Thomas Sowell Vs. Adam Smith Essay

1758 words - 7 pages

Sowell presents mercantilism as a misconception of what is best for a nations' economy. This conception is based on what mercantilists think is best, this is to have more goods being exported from your country then goods being imported in to your country. Sowell describes this system as one that benefits merchants who in essence capitalize on the hard work and sweat of the common man or poor man as he puts it. In addition to this system being set up this way there were also controls put in place to keep it this way. Maximum wage laws and educational selection were examples of such controls used to perpetuate mercantilism. Maximum wage laws were used to lower costs thus allowing merchants to sell goods cheaper than that of other countries. Educational selection was used to teach poor children skills for specific jobs. This tool used by mercantilists keeps poor families in poverty by not allowing them equal education so they have no way to climb out of the lower class. This same idea is seen present day in ghettos and impoverished areas and was of the main reasons for riots such as the Watts riots of L.A. Another characteristic of mercantilism was the class separation and the effects on the common man; this is where Smith's ideas come into play.Smith's book IV is a response to mercantilism in that it was written during a time of elitist domination of the lower class in France and England. Smith attacked the current system and stated that the amount of a nations gold should not be the way it wealth is measured. This is the basis for Smith's response and leads to the idea that it is possible for all nations to grow wealthier at the same time through the gaining of efficiency. Smith's response to mercantilism acknowledged the fact that the common man makes up the largest portion of a population. Smith does this by measuring a countries wealth on the amount it produces divided by its population and placing importance on the happiness of that large portion of "wage-earners".Since mercantilism puts the wealth of a nation especially that of merchants and manufacturers, over the effects it has on the common man it is important to note that Smith did not intend to make the common man a victim in his response. Smith does not let them off the hook because they are guilty of human nature and success of their nation even under mercantilism, meaning that even though they are dominated by manufacturers and merchants they enjoy the same success of armies and fleets in war and the so called prosperity of their own nation. In this way the common man is no better than the elitist, the politician or the merchant.Overall, Smith places his emphasis on production and the market and not on politics. Since the market place is mostly made up of the common man, a country is better represented when its economy places emphasis on the market. Smith also sided with social controls but his ideas of social controls were fire and bank regulations as well as public works. However,...

Find Another Essay On Thomas Sowell vs. Adam Smith

An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of NationsAdam Smith

693 words - 3 pages of. "Adam Smith Wealth Nations." faith vs reason debate spiritual insights quotations quotes aldous huxley perennial philosophy. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Sept. 2011. .

Banking and the Acquisition of Toxic Assets by the US Government

1461 words - 6 pages with regard to tarp and stimulus Thomas Sowell the housing boom and bust) In 2008 ( ) large Investment banks, insurance companies and (holding companies) cuhs as Aig, Citigroup, Merrill Lynch suffered substantial loss from the subprime mortgage market corporate neglect of risk management (inquiry report ) As of February 2009 the largest recipients of Tarp were JP Morgan (25 billion) wells Fargo (25 billion) Aig (40 billion) Bank

Affirmative Action

2270 words - 9 pages and Feingold, Stanley, ed., Taking Sides: Clashing Views on Political Issues. Dubuque, Iowa: McGraw-Hill Contemporary Learning Series, 2010. Mills, Nicolaus, ed., Debating affirmative action : race, gender, ethnicity, and the politics of inclusion. New York: Delta Trade Paperbacks, 1994. Plous, S. (2002). Understanding Prejudice and Discrimination. McGraw-Hill. Sowell, Thomas. Preferential Politics: An International Perspective. New York: William Monroe and Company, 1990.

Rejecting the Myth of Colorblindness in Education

1723 words - 7 pages , abuse, social injustice, and general dislike of an individual or group will never be controlled or extinguished through any means of education or political mandate. These terrible practices are part of the human frailty of life, and can be found among every ethnicity and culture. While it should never be condoned, it cannot be eradicated. In The Multicultural Cult, Thomas Sowell argues that cultural differences matter and always have. He claims

Affirmative Action is Discrimination in a New Form

1793 words - 7 pages , what about the individuals that were not even born when this atrocity of discrimination was going on. Society should not punish the youth for the crimes of their white male forefathers. Thomas Sowell gave an interesting story in his article "Free Markets vs. Discrimination" about Albert Greuner. He had graduated from Pensacola Naval photography school and was refused a job he was more than qualified for. The reason Albert was denied the position

