This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Thou Shalt Not Steal: Should Self Plagiarism Be Allowed In Colleges

1406 words - 6 pages

As society moves towards an electronic-based culture, plagiarism, the act of using another person's words or ideas without giving credit to that person, has become much more prevalent due to the ease with which it can be done. Ever since the invention of the printing press and other forms of mass reproduction, duplicating the work of another has gone from being a painstaking and time-consuming task to a simple click of a mouse. With plagiarism becoming commonplace in colleges and universities, teachers have begun to restrict what can and cannot be submitted to fulfill assignment requirements. As a general rule, a paper that was written by a student for one course may not be handed in again, even by the same student, to satisfy a different course requirement. This is called self-plagiarism, the reuse of one's own work, and is usually not considered an accepted practice in the writing world. However, is self-plagiarism really considered a form of stealing or is it actually allowed and just frowned upon by professors?
According to Green, a professor of law, plagiarism is a relatively recent concept which started sometime in the eighteenth century:
It was not, until the Romantic Era of the eighteenth century—when the notion of “authorship” and “originality” emerged as significant cultural values—that the norm of attribution and the taboo of plagiarism came to the fore. As art and literature became viewed as the expression of the unique and autonomous personality of the artist or writer, the crediting of literary sources became an increasingly important concern…it was not until words and ideas could be viewed as “property”—typically, through publication—that “originality” became a significant cultural value, and plagiarism a powerful cultural taboo (176-177).
What Green is saying is that society considers the act of passing off another’s ideas as their own to be “a powerful cultural taboo” and should not be allowed for ethical reasons, although not necessarily for legal ones. Similarly, it is found that although there are ethical problems that can arise from unauthorized duplication, plagiarism is not inherently illegal according to U.S. law:
The most common vehicle used by owners of material to challenge plagiarism is the Copyright Act. However, the law and plagiarism intersect only imperfectly. Plagiarism is not a legal term, and though an instance of plagiarism might seem to be the quintessential act of wrongful copying, it does not necessarily constitute a violation of copyright law. Copyright protection applies only to original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression (Mawdsley 261).
In other words, although plagiarism may appear to be wrong, it is very difficult to challenge legally due to the fact that there are no laws against it. The sole legal basis would be the copyright law which does not cover self-plagiarism since one cannot steal their own ideas.
However, in Jewish law, the general consensus is that ordinary...

Find Another Essay On Thou Shalt Not Steal: Should Self-Plagiarism be Allowed in Colleges

Teen Pregnancy Should Not Be Allowed in High School

1657 words - 7 pages “Teen pregnancy should not be allowed because it results in an increase in high school dropouts” . Its important for teen to stay in school its probably much easier for them to drop out or either the school tells them to they also might feel embarrassed to go to school due to the rumors about her being pregnant some of the teen girls get bullied over the internet being pregnant at an early age some feel worthless and regret what they have

Why Women Should Not Be Allowed In Combat Occupations?

1502 words - 7 pages it’s not just the physical differences, there is also the risk of sexual assault. Due to the detrimental impact on the military, soldiers, and society, women should not be allowed to be in combat occupations. The Women's Armed Services Integration Act created in 1948 formed a force of women in all the military departments. This was considered a step in the right direction while also being responsible for current combat restrictions. The act

Performance Enhancing Drugs Should Not be Allowed in Sports

1247 words - 5 pages . Today doping has come to a point where it is improved by many biological techniques and this had brought the WADA (world anti-doping agency) a real problem. The WADA gives grave punishments for athletes who are tested positive for doping, and sometimes these punishments may exceed the limit or causes an injustice, false accusation, and ruin ones carrier. Therefore doping should not be allowed in any sport circumstances. Doping, also

Cell Phones Should Not Be Allowed In School

1387 words - 6 pages purely for productivity and efficiency could not be found without first discovering how they can be used adversely, especially in the hands of mischievous high school students. With the popular emergence of cell phones with internet capabilities and large amounts of digital space, educational opportunities seem to be at a peak and with these advantages in education also come disadvantages which could pose a risk for academic fallacy and also a

