To What Extent Was The American War Effort In Vietnam Undermined By Public Opinion?

3132 words - 13 pages

The Vietnam War is viewed by the majority as one of the worst periods in American history. The Americans moved into Vietnam in 1954 under the pretence of fighting against an "evil and aggressive Communist regime"1. The government stated the Domino Theory as a reason for involving themselves in someone else's war, whereby if America did not stop Vietnam from falling to Communism then other countries would follow, and American liberty, free enterprise and security would be put at risk. It is hard to define one important reason for the American's defeat in Vietnam. There are many factors that explain it: restrictions on the military and tactics that the American army employed, coupled with the strength of the North Vietnamese Army. The war also cost a lot of money, which meant inflation, tax rises and America's economy suffering. The collapse of the home front and the lack of support from the media was cause for the presidents to retreat and was another reason for the undermining of the war effort. This information from home often leaked to the front line and caused the deterioration of troops' morale, also, the government was often criticised for not understanding the political nature of Vietnam, where no-one really understand or cared about the term democracy.The general consensus by most historians is that the military tactics employed played a large part in determining the outcome of the war. Justin Wintle's 'The Vietnam Wars' concentrates on the military aspects, and suggests that while the Americans had a superior military and equipment, the tactics they used were useless due to the environment in Vietnam - Westmoreland's search-and-destroy operations would have been an effective opposition to guerrilla combat, 'or would have done had they been able to take place in a sealed environment ventilated by the Ho Chi Minh Trail'2, proving that the tactics used were inappropriate and not well thought out by the army generals. Even Major John Fenzel in the US Army agreed that defeat was due to tactical failures, which meant that they could not compete with the 'multi-faceted strategy of insurgency and protraction'3 of the North Vietnamese army. General Bruce Palmer Jr. stated that Vietnam was '...a devilishly clever mixture of conventional warfare fought somewhat unconventionally and guerrilla warfare fought in the classical manner'4. It was not just that the American strategy was ineffective; it was ineffective in the conditions and against a strong North Vietnamese army perfectly adapted to their environment. Due to the absolute strength of American air power, the Americans were lucky enough to keep a good death ratio where the number of Vietnamese deaths heavily outnumbered their own, however the fact that the war dragged on for so long greatly deteriorated the troops' morale. Obvious tactical failures were the Phoenix Program under Nixon where troops agents infiltrated into Vietnamese peasant districts to detect activists, and while its effect was...

Find Another Essay On To what extent was the American War effort in Vietnam undermined by public opinion?

Vietnam Essay Public Opinion the US withdrawal

3289 words - 13 pages communism it would only be enforcing Eisenhower's domino theory. Kennedy's presidency saw an increased commitment to Vietnam with 12,000 advisors by 1962 and increased equipment. Under LBJ, Vietnam had around 200,000 US troops by 1965 . However, 1966 had increased domestic opposition to American involvement in Vietnam and as the war continued further, opposition to it grew. Although to what extent the lack of public support was the main factor to

At the greatest level, what was the extent of the US combat power in Vietnam? Is the US better or worse off because they lost? Is Vietnam better or worse off because of the North?

926 words - 4 pages The Vietnam War is not such an honorable and noble war for the US. It started as a war for independence, and then it turned into a conflict between the North and South Vietnam for the future direction of the country after the withdrawal of the French. However, the North was led by a nationalist, Ho Chi Minh, and the US viewed this conflict as communism versus the free world. It was similar to the Korean War, with a communist, Kim Il Sung, in the

To What Extent was the Cold war Caused by Ideological Differences?

1927 words - 8 pages mixed into this school of thought. Orthodox historians argued that the USSR’s expansionist policy in Eastern Europe and beyond, driven by the ideological goal of exporting world revolution, started the Cold War. According to Michael Hart, “the Cold War was caused by the military expansionism of Stalin and his successors. The American response… was basically a defensive reaction. As long as Soviet leaders clung to their dream of imposing Communism

To What Extent Was Lincoln's Leadership Essential to the Northern Victory in the Civil War

1881 words - 8 pages This investigation will evaluate to what extent was Lincoln’s leadership essential to the Northern victory in the Civil War? In order to determine whether or not Lincoln’s presidential leadership truly did influence the outcome of the American Civil War, the investigation focuses on several historical accounts of his life and presidency during the years in which the Civil War took place. His decisions during this time period, as well as any

To what extent did economic considerations influence the American decision to go to war in Korea?

