Tolerance, Liberalism, And Community Essay

3297 words - 13 pages

Tolerance, Liberalism, and Community

ABSTRACT: The liberal principle of tolerance limits the use of coercion by a commitment to the broadest possible toleration of rival religious and moral conceptions of the worthy way of life. While accepting the communitarian insight that moral thought is necessarily rooted in a social self with conceptions of the good, I argue that this does not undermine liberal tolerance. There is no thickly detailed way of life so embedded in our self-conceptions that liberal neutrality is blocked at the level of reflection. This holds true for us in virtue of the socially acquired reflective self found in the pluralist modern world. I reject Michael J. Sandel’s argument that to resolve issues of privacy rights we must reach a shared view of the moral worth of, for instance, homosexual conduct. The view of community most consistent with our situation is a simple causal conception: we are all members of the same community to the extent that we inhabit the same world of causes, physical and social. Any attempt to call us to some thicker, stronger conception of community fails to speak to us in our modernity.

Liberalism includes many views on many topics. I will confine my attention to the liberal principle of tolerance: the coercive powers of the society are limited by a commitment to the broadest toleration of rival religious and moral conceptions consistent with the protection of crucial social interests such as preventing harm to others and preserving institutions of law and government. The state is thus to be neutral in the religious and moral wars that rage over the point of human life and the detailed ways of life worthy of human beings; but, of course, the state must keep the peace between one individual and another and between competing factions. This peace-keeping function requires that the state intervene when one person (or group) interferes with another's pursuit of happiness or salvation. In exercising this role, sometimes fine distinctions will need to be made, and there is room for worry that in the guise of peace-keeping the state will really work to promote a favored vision of the worthy way of life. Still, this liberal principle tells us what to worry about in such controversies, though its abstractness means that by itself it cannot deal with difficult issues. However, the principle of tolerance does not even abstractly address questions about property rights and the distribution of wealth, so here the liberal tradition includes opposing approaches.

The principle of tolerance is, if not the only thing liberals share, at least a touchstone of liberalism. Tolerance can be defended pragmatically, as a mode of living together justified simply by its success.(1) Or it can be given a basis in critical morality, in differing ways depending upon the particular critical stance of the defender. Both autonomy-based approaches and welfare-based approaches are found. I think that the approach of H.L.A. Hart...

Find Another Essay On Tolerance, Liberalism, and Community

The Classical Liberalism Essay

1096 words - 5 pages governmental power and private property. It’s main actor in International Political System From the Classical Liberalism point of view the main actors in the international political system are not only the states but also the non- state actors such as the United Nation and International Non-Governmental Organizations. According to liberalism point of view alongside the states there is a global community that operates and co-operates. Classical

Similarities and dissimilarities between liberalism, nationalism, and socialism

846 words - 3 pages and Liberalism were also slightly similar because they were about the people and not the government. Nationalism is dissimilar to liberalism in the way that nationalism primary focus is to advance the power of the nation.Another government style that came for the revolutions during the 19th century was Nationalism, nationalism was that people needed to be aware and part of the community. In the government system of nationalism: culture, ideas

John Locke: Founding Father of Modern Era Liberalism

1654 words - 7 pages provided everyone with adequate protection endorsed by the community while preserving the free will and liberty of each (A Discourse on the Origins of Inequality, II, p. 29). Rousseau’s account of the social contract does not reflect the framework of modern liberalism due to the fact that it stresses the importance of community, whereas modem liberalism emphasizes the importance of individualism, an aspect that Locke focuses on when discussing

Understanding International Relations

1597 words - 6 pages to the liberalism approach. Many scholars contemplates that liberal institutionalism to interpret international relations demonstrate the most convincing challenge to realist, however the realism approach could provide counter argument for the idea. The liberal institutionalism suggests that states should pool their resources and even yield some of their sovereignty to create interconnected international community which would assist in

Comparing Classical vs. Modern Liberalism

1673 words - 7 pages Typically Liberalism can be categorized into two different strands, Classical and Modern (yet some thinkers advocate a third strand that is referred to as Neo-Liberalism), each characterized by their differing and to some extent unavoidably overlapping attitudes regarding the theory behind the ideology and how it should be put into practice. Prior to examining how these relate to one another and before making any comparisons, it is important to

