This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

This Is An Analytical Essay On The Murder Of William Robinson, Which Occured In 1868 On The Salt Spring Islands In British Columbia.

1512 words - 6 pages

The Unsolved Murder of William RobinsonThroughout history there have been many unsolved murder cases, from Jack the Ripper to Lizzie Borden. These cases have plagued criminal investigators and historians alike for centuries. One of the greatest unsolved Canadian murder cases is undoubtedly the murder of William Robinson, which took place in March of 1868. In the small village of Saltspring Island, just north of Victoria B.C., three murders occurred within a one-year span and inevitably ended with the conviction and death of an Aboriginal man by the name of Tshuanahusset (hereafter known as 'Tom'). Sentenced to death by jury members of Caucasian background engendered a controversy towards the matter. The circumstantial evidence created broken stories and fallacious hearsay which did not prove beyond reasonable doubt that this man was in fact guilty of said crime. There are many different opinions on the matter, but with logical evidence and conflicting accounts, this essay will prove that the judicial system of the 19th century was culpable for the death of an innocent man. The first historical occurrence that rendered a false notion of Tom's conviction in my opinion is the atrocious racism committed by the esoteric-like group of the jury. Thus the Bittancourt brothers are introduced into the picture: two gluttonous fiends who won't stop until they own everything and everyone around them even if it means killing a Sunday school teacher. And like many murders in history, the murderer is not necessarily the one who commenced the idea of the act. Suggested in this essay is the connection of the Bittancourt brothers to an accomplice; one, Mr. John Norton, the man who happened to be involved with every 'Indian disruption.' Through powerful evidence, this essay will definitively prove history wrong and state, in my opinion, who are the true offenders guilty of murder.The trial of Robinson's murder is the biggest injustice of all. Several undeniable factors led to the false conviction of Tom. Being a Native American, Tom never learned the English language, he had no need for it nor did he want to communicate with the white people. The trial, held under control by Judge Needham, was communicated in an English dialect. The spoken language during the trial put Tom at a sever disadvantage for communicating his side of the story, although a translator was provided by the judicial system, he was of different ethnicity and translation error was likely to affect his story. The sworn statement of the accused provides sufficient evidence that the translator could not provide a truly accurate translation of Tom's stories; "...perhaps he wants to see me killed. I have been sick two years. I went to New Westminster and go the fire sick and could not go about. Mr. Franklin knew me a good Indian and made me a constable. (from Tom's sworn statement)." Salt Spring Island was inhabited by many different ethnicities; African American, Azorian Portuguese, Kanakas...

Find Another Essay On This is an analytical essay on the murder of William Robinson, which occured in 1868 on the Salt Spring Islands in British Columbia.

This essay is an essay on abortion which is written in Regerian argumentation style. It addresses both the prolife and prochoice viewpoints but is ultimately pro life

1758 words - 7 pages During the past quarter century, abortion has joined race and war as one of the most debatable subject of controversy in the United States. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemma which for many individuals face; hence, the atmosphere for this debate is both an emotional and violent one. There are many points of view toward abortion; the main two distinctive ones being "pro-choice" and "pro-life".A pro-choicer would feel that the

An essay about the new graduated licensing program in British Columbia

515 words - 2 pages lost by impatient drunks just wanting to get home.In the outskirts of the lower mainland busses are few and far between. Many teenagers rely on one another for transport. It is not like downtown where you can simply catch the bus, sky train or even walk to your desired location. In small towns, such as Aldergrove, it could take hours to get anywhere you want to go. Most parent's work and therefore are not able to chauffer people around, causing

This is an Analytical essay describing the connotative language in the Koran

712 words - 3 pages , nor of those who are astray." This last piece of the opening causes an emotional cascade in those who haven't submitted their will to the almighty Allah. They feel that this powerful deity's wrath will be unleashed upon them the very instant they finish the opening. The connotative language in this section alone is overwhelming.In the piece called "Daybreak", we are bombarded by connotative language yet again. After the introductory "In the

This is an analytical essay on Beowulf and the role of evil versus good. It talks about how evil is needed to define the good guy

1269 words - 5 pages slaughter, mangle and murder, yet show no remorse.They are the enemy; they are the evil. There is an important connection between the enemy andthe hero, without this connection the hero is never defined. The evil enemy has essentialcharacteristics which lead to Beowulf as a hero. Not only do the Dane, Geat and readers see himas a hero, but most crucially he see's himself as a hero. I will argue the necessity of having anenemy, in comprehension of evil

The Jewish cemetery in Victoria, British Columbia

1281 words - 6 pages Introduction The Jewish cemetery in Victoria, British Columbia, is located on the corner of Cedar Hill Road and Fernwood. This historical cemetery remains active within the Jewish community. It was consecrated in 1860, and the first burial was conducted on March 20, 1861. The individual buried was murder victim Morris Price. In 2012, the cemetery was victimized by vandalism, which resulted in the destruction of multiple gravestones. Since

