Thoughts On Assisted Reproduction Essay

800 words - 4 pages

Assisted reproduction is the use of assisted reproductive technology to achieve pregnancy by artificial or partially artificial means. The results and the implication of these different techniques and technologies in the society raises questions on the morality of these acts. Are these acts always right or wrong? Are they only right for certain groups of people? Are they morally correct? Those are the kind of questions that many people have on their mind, but the plurality of arguments makes it difficult to find clear cut answers. An analysis of different arguments by bioethicists might lead us to a better understanding of the issue.
Some philosophers like Laura M. Purdy and Gillian ...view middle of the document...

In contrast, others like Gregory E. Pence, Susan Dodds and Karen Jones argue against assisted reproduction. Indeed, Dodds and Jones in their essay are giving a response to the arguments of Purdy. They believe that focusing on what is necessary wrong like Purdy did, is taking the risk of being “falsely” reassured as the permissibility of surrogacy in the world (100). Also they think that Purdy overlooks the way practice of contracted pregnancy might affect attitude of women as a group (101). They consider Purdy’s discussion on the possible harms of surrogacy to be too narrow because she only considers physical risks (101). Foe them, surrogacy today is more about “enabling men to have children genetically related to themselves than it is about women agreeing to transfer burdens or risks” (102).
Pence on his side, is analyzing the case of the “McCaughey Septuplets” and believes that people should not run the risk of having severely disabled kids and say that it is God’s will (88). He thinks that people taking fertility drugs should be willing to reduce embryos for the good of the children born (88). He does not find correct to make people like the McCaughey heroes, while women using cocaine while being pregnant could be prosecuted because of the harm on the fetus.
Another argument is the one by Parfit. He believes the idea that it would be wrong to use certain kinds of artificial fertilization, believing that...

Find Another Essay On Thoughts on Assisted Reproduction

In Vitro Fertilization Essay

1791 words - 7 pages unprotected intercourse (Purdy, 2001, Bioethics of New Assisted Reproduction). In Vitro Fertilization is used when a women has irreparably damaged fallopian tubes. Using this, attempts to fertilize the egg outside her body. In vitro fertilization can help women with hopelessly blocked fallopian tubes to become pregnant (Purdy, 2001, Bioethics of New Assisted Reproduction). In addition, in vitro fertilization could lower the costs associated with the

The Right to Die in Assisted Suicide

2878 words - 12 pages Journal 1: Initial Thoughts on Physician Assisted Suicide (February 28th, 2013) The promotion of physician assisted suicide has sparked a debate throughout the world. From my point of view, assisted suicide is doctors assist patients who could not endure the pain of diseases and are voluntarily given lethal amount of substances resulting in death. However, physician assisted suicide might be considered to be deviant in many countries

Animal Assisted Therapy

1055 words - 5 pages (Source:PDF file). By creating a new role in the patient's environment, the patient is given the opportunity to develop a new perspective. This new perspective allows the patient a new outlook on their life. For example, a person who is contemplating suicidal thoughts could find a new role as a caregiver to an animal and develop an understanding that the animal needs them. Another way that animal-assisted therapy works is based on the cognitive

Assisted Reproductive Technology

4732 words - 19 pages . (October 16, 1999). Austin, C.R. (1989). Human embryos: The debate on assisted reproduction. New York: Oxford University Press. Blank, Robert & Merrick, Janna C. (1995). Human reproduction, emerging technologies, and conflicting rights. Washington D.C.: CQ Press. Bohle, Bruce. (1979). Human life: Controversies and concerns. New York: H.W. Wilson Company. Conrad, Denise. (1997). "Assisted

Physician Assisted Suicides

2435 words - 10 pages Physician assisted suicides Introduction Physician assisted suicides is among the modern greatest challenges that come with the medical professions ethic responsibilities. Assisted suicides threaten the greater core of the profession of medicine and its integrity since it is not just a proposal towards the care of the dying but the means to their death. Even though the council on Ethical and judicial affairs of medicine has long standing

