This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

To Whatt Extent Did The United States Fail To Implement The Policies Set Forth In The Monroe Doctrine During The Fifty Years After It Was Issued?

2133 words - 9 pages

A. Plan of The Investigation
This investigation asks the question: to what extent did the United States fail to implement the policies set forth in the Monroe Doctrine during the fifty years after it was issued? The investigation will be carried out by evaluating the policies of the Monroe Doctrine as well as analyzing the shortcomings and the failures of it. The policies of the Monroe Doctrine will be evaluated by how effective they were overall and the extent to which they changed over time. The analysis of failures will consist of discussion of specific events in which the United States failed to implement the policies of the Doctrine.
Word Count: 100
B. Summary of Evidence
The Monroe Doctrine was created to ensure that European powers would have no influence over the independence of countries in the western hemisphere of the world. Whether the Doctrine was constantly implemented or not is debatable, but the commonly held opinion is that it was generally successful in preventing European colonization of the Americas. Over the time period the policies of the Doctrine have existed, it has created much conflict with other countries as well as with citizens of the United States. Gaston Nerval argues in his book Autopsy of The Monroe Doctrine that “There was no problem with Pan Americanism, political or economic, which had not been, in one way or another, at one time or another, related to the Monroe doctrine or one of its multiple derivatives.”(v). The reasons for the Doctrine’s existence as a center of conflict can be split into the issues of its transformation over time and the instances in which the US did or did not implement it. During the nineteenth century, the Monroe Doctrine had multiple additions “extending it to cases not originally contemplated by it” (Alvarez 17). These cases include that the United States could oppose European acquisition of Latin American land even with Latin American approval and that they could oppose permanent European occupation as result of war. With the Doctrine ever-changing to fit whatever conflict in the Americas that head the US’s way, how would other countries see it? A.B. Hall claims that the document saw little resistance from Europe because of a delicate balance of powers and “the lack of sufficient incentive to compel a nation to face American opposition…and jealous rivalries in Europe.” (125). If one country went out against the Monroe Doctrine because of its failures or injustices, who is to say that other countries would support those countries against the US? Hall lists the example of England “who has been friendly to the doctrine when applied to other European Powers, has officially declared that it does not have the binding quality of law and this position has received the support of every European power” (112). If the Doctrine that defends against European Powers isn’t accepted by those same European Countries, how can it ever be carried out effectively? The credibility...

Find Another Essay On To Whatt Extent Did the United States Fail to Implement the Policies Set Forth in the Monroe Doctrine during the Fifty Years after It Was Issued?

"To what extent was the United States successful in stopping the spread of communism from 1945-1963?"

747 words - 3 pages developed shortly after, who were the perpetrators of the Berlin blockade, 1946; the Berlin airlift was considered a victory that proved the USSR could be tamed ironically. Overall, the United States were successful in light of their efforts in eventual eradication of communism. Through several different methods the U.S. revived post WWII traumatized European countries. The Truman Doctrine allowed Greece and Turkey to prevent them from turning to

To what extent did southern commitment to states' rights weaken the Confederates in the Civil War?

2718 words - 11 pages To what extent did southern commitment to states' rights weaken the Confederates in the Civil War?The reasons for the secession of southern states that led to the American Civil War were based largely on their belief and ideas of state rights (or "states rights," a variant that came into use after the war). This exalted the powers of the individual states as opposed to those of the Federal government and generally rested on the theory of state

Gun Policies in the United States

720 words - 3 pages “Our big concern is to make sure that guns get into the hands of only those who know how to use them. Guns don’t kill people. People kill people.” -NRA slogan. Many citizens believe in this quote but many do not. Some say guns should be out overall; although, this would change the independence of the United States. The largest issue is mass murders with high powered artillery. American's say that guns are killing people and if we had no guns we

Did the United Nations and the International Community Fail to Prevent the Rwandan Genocide?

1795 words - 7 pages Did the United Nations and the International Community Fail to Prevent the Rwandan Genocide?In 1994 in a period of 100 days approximately 800, 000 Rwandan Tutsis and moderate Hutus were killed by Hutu extremists in what was undoubtedly the largest genocidal attack since the Jewish holocaust in the Second World War. The tragedy lay not only in the events which unfolded but the incredibly disappointing response from the rest of the world in terms

The United States’ Relationship to Israel During the Cold War

2145 words - 9 pages relationships with Israel and support many Arab countries. The United States recognition of Israel angered many Arabs and made Truman to take a defensive standpoint in Israeli-American foreign policy. This tactic step back in support recognized that the Arab countries were the United States’ main priority during the Cold War. For the first seventeen years of Israel as a state, it did not formally receive any military or economic aid from the

Extent to Which the United States is Affected

908 words - 4 pages , who had visited China just days before to discuss the incident. The United States backed South Korea, and in an attempt to demonstrate its strong alliance solidarity, by moving ahead with plans for “high-profile joint military exercises.” China was also reluctant to restart the Six Party Talks because it feared that talks would further fuel North Korea’s unpredictable behavior, and ultimately strengthen US influence in the that theatre. Seeing

Was it Smart for the United States to enter the 38th Parallel?

