This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Title Ix Claims For Student On Student Sexual Harrassment

3684 words - 15 pages

Since the Davis ruling in 1999, the federal circuit courts have reviewed multiple peer sexual harassment cases. While not exactly the amount of litigation the dissent in Davis warned, there are enough cases to determine that the federal circuit courts of appeal are not entirely comfortable with the Davis standard. Although the federal circuit courts understand the general test set forth in Davis, they are struggling to define the vague terms within the Davis test. Accordingly, the courts have narrowly interpreted the Davis standard, aware of the unanswered questions. This conservative approach has resulted in very few winning student Title IX claims for student-on-student sexual harassment.
The federal circuit courts, while understanding the general Davis standard, still vary in their presentation of the essential elements of Davis liability. While some circuits focus primarily on the specifically numbered Davis elements--that Title IX liability requires that 1) the sexual harassment be so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it could be said to deprive the plaintiff of access to the educational opportunities or benefits provided by the school; 2) the funding recipient had actual knowledge of the sexual harassment; and 3) the funding recipient was deliberately indifferent to the harassment n125--other circuits also include an element that the school district must have the power to exercise substantial control over both the harasser and the context in which the known harassment occurs. n126
However, how the federal circuits have defined each of these elements varies widely, with several circuits commenting on the lack of guidance in O'Connor's Davis opinion. n127 Consequently, the courts have been left to search in the pages of the Davis opinion for some guiding light. What they have been left with is a dissent in Davis that warns of a barrage of litigation that will drain taxpayer dollars and a majority opinion that attempts to persuade readers that it is sufficiently narrow to combat this misconception while still offering relief to victims.
Severe, Pervasive, and Objectively Offensive
Understanding that Davis requires sexual harassment to be "so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it can be said to deprive the victims of access to the educational opportunities or benefits provided by the school," n128 the First, Sixth, Seventh, and Tenth Circuits have attempted to determine at what threshold sexual harassment becomes actionable sex discrimination under Title IX. While always a prong that must be satisfied, other circuits stopped short of this severe and pervasive inquiry upon finding other prongs of the Davis standard were not met. However, four circuits that have addressed the severe and pervasive prong represent the continuum on which most peer sexual harassment cases will fall: the Seventh Circuit found the conduct was not severe enough; n129 the First Circuit found that while the one incident of sexual harassment...

Find Another Essay On Title IX Claims for Student-on-student Sexual Harrassment


1509 words - 7 pages require to compete on the 21st century global job market. Second, the Registrar is responsible for the establishment of the infrastructure that supports learning. The research is expected to generate findings, insights and recommendations regarding how educational technology can facilitate student learning in the APUC. If that is true, then the APUC senior leadership may need to explore and adopt policies that could help integrate educational

Title IX: Creating Opportunities for Women

2885 words - 12 pages . University of Arkansas’ track and field and cross country coach, John McDonnell states: “A student should never be told, 'You can't try.' We are supposed to build leaders and instead we're saying, 'Don't reach for something.' We have an obesity problem, and we're telling college kids to go back to the dorm, sit on the couch, and watch sports on television” (Marca, par. 8). Many supporters of Title IX still believe that cutbacks of men’s

Men’s ASUFC Takes on Title IX

1471 words - 6 pages hundreds of thousands of females that are now involved in sports would still be on the sidelines as spectators if it wasn’t for Title IX. Even though Title IX is supposed to help more than hurt, it hurts men’s athletics because they are either eliminated or limited. McAndrews states that “as of 2004, over 350 men's teams have been eliminated by universities since 1972.” (McAndrews) Many universities have attempted to not discontinue athletic teams

Title: Personal Goals as a Unversity of Phoenix Student / This paper was a requirement for first year adult students returning to school

819 words - 3 pages Personal Goals as aUniversity of Phoenix StudentSomeone once told me that a goal without a plan is only a dream. My plans for the future are geared towards personal achievements and financial stability for my family and myself. To reach these goals, I would have to rely on my strengths and strengthen my weaknesses. The root to my quest lies in my faith, coupled with the unique learning styles taught by the University of Phoenix Online. By

Title IX: Crucial in the Fight for Women's Rights

3207 words - 13 pages not intend to hurt men and Title IX was revolutionary for gaining equality between women and men. Title IX was passed by the U.S Congress on June 23, 1972, and was signed by President Richard M. Nixon on July 1st, 1972. The first person to introduce Title IX in Congress was its author, Senator Birch Bayh of Indiana. Bayh was working towards solving issues related to women's rights in order to build "a powerful constitutional base from which to

