To What Extent Is Life Imprisonment Without Parole An Acceptable Alternative To The Death Penalty? Criminology Essat

2799 words - 12 pages

To what extent is life imprisonment without parole an acceptable alternative to the death penalty?
This essay will identify and compare the advantages and disadvantages of life imprisonment without parole (LWOP) and the death penalty, to support the argument that on the whole life imprisonment without parole is an acceptable alternative to the death penalty.
The death penalty was created as the ultimate punishment for heinous crime. It’s purpose is to deter, to retribute and to incapacitate the perpetrator by removing them permanently from society. LWOP does the same. Two key factors which will be focused on throughout the essay are retribution and deterrence because these are the two main reasons why the death penalty is still in place in 31 American States (DIPC, 2017) and why LWOP was introduced. Incapacitation and public protection are also important arguments for both punishments. However, there is a complex moral debate at the heart of the issue which divides opinion. Logic suggests that LWOP is an acceptable alternative to the death penalty because it does not take human life, however there is a strong moral case to argue LWOP is equally inhumane for different reasons. Does society believe that human beings have the ability to change and should even the worst criminals be given a chance for rehabilitation?
For many abolitionists the rational argument for LWOP as an acceptable alternative to the death penalty is the fact it satisfies retribution, incapacitation and acts as a deterrent without compromising the moral implications of taking another person’s life. Abolitionists believed that the majority of criminals who commit bad crimes can change and the use of the death penalty as a form of punishment robs a human being of this chance and removes hope and does not allow for rehabilitation of the criminal. Many have surrendered the moral basis of their position and most abolitionists accept LWOP (Dow, 2012). However, LWOP denies the criminal these exact opportunities in the same way as the death penalty, with the added knowledge that there can be no hope. Is this a worse alternative? Depriving inmates of all hope resulting in individuals becoming ‘vegetable-like’ in their demeanors and taking on the I don’t give a damn attitude (Robinson, 2012).
Life imprisonment without parole is described as the ‘penultimate penalty’ after the death penalty as it is regarded as the severest sanction a court can pass (Hodgkinson, 2013). Before the 1970s LWOP was of little interest to the criminal justice systems across the world. However it came into prominence when the United States passed the LWOP laws following the Furman V. Georgia case in the Supreme Court in 1972 where the decision was made to overturn Furman's execution. “The court in Furman v. Georgia stated that unless a uniform policy of determining who is eligible for capital punishment exists, the death penalty will be regarded as “cruel and unusual punishment” (Laws, 2017). Following closely on...

Find Another Essay On To what extent is life imprisonment without parole an acceptable alternative to the death penalty? - Criminology - Essat

An Arguement to Eradicate the Death Penalty

2378 words - 10 pages , death penalty cases are far more expensive than cases where the offender is given a life sentence without the possibility of parole. In order to save the 80% of defendants falsely accused and therefore executed the death penalty must be abolished.

'The death penalty is justified because it - and it alone - pays proper respect to the importance of human life.' What is your view on this?

1305 words - 5 pages , without parole. While it has been frequently debated what kind of mercy this is in comparison to death, what kind of life then does it leave the murderer? To live each day with the knowledge of his crime and guilt eating at him? How much more mercy is it, to jail him in a living tomb, to waste the rest of his life away in monotonous toil, without the small pleasures of life others are entitled to enjoy, depriving him and making him suffer? Is it

Death to the Death Penalty

1236 words - 5 pages solitary confinement and can damage a prisoner’s mind forever. They claim that there are alternative punishments such as the life imprisonment without parole, which is a punishment in which prisoners must spend the rest of their lives in jail without any possibility of appealing to a different sentence (Source 1). The death penalty is used to punish criminals who deserve harsh consequences for their criminal actions. Nonetheless, there are

Death to the Death Penalty

1371 words - 6 pages . There are multiple reasons why one should be against the death penalty. For a society that wants to be civilized, putting people to death does not solve that problem. Thinking that its helping, the death penalty actually creates a whole new set of victims. Mistakes are made because cases always turns out to be innocent. The death penalty is often used as a discriminatory tool for poor, blacks, and other specifics. Like life imprisonment the death

Life Without Parole

1207 words - 5 pages . "Death row is not now, not has it ever been, a more economical alternative to life imprisonment, " said Spangenberg and Walsh in an article in the Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review (Pragmatic Arguments 1). "A study by the NY State Defenders Association showed that the cost of a capital trial ALONE is more than double the cost of life imprisonment" (Pragmatic Arguments 1). "It is estimated that tax payers spend about three

"There is no feast without cruelty" To what extent does this apply to "Twelfth Night"?

