Thomas Hardy's Views On Religion Essay

1616 words - 6 pages


Thomas Hardy's views on God and Religion
Thomas Hardy was born into a religious family and brought up with very Christian values and morals. As he matured and was exposed to the new ideas of the time, he became conflicted in his views about God and religion.  He was criticized for writings that many of his peers considered to be obscene, immoral and blasphemous. Throughout his adult life, Hardy considered himself to be an agnostic. His poems show that he was much more complicated than that. His writings show a Christian who was tormented by the fact that he was no longer able to believe in the church doctrine. He had a conflicted soul that was searching for some meaning.  This is evident in his poetry, especially Hap and Channel Firing. In these two poems, Hardy reacts to a world with a god that is either indifferent to human suffering or nonexistent and replaced by random chance.
In Hap, one of Hardy's first poems, the author longs for any kind of god. Even a "vengeful god" (1) who finds amusement in human suffering would be preferable to the randomness that the poet sees. If Hardy could "know that thy sorrow is (God's) ecstasy" (3) then at least he would see some purpose in his misery. If only the poets "love's loss was (God's) hate's profiting" (4) then Hardy would be "steeled by the sense of ire unmerited."(6)  In other words, even if God was cruel and uncaring, Hardy would be at   least "half-eased" (7). He would be comforted by God's anger or wrath even if it was undeserved.
However by the third stanza Hardy shows that there is no god. It is not a "powerfuller than I" (7) which controls life. It is random chance that there is suffering. It is   "Crass Casualty obstruct(ing) the sun and rain," (11) It is "dicing Time" (12) for which he cries. Hardy wishes for a god who is mean spirited and vengeful. Then at least life would not be so random and man would have some kind of notion of what to expect. Instead the Fates are responsible for our sorrow, not because they take pleasure in doing so, but because they are "partly blind" and do so for no reason. In the last two lines Hardy writes that "These purblind Doomsters had as readily strown / Blisses about my pilgrimage as pain."(13-14) For Hardy, the sorrow and pain are that much worse because they could have just as easily been joy and bliss. Instead of finding some kind of purpose or reason, Hardy sees only a universe ruled by the laws of nature. It has been said that Hardy was influenced by Darwin and perhaps this poem records Hardy's troubled response to Evolutionary Theory. The scientific advances of the time were a direct contradiction to the Christian God with whom Hardy was raised. This was probably very frightening and confusing. In Hap Hardy longs for the time of his youth, a more innocent time with the universe controlled by a benevolent higher power.
In contrast, Channel Firing shows not blind fate but a cruel and uncaring god who is running...

Find Another Essay On Thomas Hardy's Views on Religion

Thomas Jefferson and James Madison's views on the interpretation of the Constitution (DBQ)

611 words - 2 pages The general consensus among historians is that there was a difference of opinions between Thomas Jefferson and James Madison on the policies of the interpretation of the Constitution. It is generally believed that Thomas Jefferson felt that there should be strict and inflexible interpretation of the Constitution, while James Madison felt that the Constitution was elastic and that many different laws could be derived form a single clause. Their

"Fire Can Burn" on Thomas Hardy's Tess of the d'Urbervilles. An essay arguing that Tess is _not_ a victim of cosmic irony.

2325 words - 9 pages agree on this; today, with the rise of pure reasoning and logics, it is becoming increasingly difficult to believe in a single cosmic finality towards which everything converges. In this regard, Thomas Hardy can be seen as a contemporary, if not a precursor, 19th century British writer. In his acclaimed novel Tess of the d'Urbervilles, he skilfully manages to address many themes: a promotion for the end of social classes, the realistic depiction of

Worldwide Views On Religion

1640 words - 7 pages Evaluate the impact on human life of at least three different religions you have read so far. Be specific as you discuss how the particular religious tradition affects everyday life. Draw comparisons and contrasts between traditions as appropriate. What is religion? Endless pages have been dedicated to defining this one word however, there are so many opinions it seems impossible to do so. For the moment that one defines such, another

John Updike: Views on Sex and Religion Reflected in his Writings

1309 words - 5 pages -class Americans. His patriotism and religion formed a relationship with the common life experience of average Americans. His earliest aspiration was to become a cartoonist and later he desired to be a poet. He wrote many popular short stories however; his most celebrated works are among his novels. Mr. Updike was a religious man with a Protestant perspective on his Christian faith. He also made a habit of attending church regularly

Jude The Obscure: Theme in Relation to the Author

919 words - 4 pages subtleties throughout the story suggest that the places Jude visits are based on real cities from Thomas Hardy's life. For example, Christminster, a collegiate city, is said to be modeled on Oxford, while Marygreen and Melchester are modeled on Fawley and Salisbury, respectively. Though Jude The Obscure is filled with several themes involving religion, love, class, and dreams, its central theme focuses on marriage and its societal constructs during