Political Liberalism

1110 words - 4 pages capacities and reap the harvest of freedom. For all members of society to make the best for themselves, it is necessary to place some limits on individual freedom." (Sources of the Western Tradition, p.173) Hence, if people cause harm to another, they not only hurt that person, but also the community. Again, the rights of man are introduced man is not allowed to cause harm to another without punishment. Liberalism, as a result of these rights, has

Neo-liberal model of economic policy-making

1898 words - 8 pages opportunity-driven pseudo-planning. According to the author, the “urban regeneration” which the Neo-liberalism supported, is more of a biased term for the urban construction which only created socially questionable and often environmentally harmful developments (Lovering, 2009). Looking at the absence of net growth in global employment during 1990s and 2000s while GDP per capita decreased, it is clear that the urban regeneration failed to regenerate


1559 words - 7 pages The term ‘liberal’ has been used since the fourteenth century but has a wide variety of meanings, latin liber referred to a class of free men, in other words men who were neither serfs nor slaves. It is implied in reference to openness or open-mindedness. The term Liberalism is becoming more and more associated with ideas of choice and freedom and the term ‘Liberalism’ denotes a political allegiance and made its appearance much later in the

The Transformation of Liberalism

2879 words - 12 pages Liberalism is a force that has produced change from the birth of this nation to the politics of today. Liberal tenets have been a basis of thought and action in American politics since well before the signing of the Constitution. Certainly, liberalism has had to transform in order to remain a legitimate force throughout the years. When considering this transformation, one may ask whether or not the ideas and goals of classical liberalism have

A Discription of Contemporary Liberalism and Communitarianism.

919 words - 4 pages Liberalism is the leading and background theory in contemporary political ideologies. As Bellamy states, twentieth-century liberalism has a broad area, from New Right conservatives to democratic socialists; it makes everyone seems a liberal. One of its major critics is communitarianism.Communitarianism sees individuals as strongly linking in community, and their debates with liberalisms are basically founded in the contemporary liberal John

A Personal Poltical Profile.

1791 words - 7 pages political information on each candidate and voted according to their beliefs, then I must have some ideologies and that led me to liberalism. Liberalism is the type of ideology I can relate to the most because ideologies are considered to be value-laden belief systems and my reasons for being liberal are based on the values of freedom, which relates to the beliefs of liberalism.Liberalism became a recognized ideology back in the eighteenth and

Similar Essays

Liberalism Essay

2790 words - 11 pages if the community was totally hurt by the king's will. Liberalism is also divided in two branches, liberal liberalism and modern liberalism.The modern liberalism stresses the importance of the liberty of each individual limiting the power of the government as much as possible while the modern liberalism gives more power to the government. The theorist Benjamin Constant, (1767-1838) stresses clearly the opposition of the classical liberal thinking

Neo Liberalism Essay

2002 words - 8 pages through lack of participation, community involvement or family support in the meantime, then it is neo-liberal justice. The absence of opportunity for state intervention as an alternative to economic participation within the article highlights an example of neo-liberalist ideology in promoting individual freedom. Neo-liberalism strongly defends the self-help values as promoted by Samuel Smiles and others, and regards government intervention in


1409 words - 6 pages judge of his deeds. Neo-liberalism argues that those involved in judging other in absolute monarchs are still men and if the government is to be the remedy of all evils resulting from men being the judge of their selves then the state of nature will be violated. Therefore, men have the freedom to be the judgesof their own cases.Moreover, people have the freedom to socialize and has the liberty to agree together mutually to enter into one community

The Concept Of 'metaphysical Liberalism': On The Philosophical Source Of 'liberal Democracy'

3232 words - 13 pages The Concept of 'Metaphysical Liberalism': On the Philosophical Source of 'Liberal Democracy' ABSTRACT: There have been many discussions about ‘Liberalism’ in modern political philosophy. In this paper, I want to discuss the liberal principles of political philosophy on the metaphysical level. This includes the liberal mind, the liberal consciousness, and the liberal ethos, all of which are presupposed in our liberal behaviors, and in turn