Threats To Democratic Consolidation Essay

1108 words - 5 pages

Creating a democracy is no easy task. It requires a lot of internal and external factors that could either make or break a successful transition from a non-democratic regime to a democratic one. This essay explains the three major threats to democratic consolidation (international relations, elite commitment, and the role of the military) that countries undergoing transitions from a non-democratic regime to a democratic one might face. This essay will also explain on the argument on why international relations is considered the greatest threat to democratic consolidation.
International Relations
International relations represents one of the three major threats to democratic ...view middle of the document...

2 Elite commitment is necessary to show that democratization is not a threat to the lives and interests of the old elite.1 According to O'Neil, if the old elite see democratization as a threat to their lives and/or economic interests, they will be less inclined to support any democratization movement. Because of this, O'Neil also points out that elite commitment could be a disadvantage for democratic consolidation in countries rich with natural resources.3 This is why despite peaceful protests and negotiations, the old elite in countries with rich natural resources like Zimbabwe (rich with diamonds)4 and Bahrain (rich with oil and natural gas)5 have difficulty supporting any democratization movement.
The Role of the Military
The role of the military represents another important factor in democratic consolidation for transitional democracies. According to Pinnell, it is important for the military to not get involved in political disputes and squabbles and having the military institutions itself to be integrated to the new regime with civilians in charge in running it—hence the principle of civilian control of the military.1 Pinnell also points out that if the military itself is not integrated with the new regime and the officers who are running the institutions see itself as separate from the new elite, it would cause conflict between the military and the new elite that could end up crushing away any chances of democratization.1
Why international relations is the greatest threat to democratization?
In terms of elite commitment and role of the military, these two threats can be controlled during democratization if there is a political will by the old elite and/or military to have an common understanding with the new elite to step aside from politics/reduce their political power and allow democratic consolidation to occur. However, in terms of international relations, it is difficult for new democratic elites to alleviate/control the threat of international relations unless they risk losing its popular support base that fought for democratization if they are seen by its own people not as democratic heroes but as puppets for foreign interests. It is also difficult to balance both between protecting the interests of a neighboring/powerful state vs. bringing democratization and reform to the populace, because the interests of a neighboring/powerful state may go against bringing democratization and reform to the...

Find Another Essay On Threats to Democratic Consolidation

The Grim Prospects of Tilly-style Democracy in Modern Africa

1118 words - 4 pages “ratchet effect” that allowed for greater taxation and bureaucratic expansion of what would become the modern democratic state. And, while scholars such as Herbst (1990) hold that Tilly's thesis is merely characterization of the formation of modern democracies and not a universal imperative, the mechanisms for a peaceful transition to democracy continue to elude world leaders and political scientists alike. It is on this premise that the present essay

Constructing a Democracy Essay

1631 words - 7 pages transition to consolidation. Popular support for a political regime is the essence of its consolidation. By voluntarily endorsing the rules that govern them, citizens endow a regime with an elusive but indispensable quality: political legitimacy. The most widely accepted definition of the consolidation of democracy equates it squarely with legitimation. In a memorable turn of phrase, Linz and Stepan speak of democratic consolidation as a process

Argentina and Kenya

4903 words - 20 pages Ten Challenges of Democratic ConsolidationDemocratic consolidation confronts a number of characteristic challenges in new and insecure democracies. What is striking about these challenges varies across countries (and over time), however, and it would be an overstatement to characterize the complete resolution of any one of them as 'necessary' for democratic consolidation. Beyond establishing and routinizing broad commitment to the rules of the

Aftermath of military rule in Latin America: A case of Brazil and Argentina

1807 words - 8 pages Democratic governments of the Southern Cone of Latin America have dealt with the human rights abuses committed under military rule by protecting those involved form prosecution with amnesty laws, acknowledging the crimes committed on victims of torture by establishing truth commissions, compensating families of victims, and in some instance eventually repealing the amnesty laws to bring about justice. The Brazilian and Argentinian government

Pakistan is Better of Ruled by a Dictator than by a Democratically Elected Government

