This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Thomas Hobbes And Rene Descartes: The Science Of Man

1390 words - 6 pages

In this paper I intend to examine the political philosophy of

Thomas Hobbes and Rene Descartes, in particular their ideas

relating to the science of man, and attempt to explain why their ideas

prove that it is not possible to construct a science of man. I will also

briefly mention the philosophy of Donald Davidson in regards to a

science of man.

The theories of Hobbes and the contemporary socio-

biologists attempt to recognize how man works and on that basis

build a society. "Hobbes wished to be seen as the inventor of the

science of politics" (Sorell, p45) He went about this by looking at the

psychology of man and discovering that man is a mechanism.

Hobbes wanted to understand mechanics. He wanted to look at why

men live the way that they do in society and therefore, breaks it

down. By doing this he discovered that people are cogs in the social

machine. Therefore he wants to examine these cogs in order to

achieve an understanding of the social mechanism, and does this by

looking at the psychology of the mind. Hobbes is both an empirist

and a materialist. Empiricists believe that sense gives all knowledge.

Generally, they do not believe in astrology, god, electrons etc. Their

philosophy is summed up by saying that all things that give true

knowledge can be sensed. Materialists believe that all things in

existence are physical matter. In other words, the soul and the spirit

do not exist. Therefore Hobbes believes that thoughts are material,

that they are caused by sense and vice versa. Tom Sorell suggests

in his essay, entitled "Hobbes’ scheme of the sciences", that rather

than have knowledge of how the mechanics of the mind’s passions

work, a more successful way of gaining political knowledge is to

understand what these passions cause. They cause various degrees

of action, with the possessor going to various extents to achieve

what they want.

In chapter six of "De Corpere", Hobbes makes a connection

between the knowledge of the principles of politics and the

knowledge of the motions of the average human mind. Hobbes’

account of political science is an idea of what man must do if his

goal is self-preservation. These ideas are not what mankind will do

but what it will have to do, in a rational way, to form a political

civilization. One would assume that as Hobbes identifies both a

natural science, and a civil science, he would suggest that they are

parallels which, in political philosophy, work together. However,

there are a few problems with Hobbes’ theory. Hobbes suggests that

a monarch makes a better sovereign than an assembly. Yet, surely

he would not agree that a monarch who is not dedicated would be

better suited than a group of thoughtful representatives. A politically

secure society is built up from its people. Hobbes believes that these

...

Find Another Essay On Thomas Hobbes and Rene Descartes: The Science of Man

The philosophy of thomas hobbes Essay

1199 words - 5 pages any kind of ruler is better than no ruler at all. His views are somewhat skewed with my views and the views of people around me but one must remember when he wrote his philosophy and what was going on at the time. But many of his ideas although they were created from his time, they can be translated and compared to the world we live in today. Human nature is the same except for the extreme violence and literal bloodshed I see many similarities. It's a man eat man world out there where only the strong survive which I see Hobbes explaining in his theory.Works Cited:-Hobbes, Thomas, Leviathan, N.Y. Penguin Books, 1968

A summary of "Discourse on the Method" by Rene Descartes

758 words - 3 pages . Because he cannot conceive of a way that the soul could perish or be killed, he is forced to conclude that the soul is immortal. In part 6, Descartes cautiously touches on possible conflicts with the church over his ideas about physical science. Finally, he implores his readers to read carefully, apologizes for writing in French rather than Latin, and vows to shun fame and fortune in the name of pursuing truth and knowledge.

Rene Descartes In Proving the Existence of God

1332 words - 5 pages René Descartes tried using reason alone to prove the existence of God, and that the soul is separate from the body. In theMeditations, he starts out by doubting completely everything and then progressively explains human existence, and then theexistence of God. By using reason, he also attempts to prove that the soul is separate from the body. Although Descarteshad some very excellent points, it is impossible to prove the existence of God

Thomas Hobbes and the Social Contract

1634 words - 7 pages Thomas Hobbes was the first philosopher to connect the philosophical commitments to politics. He offers a distinctive definition to what man needs in life which is a successful means to a conclusion. He eloquently defines the social contract of man after defining the intentions of man. This paper will account for why Hobbes felt that man was inherently empowered to preserve life through all means necessary, and how he creates an

Rene Descartes: French Mathematician and Philosopher

2243 words - 9 pages married but had one child who died from fever at age 5. He spent his later life in the Netherlands and then Sweden, where he died from complications of pneumonia at age fifty three in 1650 (“René Descartes,”2014). Summary: Discourse on Method Part IV The previous works in mathematics and science along with philosophy of reason leads Rene Descartes to the process of self-doubt. This doubt lead to the conclusion, as outlined in part IV of Discourse

