To What Extent Did Southern Commitment To States' Rights Weaken The Confederates In The Civil War?

2718 words - 11 pages

To what extent did southern commitment to states' rights weaken the Confederates in the Civil War?The reasons for the secession of southern states that led to the American Civil War were based largely on their belief and ideas of state rights (or "states rights," a variant that came into use after the war). This exalted the powers of the individual states as opposed to those of the Federal government and generally rested on the theory of state sovereignty in which the ultimate authority lay in the separate states. Also associated with this principle was a sense of state loyalty. This strong southern belief played a key part in ante-bellum politics and in many of the sectional issues with the north, from the Nullification Crisis in 1832 to Lincoln's election almost thirty years later. During the war the state rights re-appeared in the Confederacy and affected the southern war effort in a number of ways.The first example of how the belief in state rights weakened the south was due to the reluctance to tax her citizens. The Nullification Crisis in 1832 and the rejection of raising tariffs after the 'Panic of 57' clearly illustrated southern views on taxation. Therefore Congress only enacted a tiny tariff in 1861 which in the whole war made only $3.5 million, and a direct tax of 1.5% on real and personal property. Furthermore, there had been no prepared machinery for levying internal taxing and coupled with southerners' reluctance to pay anyway this proved an added problem. Therefore instead, the Confederates preferred to print money (60% of funds) and suffer rampant inflation which by 1865 had reached 9000%.This inflation created huge problems and was a major reason for the loss of morale in the south. For example, conditions on farms deteriorated uncontrollably. Already suffering from the absence of adult males, the shortage of salt (only means of preserving meat) added to this hardship as prices went up from $2 a bag before the war to $60 a bag by the end of 1862. As the war proceeded, food became more and more scarce and this led to many desertions from the army by soldiers to prevent their families at home starving. A number of riots in protest to this hardship also emanated as a result. For example the Richmond bread riots in 1863, where a mob of more than a thousand broke into shops taking mostly bread, but also other goods.So therefore this state rights belief on taxation was a key cause of the huge inflation in the south that caused so many problems during the war. Its significance can be summed up by Jefferson Davis himself, "inflation is a gigantic evil that has seduced citizens from a determined prosecution of the war to a sordid attempt to amass money".The second example of how belief in state rights hampered the south was a two-fold issue regarding the protection of slavery. The first fold attributes the lack of arms in many southern armies, especially at the beginning of the war, to the insistence of many governors of retaining weapons...

Find Another Essay On To what extent did southern commitment to states' rights weaken the Confederates in the Civil War?

Assess the degree to which African Americans were denied Civil and Human Rights in the southern states of the USA in the decades leading up to the 1950s.

1000 words - 4 pages slavery.Modern (1500's onwards) slavery started when the Spaniards began importing slaves in 1517. The first African slaves in the now United States arrived at the English colony of Virginia on a Dutch ship in 1619. The slave population grew from then on to approximately 4 million in the mid 19th century. The Civil War was a major part in the lead up to civil rights as it was not only fought for trade tariffs and the doctrine on state rights but also

The United States and Iran: To What Extent Did the United States Influence the Iranian Revolution?

2323 words - 10 pages The United States and Iran: To what extent did the United States influence the Iranian Revolution?  Table of Contents Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………………2 A. Plan of the Investigation…………………………………………………………………..3 B. Summary of Evidence…………………………………………………………………..3-5 C. Evaluation of Sources…………………………………………………………………...5-6 D. Analysis…………………………………………………………………………………6-7 E. Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………………. F. Bibliography

To what extent did Kennedy and Johnson improve Civil Rights of African Americans?

1333 words - 5 pages little Kennedy actually accomplished as president but how much Johnson and the civil rights movement achieved thanksTo be able to compare and objectively see the extent to which these two presidents improved civil rights for African Americans, we must first ascertain what their goals were and if they accomplished them or not; establish the extent of what they did with president each of the surrounding circumstances.In the early 1960S, the drive

To What Extent Did Roosevelt's New Deal Programs Aid the End of the Great Depression in the United States?

2097 words - 8 pages . Although President Roosevelt's New Deal program was not as successful as he had hoped, it did allow United States to enter World War II in a superior state. He was able to improve US’s economy with four main elements: civic uplift, economic revival, job creation, and public works investments . The different measures increased the quality of life greatly compared to other suffering countries. Contrary to other presidents, FDR chose an approach that was

To What extent did the spread of Christianity violate Human Rights and Freedom in Africa? By Walubo Jude Tadeo

1919 words - 8 pages promoted slavery in Africa. The Christian missionaries were, because of their interest to promote legitimate trade willing to compromise with Slave owners once again. When they discovered that they needed to promote internal slavery and Slave trade in order to promote agricultural production for European industries, they did not hesitate to make the compromise. From the 1840's to the 1880's, they promoted what they called legitimate trade by

To what extent did the Spanish Civil war represent a microcosm of the polarization of European politics between the right and the left?