1384 words - 6 pages against the internal threats. For example, Bhutto rigged the elections during his tenure leaving behind his integrity which led to mass protest against him and military came in because even the fellow political parties preferred the military rule rather than democratic.(General Elections, 1977). Secondly, the military has had high prestige in the eyes of the people because of the Kashmir issue and ever present Indian threat, so it is not against the

Azalea Seafood Gumbo Shoppe

867 words - 3 pages 1.What is competition like in the value added seafood industry? Companies use either their own staff to market and sell products to grocers and restaurants. Producers also use a variety of independent contractors to sell their products for them (15%-20%). A lot of consolidation has taken place reducing food brokers from 2,500 to 200 in ten years. Most of the consolidations include food producers and food retailers merging together. Small brokers

DEMOCRAY’S RELEVANCE IN FACE OF NEW GLOBAL THREATS - hindu higher secondary school - essay

988 words - 4 pages DEMOCRAY’S RELEVANCE IN FACE OF NEW GLOBAL THREATS In 18th century, world get transformed to democratic system. From that time to today, many countries struggled and formed as a democratic government. Now more than half countries are democracies. Like that, second transition started in 1950’s. After realising the importance of democracy, countries themselves developed mutual relationship and cooperation with other countries and try to form world

Politcal parties and their affect in the USA - GOVT 2305 - Essay

332 words - 2 pages Americans, Confront Global Threats etc. Now what I would use against the Democrats now knowing a bit about their Democratic Party Platform is that they focus too much on the people having all the power and control in government when it should really be the other way around for a better America. Now one of the biggest differences between the GOP and the Democratic parties platforms are that if you go to the site for the democratic party its filled

Fighting for Air: Battle to Control America's Media

1721 words - 7 pages . Klineberg does a fantastic job bringing into the spotlight the role played by the Democratic commissioners coops and Adelstin. These two have engaged in a successful war of mancurer against the forces of consolidation, although in the minority, on the FCC. They have done so through their willingness to go all over the country and raise awareness of the profile of the media consolidation issue. This has led the FCC commissioners to make themselves

A Strong and Free Society Needs both Public Engagement and Government Intervention

1200 words - 5 pages to economic needs and some social concerns, and public interest needs to be a priority . A strong, free democratic society cannot exist without the public’s engagement in social concerns to foster democratic traditions. Civil Society is a “realm of organized social life that is voluntary, self-generating, (largely) self-supporting, autonomous from the state, and bound by a legal order or set of shared rules” (Diamond 146). Civil Society must be

The De-Colonization of Africa

3515 words - 14 pages general population. Despite being better prepared than most, South Africa was in no way fully prepared, and as recent history has already proved South Africa has encountered problems with its transition to a multi-racial democracy. According to Robert J. Griffiths, "one crucial element of successful democratic transition and consolidation is an alteration in the pattern of civil-military relations" (395). During the rule of apartheid in South

Similar Essays

The Current State Of Mexican Democracy

1132 words - 5 pages According to Stoner and McFaul when the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) was defeated and voted out of office in 2000 this turnout allowed for a completion of a successful transition to democracy in Mexico (264). Although a transition did occur and Mexico does have solid democratic foundations, bewildering corruption, poor rule of law, and narco related violence have halted Mexican democratic consolidation. The current state of

Indonesian Democracy And Islam: Midterm Essay

994 words - 4 pages Despite Huntington’s view in the failure of the democratic experiment in Islamic countries, Indonesia has proven to be the contradiction that has successfully proven the compatibility of Islam with democracy. After the fall of Suharto, moderate Muslims substantially contributed towards the progress of democratic consolidation over the past decade through the rise of cultural Islam. Furthermore, having not attained the majority of votes in three

Nazis' Consolidation Of Their Power In Germany

2999 words - 12 pages Nazis' Consolidation of Their Power in Germany When Hitler became chancellor in January 1933, he was far from achieving the amount of power that he ultimately gained during the course of the Nazi regime. There were various obstacles to overcome in order to gain total power and to fully

Democracy In Latin America Essay

3430 words - 14 pages are considered to be the only countries that democratization did not achieve consolidation, in differ from Chilli and Central American. Firstly, K. Isbester mentions that democracy has a different meaning for everyone, as some can define democracy as a good aspect for development, on the contrary other believe that it is nothing more than voting after several years. Although, Latin America see democratic government as growth of a justice system