Life of Thomas Hobbes

1720 words - 7 pages , general philosophy, and political science. Even though his work can be very controversial, it is hard to put any strong argument against any of his thoughts or theories. Due to his lifelong dedication to philosophical reasoning, he is known as one of the few "giants" in all aspects of knowledge.Work CitedEbenstein, Alan O. and William Ebenstein. Great Political Thinkers; Plato to the Present. Orlando: Harcourt Brace & Co., 1991.Hobbes, Thomas

The Certainty of the Mind: Arguements from Rene Descartes' Meditation II

799 words - 4 pages It is human nature to question our origins and wonder if we have purpose in this world. Rene Descartes sought to answers these questions by examining himself and God through his Meditations. In Meditation II, Descartes believes his mind is certain because he is able to perceive and understand thoughts. His many questions lead him from one idea of certainty to the next. The explanations of these ideas are clear enough for his argument to be

Compare and Contrast the Philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, and Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages In the idea of human nature; origin of state, the nature of government, the rights of regulation can be drawn as the reflection of insightful philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes and Karl Marx. By understanding this within the context of human nature, we can see their ideas play to how they perceive a modern philosophy. Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto illustrates the desire to build "a society without economic classes". John Locke's

Thomas Hobbes' Idea of the State and Its Relation with the Citizen

1578 words - 6 pages Hobbes' Idea of the State and Its Relation with the Citizen When looking at Hobbes’ idea of the state and its relation with the citizen, it is strikingly shocking how supportive of the authoritarian and absolutist form of monarchical government he is. His ideas are extreme for today’s democratic world however, he is seen as the founder of great liberal political thoughts such as the natural contract. Furthermore he gives great emphasis to the

Rene Descartes' Examination of the Nature of Mateial Things and What is Possible to Know of them Based on Passages from Meditations on First Philosophy. (the Wax example)

605 words - 2 pages "How do we know what we know?" This is a question asked by Rene Descartes as well as a host of other philosophers. A particular passage written in Meditations on First Philosophy by Descartes dubbed the "Wax Passage" examined the nature of material things, and what we really know about them. Descartes' thought process shall be followed, and his conclusion that if all attributes are stripped away, what is left is the "essence" of the wax, will be

Title: Mind and Body: An interpretation on the works of Rene Descartes and Benedictus de Spinoza -Talks about "Dualism" and "Double Aspect Theory"

1152 words - 5 pages view in perspective. Two philosophers who argue over this topic are Rene Descartes and Benedictus de Spinoza. Descartes was one of the few early thinkers to dissect and assess the mind/body problem with his argument for dualism. In contrast to Descartes was Benedictus de Spinoza who provides a counter-example to Descartes' "dualism," namely what is known as the "double aspect theory." By analyzing the views of both philosophers we can see which

Similar Essays

Morality. Rene Descartes, Thomas Hobbes And David Hume Were All After The Truth

608 words - 2 pages Rene Descartes, Thomas Hobbes and David Hume are well known philosophers of the time. These three men were after the truth. The truth about life. The truth about how one exists. The truth about the world around them. They questioned, thought, and reasoned. This is what they did. There goal was to arrive at true and certain knowledge.Descartes and Hobbes were both rationalists. They did not trust their senses. Senses deceive and cover up the

René Descartes And Thomas Hobbes : A Dialogue

1467 words - 6 pages René Descartes and Thomas Hobbes: A Dialogue As one embarks on the incredible journey through Descartes’ meditations, a plethora of doubts, criticisms and seemingly fundamental problems arise and block one’s progress. No doubt, many of these can be attributed to the fact that we of the twenty-first century come more than three and a half centuries after the brilliant mind of Descartes (or shall we say, ‘that was Descartes’) spawned the

Morality. Rene Descartes, Thomas Hobbes And David Hume Were All After The Truth

565 words - 2 pages COMPARACIÓN ENTRE RENÉ DESCARTES Y DAVID HUME. - Por un lado, Descartes es un autor perteneciente a la Modernidad (S. XVII), mientras que Hume es un ilustrado (S. XVIII) y fue contemporáneo de Rousseau. - Por otro, Descartes era racionalista (como Spinoza y Leibniz). Es decir, para él, el origen de todo conocimiento se debía la razón y las ideas innatas que ésta contiene. Sin embargo, Hume fue

The Meditations Of Rene Descartes Essay

700 words - 3 pages The Meditations of Rene Descartes In 1916 Rene Descartes wrote "What I wish to finish is . . . an absolutely new science enabling one to resolve all questions proposed on any order of continuos or discontinuous quantities." (p8 Methods & Meditations). He made this ambitious statement at the young age of twenty-three. Rene's ambition would take him far but it kept him from becoming the Aristotle of the modern age. The Meditations were an