Same-Sex Relationships Should Not Be Allowed

1137 words - 5 pages Same sex relationships should not be allowed In recent reports there has been increasing interest in same-sex couples within Australian society. At both State and Commonwealth level there has been a removal of the majority of legal distinctions between homosexual couples and heterosexual couples. The changing face of relationships in contemporary society and continuing expansion in human rights laws have brought attempts to recognise and

Annexation: Tyranny That Should Not be Allowed

1959 words - 8 pages In the United States, a tyranny of power has been allowed to occur. Thousands of residents have been done wrong by governmental powers without having any say so to stop it. The forcible annexation of residential areas without voter permission should not be allowed in the United States. Many would say the source of this problem of abuse of power comes from the days of American Imperialism. American Imperialism is when we would annex small, and

Human Torture Should Not Be Allowed

1555 words - 6 pages allowed for use. The act of torture should not be used under any circumstances as proven by its violation of international law, human rights, and the false information given by torture. Torture, by law, is undoubtedly illegal. In 1975, the United Nations General Assembly approved the Declaration on the Protection of All Persons from Being Subjected to Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (Pope). This vote, being

Hydraulic Fracking Should Not Be Allowed

1541 words - 6 pages into the atmosphere. This leads to a higher concentration of toxins within the surrounding perimeters of the fracking well. The fracking compounds which do not resurface into aquifers or into the air are returned through the pipeline as waste water. These waste waters are produced in large amounts and have no additional use except to be disposed. The disposal is necessary due to the high amount of toxic agents found in this water. There are

Same Sex Marriage Should NOT Be Allowed

1202 words - 5 pages raise children. Children who are raised in a same sex environment are more inclined to pick up their parents sexuality and lifestyle. Children should be raised in a heterosexual environment, which is biologically correct. Children should not be brought up with a predisposition to be homosexuals or lesbians. The purpose of marriage is to protect our children not our sexual preferences. “With the legalization of homosexual marriage, every

Self-Plagiarism is Allowed by Jewish Law

1459 words - 6 pages becoming commonplace in colleges and universities, teachers have begun to restrict what can and cannot be submitted to fulfill assignment requirements. As a general rule, a paper that was written by a student for one course may not be handed in again, even by the same student, to satisfy a different course requirement. This is called self-plagiarism, the reuse of one's own work, and is usually not considered an accepted practice in the writing

Argumentative Essay: Women Should Not Be Allowed To Go Topless In Public

806 words - 3 pages Argumentative Essay: Should Women Be Allowed To Go Topless in Public      In the summer of 1996 Gwen Jacobs enjoyed a topless summer stroll during which she was seen by a local O.P.P officer, was apprehended and subsequently charged with indecent exposure. Gwen Jacobs pleaded not guilty in court and won the right to go topless in Ontario. This incident brought up an excellent question: should women be allowed to go topless on public

Similar Essays

Doping In Sports Should Not Be Allowed

1146 words - 5 pages Sports should not be allowed. Doping in sports causes several health problems. According to Lydia Bjornlund, a freelance writer with a degree in Education from Harvard University, it causes some physical problems and mental problems. Not knowing about the danger they are putting their life in, only about half will stop. Thirty Percent of the dopers continue doing it looking past all the serious problems. Is it that serious that you must win in

"Thou Shalt Not Kill" So Take That Into Consideration

1120 words - 5 pages stress disorder. If women are able to lie in the bed and have sex then they should be able to carry a baby. Abortion could affect you mentally. There are case's ability to capture the attention of the international community illustrates the furor surrounding the abortion debate. Though abortion is a topic that inspires intense debate, research suggests that not all abortions are viewed equally. Elective abortion is motivated by nonmedical

All Male Colleges Should Not Be Abolished

1460 words - 6 pages -male colleges in nation and some of them are considering accepting female students, I strongly believe that all male colleges should not be abolished because of the significant growth and development they bring to male students, the distinctions among genders the tighter bond they build among males Students in all male colleges are found to have more significant developments and growths than students in coed colleges are. Edith Simms, once an

Military Women Should Not Be Allowed In Combat Positions

1652 words - 7 pages The prospect of women in ground combat or on the front-line in the military has proven to be a controversial issue throughout decades of war. This controversy stems from criticisms such as women’s physicality versus men’s, the association of sexual-related situations within the military, and a history of failed gender-integration training. The bottom line, however, is that women should not be allowed in front-line or ground combat unless they