This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

This Essay Is About Plato And His Book "The Republic".

1178 words - 5 pages

Is Plato a communist or a socialist? Does the Republic reflect his belief that the state should be more important or take on a higher position in priority lists than the individual's needs and wants? The Republic by Plato is centered around one point: justice. In order to define justice, Plato has to first define what a just or ideal state is, and it is through the process of defining of the ideal state and what is just that one is able to see a clear definition of Plato's beliefs on the individual and on the state. So was Plato's view of an ideal state actually a socialist state?I believe it was very much like a socialist state. The question at the center of the Republic is whether it is better to live justly or unjustly. To answer this question, Plato first describes his ideal city. His ideal city includes guardians, auxiliaries, and tradesman. In Plato's view every person has a certain talent that they are good at and they should pursue this talent from the end of their education through their death. The city's leaders are chosen based on the educational system and how well each child does in the program. The city is just and ideal because everyone winds up doing the jobs that best suit their innate abilities--the guardians lead, the auxiliaries fight, and the rest of the people work.Plato, or Socrates who is actually defining the ideal state through a debate, begins the argument by pointing out two things: first that there should be three divisions within the state: the guardians, the farmers or craftsmen, and the auxiliaries and second that there are several basic human needs like food, shelter and clothing. In the ideal state these will be provided for and taken care of if everyone is doing their proper jobs.Plato bases his divisions on the needs of the state and on the principle of specialization. We all have those common needs, however we are each different from one another in many respects. Each person has at least one talent or specialty. Therefore, our state should encourage our individual talents, which will provide different needs for our state. Plato believes the most efficient state is one that puts each person in the job to which they are best suited. For example, once a child reaches a certain level of education, according to Plato, they should know if they are suited to be a guardian or leader or should they be a fighter or a farmer. If there are particular tasks that need to be done in the state, then there is a particular person who can do this job. Just like a communist or socialist state, people are being assigned to certain tasks in order to benefit the state, not themselves because even if they may have a talent they still may not want to do that job. Each person sacrifices their own desires so the state can run more efficiently.In Plato's ideal state there is a limited amount of reading that may be done. Because the guardians or leaders are educated in the same system as others, certain topics are prohibited. For example,...

Find Another Essay On This essay is about Plato and his book "The Republic".

This essay is on JFK and about his life

1043 words - 4 pages thousands of Americans from being harmed. There was no telling what the Russians might have done with the missiles and he acted appropriately.Kennedy was very concerned about the spread of communism at this time. He wanted to make sure that vulnerable countries would not be taken over by the Communists because they were a threat to world peace. His concern and aid helped to stop the spread of communism. He helped others to realize that communism

Plato, Book IV of The Republic

1487 words - 6 pages In Book IV of The Republic, Socrates has gone on a bit of a digression. He has done this for the sake of proving his argument as to what constitutes the ideal city. In order to do this, Socrates feels that he and Glaucon must evaluate the individual citizen, specifically the mind and soul of the individual citizen. A city in itself is nothing more than a city, it is the individuals within it who make it just or unjust. If it can be proven that

This essay is about the psychohistory which is used to analyse Hitler and his beliefs

677 words - 3 pages debt but after persuading a crippled aunt to donate a large proportion of her life savings to him, he was able to repay the debt and live quite comfortably in a men's home whilst reading more about some extremist political views. It was later in life that Hitler considered these years as the greatest of his life and he wrote that all he had to do was "add a few details" to the "great ideas" he had learnt of in this time.Although through looking at

Utopia by Sir Thomas More this is sort of a comparison essay on More and Machiavelli but it is moer about More and his book, Utopia

1061 words - 4 pages Roman ideals were being resurrected, writers were composing works of literature about valued earthly life, nature, and individual achievement. More writes a novel based on those principles entitled, Utopia. He wants to see a society where the inhabitants live according to God and nature. He wants to get rid of the idea of greed which is portrayed by the princes, kings and leaders. Machiavelli thinks on the opposite side of the spectrum as More. He

This essay is about sylvia plath and her book the bell jar.i compare her life to her book

1464 words - 6 pages Everyone's life is filled with unique experiences, either positive or negative. It is often helpful to express those experiences and thoughts through writing. Sylvia Plath, a famous novelist, has adapted this method of expressing her thoughts and feelings. She gives life to her character by reflecting her own personal happy and unfortunate life experiences. In the novel, The Bell Jar, by Sylvia Plath, the main character's, Ester Greenwood's

