's 1984. It Answers The Question: Can What Happened In 1984 Happen Today? It Anaysalies The World Of 1984 And Our World Today

1182 words - 5 pages that are different thanthemselves. They mold the kid's malleable young minds into thinking that they aresuperior to everyone else. Also groups like Hitler youth were incredibly similar to theSpies because they took away the parent's rights and they trained the kids to love theirrespective dictators.The threats that Orwell warns of in 1984 are very real and it is possible that theycould happen. With laws like the Patriot Act being passed and dictators like Fidel Castroand Kim Jong II in power we are well on our way to the society described in 1984. Thisbook has been written off by some as just science fiction but it could one day becomereality.