This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Too Much Science In Walden Two By B.F. Skinner

1446 words - 6 pages

Too Much Science?

In the 1930s, Europe began to fall under the shadow of socialism with the rise of the Nazi party in Germany, the Communist Revolution in Russia, and the Fascist uprising in Italy. Americans tried to ignore this growing crisis in Europe for as long as possible; even some in the United Kingdom were not unduly concerned with this sudden change. Some people, including authors Aldous Huxley, were startled and put their fears down on paper. Huxley’s Brave New World shows an unsettling optimistic front that covers the disturbing reality of a futuristic socialist world. After the war ended, more novels about the socialism appeared, George Orwell’s 1984 and B.F. Skinner’s Walden Two as a few examples, though they are complete opposites on the views of socialism presented.

In Walden Two, the tone is very positive. The head of the community, a man named T.E. Frazier, explains every aspect of the thriving communal settlement to a group of curious enquirers. The party includes an old colleague of Frazier’s, a psychology professor named Burris, a philosophy professor named Augustine Castle, and two veteran soldiers from World War Two named Steve Jamnik and Rogers, along with their girlfriends Mary Grove and Barbara Macklin, respectively. Frazier walks them through all the workings of the Walden Two community, from the agricultural processes, sheep herding techniques, and work schedules to the moral code, education system, and personal relationships. He says that one of the problems with the United States government is that it does not use the scientific process to find out what the people of the nation need and want. He claims that everything runs so smoothly in Walden Two because the community is set up as an experiment, whether the people who live there realize it or not. A good example of the experimenting process is the education system that was set up in Walden Two.

Education seems to be completely opposite of the standard in American schools, even today. Frazier explains that the children begin their “ethical training” (Skinner, 98) at the age of three or four. This training teaches the children to have high levels of self-control and high tolerances to annoyances, jealousy, envy, and anger; emotions that are found all too often in our society today. The children are tested in many different ways to develop a keen sense of obedience; one of the tests involves young children who are given lollipops but are not allowed to eat them until they are instructed to do so. Frazier explains, “Then the lollipops are concealed…Then a strong distraction is arranged – say, an interesting game. Later the children are reminded of the candy…. A day or so later, the children all run with the lollipops to their lockers [and put them out of site]” (Skinner, 98). While most Americans would react as Mr. Castle does, with revulsion to the very idea of doing such a thing to a toddler, Frazier claims that the...

Find Another Essay On Too Much Science in Walden Two by B.F. Skinner

Too Much Stress in Today's Children

1226 words - 5 pages frame (Wiesel 31). Another, effect of stress is loss of sense of times as experienced by Elie here, “so much has happened within such a few short hours that I had lost all sense of time.”(Wiesel 34) Stress can, also, cause Butterflies in the stomach, increased blood pressure, fatigue, sweating, trouble sleeping, and trouble waking up (Veillette). These short term effects come in pieces or in wholes and can come and go. They have the potential to

Too Much, in Too Little: The Unimportance of Homework

1272 words - 6 pages Imagine. Just imagine. A chunk of homework from today stacked up on your desk. A two-foot pile of paper gone to waste, only to “reteach” what you have learned today in school, which is already seven hours of hard learning, working, and participating. Tired and desperate for just a second to get some fresh air, you glance at your watch. It’s eleven at night and you must finish every paper before school starts, or else your teacher will mark your

Positive Change In World Through Manipulation of Behavior in B.F Skinner's Waldo Two

740 words - 3 pages Positive Change In World Through Manipulation of Behavior in B.F Skinner's Waldo Two      B.F. Skinner, in his novel Walden Two, presents many arguments about how he foresees a positive change in the world through manipulation of behavior on the personal level. Sigmund Freud, in his works, specifically Civilization and Its Discontents, presents his view of human nature and what is innately problematic about it. Both Freud and Skinner

Science in Not Going Too Far

1961 words - 8 pages science and what it can do comes from Bishop, and he says, "Resistance to science is born of fear. Fear, in turn, is bred by ignorance. And it is ignorance that is our deepest malady." (241) What he means is that we are scared of science because we are unaware of what it can do. We don't realize that it takes time for cures to arise and that not everything can be solved in a year or two. That is where our ignorance of science comes in. What we can

The World is too Much With Us by William Wordsworth

939 words - 4 pages The World is too Much With Us by William Wordsworth I am writing this essay in order to give one interpretation of William Wordsworth's sonnet, "The World Is Too Much With Us". The poet seems to take the viewpoint of a Pagan and ascribes a godlike status to nature much along the way the Greeks did in their time. He then proceeds to use personification along with simile, metaphor, imagery and breaks in syntax to describe how we have