Technology Assisted Reproduction

3247 words - 13 pages infertility. Some couples require only information on sexual practices favorable to conception. Other simple treatments include drug therapy to arrest an underlying infection or hormone deficiency. For difficult infertility problems, assisted reproduction technological procedures are required for conception. Artificial insemination is the oldest technological method of conception and has been used for over a century (Reproductive Tech, 1996). The

Assisted Suicide Should Not be Legalized

1878 words - 8 pages Assisted Suicide Should Not Be Legalized Throughout the course of history, death and suffering have been a prominent topic of discussion among people everywhere. Scientists are constantly looking for ways to alleviate and/or cure the pain that comes with the process of dying. Treatments typically focus on pain management and quality of life, and include medication and various types of therapy. When traditional treatments are not able to

'Explore how mechanical reproduction in the twentieth century has altered the way in which art is perceived and understood.'

1505 words - 6 pages evolving thoughts of an era.These mass produced items and the commercial market they created are evident in the art produced during the age of mechanical reproduction. Pop art was an avante garde movement within this period which predicted and reflected the rapid growth of the economy and the sudden need to consume.American pop artist Andy Warhol created numerous works throughout the rise of the movement. His works were primarily screen prints of

"Sex is easy to find. Commitment is easy to avoid. Childlessness among well-educated women is on the rise. Relationships are on the nose." Discuss making families in the new millennium

2026 words - 8 pages -being of its members may be negatively affected the family. There is a need to study the impact of the various changes on the well-being of its constituent members such as the father, the mother, the children, ageing grandparents, other dependent relatives and so on. Strategies can then be introduced to prevent or limit the negative effects of such changes. Assisted reproduction as discussed previously, advances in the technology of assisted

How Boys Become Men

4043 words - 17 pages P1: GCP/GOQ P2: GCV Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics pp532-jarg-375549 August 16, 2002 11:53 Style file version June 3rd, 2002 Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, Vol. 19, No. 9, September 2002 ( C° 2002) Regional-Geographic Views Gender Selection in China: Its Meanings and Implications Cecilia L. W. Chan,1,2,5 Paul S. F. Yip,2,3 Ernest H. Y. Ng,4 P. C. Ho,4 Celia H. Y. Chan,1,2 and Jade S. K. Au1 Submitted February

Using Assisted Reproduction Techniques and the Implications

1554 words - 7 pages During the past six decades, the human being has been making great strides in science and technology. One of the most developed areas has been the new Assisted Reproduction Techniques (ART). How far will you go? How perfect will your baby be? These are some questions that people do these days when they make the decision to have descendants. The determination of having children and pregnancy is a complex process. In these are involved

Similar Essays

Assisted Suicide Or Euthanasia Essay

1297 words - 6 pages the end of their days; instead they want to take matters into their own hands and handle death on their own terms. The authors state that assisted suicide is wrong as well because it is society’s “moral duty to protect and to preserve all life. To allow people to assist others in destroying their lives violates a fundamental duty we have to respect human life. A society committed to preserving and protecting life should not commission people to

Assisted Reproductive Technology Essay

1327 words - 5 pages of zero or very few sperm may be the result of a blockage in the tubes that carry sperm to the penis, or a defect in the testes or the hormonal system that stimulates the production of sperm. "Some medicines or radiation treatments, as in the case of cancer, can also reduce sperm count or kill them" (Pellicer, Assisted Reproduction in Spain). Ill with mumps in adulthood may be another cause of male infertility.Sperm production is very sensitive

Reserach Paper

1812 words - 8 pages open to philosophical, political, legal, and ethical challenges. The lack of consensus, in American society on the ethical question of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide attributed solely to the complexity and gravity of the issue. This study will discuss and explore the question of under what circumstances, if any, is euthanasia considered ethically appropriate? As such, this study will examine the ethics of euthanasia from three

Infertility Treatments Essay

1143 words - 5 pages insemination), where the woman is injected with specially prepared sperm. This method of treatment is used when the male has a mild case of infertility, or the woman has problems with her cervical mucus ( Assisted reproductive technology works by removing the woman’s eggs, then mixing them with sperm to make embryos, which are then put back into the woman’s body (