This essay is all about Leonardo da vinci . His life and his works

1600 words - 6 pages against smaller neighboring states to increase their power.Leonardo da Vinci was born in the year 1452 in the small hill town of Vinci. His father was a successful notary and his mother a peasant woman.The little town of Vinci has changed very little in 544 years since then. Stone houses are clustered together around the protective battlements of a castle. The tall church bell tower is still an important landmark which can be seen for miles. Vinci

American Notes; A Journey (this is a book review essay on the American Notes: A Journey, written by Charles Dickens about his experienes in the U.S

2153 words - 9 pages people in Britain. Most of his other works were fictional, so I believe this was just a personal choice of his to journey to America. I believe the strongest points of this book is that it so colourfully described and detailed by Dickens, that he pulls the reader right into each and every situation as if it were occurring in front of their eyes. Although the descriptions make the book very fun, I personally found it difficult to understand what

This essay is about the catcher in the rye. This is sort of a bookreport about the book

372 words - 2 pages nice guy. He wrote about his cousin's baseball mitt. Holden admired Allie; he says he was intelligent and sensitive. It looks like he still feels sad about Allie's death. It may be why Holden acts like this. When stradlater came back from the date he seemed angry. He did not tell Holden why though except that she signed out at 9:30. Holden asks him questions but stradlater doesn't answer them. Then he looks at the composition that Holden

Basically this essay is about "The Life and Times of Edgar Allen Poe" it will tell you about his early life to his death

969 words - 4 pages lips, and went to Richmond, this time taking Virginia and his aunt Maria.?In the years to come, he wrote and published several poems and stories, like "The Murders in the Rue Morgue", "The Purloined Letter", and most famous, "The Raven". He eventually broke his vow and went back to drinking, which only caused problems. Several times he was found wandering drunk in the streets of New York where he had recently relocated with his wife and mother-in

This book was all about Forrest Gump and his life

889 words - 4 pages This book was all about Forrest Gump and his life. Forrest is such an amusing character because his life was interesting.Just after Forrest was born his father had been squished by a half a ton of bananas and he was killed and he never knew him. His mother raised him and they got along really good. He never really had many friends during all his year in public school, except for one and her name was Jenny Curran. They were best friends forever

This essay is about Hopper, and how his works are linked with psychology, particularly with the theories of Freud

618 words - 2 pages she has never seen such a dark house in such bright light. The house is viewed from a perspective of a passerby and it presents a fleeting image that is parrallel to fleeting memeories of the mind. Iverson relates to this piece not as a pleasant memory, but as an forboding presence akin to the personality of the house in the movie Psycho.Hopper also used voids of space in many of his paintings. Iverson equates this to the idea of Thanatos, which

Similar Essays

This Essay Is About Jacksonain Politics. It Is Based On The Book "The Jacksonian Era" Which Talks About Andrew Jackson And His Presidency

1156 words - 5 pages for years. They consisted of such personal opinion and were so controversial few will ever forget.Jackson was a selfish, tyrannical ruler. He did not make decisions based on the interests of the whole nation but on his own personal benefit, in search of self-achievement. Although he was portrayed, or possibly manipulated the citizens to believe, that he was a president for the common man, this was simply not how he acted. As president, he

Plato And The Nuclear Family In His Work:The Republic

1234 words - 5 pages The nuclear family, consisting of a mother, father, and children, is something very familiar to our society. We hold these relations as ideal and form our lives around their bonds. In the Republic, Plato suggests to abolish families and replace them with the Guardians. This is easily one of Plato’s most controversial ideas; it contains positive elements, but is seen as impractical to undesirable by many. The rationale behind Plato’s idea

The Miller, This Essay Is About The Book, The Canterbury Tales, By Geoffery Chaucer. The Miller Is A Certain Character And This Essay Tells Of His Part In The Book

820 words - 3 pages on the way back. He never finished his enormous project and even the completed tales were not finally revised. Scholars are uncertain about the order of the tales. As the printing press had yet to be invented when Chaucer wrote his works, The Canterbury Tales has been passed down in several handwritten manuscripts. Among all of the tales, the Miller sticks out the most. The Miller not only is a drunk but deceitful in many ways, to tell his story

Charles Dickens.....This Essay Is About His Life And Works

532 words - 2 pages Charles DickensCharles Dickens, a nineteenth century writer, tells a story about ayoung boy in England and the adventures that happen to him. In readingthe book the reader becomes entwined in the plot by Dickens^Òs expertwriting and style. Using different scenes and scenarios, Dickensdisplays his characters' personality in a way the few other writerscould. In the book Oliver Twist, Dickens uses different events thathappen around Oliver