1084 words - 4 pages war (POW). The problem proposed in this paper is for those like I who want a clear and cut answer to why the United States took part in someone else’s problem and was it wise for the U.S. to get involved. It is also for the military history enthusiast who does not mind a female perspective on the United States decision to enter into a place that did not have a true identity thus was bound to face imperialism because of its size, location and

United States in the Years 1860-1870

550 words - 2 pages . purchased Alaska from Russia for a scant $7,200,000 (Museum). The Civil War was by far the most notable event to take place. Abraham Lincoln won the election for the Presidency of the United States in 1860. The most famous battle of the war, the Battle of Gettysburg took place in 1863; the Union army was victorious. Five years later in 1865, General Robert E. Lee surrendered to Ulysses S. Grant, ending the Civil War. Shortly after, the Thirteenth

This is an essay about the New Women's Movement in the United States that emerged in the 1960s. The question: What did the New Women's Movement seek to achieve and was it successful?

2515 words - 10 pages What did the New Women's Movement seek to achieve and was it successful?The New Women's Movement emerged in the 1960s with a reconditioned society. Women were moving into the labour force, their education levels were increasing, the birth rate was decreasing and the divorce level and single motherhood were rising, leaving behind new situations and experiences that opened up many unanswered questions and a new consciousness . The Kennedy

Why Did The United States Go To War With Iraq?

1678 words - 7 pages become a democratic state. Now Saddam had not been the highest priority until September 11th because the United States felt as if they were dealing with the situation in their own way and did not need to go to war with Iraq, but after September the 11th that all changed when Iraq was looked upon in harboring terrorist and also being looked at as a possible terrorist country themselves.A Major reason of why the United States entered into war with Iraq

How Far Did Stalin’s Social Policies Change the Lives of Children and Women in the Years to 1945?

1428 words - 6 pages Russia rather than to show concern for Russian women as a whole, despite his motive women in Russia were still effected by Stalin’s policies, whether it was for the best is opinionated, I personally believe it would have been in the best interest of the Russian people to have these policies in the lead up to the Second World War, as we can see in Nazi Germany Hitler had been thinking along the same lines during the decade prior to WW2. In

Similar Essays

The United States And Iran: To What Extent Did The United States Influence The Iranian Revolution?

2323 words - 10 pages , Ayatollah Khomeini, became the supreme leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran, soon after the provisional government collapsed, in December 1979 (Stock). During the same year, a group of Iranian students stormed the United States embassy in Tehran, and took 52 Americans hostage (Stock). The United States government officially ended diplomatic relations with Iran in 1980 (Stock), nearly 30 years after working to depose Iran Prime Minister. E

To What Extent Has Music Piracy Affected The Music Industry Market In The United States Over The Last 10 Years

1409 words - 6 pages Music piracy is a developing problem that it affects the music industry in many different ways including being responsible for the unemployment of 750,000 workers, as well as a loss of $2,5 billion; therefore, I want to explore ‘To what extent has music piracy affected the music industry market in the United States over the last 10 years?’ To discover what is the real effect of music piracy I will first look at how the industry works and the

The Role Of Music During And After Puerto Rican Migration To The United States

1164 words - 5 pages The Role of Music During and After Puerto Rican Migration to the United States For Puerto Ricans, music served infinite purposes. It allowed for the formation and reformation of cultural views and opinions, through the lyrics in the songs. These views were constantly changing, which in turn fed into the ever evolving identity of the Puerto Rican people. As a vehicle of expression it stimulated thought and provided a method of

To What Extent Did Roosevelt's New Deal Programs Aid The End Of The Great Depression In The United States?

2097 words - 8 pages . Although President Roosevelt's New Deal program was not as successful as he had hoped, it did allow United States to enter World War II in a superior state. He was able to improve US’s economy with four main elements: civic uplift, economic revival, job creation, and public works investments . The different measures increased the quality of life greatly compared to other suffering countries. Contrary to other presidents, FDR chose an approach that was