This Paper Argues That Aristotle's High Minded Personality Would Not Make A Good Friend, And Examines The Works Of Aristotle

1547 words - 6 pages

In this paper, I will argue that Aristotle's high-minded person will not make a good friend. By identifying that a high-minded person will not befriend an inferior one, there is no dispute that Aristotle would not make a good friend.Friends are mirror images of themselves. They will reflect back what is good as well as what is not good about each other. This is why the high-minded Aristotle would not make a good friend to most people. High-minded people are the best at what they do. In philosophy, Socrates is high-minded in that no one really compares to his philosophical ability. No individuals can compare themselves to Aristotle, as he is far superior intellectually and philosophically. This leaves Aristotle to be a bad friend because he is superior to anyone wanting to create a friendship with him. "Persons much inferior to them in station do not expect to be friends with kings, nor do insignificant people expect to be friends with the best and wisest men"(228). Just as an average person would not expect to befriend someone superior, the high-minded Aristotle would not befriend an average person. By being so superior, Aristotle would be mirror his image to a friend, and reflect back how inferior the friend is in comparison to Aristotle. This would not develop into a long lasting relationship, as both sides of the friendship would eventually become unhappy with the other. Aristotle would see his friend as being unintelligent and become tired of his ignorance. The friend would feel stupid in comparison to the high-minded Aristotle and so would not be able to tolerate the relationship. Examples of this are found in everyday life. People segregate themselves in accordance with many things including intelligence. In school, kids who are smarter than others tend to bond with those of the same intellectual level. The younger children stay away from the older ones and vice versa for the reason that both sides cannot tolerate each other's intelligence levels. If they were of equal intelligence levels, the younger children may be able to identify with older children because they are similar in this respect. Unfortunately this is not plausible so the younger children will always be viewed as immature in comparison to the older.Through Aristotle's own philosophy, he explains why he himself would not make a good friend. I feel that I have made a solid argument as to why Aristotle would not make a good friend. No one would expect Aristotle to have many friends, as he would be far superior to anyone offering any kind of friendship. His own philosophy states that someone far superior like himself is not likely to befriend anyone. The argument is particularly strong in that identifies not only why the high-minded Aristotle would not make a good friend, but also as to why an average person can't become friends with Aristotle.The largest objection to my argument would be that Aristotle would make a good friend because, being high-minded, he would know what is...

Find Another Essay On This paper argues that Aristotle's high-minded personality would not make a good friend, and examines the works of Aristotle

This essay argues that Machiavelli was not evil, but a patriotic citizen

1737 words - 7 pages There is good reason to believe that Machiavelli taught evil. One has only to open the book to find Machiavelli advising the use of violence in defense of the prince's power. In Chapter 3 he says, " . . . if [the prince] wants to hold [acquired principalities] he must have two concerns: one, that the bloodline of [the principalities] ancient prince be eliminated. . ."(9), and in Chapter 19 he states, "And here one should note that hatred is...

This paper is a personal story of my travel to a part of town that has a high amount of people of a particular ethnic make up. It was part of a personal experience for a education class

741 words - 3 pages Title: Field TripAmerica is sometimes referred to as a 'nation of immigrants' because of our largely open-door policy toward accepting foreigners pursuing their vision of the American dream. In cities across the United States you will find people of every race ethnicity, ethnocultural or cultural group, some more diverse than others. Unfortunately, in some places, we blind ourselves to the richness of what some cultures have to offer?the history,...

"Video Game Violence" This essay answers the question of wether or not video games have a violent affect on childrens behavior. It argues that video games do not have any affect on behavior

525 words - 2 pages In America teenagers committed thousands of homicides last year and many believe these are due to video game violence. This paper clearly explains why video games do not cause any type of actual violence. My argument is based on three main points. All video games produced in America today are required to have a rating system. No proof exists that there is any relation to video games and violence, and a large number of Americans play video games...

Exploring How I Would Make High School and College A Better Place

697 words - 3 pages Exploring How I Would Make High School and College A Better PlaceEvery day teenagers are asked many questions about school when coming across adults who are wild about school and college. The most popular question asked to us is "Do you like your school?" and the answer is normally "no." However, no well thought out explanation about why we do not like our school is ever said. I attend Frederick K.C. Price the 3rdhigh, a college preparatory...

Harvey Milk, a celebrity who would make a good president

746 words - 3 pages Harvey Bernard Milk was born on May 22, 1930 at Woodmere Hospital in Long Island, New York. His official name, derived from his Lithuanian ancestry, was Glimpy Milch. He graduated from Albany State College in 1951 where he had majored in math and minored in history. Milk entered the Navy shortly after he finished college and advanced to the rank of chief petty officer on the U.S.S. Kittyhawk, only to be dishonorably discharged when his...

