This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

To Regionalize Or Not To Regionalize? A Study In The Politics Of Policing In Greater Vancouver

2733 words - 11 pages

INTRODUCTIONPolice regionalization is a recurring theme in British Columbia (BC). The Oppal Report (1994) notes 'at least seven studies' had been conducted in the fifteen years preceding its publication and four of these had addressed directly the specific issue of police regionalization in Greater Vancouver (British Columbia Police Commission 1978; de Haas 1980; Leighton 1988; Police Services 1990). However, despite generally favourable findings the political will to create a Greater Vancouver Police Department has not been forthcoming. In considering why this is the case the political nature of decisions to amalgamate police agencies in Greater Vancouver into a metropolitan style police service is stressed. As was noted in the report of a police officers' working group on regionalization of police departments,a decision on regional policing would be more dependent upon the political acceptability of the concept than upon a rational evaluation of the pros and cons (Police Services 1990, Appendix G, p.2).This is not to say that there aren't valid technical and administrative considerations, such as cost, accountability and efficiency. However, the decision to regionalize police services, or not, is ultimately dependent upon what Lustgarten (1986) refers to as 'political choices' and this is most evident within the Greater Vancouver context.The paper is structured in two sections. The first section describes the current policing arrangements in Greater Vancouver. These are considered in comparison to a selection of other Canadian cities and to policing arrangements in Greater Manchester, in the UK. Although the focus of the paper is on regionalization in Greater Vancouver it is also, at least in part, a comparative study in the sense that a primary motivation for writing the paper is the extent to which policing arrangements in BC vary from my own experiences of those in the UK . It is not a systematic comparative study but references are made to other metropolitan areas in Canada and the UK to provide comparable contexts. As Bayley (1999) notes, included in the benefits of comparing policing arrangements from different parts of the world is the way knowledge of alternative possibilities opens our minds to the consideration that, 'what we are most familiar with, is not necessarily the best way of doing it'. Furthermore, we learn about ourselves from the study of others in that it "provides a mirror in which we can see ourselves reflected against the backdrop of others" (p.11). As such, the paper is concerned as much with police regionalization in general, as it is with providing a definitive answer in favour of, or against, the amalgamation of police departments in Greater Vancouver.The second section examines debates concerning police regionalization in Canada and, in particular, the relatively reserved approach adopted by the BC government. The paper draws upon Oppal's (1994) distinction between regionalization, which involves the complete...


To Die or Not to Die, Euthanasia in the U.S

1666 words - 7 pages wrote to the Senate Health stating: "Compelling a competent terminally ill adult to endure unremitting pain and suffering against his or her own wishes is analogous to torture, (we) urge you to support and pass this (Death with Dignity) bill"(Roland, pg A11). There is much controversy when it comes to religion. Majorities of religions do not believe in any form of suicide, such as Catholics don't believe in any form of birth control

To Fight or Not to Fight ( Terrorism in the USA )

779 words - 3 pages An aggressive retort by the United States will have a better outcome than no action at all as a result of the terrorist's acts in New York. If you live in America right now you can't turn around without being assaulted by the media blitz on the recent attacks in Iraq or Afghanistan, not to mention a couple of years ago we were attacked on our own soil.Until this incident we had considered ourselves immune to any foreign massive attack on our own

To Be or Not to Be in the Gange

1486 words - 6 pages To Be or Not To Be In The Gang Tyrone walks into Jefferson High School. To him, the world is out to get him. His folks recently divorced. His dad, the person he absolutely admired and respected, had cheated on his mom. His mom met someone new and she moved herself and the kids in with him. The new boyfriend is ok, but he tries too hard to be nice, and Tyrone wants his old family back together. To make matters even worse, his girlfriend

Analysis of the Tone of the “To Be or Not to Be” Soliloquy in Hamlet

797 words - 3 pages The soliloquy that appears in Act 3 Scene 1 of Shakespeare’s Hamlet is easily one of the most popular speeches in English literature. It has been referenced to in Star Trek, Calvin and Hobbes and A Nightmare on Elm Street. However, this speech was not intended to be a lighthearted reference as indicated by Hamlet’s contemplative, philosophical, and bitter tones he uses while questioning the nature of life and death in this soliloquy. To

To Censor Or Not to Censor in The Adventures of Huckberry Finn by Mark Twain

1253 words - 6 pages fail to see the importance of strong language in literature. If we censor everything that might offend someone there will be nothing left to read or say.(1 Delia Llyod). Not only was Twain using this as method of conveying satire, it also plays a crucial role in reminding us of the past. Realist like Twain provide us with an honest true to life depiction of what life was like that history books can’t capture. It is easy to forget how far we have

Management Should Have the Right to Allow a Union in the Workplace or Not

1906 words - 8 pages reference tend to be against unions and government intervention hence will not want unions in their workplace. However, many manager and employees tend to see their workplace or firms in unitary term and are happy with their situations. So in order to avoid conflict management will provide a better working environment, decent wages and work flexibility. However, this perspective is market based because if the company with these frame of

Legalization of Marijuana: 125 Years in the making - To legalize or not to legalize, what is it going to be?