Title IX Must Be Tailored for Today's Society

2093 words - 9 pages order to sustain those scholarships, universities must eliminate male sports teams such as wrestling and tennis (LaGesse, 2012). Supporters of Title IX concur that this is an unfortunate, but entirely necessary sacrifice. Many young women justifiably fear that termination of Title IX would have a thoroughly negative impact on the females of the future. Since Title IX was signed, the number of opportunities for young female athletes has

Case Study for Student Analysis

905 words - 4 pages Running head: CASE STUDY FOR STUDENT ANALYSISCase Study for Student AnalysisPeggy BarnettCOMM/215 - Essentials of College EnglishJerry BolzakOctober 16, 2003Case Study for Student AnalysisArthur Reed is doing an excellent job in managing both first and second shifts. He has the respect of his peers in the grocery business. His primary management dilemma continues to be on a yearly basis of having a dependable constant pool of summer replacement

Campaign Speech for Student Council

544 words - 2 pages Hi Everybody!!!!!! First of all, we want to apologize. We were planning to do an extraordinary speech, which was a skit depended on PowerPoint. By the way, we did not know that we could use PowerPoint until a kindhearted teacher STRONGLY recommended it, and so we did. But at the last minute, we were told that the projector and screen were not available. What a shame! We spent so much effort and time to make the PowerPoint and design the skit for

Suitable Job For A Student

5400 words - 22 pages Job for a Russian Student PAGE 5 Suitable Job for a Russian StudentTerm PaperIntroductionA great number of students and teenagers nowadays are taking part in living independently from the parents. Sometimes young people still continue living with their families, but try not to rely upon them in financial issues. Taking a student job is the mark of living life on your own, not depending on career, mood, or prejudice of other family members

Case Study for Student Analysis

921 words - 4 pages Case Study for Student AnalysisCarl Robinson is the new campus recruiter for ABC, Inc. He takes us through his experience at work that was becoming very hectic and frustrating due to number of reasons such as unavailability of the training room, missing important newly hired employees information as well as shortage of orientation manuals. All of this is making Carl extremely frustrated. In this paper, we will analyze possible reasons for such

Dowden on Student Centered Learning

658 words - 3 pages A brief comment on Tony Dowden's (2007) journal article calledRelevant, challenging, integrative and exploratory curriculum design: perspectives from theory and practice for middle schooling in Australia.Dowden's (2007) journal article is specifically orientated towards education in the middle years, that is, students between ten and fourteen years of age. In order to make recommendations for the curriculum design of this age group he examines

Similar Essays

Title Ix And It’s Influence On Facilities Access By Scholastic And Collegiate Student Athletes

1467 words - 6 pages . Sometimes it cannot be all about football and men’s basketball at universities, or even just the male sports. There must be that equal access of facilities by both genders to comply with the policies of Title IX. When President Richard Nixon signed the Title IX of the Education Amendments in 1972, it said “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation, in be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to

Title Ix: Protecting Our Right To An Education Free Of Sexual Harrassment And Equal Opportunity In School Activities

1254 words - 6 pages , Teddy) Many very prestigious universities have Title IX complaints against them too. On March 31, 2011, the OCR said that they were going to an investigation of Yale University for violating Title IX. Sixteen students filed the complaint saying, “Yale is a sexually hostile environment and prevents women from participating in campus life.” (Gordon, Claire) Harvard University, many sexual assault survivors accused the school of providing and

No More: Title Ix And Sexual Assault On College Campuses

1270 words - 6 pages include all of the children who are victims of sexual assault. The government has tried to combat these appallingly high statistics with various pieces of legislature, including Title IX. “Title IX is a law passed in 1972 that requires gender equity for boys and girls in every educational program that receives federal funding” (“History”, Part. 2). Title IX covers 10 different aspects of gender equality (“History” Par. 3 ). The different aspects are

Sexual Harassment Of Student Athletes Essay

2421 words - 10 pages based on harassment committed by students but also by faculty members. The difficulty with this situation is the fact that you cannot discriminate against a student based on his past criminal records to be admitted yet if admitted the college is responsible to have authority over the harasser and over the environment in which the harassment takes place. As stated in the article, “Title IX and Sexual Harassment of Student Athletes” gives