To What Extent Was Doree Controlled By Lloyd?

1070 words - 4 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed

In Alice Munro`s short story “Dimensions”, the main character Doree has married Lloyd and wishes of ending with “happy ever after”, but ends up getting her three children killed by daring husband. Lloyd first appears in the beginning of the story with a very favorable impression. Even though he is only few years younger than Doree`s mother, he marries Doree and gets two daughter and one son. However, Lloyd`s image of nice fatherhood falls apart in the early stage of the story. Although Lloyd treats Doree kindly at first, but it is obvious that Lloyd is controlling Doree as the story advances. In fact, Doree is caught in Lloyd’s traps in order to control Doree which makes her loyal to him, but the relation between them breaks at the end.
Lloyd is certainly not a person that most people want to hang out. He treats Doree carelessly. Even in the story it is hard to find Doree and Lloyd in a good mood. The only place where the reader can imagine Doree and Lloyd smiling is when they meet at the hospital. As a matter of fact meeting Lloyd makes Doree loyal to him. When Doree first meets Lloyd, he is a great gentleman. He is funny, has strong touch, and authoritative. He is the perfect model for most of the girls and Doree likes him more than as her mother`s friend. Doree is now completely opens her heart and made Lloyd very easy to get into her. In other word, Doree`s first impression of Lloyd made her loyal to him. In order for Lloyd to control Doree, or make her respect him, he plans a well calculated trap which he thinks it would work perfectly. The crafty trick Lloyd performs is to win Doree`s heart with a sweet word: “He kissed Doree in the elevator and told her she was flower in the dessert” (Alice Munro 6). From here, Doree is going to be controlled by Lloyd. Importantly, it was easy for Lloyd to control Doree not only because his impression is attractive, but due to that the image of Lloyd in Doree`s mind is fixed with “nice” Lloyd. Even if Lloyd treats her terribly, this image of Lloyd helps Doree being loyal keeps being controlled by him.
Even though Doree has fallen into Lloyd's trap, he doesn’t reveal his true personality until their third children, Dimitri, is born. Lloyd keeps his nice attractive character outside in order to make Doree more allure to him. He decides to expose his character when his children are born because he thinks that even if he reveals his true personality, he is certain that Doree would still be with him. It could be said that even with Lloyd’s awful behavior, Doree stays with him because Lloyd controls her. Doree now fully trusts Lloyd and believes that he is the correct person. She is almost being close to brainwashed:
Lloyd had a certain way of looking at things; that was just how he was. Even when she’d first met him, in the hospital, he’d been like that. The head nurse was a starchy sort of person, so he’d called her Mrs....

Find Another Essay On To what extent was Doree controlled by Lloyd?

To What Extent was the European ‘Scramble for Africa’ Driven by Economic Factors?

2337 words - 9 pages by Europeans. (Except Liberia a colony for freed American slaves, and Abyssinia managed to hold out against Italian aggression). It will be my objective in this essay to analyse the economic factors which resulted in the almost complete colonisation and takeover of Africa, and also to determine to what extent the scramble actually happened due to these factors. I am of the opinion that the scramble happened in different places for different...

To what extent was Lincoln a mandate to abolish slavery?

998 words - 4 pages primary platform while running for president was to stop the spread of slavery, not to abolish it. His Republican principles were the foundation for his disapproval of slavery. However, Lincoln realized that slavery was protected by the constitution and that he did not hold the power to abolish slavery. The popular votes showed that more than half of the population did not vote for Lincoln. The outcome of the election was not a mandate to end slavery...

To what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King

760 words - 3 pages Ffion LaveryTo what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King?It is debatable whether Charles Albert was a liberal king or not. Much of his earlier career as the ruler of Piedmont was marked by contradictions and led to a change of focus and beliefs; this therefore leaves historians questioning what his true...

To what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King

760 words - 3 pages Ffion LaveryTo what extent was Charles Albert a liberal King?It is debatable whether Charles Albert was a liberal king or not. Much of his earlier career as the ruler of Piedmont was marked by contradictions and led to a change of focus and beliefs; this therefore leaves historians questioning what his true...

To what extent was the U.S. failure in Vietnam predictable

1839 words - 7 pages A. Plan of Investigation The investigation evaluates to what extent the failure of the United States in the Vietnam War was predictable. It assesses how this failure was predictable in the long and short-term and what factors were involved. The two sources used for a deeper study are from America in Vietnam, by Guenter Lewy and The army and Vietnam by Andrew F. Krepinevich Jr. Their origins, purpose, values and limitations will be discussed to...

