To Resurrect A Ghost Essay

3167 words - 13 pages

To Resurrect a Ghost

Cartesian dualism has largely been replaced by empirical theories of the mind. Central to this development is Gilbert Ryle’s criticism of an immaterial ‘ghost’ inhabiting the material ‘machine’ of the body. A metaphysical self is incredible, and even if it is credible, both it and its manifestation in phenomenal experience are unknowable by others. Failure of this approach occurs when it is realized that existence of the physical is just as incredible as existence of the metaphysical. Free will is also inconceivable without the assumption of a metaphysical self, it being the ‘ghost in the machine’ after all. As for consciousness, it is presupposed by the empirical. What counts as physical manifestations of mind are the effects or causes of phenomenal experience. Without this criterion the individual is a unity, it being impossible to separate the psychological since effectively it encompasses every aspect of the individual. Additionally, it is in phenomenal experience that the empirical is observed, and observation is the basis of empirical verification. To advocate the scientific method of intersubjective verification while denying the existence or significance of the phenomenal is inconsistent. At root, the mental attributes are ontologically distinct. Limited to only one ontological substance, empiricists either redefine or exclude troublesome attributes, commiting the error of confusing distinct kinds of substances. Dualism can accommodate all of the properties of mind in a single coherent theory by acknowledging these kinds of substances.

I

Perhaps the most influential recent philosopher of mind is Gilbert Ryle. Beginning with his criticism of Cartesian dualism, empiricism has come to dominate current thinking on the nature of mind. Basic to this evolution is Ryle's position is that "the dogma of the Ghost in the Machine" confuses one logical with another. Mind is physical rather than metaphysical, there being no other way to account for knowledge of other minds.

What Ryle and other empiricists fail to recognize is that there is no category error in accepting a "ghost in the machine." Such an error occurs only if setting out to resolve a particular problem, that of other minds. But psychological dualism is concerned with more than this, the issue of other minds being only an aspect of a more comprehensive theory of mind. To focus simply on other minds as Ryle does, is to ignore or deny the other mental features encompassed by a dualist theory.

Three aspects are contained in dualism, each presupposing an ontologically different kind of substance. Free will is accounted for by a metaphysical self, consciousness by phenomenal events, and knowledge of other minds by empirical events. Ryle accuses dualists of misconstruing one kind with different kinds, when it is he who commits the category error of misconstruing different kinds with one kind.

What lies at the basis of the metaphysical self is free will....

Find Another Essay On To Resurrect a Ghost

Revenge in "Hamlet" Essay

2245 words - 9 pages spirit and addresses the ghost, “That I will speak to thee, I’ll call thee Hamlet, King father royal dane” (Shakespeare I.IV. 44-45). Hamlet is a man with strong filial love. His love towards his father is illustrated in the beginning of the play, as he mourns so deeply. It is because of this love, that Hamlet confronts with the ghost which reveals the murder of

The Ghost: Bona fide or Bogus?

977 words - 4 pages The Ghost: Bona fide or Bogus? In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, the ghost of Hamlet’s father is intended to be seen as a real ghost. Around 1600, when the play Hamlet was written, many people believed in mystical creatures like witches, monsters, and most importantly: ghosts. With so many people believing in these characters, it makes sense that Shakespeare portrays the ghost of Hamlet’s father as a real figure. Many examples support this

Julius Caesar's Ghost

610 words - 2 pages Julius Caesar's GhostDue to the fact that many people in the ancient Roman era believed in the super natural. Julius Caesar's ghost plays a crucial roll in the play, Julius Caesar. Caesar's ghost is very important to this literary work because not only does the ghost visit Brutus and convince him to travel to Philippi, but it also "controls" the rest of the play, and he rests when Brutus is finally dead.We are first introduced to the ghost when

Julius Caesar's Ghost

610 words - 2 pages Julius Caesar's GhostDue to the fact that many people in the ancient Roman era believed in the super natural. Julius Caesar's ghost plays a crucial roll in the play, Julius Caesar. Caesar's ghost is very important to this literary work because not only does the ghost visit Brutus and convince him to travel to Philippi, but it also "controls" the rest of the play, and he rests when Brutus is finally dead.We are first introduced to the ghost when

Shakespeares Definition Of A Ghost

1082 words - 4 pages Shakespeare's Definition of a Ghost      The American Heritage Dictionary, published in 1973, defines a ghost as, "the spirit or shade of a dead person, supposed to haunt living persons or former habitats." Unfortunately, this simple definition does not explain where a ghost comes from or why it haunts. When used in the context of Shakespeare's Hamlet, this definition seems to suggest that the ghost who

Shakespeare's Definition Of A Ghost

1165 words - 5 pages Shakespeare's Definition of a GhostThe American Heritage Dictionary, published in 1973, defines a ghost as, 'the spirit or shade of a dead person, supposed to haunt living persons or former habitats.' Unfortunately, this simple definition does not explain where a ghost comes from or why it haunts. When used in the context of Shakespeare's Hamlet, this definition seems to suggest that the ghost who visits Hamlet truly is his dead father seeking

Why did the American Frontier Close?

