This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

To What Extent Can The Aeneid Be Viewed As A Tragedy? Answer With Reference To The: Destruction Of Troy And Its People; Suffering Of Aeneas; Suffering And Death Of Dido?

599 words - 2 pages

Apart from the events of Book IV, the Aeneid cannot be viewed as a tragedy to the extent of classifying it as a tragedy. Instead, whilst it contains certain elements of tragedy, the epic nature of the story and the final victory of Aeneas over Turnus draws a sharp contrast between the elements typical to tragic literature.The Greeks, creators of tragedy, defined it as a work that summons in the audience feelings of pity for the character, and fear that such events could also happen to them, as is the case of Sophocle's Oedipus, Aeschylus' Niobe, and all great Greek tragedy. The Aeneid however, while it begins with elements of tragedy, becomes less and less attached to tragedy as the story proceeds. At no point in the story, excepting the character of Dido in book IV, does the reader feel both these emotions for a character in the story.For example, when the city of Troy is destroyed in book II, the reader feels a certain pity for Aeneas as he flees his burning city. However, the fear of such events happening to them is not present, as the reader is aware that this is happening to the Trojans and to Aeneas because of divine influence. A large part of the reason for Troy's fall is that the many gods side with the Greeks, in particular Juno. Her hate for Aeneas is well known to the reader, due to the incident with Ganymede and the fact he is destined to destroy her town of Carthage. Because the reader is in no way poised to be in any of those situations, they can but feel pity for Aeneas who is. Also, the impact of the sack of Troy on the inhabitants in general does not satisfy the requirements of tragedy in that it...

Find Another Essay On To what extent can the Aeneid be viewed as a tragedy? Answer with reference to the: Destruction of Troy and its people; suffering of Aeneas; suffering and death of Dido?

Could herbal medicines be the answer to your suffering?

1191 words - 5 pages of the immune system in preventing colds and flu. It is also mildly antibacterial and is used in healing wounds. As a preventative, six to nine millimeters of expressed juice should be taken daily.Ginkgo, or Ginkgo biloba, has many benefits to its use. It increases blood circulation and is thought to be an antioxidant. Studies have confirmed it can treat a wide variety of conditions having to do with aging, such as memory loss and poor

How does Aeneas present himself and his people in Book 2 of the Aeneid?

2954 words - 12 pages The second book of Virgil's Aeneid is the account of the sack of Troy from Aeneas' point of view. Since Aeneas is the narrator, the characterisation of him and his men is particularly interesting because it demonstrates the way in which Virgil intended his future founder of the Roman race to portray himself in the face of adversity. As a result Virgil is able to emphasise the bravery of the Trojans in contrast with the merciless Greeks, showing

To what extent can Lady Macbeth be considered the fourth witch in Macbeth? Support your answer with reference to the text

539 words - 2 pages To what extent can Lady Macbeth be considered the fourth witch in Macbeth? Support your answer with close reference to the text.Lady Macbeth can be considered the fourth witch in Macbeth to a great extent.Firstly, Lady Macbeth is wicked. She calls upon "thick night and pall thee in the dunnest smoke of hell" so that her "keen knife" will be unable to see "the wound it makes". Although her senses are so alive and acute, Lady Macbeth's speech is

The Importance of Jesus' Suffering, Death, and Resurection

1348 words - 5 pages The Importance of Jesus' Suffering, Death, and Resurection C.s Lewis wrote these words as he watched his wife die of cancer. '' Pain is God's megaphone to rouse a deaf world. We can/are like blocks of stone out of which sculptors carve the forms of men. The blows of his chisel, which hurt us so much, are what makes us perfect. We think that our childish toys bring us all the happiness that there is and our

Suffering Death and Resurrection of Jesus Christ

1158 words - 5 pages have the choice to live and to have their beliefs. Martin Luther King is an example of someone who stood up for what he believed to be right and was prepared to die for this belief. He was the leader of the battle against racism in America and was assassinated by someone who did not agree with him. This case shows that dying for your beliefs can work as racism is nowhere near as big a problem as it once was. Some people

Destiny,Love,and Suffering in the "Aeneid" by Virgil

646 words - 3 pages thwart any attempts Juno makes against Aeneas. In the guise of young Ascanius, Aeneas's son, the spell is woven. Dido feels her heart warming to Aeneas as he tells of the fall of Troy and his sea wanderings. She tells Aeneas that his people are welcome in Carthage. Juno, never to miss an opportunity, plots with Venus. Together they arrange a storm for Aeneas and Dido to encounter.Aeneas is careless in starting a relationship with Dido, knowing

To what extent was Stalin's rule a disaster for the Soviet Union and its people?