1987 words - 8 pages now officially polarised. The battle lines for civil war had been drawn.The election of 1936 is a prime example of the polarization of Spanish politics. Perhaps this can best be seen in the two sides respective visions of what victory for the other would mean. For the Popular front the rights victory would lead straight to fascism, for the right, that of the Popular front to 'Bolshevik revolution'. The election gave the popular front a narrow

What were the reasons for the Confederates defeat at Gettysburg and how did General Robert E. Lee respond? What effect did their loss on the rest of the Civil War?

1872 words - 7 pages unexpectedly at the small town of Gettysburg, Lee's men encountered the Union army, led for the first time by the newly appointed General George Meade. What eventuated was three days of bloody warfare, with one of the highest recorded casualty counts of the Civil War. Ultimately, Lee's Confederate soldiers were not successful, being forced back to the South just three days after the battle had begun. Failures in intelligence and lack of information

The Antebellum period. Speaks of what was happening in pre-Civil War time, reasons for the war, and differences between the Northern, and Southern states

1588 words - 6 pages The purpose of this essay is to show what was happening in pre-Civil War time. To show the reasons for the war. To show the differences between the Northern, and Southern states.The antebellum period started with the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution was brought to the United States by Samuel Slater from England in the late 18th century. He was a textile worker who actually founded the American cotton textile industry.This

The Southern states were in political and economic ruins after the civil war.

695 words - 3 pages Discuss the reality of the reconstructed south with special reference to the situation of the freed slaves in that part of the countryThe Southern states were in political and economic ruins after the civil war. Severaldifficult decades of reconstructing the south lay ahead. In the short term, theFederal and state governments needed to plan for the adoption of new state constitutions,new land policies, and rights of suffrage. The reform of the

How did the clash between states right's VS the Union contribute to the outbreak of the American civil war?

588 words - 2 pages , where Union President Abraham Lincoln believed in the union, a federal government and in one strong nation with a mission to fulfil, as he put it. The problem of slavery was a major contributer to the civil war in 1861. As the United States was a union it would have to make a decision to either go for slavery or go against it. As the majority of the North wanted the abolition of slavery and the South believed in states' rights as a means to continuing what they had done for as long as they could remember, a major conflict was inevitable.

Why did the Southern states secede in 1861?

1858 words - 7 pages on the farms. Plantation owners would make less money since most of the people working on the plantations would have to be paid. In other words, the main reason the Southern states seceded from the Union was to escape what they felt was a threat to their right to own slaves.The secession of the southern states would cause the bloodiest war in American history. There were less American men killed in the world wars than there was in the civil war

Similar Essays

To What Extent Did The Federal Government Contribute To The Civil Rights Movement.

1358 words - 5 pages political process, and that reform might been more effective or better crafted if the elected branches had brought it about.Congress' attitude towards civil rights was a mixed one because the southern states had a significant voice in congress and as a result southern senators and congressmen obrustucted civil rights bills quite often by staging filibusters, a technique used to expire the time a bill can be debated in congress by staging a very

"To What Extent Had African Americans Acheived Equal Civil Rights By 1940?" A Reviw Of The Civil Rights And Treatment Of Blacks In Pre Civil War America.

973 words - 4 pages To What Extent Had African Americans Achieved Equal Civil Rights by 1940?The civil rights of black Americans have improved greatly since the first pioneersof the civil rights movement began their quest for equality. Though most people associateblack civil rights with the radical movements of the 1950's and 60's, the African Americanfight for equal human rights had actually begun almost two hundred years earlier.In 1776, the white American

To What Extent Did President Lincoln's Decisions Shape The Civil War?

1866 words - 8 pages Section A: Scope of the Investigation The focus of this investigation will be: What are some of President Lincoln’s major decisions during the Civil War, and to what extent did they shape the war? The study will start chronologically at the beginning of Abraham Lincoln’s first term as President of the United States, and focus on who Lincoln picked as part his cabinet. The examination will then look at the start of the Civil War to its finish

States Rights In The Civil War.

1347 words - 5 pages The states secession from the union was a very controversial issue during the Civil war. Some people believe it was the rights of the states under the Constitution to seceded from the union when others believed it was unconstitutional and the states were wrong in doing so. What it all comes down to is the rights that the constitution gave to the states and whether or not their secession was justified. I believe it was. The relationship that the