Isolation in Tess of the D'Urbervilles and Catcher In The Rye

1772 words - 7 pages about society as a whole, he desperately wants to have a girlfriend, have sex and achieve emotional intimacy, yet at the same time is desperately afraid as well.Hardy's view on religion is made clear as he uses his characters to make observations that may have been quite disconcerting to his Victorian readers. Hardy agnosticism is noticeable, meaning we are isolated as a reader as we are swayed by Hardy to follow his views and opinions. Angel's

Thomas Hardy's Use of Fallen Women in His Writings

540 words - 2 pages Thomas Hardy's Use of Fallen Women in His Writings Thomas Hardy sheds new light on the idea of the fallen woman. Throughout several of his works, he portrays the fallen woman through her own eyes, and, in doing so, presents a different perspective. Three of his works which establish this new perspective are the poem, "The Ruined Maid," and the novels Far from the Madding Crowd and Tess of the d'Urbervilles. In "The Ruined Maid," which

"My Enemy, the Stranger" References to Thomas Hardy's " The Man He Killed"

1484 words - 6 pages they could have been friends. The attitude expressed in Thomas Hardy's "The Man He Killed" is that of satire, or dark humor as Hardy subtley expresses the "evil of war." There exits no real bitterness in the poem, but Hardy's writing of the poem indicates that he was indeed thoughtful towards war and its implications on the soldiers. Former liberal senator George W. Norris expresses his views on the question of "Who reaps the benefits of war?" In

Thomas Hardy's Tragic Stories

808 words - 3 pages specific tragic form that is Thomas Hardy's. One can argue that Shakespeare was the most influential literary figure in Hardy's life - setting, plot, and themes all have their nativities in Shakespearean plays. Nonetheless, while Shakespeare's own tragedies adhere to the tradition of Seneca and to the medieval morality and mystery play conventions, it seems that Hardy paradoxically structures his tragic form on a pre-Christian, and even pre

"Tess of the D'Urbervilles"- hypocrisy

1029 words - 4 pages Victorian era are presented by Hardy's portrayal of the Durbeyfield household, the treatment of Tess by both Angel Clare and the main antagonist, Alec Stoke-D'urberville, while critical comments on religion and class structure of Victorian society is prevalent through character development and relations.A complement to the patriarchy of Hardy's times is the subserviency of women in Tess. The female characters, Joan and Tess Durbeyfield, and the three

The Sexual Expression of Women in Thomas Hardy's Writing

554 words - 2 pages The Sexual Expression of Women in Thomas Hardy's Writing The nineteenth-century woman was defined by her adherence to submission and resistance to sexuality. She was portrayed by most writers as a naive, accepting figure with strong concerns about living up to the prescribed societal ideals for a respectable woman. The women in Jane Austen's novels offer a clear representation of the nineteenth-century woman. Austen refuses these women any

Similar Essays

Thomas Hardy's Poetry On Religion Essay

611 words - 2 pages 'Poetry is a ceremonial form and ceremonies can help reconcile us to the aspects of our human experience which are themselves irreconcilable.' (Haslam & Turton) How do at least three of Hardy's poems about religion and agnosticism attempt to do this?Ceremonies mark most rites of passage in our lives. Parties and festivals mark happier events while rituals and funerals occur at sadder times. As well as assisting the deceased's passing to an

The Role Of Religion In Thomas Hardy's Poem Channel Firing

546 words - 2 pages The Role of Religion in Thomas Hardy's Poem Channel Firing "Channel Firing" by Thomas Hardy is a poem about the atrocities of war. Published shortly before the beginning of World War I, the poem seems almost prophetic. It not only decries the barbaric nature of war--an institution so vile and obnoxious that in this poem it awakens the dead--but also questions our inability to break our addiction to that institution. Less clear, however, is

Marx’s Views On Religion Vs. My Own

551 words - 2 pages Marx’s Views on Religion vs. My Own Karl Marx wrote that religion was, “an opiate of the people.” Although those words were not published in The German Ideology, they best describe his various views on religion. Marx wrote that there was a social relationship between the upper class or bourgeoisie and religion. The upper class that owned the means of production used religion as a tool to keep the working class or proletariat, oppressed and

Thomas Hardy's Philosophy On Life Essay

2214 words - 9 pages the Native is one of Hardy's representative novels based on his sombre recognition of life as a series of ironic situations which play with mankind, allure them to his doom, and he dies -either spiritually or physically or both-with the kind of bitterness in his heart which may be found in a Macbeth or an Oedipus. The critic John Paterson is not ready to place RN in the same category with The Mayor of Casterbridge, Tess of the d'Urburvilles