1635 words - 7 pages with new solutions to problems that you would not normally think of when you're not "high". A number of friends that I know are able to concentrate with greater focus on a task or assignment, while "stoned" or "high".Marijuana affects everyone differently. Just because marijuana has some beneficial effects on some people, that does not mean it will do the same for you. Drugs affect different people in different ways. Some people experience fear

Euthanasia: A controversial issue paper dealing with whether or not people have the right to choose to die. This paper is in support of euthanasia/assisted suicide

1257 words - 5 pages , terminally ill patients have the right to choose.The Hippocratic Oath is an oath in which a doctor promises not to givea lethal drug to a patient, or to suggest that a patient take any lethaldrug. In the past, state legislatures have advocated the medicalprofessions monopoly by not allowing unauthorized medical procedures and bygiving physicians control over powerful drugs. In return laws have requireddoctors to abide by the Hippocratic Oath which

The big boom of criminals in prisons. To Rehabilitate Or Not?

1935 words - 8 pages years to life for minor offenses simply because it is their third offense. The law was introduced with the intent to cleanse the streets and protect the innocent from potential criminals, and so far it has been successful. (Marshall, Patrick) However, this law, which has been in effect for the last decade or so, has created a critical problem with prisons being filled with minor offenders that are sentenced for long periods of time with other

A response to Aristotle's Politics, stating that all mankind is in the pursuit of some good

906 words - 4 pages are not slaves by nature. Although I understand Aristotle's point of view and pondered on it for a while, I disagree greatly in that I don't believe in enslaving any people. It is unjust and immoral.However, in part, I agree with him while he states that the relationship between body and soul are intertwined. Without one or the other, humans would not hold and be as complete or as strong as it could be. Connecting this to slavery, Aristotle

Land Use in the District of North Vancouver

2028 words - 8 pages and it is difficult to even get funding approved. The residents are worried that basic necessities in transportation and education infrastructure will be stressed in the long-term to the point of total inadequacy. The residents of the district see their efforts as a fight to save 'green space,' not only for themselves but also for the Greater Vancouver residents as well. About one half of the Mountain and Cove Forest recreation users come from

Similar Essays

A Case Study On Traffic Congestion In Vancouver Downtown *Note That Grammar Is Not A Factor In The Grading System Of Any Ib Geography Assignment

943 words - 4 pages IB Geography 11 HLTraffic Congestion in Vancouver DowntownCommuting to, from, or within the Vancouver downtown has become a more timely business than it was in the past decades. This problem will become worse, with the increasing volume of cars traveling into downtown each day and the continual rise of residential population in the area. The number of cars commuting into Vancouver downtown daily has grown from 225,000 in 1981 to 255,000 in 2001

Do Philosophers Or Theorists Have Anything Of Value To Offer In The Conduct Of Politics?

2438 words - 10 pages contrasting arguments and ideas, set out to show us "how to live" in society. Socrates was an idealist, and Machiavelli was a pragmatic realist. I will discuss whether it is in fact it is true that philosophy or theory has anything of value to offer in the conduct of politics. Socrates' argument is that philosophy has something of value to politics, but Machiavelli does not completely agree.The writings and thoughts of Socrates and Machiavelli outline

Community Policing Policy In Order To Establish A Community Based Policing Program A Number Of Needs Must Be Met

3664 words - 15 pages 1997) This study was administered to police chiefs in which their communities were 50,000 strong, 100 police officers or more, and using community policing within their community. (Trojanowicz 1997) To answer many of the skeptics, yes, community policing works and is effective.A good example of a town transforming from a reactive police department to a proactive one is the Lordstown Police Department in Ohio. In 1997, W. A. Catlin, Lordstown Police

To Write Or Not To Write (A Discussion Of Three Soliloquies In Hamlet)

744 words - 3 pages to it. First being, Hamlet is talking about suicide when he says, “Or that the Everlasting had not fixed his canon ‘gainst self-slaughter. O God! God!” (Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act one scene two lines, 133-134) Agonized in such grief in the death of his father, Hamlet wishes that he could kill himself. However, being an educated catholic, he knows that if he were to kill himself, he would probably end up burning in hell. The second concern of