864 words - 3 pages came the 'battle' of Sand Creek where, entirely unprovoked, and group of US soldiers brutally slaughtered a small group of who were performing a ceremony called the Ghost Dance, which they believed would make the whit men's bullets pass straight through them, and resurrect the deceased Indians who would help them win back their sacred land. No one was left alive; Sand Creek was to be the last battle ever fought for the Plains.In conclusion I

Supernatural used to Present Morality in "Hamlet".

1192 words - 5 pages many audiences to help hold curiosity in the plot ("Supernatural" 1). In Shakespeare's "Hamlet", ghosts are used to provide action and serve as an important role in the play. Shakespeare used a ghost to test the audience's morality. "Hamlet" told a story that sets up an argument for good or bad. Hamlet listened to a ghost that guided him into a series of events that ultimately lead to his death. Whether the ghost was real or a product of his

Significance of the Ghost to William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1872 words - 7 pages Significance of the Ghost to William Shakespeare's Hamlet In Shakespeare's 'Hamlet', the ghost plays a key role in influencing the destinies of the other characters. The ghost is important to the play as it symbolizes both fate and catalyses the plot. It also brings the play into the revenge tragedy genre, which allows foreshadowing to occur and helps the audience, both Elizabethan and contemporary to better

Hamlet analysis

734 words - 3 pages In Act 1 Scene 5 of Shakespeare's Hamlet, the ghost of King Hamlet can be portrayed as either, a harsh, mean, and demanding father or a caring, nice, and understanding dad. This depends on how you manipulate the lighting, actions, which includes speech, and other special effects.By manipulating the lighting on the ghost of King Hamlet, he can be presented as either a demanding and harsh father or a caring and understanding dad. To present the

Contrast of Hamlet – Gibson and Branagh

558 words - 2 pages . This put a focus on the emotion and tone of the ghost. In the Gibson version, the zoom was focused on the faces of the characters only. In the Branagh version, the lighting was bright on the face of the ghost, as to create the feel that the ghost was not human. In the Gibson version, the lighting was faded on the ghost, as to create a sad emotion of the ghost.The second difference between the two films is the setting in which each scene takes

Similar Essays

Macbeth Presenting The Ghost Scene [If You Were A Movie/Play Director, How Would You Present The Banquet Scene In Macbeth? Would You Choose To Make The Ghost Visible Or Invisible?

1397 words - 6 pages Directing a movie or a play is never easy, especially when the movie or play is based on a Shakespearean work. In Macbeth, for example, there are quite a number of challenges, one of the main ones being the Banquet Scene in which Banquo's ghost appears before Macbeth. To make the ghost visible or to leave it to the imagination? That is the question.Fortunately, there are many different possibilities. Some might suggest casting an actor, others

King Hamlet's Ambiguous Ghost Essay

2480 words - 10 pages In discussions pertaining to the nature of Hamlet’s ghost, there is much debate. On the one hand, authors such as W.W. Greg believe that Hamlet’s ghost was merely a hallucination, but on the other hand, Maurice Egan believes that Hamlet’s ghost was a real character who truly existed. Egan also contends that the ghost is sent from purgatory, however, authors such as Roy Battenhouse believe that the ghost is pagan and came from hell. Others

The Meaning Of The Ghost In Hamlet By Shakespeare

798 words - 3 pages In traditional and modern, ghost reflects death and fear, and it never change. In Hamlet, the ghost is a symbol of Hamlet’s father who is killed by Claudius. Its propose is to demand Hamlet to avenge its death. Although the ghost only appears three times in front of Hamlet, it is a specify role to develop the whole story and plot. Through Hamlet, the ghost is the motive to make Hamlet kill Claudius, and the ghost plays a critical role to

Hamlet Essay

695 words - 3 pages The Spirit of King Hamlet In the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, Hamlet's attitude toward the ghost changed with his new experiences throughout the play. His initial reaction was to agree with what the ghost had asked him to do. As the play progressed, Hamlet began to have second thoughts about the ghost's request. Finally after a great deal of contemplation, Hamlet recognized that the ghost's desires were realistic. Hamlet acted upon his