2267 words - 9 pages Although Acheson's "Defensive Perimeter" speech in Jan 12, 1950 did not include Korea, when the war broke out the US was involved immediately. The aim of this investigation is to find out to what extent did economic reasons influence the USA's decision to go to war in Korea. The main sources will be books that relate to the Korean War. Internet sources will be used if it is necessary for the summary of evidence. In B, the changes of the American

To what extent was Hitler responsible for the outbreak of the second world war in 1939 ?

1716 words - 7 pages heavy. The populations of the nations confronted to the horror of the war were traumatised by what they had had to go through. The losses were counted in millions around the world with more than 18 million dead and more than 70 million soldiers mobilized. After the victory against the Axis, Europe assisted to a ravaging economic decline. The important loss of young men creating a birth deficit and an aging of the population were a problem for

To what extent was the Civil War an important watershed in US social and economic history?

1749 words - 7 pages The period in American history prior to the Civil War was known as the "Great Expansion". Economic boom followed the expansion of the railroads westward across the continent and southward into Florida. The Civil War punctuated Florida's growth but left it relatively unscathed. Economic growth quickly followed the end of the Civil War.The Civil War split the nation. It was the most bitter conflict ever within the United States. The source of the

To what extent was Germany responsible for the outbreak of war in 1914?

981 words - 4 pages Germany responded by the construction of their own Dreadnoughts. The expenditure of both Governments was well in the millions in the arms sector.The alliances did play a major role in the lead up to the outbreak of the First World War, even though these alliances cannot be entirely blamed for war they did contribute. Germany was part of the triple alliance with Austria and Italy, at the same time the Reinsurance treaty resulting in a Franco-Russian

To what extent was imperialism a cause in the outbreak of World War I

1289 words - 6 pages plans were unalterable and believed that the key to victory was mobilizing first, politicians were forced to quickly name their enemies as aggressors, justifying the mobilization of their army. As a result, in the summer of 1914, each European power sought to name the other as the aggressor and so justify their declaration of war. Nationalism was another important factor in the outbreak of World War I. By 1900 Germany had emerged as a dominating

The American War in Vietnam

1430 words - 6 pages Dominos. One falls then they all fall. People spend hours to set them up, just to watch them all fall in the blink of an eye. This is similar to the theory of what the U.S. believed would happen if one country, Vietnam, was to fall to communism. This is what caused the war between North Vietnam the communist lead government and the anti-communist South (Encyclopedia Britannica1). How does a war relate to a game enjoyed by millions of people all

To what extent did the My Lai Massacre shift the American people’s attitudes towards their government, and the American involvement in Vietnam?

2046 words - 9 pages . The reaction to Vietnam as a whole and My Lai were also quite similar. Some blamed the war itself and many were dismayed by the incident, and pushed for the termination of the war. In addition, the reaction to My Lai was so grave that the American army used it to train soldiers in the challenges of war ethics (Herring). Suspicion from the American public towards their government greatly increased, shown in event such as Kent State and Watergate

Similar Essays

American Public Opinion Of The Vietnam War

2336 words - 9 pages American Public Opinion of the Vietnam War At the beginning of the U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War, in 1965, the American Public favored the idea of war because they feared the threat of communism. Polls conducted in 1965, showed 80 percent of the population agreed with President Johnson and were for the war (Rousseau 11). The U.S. got involved with the war to stop communism from spreading throughout South Asia

To What Extent Did Realism In Photography Impact The Public Opinion Of The Civil War

2081 words - 9 pages A. PLAN OF THE INVESTIAGTION This investigation explores to what extent did realism presented by photography impact the public opinion of the Civil War? The Civil War was the pioneer war in terms of actively using photography as a means of recording. The investigation focuses on photography’s role in capturing the war at face value. Photos of major battles and scenes that exposed citizens to the reality of war will be analyzed, as well as how

To What Extent Was The U.S. Failure In Vietnam Predictable

1910 words - 8 pages American generals to lead them • Public opinion was very harsh towards the war, especially by Liberals and students • John F. Kennedy was facing enormous pressure during his presidency due to failures like the Bay of Pigs dilemma and the Berlin Wall, and tried to convince global adversaries and the general public that the Vietnam situation was under control • Heavy bombings followed in 1964 by the U.S. army • The Viet Cong answered with Guerrilla

To What Extent Should Governments Influence Public Opinion?

1549 words - 6 pages . Even in democracies like the U.S.A, president George Bush manages to convince citizens the good of international concerns like the greenhouse effect and war in Iraq, which otherwise they would oppose. The true question still remains, to what extent should governments attempt to influence public opinion. Governments should be able to inform the public, give advice, but never physically force anyone to do what they do not wish to. When force becomes a