The Man Who Knew Too Much by Alfred Hitchcock

1013 words - 5 pages In this 1956 remake of the 1934 version of Alfred Hitchcock’s The Man Who Knew Too Much, Dr. Ben McKenna, played by James Stewart, and Josephine ‘Jo’ Conway, played by Doris Day, inadvertently get involved in an assassination plan after a mysterious Frenchman is murdered and their son is subsequently kidnapped. Hitchcock himself said, “Let’s say the first version was the work of a talented amateur and the second was made by a professional

The World is Too Much With Us by William Wordsworth

921 words - 4 pages The World is Too Much With Us by William Wordsworth In William Wordsworth's 'The World is Too Much With Us,' this poem heeds warning to his generation. This warning is that they are losing sight of what is actually important in this world: nature and God. To some people both of these are the same thing '...as if lacking appreciation for the natural gifts of God is not sin enough, we add to it the insult of pride for our rape of His land

Stress in Teens: When is it too much?

1275 words - 6 pages volleyball team. Giant amounts of stress on a young person will lead them down a destructive path. Sadly this problem happens on a daily basis. Some teenagers are excellent at managing their time whereas others simply cannot handle as much on their plate. There are many various causes of stress and even more ways in which it will have an effect on the person. Some causes of stress could include however are not restricted to: expectations from those who

Too Much Gun Control in the United States

1601 words - 6 pages      Do you like guns or would like to own a gun? Would like to have a gun for self protection if the time comes? If so the gun control laws could cause you not to be able to. For that reason gun control laws are way too strict. Some of the elderly that live alone look to guns as self defense. That is way is why I believe there shouldn’t be so much gun control.       Approximately 2.5 million times a year guns are used in self defense. There

Nature depicted in Walden, by Henry David Thoreau

733 words - 3 pages The excerpt from Henry David Thoreau’s book Walden takes us through Thoreau’s extended mystical experience as he attempts to discover how to live with the guidance and observance of Nature. In this excerpt he cherishes Nature and its elements. Thoreau’s primary motive behind moving to the woods near Walden Pond is to understand what it is to live. To him Nature sort of sets out a path to the comprehension of life. On this “path” created by

Simplicity and Freedom in Walden by Henry David Thoreau

1008 words - 4 pages In chapter two of Henry David Thoreau's Walden, entitled "Where I Lived, and What I Lived for", there are two themes that run throughout the narrative. The key theme that emerges continually is that of simplicity with the additional theme being that of freedom. Thoreau finds himself surrounded by a world that has no true freedom or simplified ways, with people committed to the world that surrounds them rather than being committed to their

Similar Essays

B.F. Skinner's Walden Two Essay

3161 words - 13 pages Is it possible for psychologists to ever understand the human condition well enough to create a utopia by "engineering" human behavior? This is the challenge thrown out by behavioral psychologist, B.F. Skinner in his novel, Walden Two (1948). Well written and entertaining, Walden Two is directed to the layman rather than to the professional psychologist. It concerns a fictitious intentional community of 1,000 started by one Frazier (no first

Carl Rodgers And B.F. Skinner: Behaviorism Comparison Between Two Descriptions Of Behavior

829 words - 3 pages B.F. Skinner, who favored the behaviorist approach to psychology, criticized the psychoanalytical theory by suggesting that psychology should be the study of behavior and not just the mind. However, Skinner's approach was radical, in that he did consider our inner thoughts and feelings, but denied that they had anything to do with behavior. His study of behavior involved close contact with the experimental laboratory, where he experimented with

B.F. Skinner And His Three Famous Ideas In Psychology

1534 words - 7 pages manipulate how often the food would be released in order to obtain different results (Iverson, 1992, p. 1318). According to James Capshew “Skinner discovered many regularities in the response rates of his subjects under various stimulus protocols and reinforcement schedules (B.F. Skinner and Behavior… Capshew, 1993, p. 129). It was found that a “single response could be immediately followed by a single reinforcement” (Iverson, p.1321). Skinner did

Creation Of Suspense In "The Man Who Knew Too Much": Directed By Alfred Hitchcock

1235 words - 5 pages Creation of suspense in "The Man Who Knew Too Much": directed by Alfred HitchcockAlfred Hitchcock is one of the most famous filmmakers of all times. His work and name will always remain know throughout all generation. Alfred Hitchcock is synonymous to fear, terror and mostly suspense. His outstanding cinematographic techniques and unique story telling ways are the main creators of this phenomenon, who is able to keep an audience in suspense