This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Threads: Gender, Labor, And Power In The Global Apparel Industry By Jane Collins

1258 words - 6 pages

Jane Collins’ book Threads: Gender, Labor, and Power in the Global Apparel Industry (2003) shows how the apparel industry developed to become labour intensive, driven by low wages and is particularly oppressive against females. The book outlines how two clothing companies, Tultex and Liz Claiborne subcontract work out to plants in Mexico. Collins suggests labour conditions in developing nations help shape new unions with both communal and women’s interests as a driving force. However in order to critically examine the strengths, weaknesses, and methodology of the book, it is necessary to have a full understanding of the author as it gives insight into any possible bias which may appear. ...view middle of the document...

This clearly shows the books target audience is not the general public.
Another weakness has to do with the age of the book and the many campaigns since it was published aimed to educate the general public about sweatshop conditions. When the book was first published in 2003 it is unknown what the general public’s knowledge base was when it came to this subject. However, eleven years later it could be said for the most part, people have some sort of understanding about the horrid conditions that our clothing is made in. That being said the book does not present any new information in regards to what is already known or has been presented to the general public.
Collins also reference’s two companies that may have been well known at the time but are no longer popular now, causing readers lose interest rather quickly. However, it should be stated that although the companies in the book are no longer relevant the some concepts apply to many corporations today.
The last weakness that will be reviewed is the rather broad presentation of the topic of industrial globalization of the apparel industry. Throughout the book Collins presents the historical development of the apparel industry in relation to Tultex and Liz Claiborne, as well as the impact of trade laws (such as NAFTA), the U.S. Tariff Code, quota regulations, and labour relations. It is also explained to readers that women are given less then subsistence wages because their incomes are seen as supplemental and therefore any amount of pay is beneficial. However, it is only in the last chapter that Collins talks about the emerging feminized unions coming from the maquiladoras. This aspect of the book seems to be the most important but is left until the end and is not fully developed in terms of its content. Collins highlights problems within the industrial apparel industry but does not offer any solutions. As previously stated the broader message of this book for the most part is already known, therefore this book is outdated and irrelevant.
The book is presented as a multisited ethnography based on four different locations: a knitting mill in Virginia, office headquarters for a large apparel corporation in New Jersey and two factories in Mexico. Collins examines changes to within the apparel industry using two methods: chain analysis and comparisons. Chain analysis traces the economic linkages between a number of different aspects such as: the factories that make the product and the stores that sell them. The purpose of this is see a chain reaction from one area of production and how it affects other aspects. The purpose of comparison is to see how production in America differs from production in Mexico in an attempt to see how...

Find Another Essay On Threads: Gender, Labor, and Power in the Global Apparel Industry by Jane Collins

Gender and Power in The Arabian Nights

1572 words - 6 pages Gender and Power in The Arabian Nights Works Cited Not Included Contemplating the relationship between gender and power, one undoubtedly notices that tradition regards men as the holders of official office and power. Historically, men have also always been the leaders of their families, and turned to in times of trouble or need. Making generalizations is normally a weak approach to any task; in this case however, it is necessary to do so in

Gender and Power in the Handmaids Tale

1877 words - 8 pages Topic Question: What understandings of the issue of gender and power are gained from characterization of men and women constructed in the text studied?The notion of power is a fundamental building block of any ancient, modern or futuristic society. The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood is an example of the distribution of power across a futuristic society, specifically a patriarchal dystopia. The power which women hold in this society is

The Woman In White, by Wilkie Collins

1520 words - 6 pages by her grave! If Laura is alive, then who has been buried? It seems to have been Anne Catherick. We later find this out when we read the third epoch, but Collins has cleverly placed a cliff-hanger at the end of the second epoch. Laura is really alive, but how? He wants the readers to buy the next one and wait in anticipation, to find out what is going on. The reader already has suspicions that it could be Anne Catherick we know that Anne

Contrast and compare the two marriage proposals made to Elizabeth Bennet in the novel "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austin: Mr Collins' proposal to Elizabeth and Darcy's proposal to Elizabeth

4647 words - 19 pages Catherine as among the least of the advantages in my power to offer.' This again demonstrates Mr Collins' lack of recognition of the fact that not every one feels high connection and money to be the greatest importance in life. As well as money and connections Mr Collins' believes Lady Catherine to be more important than love.Mr Collins' personality traits are also portrayed very well in his proposals. He is unmoved by Elizabeth's refusal and