Affirmative Action

5198 words - 21 pages } Steeh, Charlotte; Krysan Maria. Trends: Affirmative Action and the Public, 1970-1995, 1970-1995. The Public Opinion Quarterly. Vol. 60, No. 1. Spring 1996. 128-158. Stable URL:{primary scholarly, print via internet in original, authoritative} Sowell, Thomas. “Preferential Political: An International Perspective

Capitalism vs. Marxism/Communism

2924 words - 12 pages return there will be equality for everyone in our new Utopian society.Works CitedGeelong, Julien. "Communism/Socialism vs. Capitalism." 28 November 1996. The University of Melbourne. 8 April 2004.Hawken, Paul. "Natural Capitalism." Mother Jones. 5 April 2004."Karl Marx." Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. 2001. Wikimedia Foundation Inc. 5 April 2004."Karl Marx on Capitalism." Live Journal. 7 April 2004"Marxist Economics." Marxism Made Simple. 8 April 2004.Sowell, Thomas. Marxism: Philosophy and Economics. New York City, NY: 1985"What is Marxism?" Socialist Party. 8 April 2004.Wolff, Jonathan. "Karl Marx." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2003. 5 April 2004.

Write-up on “Value”

1146 words - 5 pages demand (Staveren, 2001). Exchange value according to Aristotle is dependent on the market demand of an article. The ideas of Adam Smith (1776) regarding value-in-use and value-in-exchange had a profound impact on the development of economics and study of market-based exchanges. In Smith’s understanding “value-in-use” Economist and Sociologist Karl Marx developed his own interpretation of use value and exchange value (Marx, 1909). According to Marx

Advantages to the Industrial Revolution in Early Modern Europe

1674 words - 7 pages improve the individuals overall quality of life. This resulted in economists, like Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations (1776), examining the most cost-effective method of producing the goods and services citizens demanded (such as clothing and food). It also left others, such as Thomas Malthus in his Essay on Population (1798), searching for a way to curb population growth so that Europe could sustain its growth. Ultimately both theorists’ ideas were

This essay is about Supreme Court Justice Earl Warren, Warren Court Justice, Civil Rights. 3pages, 623 words. No works Cited.

633 words - 3 pages Chief Justice Earl WarrenPresident Dwight Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren as the fourteenth Chief Justice of the Supreme Court in 1953. Warren had been the governor of California twice and was also on the republican ticket for Vice President under Thomas Dewey. It was assumed that Warren would pickup where his successor Fred Vinson left off as a conservative member of the Supreme Court, but instead Warren positioned himself as a liberal. When

The Age of Enlightenment

649 words - 3 pages kingdom or the other and totalitarianism in the form of monarchy was the accepted social order. The transformation from this oppressive political system to modern forms of democracy, as evident today, has to be attributed to the Enlightenment. Some of the most prominent thinkers who helped shape this new political consciousness were Diderot, John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, Rousseau, Adam Smith, etc (Porter & Teich, 1981). While there are critics in

Similar Essays

Adam Smith Vs. Karl Marx. Essay

955 words - 4 pages Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx, living in the typical capitalist community in the United States, it is much easier to relate to the thoughts of Adam Smith. This is not to say that I do not agree with some of the precepts of pure Communism, but like the old adage says, Communism looks good on the outside.Adam Smith states his opinion on the mercantile system and its faults, while he dissected, clarified, and revolutionized the mercantilist economy and

Stigin’ It To The Man Essay

984 words - 4 pages of perfect competition.” Price Theory is widely accepted as the heart of economics and is taught in nearly every school in unison with the neoclassical school of economic thought. (Neoclassical Economics) The neoclassical school of thought is said to be an evolution of the classical school of economic thought, which was originally proposed by Adam Smith in the 18th century. Price theory and the perfect competition model remain central to both

The Classical Model And The Great Depression.

2084 words - 8 pages time, but also by our very own President. "In France, John Baptist Say has the merit of producing a very superior work on the subject of Political Economy. His arrangement is luminous, ideas clear, style perspicuous, and the whole subject brought within half the volume of [Adam] Smith's work. Add to this considerable advances in correctness and extension of principles." (Thomas Jefferson) In our economy, we do not trade goods one for one.In a real

Colonial Person Biography Essay

707 words - 3 pages The Life of Adam SmithIn September, 1630 a group of Puritans under the leadership of John Winthrop set sail to the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Among the thousands of colonists traveling to New England was Adam Smith and his wife. Adam Smith had left England to find religious freedom. This is his story.Adam Smith was born to Mary and Thomas Smith on June 15, 1610 in Suffolk, England. He was born into a wealthy family, for his father had been a