Thomas Jefferson And James Madison's Views On The Interpretation Of The Constitution (Dbq)

611 words - 2 pages

The general consensus among historians is that there was a difference of opinions between Thomas Jefferson and James Madison on the policies of the interpretation of the Constitution. It is generally believed that Thomas Jefferson felt that there should be strict and inflexible interpretation of the Constitution, while James Madison felt that the Constitution was elastic and that many different laws could be derived form a single clause. Their views, however, seemed to have switched over the period of 1801-1817 to fit the needs of the time, and so those beliefs were not really set in stone.In the year 1800, Thomas Jefferson viewed the Constitution as a document that should be interpreted very strictly. He felt that the country could not be united if the Federalists were making so many interpretations of the words of the Constitution (Doc. A). He believed that the Constitution was made the way it was purposely because the Framers knew that that was how the country could best use it. An example of how he was a strict constructionist was in 1808 (in the middle of his presidency), when he created the phrase "separation between church and state." He felt that the Constitution does not provide the National Government with the right to impose religious laws upon the citizens (it can only make civil laws), and therefore those types of decisions are for the people to make for themselves (Doc. B).Towards the end of Jefferson's presidency was when the Federalists really lost their power and when the Democratic-Republicans increased theirs. With the loss of power of his party, James Madison changed his opinion of flexible interpretation to strict, while Jefferson did the opposite. They switched opinions because each believed that, with the changing times, their new views would be...

Find Another Essay On Thomas Jefferson and James Madison's views on the interpretation of the Constitution (DBQ)

Views of the Mongols DBQ Essay

785 words - 4 pages ). Nonetheless, some scholars and historians recognized the Mongols power and braveness, but were indifferent with their views of the Mongol civilization. Firstly, the Mongol society was viewed as merciful and fair-minded. According to Ala-ad-Din Ata-Malik Juvaini, a Persian historian who served the Mongols as the governor of Baghdad in the 1200’s, the Mongols would not use excessive punishments when collecting taxes from their tributaries. Likewise

The Lifetime Of Thomas Jefferson. This report is on Thomas Jefferson and I explain his life and the acomplishments he has done

1066 words - 4 pages successor of Benjamin Franklin as minister to France, Thomas Jefferson saw the effects the American Revolution had on its companion nation. He showed sympathy, and continued to view Britain as a rival. While he was in Europe, the Constitution that he contributed to so greatly was being framed and ratified overseas. Jefferson was worried that the document didn't directly protect the rights of Americans as individuals and that the unlimited

The View and Feelings of Thomas Jefferson in The Inner Jefferson by Andrew Burnstein

995 words - 4 pages The View and Feelings of Thomas Jefferson in The Inner Jefferson by Andrew Burnstein According to Maslow self-actualized people exibit the same fifteen characteristics. The book, The Inner Jefferson, by Andew Burnstein, expressed the views and feelings of Thomas Jefferson. Using these as a guideline to his life, it is obvious, that Thomas Jefferson was a self-actualized individual. One of the characteristics portrayed, is the ability

The Louisiana Purchase and President Thomas Jefferson

861 words - 4 pages . Print. Ellis, Joseph J. American Sphinx: The Character of Thomas Jefferson. New York: Knopf, 1996. Print. Pasley, Jeffery Robertson, Andrew and Waldstreisher, David (eds.) Beyond the Founders: New Approaches to the Political History of the Early American Republic. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2004. Print.) Peterson, Eric S. (ed.) Light and Liberty: Reflections on the Pursuit of Happiness. New York: The Modern Library, 2004. Print.