Australian Industry and Manufacturing : The Collins Class Submarine Program

2163 words - 9 pages Executive Summary The program to design and construct the Collins Class Submarine has become one of the most complex and expensive Defence procurement programs in history. It was devised to replace the existing Oberon submarine fleet. The Collins Class Submarine program demonstrated the capacity of Australian industry to manufacture a world-class submarine. Nonetheless, the procurement of the Collins Class Submarines has not been without

Traditions in The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins and The Lottery by Shirley Jackson

1028 words - 5 pages whoever is victorious will live a life of riches and freedom whereas in one family member is chosen to be stoned to death. These two stories have one major difference. While The Hunger Games are a punishment, The Lottery is a result of tradition. The stories contain scapegoating by the characters trying to escape their fate by anyway possible including selfishness. Both of these stories demonstrate the meaning of tradition, scapegoating, and

Growth of the Apparel Retail Industry

1123 words - 5 pages 1.9 Key players: The apparel retail industry is now experiencing a huge development and making a remarkable contribution to GDP, it needs a better and exclusive regulatory framework to sustain the impressive overall growth of the industry. Competition in the retail apparel sector is getting stiffer in the nation as many big market players both national and international are testing and applying different retail plans in the market .Entry by new

Gender And Power In Advertisment

584 words - 2 pages ; This advertisement suggests that women are attracted or fascinated by James Boag or people who drink James Boag.Stereotypes and gender power are commonly used in today's advertisements to help sell the product or add humor to the advertisement.

Import Competition and Efficiency in Indonesia’s Textile and Apparel Industry: A Threshold Autoregressive Model

1831 words - 7 pages deviations of annual mean score of technical efficiency and scale efficiency for this industry are 0.0716 and 0.1805 respectively. Furthermore, for apparel industry the highest annual mean score of technical efficiency is 0.506 which was accomplished in 2007 and the lowest one is 0.317 which happened in 1989. As for the highest annual mean score of scale efficiency for this industry is 0.652 (1982) while the lowest score is 0.178 (1985). In

Mixed Language and Imageries in The poem Lies by Martha Collins

1037 words - 5 pages “Lies” and “Dover Beach”     The poem “Lies” by Martha Collins who plays so well with the word “lie” in the first six lines of this poem. “Lies” is a great piece that includes a strong mixed languages and imageries.With her choice of language, “Lies”  has many of its different meanings that did get me so confusing when I just first read this poem. Collins uses the single word “lie” which seems crucial to the poem’s total effect and theme

The Power and Benefits of Monopolies in the Pharmaceutical Industry

2367 words - 9 pages Due to patents, Pfizer and other companies in the pharmaceutical industry are not always competing in a monopolist’s competition. When a business has a patent they are the only manufacturer who can produce the product until the product expires, so it is clear that the firm can act as a monopoly while in control of the patent. As a monopolistic company, the company has market power, giving it the capability to adjust the market price of a good

Similar Essays

Ec And Apparel Industry Essay

2892 words - 12 pages -93.TC (2002) "Study Reveal the Consumer, Manufacturer and Retailer All Win With Mass Customization," (, (Current November 13, 2002).Business Wire 2004. Logistics Management. Delivering "Custom-Made" for Everyone; Apparel Industry Survey Conducted by FedEx-Emergence of Mass Customization in the Next Five Years., B. (2002), Personal Communication, December 11 Turban, E., McLean E., Wetherbe J

Outsourcing In The U.S. Apparel Industry: Economic Benefits And Ethical Concerns

2496 words - 10 pages apparel industry alone, a noticeable increase from the $18.5 billion spent in 2006 (Plunkett n.p.). Although this is a drastic change, it is not surprising. Companies are always seeking to gain an advantage over their competitors, and reducing costs is the best way to do so. Since the apparel industry specifically is very labor-intensive, the wages they pay their workers in factories make up a huge portion of their production costs. By outsourcing

Jane Austen's Presentation Of Mr Collins In Pride And Prejudice

1714 words - 7 pages Jane Austen's Presentation of Mr Collins in Pride and Prejudice Jane Austen presents Mr Collins as a character with many different traits. Mr Collins is a man who is very aware of his social status, likes to impress people, is extremely proud and has an inflated ego to name but a few. The first time we get a mention of Mr Collins, is in chapter thirteen, where we learn that Mr Bennet has in fact never met the man

Paradoxes Of Power In Sociological Insight By Randall Collins

1166 words - 5 pages is almost invisible until further analyzed; it is something that we perceive as being simple and therefore take for granted. Yet there are so many intricacies in regard to power that still remain to be seen. In Chapter Three of Sociological Insight by Randall Collins, the author establishes some valid points concerning power. He posits that power is something of a self- contradiction, that it is often most effective when