1010 words - 4 pages This statement by Nietzsche applies to a great extent in "Twelfth Night" by William Shakespeare. Since it is a comedy, there certainly is a 'feast' of happiness and humour and therefore, there must be cruelty. Cruelty is shown in a number of ways, but it often coexists with disguise and things not being what they seem. The characters inflicting this cruelty have an inner 'Appolonian - Dionysian struggle', which is the reasoning and orderly side

Book Title: An Inspector Calls (Drama) Author: J.B. Priestley Essay Title: To what extent is each character in "An Inspector Calls" responsible for the death of Eva Smith

1483 words - 6 pages are all guilty in some way, the parents refuse to accept the fact that they have wronged, while the younger ones realize their mistakes and feel bad for what they have done. How the family treated Eva Smith is but an example of how many of the upper class exploit the lower class, both physically and emotionally.Birling does not feel reprehensible about firing Eva Smith at all. On the contrary, he feels that she is the one who is responsible. When

Analysis of 6 Articles: To What Extent do the Public Actually Agree with Imprisonment as a Means of Punishment?

3679 words - 15 pages articles that have been reviewed as its main focus is on attitudes towards capital punishment rather than prison as a means of punishment. The only way in which it references prison is by suggesting that more people would prefer life in prison without parole than to receive the death penalty. Something that may come across as confusing about this article is the legislators assume that life in prison is worse than the death penalty. It can be argued

To what extent is the play "The Glass Menagerie" the biography of Tennessee William's life?

1241 words - 5 pages female attachments to his life. In a way Tom becomes the alter ego of Williams. Music was incorporated into the play, as it was an important part of Williams life where his grandma was a music teacher. The religious music in the play reflects the role of his grandpa being a referentWilliam's mother Edwina, a southern belle had great aspirations for beauty and is clearly linked with Amanda who often refers to her own beauty and ability to attract

To what extent is dopamine

1749 words - 7 pages , treatment consists mainly of a psychologic basis: cognitive behavioural treatment is an example. The utility of CBT has certainly been demonstrated. Nevertheless, if dopamine would be a component involved in addictive substance abuse, which this paper supports to an extent, then alternative treatment could possibly be applied. Focusing on dopamine only, a drug that would prevent the blocking of dopamine transporters by cocaine for example, thus

To What Extent is the Purpose of an Area of Knowledge Fixed?

1599 words - 6 pages This statement implies an assumption that areas of knowledge have one fixed purpose, however, I believe the purpose depends not on the area, but on the knower itself. Nevertheless, areas of knowledge do have some general tasks that differentiate them from each other, but these purposes may overlap. In order to investigate the actual purpose of the areas of knowledge History and Human Sciences I will attempt to answer the question ”To what extent

Similar Essays

The Death Penalty Is An Acceptable Form Of Punishment

3297 words - 13 pages capital punishment, it is also true that Americans are more likely to experience violent crime than citizens of other countries. Americans might not feel so vengeful if they trusted the judicial system to protect them from the worst predators. Indeed, support for the death penalty drops from seventy-seven percent to below fifty percent when people are given a choice between the death penalty and life imprisonment without parole plus

Punishment For A Crime Has The Purpose Of Deterring Future Criminality. Death As A Penalty, Has Been Given To Serious Criminals Without Solid Evidence Of Its Effectiveness To Deter Serious Offenses

2156 words - 9 pages defense costs (King 4). If California eliminates the death penalty, at least several tens of millions of dollars would be saved annually (King 3). Florida keeps spending $51 million a year above and beyond what it would cost to punish all first degree murderers with life in prison without parole (King 4). King says "a report from the Nebraska Judiciary Committee determined that any savings from executing an inmate were outweighed by the legal costs

Should Juvenile Offenders Be Sentenced To Life Without The Possibility Of Parole

1229 words - 5 pages still not fully developed, with proper therapy and teaching, a once rebellious child can grow up to be a very sophisticated individual. The article Should Juvenile Offenders ever be Sentenced to life without the Possibility of Parole (Steinberg, L. & Scott, E. 2010) states; “studies show that the vast majority of juveniles who commit crimes even very serious crimes grow up to be law abiding adults. And it is impossible to reliably predict which

Putting An End To The Death Penalty

2230 words - 9 pages as much as pursuing life in prison without parole at the federal level (“Costs of the Death Penalty.”). That rate is just for the defense and is not including the cost of the prosecutors. California’s outlook is even worse; the California Commission on the Fair Administration of Justice estimated $137 million a year is being spent on the death penalty system. With new regulations to ensure a fair process, the Commission estimated that the cost