Arguement for the Legalization of Euthanasia in British Columbia

856 words - 4 pages I am writing to you today in the hopes that at the coming meeting of the Legislative Assembly you will help make British Columbia one of the most progressive provinces in Canada. The issue I am talking about is, of course, the legalization of Euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. The awful inadequacy of our current laws, such as Section 241.(b) which states “Everyone who aids or abets a person to commit suicide, whether suicide ensues or

Aquaculture in the British Columbia Fishery

2884 words - 12 pages : Towards 2015/2030," published in July 2000, that global fish consumption will rise by 25% by 2030. It went on to predict that, by this time, aquaculture will produce over half of the fish consumed by humans. (18)The annual sustainable yield of marine capture fisheries is estimated at no more than 100 million metric tons. (15) Thus, the bulk of the increase in supply will have to come from aquaculture, which is well suited to meet this increasing

This is an essay on "The Red Badge of Courage"

933 words - 4 pages actions are all child like. This shows the soldier's youth like side. Green is the subtle representation of the characters.In the novel the color black stand for danger. In the novel it says, "When the sunrays at last struck full and mellowingly upon the earth, the youth saw that the landscape was streaked with two long, thin, black columns which disappeared on the brow of a hill in front and rearward vanished in a wood. They were like two serpents

The "One-woman Man" Qualification for an Elder. This essay is based on the qualifications for an elder set forth in the book of Timothy in the Bible

1304 words - 5 pages to Ephesus, he wrote his first letter to Timothy to instruct him so that he "may fight the good fight, holding on to faith and a good conscience" (1:18-19). The letter deals with two main topics: false teaching and the administration of the church. The elder played and still plays an important role in the church. It is one of the three main offices of the church. In the New Testament church, elder (presbyteros) and overseer (episkopos) referred to

This is an essay on animal experimentation, specializing in the Cosmetic section

810 words - 3 pages "new and improved" stickers on nail polishes and lipsticks only show that the "new" thing about it was the extra half a million animals died to produce that title.So why keep a 30 yr old legend going when times have changed, new alternates and solutions have been discovered, and still let animals suffer? There was no use in our society then, so why now?The law, what is it? An oxford dictionary would define it as - a rule of conduct or procedure

Analyzing "One Art" by Elizabeth Bishop is an Analytical Essay of One Art by Elizabeth Bishop. It looks at the authors meaning of "losing" in this polygamous poem

1764 words - 7 pages us a list of things as if it were her resume.She tries to search for a way to master the "art of losing", but she herself fails to do so, thus losing at her attempted accomplishment. She has failed, thus making her a candidate for loss. The very thing she has tried to defeat has thus defeated her. That which she has tried to be skilled at she is an amateur.There is a play on the word "intent" and "meant". The word "intent" In stanza one, line

Similar Essays

"Macbeth" William Shakespeare: Re Read Act 2 And Examine Some Of The Methods Which Shakespeare Uses In This Act To Create A Feeling Of Tension On Stage Following Duncan's Murder

1153 words - 5 pages that the murderer deserves to go is hell. Also some of the porter's references about the devil are parallel to the murder and the reference to him being the "hell-porter" is comic-tragic because it is actually true, and this adds to the tension of the scene because he is so close to the truth but he doesn't know it. Later on in the scene Macduff and Lennox find out that the King has been murdered. Lennox refers to the night as being "unruly" which

This Paper Is An Analytical Essay On The Us Intervention In The Iraqi Conflict

1642 words - 7 pages control of their country.Another important aspect to this goal is to ensure that the Iraqi people are free, not just westernized. Although the Americans are free people, it is not in the best interest of the Iraqis to be taken over by Americans. Some Iraqis already argue that the Americans are using the Baath party as an excuse to stay in Iraq. Others feel their country is being transformed from one dictatorship to another. There is a major need for

This Essay Is About Drinking And Industrial Work Discipline. Drinking On The Job Was Normal Until The Rise Of Industrialization In Europe, This Essay Explains Why The Change In Attitude Occured

1017 words - 4 pages was prevalent during this time. When an apprentice or journeyman made progress in his profession, all workers enjoyed an informal break where alcohol was served to celebrate. During these events, the master craftsman celebrated with his journeymen and apprentices. After industrialization took off, the workplace required new customs and rituals. However, workers held on to tradition and continued to use alcohol for its social and physiological

This Is An Essay On The Culture Of Argrntina And What Life Is Like In Argentina

2144 words - 9 pages again. Their revival in Argentina has been led by man great leaders. Carlos Annacondia is on of them. He is truly an amazing man of god, I had the privilege of meeting him last summer. "Annacondia may be the most effective city wide interdenominational crusade evangelists of all times."( Wagner 4) He holds church services where he preaches god's word and thousands come to hear him. He then does an altar call service which is when one can witness