Are Leaders Born or Made a discussion of various leadership models and the factors that make a good leader

1705 words - 7 pages IntrodutionThere have been many great leaders throughout the ages Napoleon, Churchill, Mandela. However great leaders are often thought to be great militaristic leaders and not the skilled negotiators which we now consider crucial for the smooth running of business and politics. More often than not a great leader is considered to be male, this is also implicated in that fact that even if a leader is not male, they posses more often than not...

Discuss the Aims and the Work of Manet - make particular reference to his influences and contemporary life, which would have affected his work. Make reference to specific works

1622 words - 6 pages At the time Manet began working, the generally accepted art was the official art of the Salon. His work can generally be described as part of the impressionist movement, which emerged from the works of Realist painters like Courbet and Millet. Paris itself was going through several great changes at the time - the arrival of Japanese prints and woodcuts introduced a new use of perspective and space, and impressed artists with its beauty and...

Research Paper: Factors that make up individual personality traits

1400 words - 6 pages Factors That Make Up Individual Personality TraitsPeople are born with their own special traits and personality. This has been a keen interest for many scientists who have always wondered what really is the factor that makes up individual personality traits. The debate on whether human personality is influenced by nature or nurture took place ever since the time of Plato and Aristotle and is still in progress today with many supporting evidence...

Aristotle and The Human Good This is an essay on Aristotles arguement that happiness is the highest end of human good. I argue against his points and give details why

1179 words - 5 pages Aristotle and The Human GoodIn book I, Nichomachean Ethics Aristotle argues the highest end is the human good, and claims that the highest end pursued in action is happiness, "What is the highest of all goods pursued in action...most people virtually agree, since both the many and the cultivated call it happiness"(pg. 198 ll.1095a 15-20). Aristotle's argument is flawed when he suggests only human beings with full use of reason (not animals or...

This essay argues that the legal age to drink in the U.S. is to low. It supports this with explaining how it would help binge drinking, and gives examples

870 words - 3 pages One of the most controversial debates facing the federal government is whether to lower the age for legal drinking of alcohol by an individual. Nationwide, the legal age to drink alcohol is 21. In 1987, The Minimum Legal Drinking Age Law was passed to "make it illegal for any person who is less than 21 years old to either purchase, possess, or consume alcohol beverages or to misrepresent their age to obtain such beverages" (Policy and...

This is an essay that argues as to whether or not the "Progressive Era" was truely progressive or really retrogressive

1182 words - 5 pages The Progressive era lasted from 1900 to 1920. There was a great deal of change in everything. The economy changed, politics changed, and even society and the way that people interacted with each other changed. Some people think that this was a retrogressive era, where racism flourished against African Americans and immigrants, and foreign policy was too aggressive. Others think that this was a progressive era, where equality was finally given to...

Similar Essays

What Would Aristotle Have Thought About A State Lottery? This Essay Uses Aristotle's Views On Justice To Evaluate The Morality Of A State Lottery

688 words - 3 pages One aspect of justice, which Aristotle elaborated on, was that which was concerned with a fair distribution and proportionate equality. These aspects are directly related to the debate about whether a state lottery would be unjust toward those citizens of the state who are the least able to afford it. For the sake of argument we will assume that a lottery is a disproportionate tax on the poor, who are more inclined to play hoping of financial...

Topic: Is Medea A Tragic Heroine? This Paper Examines In Details The Main Character Medea And Proves That She Is Not A Tragic Hero Based On The Facts

840 words - 3 pages It is debatable whether Medea is or not a tragic heroine. It can be argued that Medea is a tragic heroine. However, Medea is not a tragic heroine. According to Aristotle's poetics, a tragic heroine or (protagonist) is someone who gains information previously unknown, leading to important insight. In lamer terms, a tragic protagonist made an error in judgment and didn't realize until it was too late. However, Medea is certainly not a tragic...

Cyrano De Bergerac Is Aristotle's High Minded Man

766 words - 3 pages Le Haut Homme Occupé D'Aristote In Cyrano De Bergerac, written originally by Edmond Rostand in French and translated to English by Brian Hooker, Cyrano de Bergerac stars in an epic of his fictional life as a high minded man. Aristotle, a great philosopher, states that a high minded man must have a mind that is concerned with all great things. Now, what are these "great things"? There are plenty of great things that a high minded man must value....

A Response To Aristotle's Politics, Stating That All Mankind Is In The Pursuit Of Some Good

906 words - 4 pages Mankind's underlying lifestyle"All associations are instituted for the purpose of attaining some good" (375). In agreement with Aristotle, I believe everything as we know it, is formed, is said, and is carried out, with some extent of good in mind. Another way of putting this would be that the ultimate end goal of human existence is happiness. By saying this, he has come to say that no body goes into any action that may be a malicious event just...