Tom And Mary Essay

1726 words - 7 pages

Tom and Mary
Mary is a patient in a hospital who is very sick. She is under the care of a doctor named Tom. Tom knows that Mary is going to die shortly and knows of three other patients in the hospital that could benefit immensely from one of Mary’s organs. Mary, who is an organ donor, does not want to give up her organs. However, Tom knows that Mary’s organs are beginning to fail and decides to take them without her permission and give them to the other patients in need. In this essay, I will explain how the case of Dr. Tom and his patient, Mary, can be examined morally using John Stuart Mill’s theory of Utilitarianism and the Greatest Happiness Principle (GHP) and Immanuel Kant’s Deontology and his Formula of Universal Law (FUL). I will also explain why Kantian Deontology works better as a moral theory in the case of Tom and Mary.
In John Stuart Mill’s, “Utilitarianism,” Mill describes his theory as, “… not something to be contradistinguished from pleasure, but pleasure itself, together with the exemption of pain (2001, p. 9).” What Mill is describing can be referred to as classical utilitarianism. There are three components that comprise this theory: consequentialism, hedonism, and impartiality. Consequentialism is the idea that only the consequences of an action matter. The second component, hedonism, states that the only standard for judging an action as moral or immoral is whether the action produced happiness or pain, respectively. The last component of classical utilitarianism is impartiality, which is the notion that no person’s happiness is to be regarded higher than another’s. These three elements of classical utilitarianism work together to describe what Mill calls the Greatest Happiness Principle (GHP). Mill states that,
…The Greatest Happiness Principle, holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure, and the absence of pain; by unhappiness, pain, and the privation of pleasure (2001, p. 10).
Mill addresses that there needs to be a distinction as to what pleasure is. He notes that there is a difference between mental and physical pleasures. Some of these may be more valuable than others. This is Mills biggest concern-providing the most happiness to the most people as a consequence of an action. This brings us back to the case of Tom and Mary.
Tom chose to remove Mary’s organs, against her will, and give them to three other patients in need of an organ transplant. This action had better consequences for the larger population than did allowing Mary to keep her organs would have. Tom’s actions also yield the most happiness since three people are given the chance to live rather than solely Mary. Although Mary’s happiness was compromised during Tom’s actions, according to the GHP, Tom acted as he should have by providing the greatest amount of pleasure to the greatest number of people.
The GHP determines morality by...

Find Another Essay On Tom and Mary

Tom sawyer Essay

1700 words - 7 pages Tom SawyerTom Sawyer is a boy who is full of adventures. In his world there is an adventure around every corner. Some of his adventures have lead him into some bad situations but with his good heart and bright mind he has gotten out of them. Tom lives with his aunt Polly, his cousin Mary and his bother Sid.One of the first things to happen in the book is a memorable one, the painting of the fence. Tom's aunt Polly made Tom paint her fence on a

Epilogue to Huckleberry Finn Essay

845 words - 4 pages When Huck said there wasn’t anything more to write about anymore, he lied. It wasn’t until after the adventure he took to the “Injun Territory”, with Jim and Tom Sawyer, that he returned home. He had vowed to let Aunt Sally “civilize” him for a year, in respect for all he and Tom put her through. Huck tried his best living the life of a gentleman. However, he felt the freest with the uncertainty of where the river would take him next. Huck

Huck Finn Portrayed as Foil

709 words - 3 pages , encountering many characters and obstacles. In the end, Huck decided to free his slave friend, Jim, with the help of his friend Tom Sawyer; however, Jim was already a free man and the two boys got into trouble by Tom's guardians. Tom Sawyer was a foil character to Huck Finn because Tom was selfish while Huck helped others, Tom viewed life as a game and acted irrationally while Huck performed responsible and purposeful actions, and Tom was socially

FUL vs GHP

1755 words - 8 pages The choice of what to do with a dying patients organs has always been a debate in the medical field. The debate of this situation is between a doctor, Tom, and a very ill patient, Mary. Mary is said to die soon and has deteriorating organs that if taken now are still viable to donate, but will surely kill Mary. The issue is that Mary still believes she will survive even when the truth is that she will die. Tom has three patients in need of

The Yellow Wallpaper

882 words - 4 pages Jim up as a “Sick Arab” so that he doesn’t have to be tied up all day. 2. The king learns about the Wilks family from a man he comes in contact with. 3.The king worries because the gold is $415 short and then he makes a “deffesit” 4.Dr. Robison thinks the king is a fraud because he does a bad imitation of an English accent. 5.Huck is determined to steal the gold back from the duke because Mary Jane is such a sweet girl and he fells guilty

The Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson

1732 words - 7 pages The Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson In “A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson,” Mary Rowlandson, a Puritan mother from Lancaster, Massachusetts, recounts the invasion of her town by Indians in 1676 during “King Philip’s War,” when the Indians attempted to regain their tribal lands. She describes the period of time where she is held under captivity by the Indians, and the dire

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, by Mark Twain

1626 words - 7 pages dead-beats” (200). He then writes Mary Jane a note telling the location of the money staying true to his honesty. When Peter’s burial is in session, the family discovers the gold hiding in his casket. This leads to the family’s realization of the king and duke’s fraud, and proves Huck’s pleasant intentions to keep the family away from further harm. Last, but not least, Huck is reunited with the exceedingly uncivilized Tom Sawyer. Huck finds a

The Misconception between Communication and Miscommunication

990 words - 4 pages with and eventually marries Mary, goes to meet her at their selected Windmill spot. When he wants to talk to her about the pregnancy, it quickly becomes clear that communication plays an interesting role between the two lovers. When Mary claims, “I know what I want to do,” she believes she is explaining herself to Tom, who obviously has no idea what she is planning to do at all, until he finds her throwing herself off of the building. This

Mysticism: Softening the Truth

1482 words - 6 pages responsibility from these women’s actions by blaming them on irrepressible heavenly intervention. His response is evident in the cases of Sarah Atkinson’s injury, Martha Crick’s portrayal as a “witch” and Mary Crick’s supposed heavenly revelation. Sarah Atkinson is an ancestor of Tom Crick, and wife of Thomas Atkinson. Thomas suspects that she has had an affair with another man and strikes Sarah in the head, knocking her to the ground and, in the

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, by Mark Twain

1627 words - 7 pages Imagine taking a great and adventurous trip along the Mississippi just a few years after the great Civil War. Well, that is a voyage that young Huck Finn took in The Adventures of Tom Sawyer written by Mark Twain. In this book, many aspects of Huck and his civilization or lack-there-of are brought up for discussion. As the reader progresses through the story, he or she will soon discover that it is not Huck whose civilization should be up for

Mary Crawford: The Satisfying Heroine

1640 words - 7 pages In Mansfield Park, Jane Austen presents her readers with a dilemma: Fanny Price is the heroine of the story, but lacks the qualities Jane Austen usually presents in her protagonists, while Mary Crawford, the antihero, has these qualities. Mary is active, effective, and witty, much like Austen’s heroines Emma Woodhouse and Elizabeth Bennet. Contrasting this is Fanny, who is timid, complacent, and dull. Austen gives Mary passages of quick, sharp

Similar Essays

Tom Sawyer Essay

567 words - 2 pages This story takes place about two decades before the Civil War in St. Petersburg, a small Missouri village on the Mississippi River. The main character is Tom Sawyer. Tom's mother is dead and he lives with his Aunt Polly. Other members in the house consist of Tom's cousin Mary and his brother Sidney.One day Tom decides to go swimming instead of going to school, so his Aunt Polly forced him to spend a Saturday white washing the fence. That same

Tom Sawyer Essay

533 words - 2 pages The Adventures of Tom Sawyer By Mark Twain This story is about a 12 year old boy whose name is Thomas Sawyer.The setting of this story takes place in the late 1800s somewhere near the Mississippi river bank. The main characters are Tom Sawyer, Huck Finn, Aunt Polly, Joe Harper, Sid, Becky Thatcher, Mr. Dobbins, Mr. Thatcher, Mrs. Harper, Widow Douglas, Muff Potter, Mary and Jeff Thatcher just to name a few. In this story Tom Sawyer is portrayed

Comparison Of Tom Sawyer And Huck Finn In The Adventures Of Tom Sawyer And Huckleberry Finn By Mark Twain

687 words - 3 pages forgets that he is a girl and threads a needle like a boy, throws like a boy, and even forgets his own name. “Sarah’s my first name. Some calls me Sarah, some calls me Mary,” he said. One more difference between Tom and Huck is that Tom is very violent and Huck is easy going and helpful. In Tom’s “gang” he said that they would kill everyone, even women. When one of the boys asked if they had to kill everyone Tom says, “Oh, certainly. It’s

The Adventures Of Huckleberry Essay

1227 words - 5 pages end of the novel, Huck finally allows himself to open up to relationships with friendship, family love, and his admiration in others. He finds a "brother" in Tom, a "friend" in Jim, and he admires Mary Jane.Throughout Huck's journey there is one person that is always present in his life, Jim. When Huck is going down the river Jim is always with him and Jim stands by him life a "friend". At the end of the novel, when Huck goes looking for Jim, who