915 words - 4 pages controlled the people more than before. This was not ruinous for Stalin as the peasants could not control the prices of their produce and charge the state excessive amounts.The purges were an absolute catastrophe for the people of Russia, with the exception of Stalin securing his absolute rule. Approximately twenty million people died as a result of the horrific purges. In the early 1930's, Stalin began to realise that there was growing opposition

Death and Destruction in Lord of the Flies and the Tragedy of Macbeth

832 words - 4 pages Tragedy of Macbeth, Macbeth also causes the death of many based on his misjudgment about the witches’ enticing prophecies, which in effect, leads to harmtia- the hero’s tragic flaw and downfall. This is evident as Macbeth admits, ‘Accursèd be that tongue that tells me so, For it hath cow'd my better part of man! And be these juggling fiends no more believed, That palter with us in a double sense.’(5.8.21-24) Therefore, death occurs not only by

To what extent was the colonization of Argentina good for its people?

1348 words - 5 pages satisfactory for the people of Argentina. By revealing the points of view of both the European colonizers and the native indigenous people and discussing different pieces of evidence I will answer my research question as accurately as my sources will allow me to.When Colombus' discovery was first heard of in Europe, a conflict arose between Spain and Portugal. This happened because they had both been promised permission by the Pope to colonize this

Bronte Uses The Character Of Cathy (Elder) To Suggest That We Cannot Always Follow Out Hearts And That Unbridled Passion Can Lead To Destruction. To What Extent Do You Agree?

761 words - 4 pages Catherine's life. Bronte uses Catherine Earnshaw Linton as an example to show what following ideals, over love can lead to destruction, evident through revenge, and subsequently, death. However, whilst this ending may have been avoidable through different decisions made by characters, Bronte also emphasises the importance of social class, and its influence on relationship choices. There is also great importance in the love story of Hareton and Cathy, that

Andy Session's "The Shadow People" - Happiness Can Only Be Achieved Through Suffering

1268 words - 6 pages , and how true benevolence can only be achieved through preliminary suffering. "The Shadow People" can be viewed as a short narrative, for it portrays the typical lifespan of a human being, going full circle from childbirth to death. As Andy Sessions states "The Shadow People" in line one, he is expressing that as a child, we are ambiguous, unknown, and vague, much like a material shadow. Because shadows are easily overlooked and extremely

Similar Essays

Destiny, Love, And Suffering: The Relationship Between Aeneas And Dido

754 words - 3 pages responsibility we can better understand Aeneas' behavior and the outcome of his relationship with Dido.In The Aeneid, the power of fate stands above the power of the gods in the hierarchy supernatural forces. Fate, to Virgil's Roman audience is divine. This, along with Aeneas' devotion of his life to his gods, fate, and his people plays a significant role in the destruction of his relationship with Dido. Aeneas behaves very honorably towards the

The Indifference Of People To Suffering

632 words - 3 pages The indifference of people is to behave or act as if something, someone or some event does not affect them or that they are somehow immune to it, or it does not apply to them, their family, or anyone they know. Indifference is to be without compassion and without sensitivity and not caring about or the denial of the suffering of others. Indifference elicits no response. Indifference is not a response. Indifference is not a beginning; it

Comparison Of Suffering In Job And Virgil's "The Aeneid"

981 words - 4 pages Elihu, he is physically alone. He begins to wonder if he is spiritually alone as well. The three comforters try to rationalize Job's suffering after they become mute at his horrid appearance. Aeneas always knows the gods are with him. He knows what his destiny is and what he must do to fulfill it. Even if Aeneas's destiny would have been for him to die a terrible death in battle, it would have been easier on his mind than to have no knowledge of

Is It Fair To Call Aeneid Book 4 "The Tragedy Of Dido"?

1927 words - 8 pages does suffer. Clearly the book could not be titled 'the tragedy of Aeneas', he sleeps with Dido and indeed falls in love with her which is undoubtedly his own doing, but the choice he is forced to make between love for a woman and love for his race is a heart wrenching one for him, and one which he did not bring upon himself intentionally.So can Aeneid Four be called 'the tragedy of Dido'? The action that takes place is indeed tragic for Dido, and