To what Extent the Progressive Movement was Successful

1275 words - 5 pages improvements in the society through laws and other federal actions. Many progressives thought that the greatest way to reform society was through its schools. Public education had grown rapidly since the Civil War. Progressives had new ideas about the purpose of education. Progressive educators believed that children should learn best by contributing in activities where they can work on projects and learn at their own rate. I thought this idea...

To what extent was World War I a total war?

1118 words - 4 pages The Great War took place during 1914 to 1918, it was a global war where the world fought the triple Alliance, which was made up of Austria-Hungary, Germany and Italy. It was one of the first times in history where every resource and weapon was used against an opposing nation. It completely fulfilled all aspects of a total war, as all civilians, both men and women, were affected by the on-going warfare. Specifically in Britain, where everybody...

To what extent was Jackson a Democratic President?

702 words - 3 pages hatreds, and the extent to which his political positions reflected mere personal animus and disposition which is still debated. Jackson demonized many of those who crossed him, in this case, Cherokee Indian Chief John Ross. Jackson’s presidency was a war against a number of individuals and it started the moment he was in office. Andrew Jackson’s main goal in the removal of the Native American Indians was a statement, he wanted to create a...

Essay: To what extent was the New Deal "new"?

2689 words - 11 pages end of the nineteenth century, the many side effects of rapid industrialization became apparent and not all of those in its path to dominating the American economy were comfortable. One of the side effects was the decline in what mainstream society of the time had considered morals. It was obvious that many populists wanted to maintain the traditional values that were being eroded by saloons, brothels, and gambling. Their popularity lay in the...

To what extent was Hitler a weak dictator?

2153 words - 9 pages To what extent was Hitler a ‘weak dictator’? The debate as to whether Hitler was a ‘weak dictator’ or ‘Master of the Third Reich’ is one that has been contested by historians of Nazi Germany for many years and lies at the centre of the Intentionalist – Structuralist debate. On the one hand, historians such as Bullock, Bracher, Jackel and Hildebrand regard Hitler’s personality, ideology and will as the central locomotive in the Third Reich...

Was, and if so to what extent was Alexander the Great, cruel?

1223 words - 5 pages The greatness of Alexander (the Great) is often a much debated question. The importance of such debates is arguably minimal- Alexander was quite clearly a great ruler, possibly the greatest to ever live. A much more disputable question regarding Alexander is that of his cruelty throughout his reign as Macedonian King. In order to ascertain the extent of Alexander's cruelty one must analyze a number of key events which occurred during his...

Similar Essays

To what extent was Jewish resistance efforts helped by the allies or hindered by allied support?

1069 words - 4 pages Generation after generation, Jews and non-Jews alike confront the greatest crime ever perpetrated against humanity – The Holocaust. Individuals and nations try to comprehend how the larges and most vibrant Jewish settlement that thrived in Europe for a millennium was eradicated in a matter of years. Jewish resistance became fierce driven by the sheer will to survive from their oppressors. Jewish resistance coordinated with the allied...

To what extent was the vision of Cambodia underpinned by the ideal of a class based revolution and to what extent was it based on nationalist xenophobia?

2303 words - 9 pages Cambodia on a socialist model. But to what extent was this vision of Cambodia underpinned by the ideal of a class based revolution and to what extent was it based on nationalist xenophobia? The policies of the Communist Party of Kampuchea were built on a feeling of inadequacy based on the grandeur of the Khmer ancestry and the more recent...

To What Extent was the Cold war Caused by Ideological Differences?

1927 words - 8 pages mixed into this school of thought. Orthodox historians argued that the USSR’s expansionist policy in Eastern Europe and beyond, driven by the ideological goal of exporting world revolution, started the Cold War. According to Michael Hart, “the Cold War was caused by the military expansionism of Stalin and his successors. The American response… was basically a defensive reaction. As long as Soviet leaders clung to their dream of imposing Communism...

To what extent was the American War effort in Vietnam undermined by public opinion?

3132 words - 13 pages have been an effective opposition to guerrilla combat, 'or would have done had they been able to take place in a sealed environment ventilated by the Ho Chi Minh Trail'2, proving that the tactics used were inappropriate and not well thought out by the army generals. Even Major John Fenzel in the US Army agreed that defeat was due to tactical failures, which meant that they could not compete with the 'multi-faceted strategy of insurgency and...