Thomas Jefferson And The US Economy

1048 words - 4 pages During the early years of the United States of America following the winning of independence Thomas Jefferson was one of the most active and influential men in American politics. Jefferson, who spent his childhood roaming the woods and studying on a remote plantation in the Virginia wilderness, became the first Secretary of State under George Washington and later president of the United States. His genius was in his ability to compromise and in

"The Declaration of Independence" by Thomas Jefferson: A look at the writing style of Thomas Jefferson

1161 words - 5 pages boiled down to one inspirational document which set the course of American history. In "The Declaration of Independence", Thomas Jefferson declares that the American Colonies should abandon King George III because of the king's tyranny toward the Colonies, demolition of the colonies' right to self-rule, and neglect of the colonies needs.The Kings tyrannical measures regarding the thirteen colonies is one of the most prominent themes in "The

Thomas Jefferson on Separation of Church and State

2354 words - 9 pages Thomas Jefferson on Separation of Church and State A popular notion among many religious conservatives is the rejection of what is commonly referred to as the separation between church and state. They maintain the United States was founded by leaders who endorsed Christian principles as the cornerstone of American democracy, and that the First Amendment prohibition against government establishment was not intended to remove

James Madison: The Father of The Constitution

841 words - 4 pages Constitution. In opposition, delegate Alexander Hamilton formed the Federalist Party. In 1800, James Madison became Secretary of State for the first Democratic-Republican president Thomas Jefferson. Moreover by 1808, James Madison became the 4th President and served two terms. However he made choices in office that he would soon regret, the shrinking of the military forces and eliminating the national bank. In the War of 1812, the United States declared

How James Baldwin views the fear and love of racism

576 words - 2 pages We always say 'Love conquers all' is commonly said and heard in our daily lives. Ironically, this is necessarily not true as James Baldwin views our society. He illustrates the stereotypes of both Blacks and Whites. In his argumentative autobiography, The Fire Next Time, the author brilliantly perceives the idea that love, instead of fear, liberates society. To truly 'liberate' society, one must discover his/her individual and personal identity

The Problem With Thomas Jefferson

796 words - 4 pages was also flawed. Sure he’s well known for the aspiring Declaration of Independence, but these flaws, also led him make some choices, that would leave a mark on his impressionable record, and lead to the problems with his presidency. Therefore, although, Thomas Jefferson was an inspiring man and renowned intellect, his imperfection led to actions such as the Indian Policy and Embargo Act, which drop him into the bad category. Although, President

Thomas Jefferson Thoughts on The Declaration of Independence - U.S History - Essay

794 words - 4 pages Individual Writing # 1: Thomas Jefferson HIST 1301 When Thomas Jefferson put down the words, “All men are created equal,”(@heritage, 1) his first execution in power was to form and build on the fact that human beings, as individual bodies, had the God given rights to “Life, liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness,” (@heritage, 1) no matter what their social status inclined. During that time, in their declaration to part ways from England and

Similar Essays

James Madison And Thomas Jefferson Essay

1428 words - 6 pages Through the Presidencies of both Jefferson and Madison, the nation had drastic changes. Each of the Presidents showed their views of being loose constructionists of the Constitution by their actions in office. These Presidents helped further the Republican ideas, like a small central government and the support of the lower class farmers. The powers of the Federalist Party slowly diminished as the Republican Party became the overwhelming majority

Thomas Jefferson And The Declaration Of Independence

1480 words - 6 pages Thomas Jefferson and The Declaration of Independence Thomas Jefferson was the author of The Declaration of Independence, and according to Bellis, Jefferson was also a jurist, a diplomat, a writer, an inventor, a philosopher, an architect, a gardener, a negotiator of Louisiana Purchase, but he only requested three of his many accomplishments to be noted on his tomb. (2005). Thomas Jefferson was a very smart politician and he knew what to say

The Presidency Of Thomas Jefferson Essay

767 words - 4 pages Jefferson in 12 Volumes Thomas Jefferson Commentaries on War and Religion The Declaration of Independence The American Nation: Beginnings Through 1877 by Prentice Hall The American Pageant [[TV]] The History Channel's Ultimate Guide to The Presidents PBS' The Presidents

Interpretation Of The U.S. Constitution Essay

1304 words - 5 pages usually hold extensive law backgrounds. Justice Antonin Scalia follows suit with the customary law background. On September 26, 1986, after a nomination by President Reagan, Scalia took his position as Justice (Supreme Court). Scalia is an orginalist, which means he believes that the original written word of the Constitution should be taken literally and enforced by means of the Framers ideals. Originalists views are straight forward and do not