This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Topic: "Gattaca Supports The Belief That Nature, Despite Its Flaws, Is Preferable To An Error Free Genetically Engineered Existence." Do You Agree?

962 words - 4 pages

"Consider God's handiwork: who can straighten what he hath made crooked?" (Ecclesiastes 7:13). Such is the opening quote and the thesis of director Andrew Nichol's film Gattaca (1997). Although the film is based on the lives of genetically engineered human beings and the effects that such have on the "invalids", that is those who are "God-children", it deeply criticises the values of a society of "valids" through its satirical tone and the use of film noir techniques. Gattaca not only supports the belief that nature, despite its flaws, is preferable to a supposed error-free genetically engineered existence, but it also advocates that nobody should "tamper with" what "[God] has made crooked." Through the medium of the film, director Nichols attempts to encourage viewers that humanism can defeat genetics and that science has simply gone too far.Throughout the film, Gattaca tackles the debate over the influence of nature versus nurture, and ultimately finds nurture in the form of humanism, to be by far more successful than a genetically "perfect" birth. This is symbolised in the game of chicken played by Vincent and Anton, both as children and as adults. Although their mother Marie knows that Vincent "will do something" someday, genetics tries its hardest to prove her wrong. This is evident when, at the beginning of the film, Anton, the "valid" child, continuously wins the game as he is stronger and "has no excuse to fail." The paradigm shifts when Vincent wins for the first time, proving that the human spirit can overcome genetic imperfection and can emerge victoriously over a supposed high "genetic quotient." Such an idea is proven even further during the course of the film, particularly during the scene where Vincent must cross the road without his contact lenses, in order to meet Irene on the other side. The other side of the road can be interpreted as the "valid" world, and it is through sheer faith that Vincent is able to cross, disabled, and to make it safely to the opposite side. This element of faith underpins the thesis of the film, as it demonstrates the real motivations behind the characters and how success is still in the hands of God.One of the paramount messages of Gattaca involves the idea that "validity" in the eyes of humans in the film is not truly as error-free as it may seem. Take, for example, Director Josef, a "valid" member of society with "not a violent bone in [his] body." The brutal murder of a colleague for the sake of a project is not what one would expect from a seemingly perfect, genetically engineered human being. It is in this that Nichols displays for viewers how "validity" in terms of a "genetic quotient" is independent of validity as a human being. Nichols encourages us to consider the disadvantages of having such a motivated, success-driven elite class, through Director Josef's "invalidity" as a human...

Find Another Essay On TOPIC: "Gattaca supports the belief that nature, despite its flaws, is preferable to an error-free genetically engineered existence." Do you agree?

Do You Agree With The Contention That The Mixed Ec

832 words - 3 pages capitalism and the command economies. The capitalism is an economic system characterized by private ownership of resources and markets. It is also known as the 'free enterprise system'. Capitalism is determined by two characteristics that are private ownership of resources and decentralized decision-making. Among the key strength of the capitalism economy system is its capacity in achieving economic efficiency. This is because the competition and

'It Is Impossible To Be Both A Participant And An Observer.' How Far Do You Agree?

997 words - 4 pages Observational studies are a qualitative method of research. It is a method which we all, as members of society and inquirers into our own society and culture, have experience of in the sense that such an ability to observe and reflect on what is going on around is an essential part of our being competent in our culture. Observation aims to look further than this. (S. Ackroyd & J.Hughs: 127) It allows a researcher to study a group in its

Translations(Brian Friel)is best read as an elegy for a doomed culture. The only response it elicits is to mourn that culture depicted in the play as forever lost. Do you agree?

1623 words - 6 pages anglicize it. Hugh's belief that english cannot express them would suggest that their life, culture and feelings are embodied in Gaelic.Sarah's silence and Manus's attempts to encourage her to speak could be equated with the playwrights or the historians job in trying to get history to speak to us, to come alive, Sarah rarely says anything but her name, she becomes more confident at that but does not pass that point, but Manus is sure she can do better

"The Internet as an educational tool is highly overrated." Do you agree?

1550 words - 6 pages internet has the potential to become one of the most valuable and stimulating educational tools availabel to the multitudes, and its recognised merits as such are noe too few. I therefore do not agree with the statement that the Internet is overrated or its merits, chief of which are the unparalled efficacy of its research and news capabilities, are celebrated without reason.Information of practically everything in existence can be found and retrieved

The 21st Century is an era of greed. Do you agree?

960 words - 4 pages needs, but not our greed. For greed, all nature is too little. That said, it does not help that in the 21st century of today, as the human population continues to surge, we are constantly working under pressure, round-the-clock, to satisfy the demands of the globalised world. Not everything we want is what we really need; the standard of society is motivated by greed. It is irrefutable that we have entered an era of greed and avarice; the 21st

Do you agree that Hardy's Poetry is 'history that records less formally'?

573 words - 2 pages Do you agree that Hardy's poetry is 'history thatrecords less formally'?Hardy himself stated that '..the mission of poetry is to record impressions, not convictions' . This mission would mean the communicating and recording of information of 'the tenor of the age' (Haslam & Turton) rather than recording specific facts; Hardy's poetry detailed how time was experienced or felt by those who lived through it. Eliot's phrase of 'un-historic acts

To what extent do you agree that the widespread recognition of the importance of learning English is a result of linguistic imperialism?

1883 words - 8 pages To what extent do you agree that the widespread recognition of the importance of learning English is a result of linguistic imperialism? Justify.Introduction:English imperialism shows the dominance of English. The formation of this dominance is based on the inequalities to other language. The features of English imperialism are domination and inequalities. There are so many languages are facing the danger of extinction while English is spreading

Carl Matt is the only character that changes in the novel, "A Bridge to Wiseman's Cove" by James Moloney. DO you agree?

756 words - 3 pages , Harley all change.When we are first introduced to Carl Matt we see that he is an introverted, shy, lonely teenage boy. During his time in Wattle Beach he transforms into a more confident person. He meets Joy and comes out of his shell; he develops a sense of security with the Duncans, one that he has never experienced with Kerry and Sarah. He works with Skip on his barge, however skip hated the Matts. “Matt the word exploded Skip turned to Joy

Carl Matt is the only character that changes throughout the novel, 'A Bridge to Wiseman's Cove' by James Moloney. Do you agree?

936 words - 4 pages was too helpless with laughter and exhaustion to challenge him for the pizza now”(Quote pg 181)This quote shows that she has changed into a person that people really do like, she has ditched her attitude and dumped the extra baggage (Nathan Trelfo). This means she is a freer person and is comfortable within herself, which at the beginning of the novel she wasn’t. Maddie also learns to stand up for herself, as she doesn’t let Nathan

Carl Matt is the only one that changes throughout the novel, 'A Bridge to Wiseman's Cove', by James Moloney, do you agree?

1282 words - 5 pages . "You're not putting him on the chain anymore. Do you hear me? No more. You won't him you won't even touch him, No matter what he does."Carl had made 2 new best friends, joy Maddie and had moved in with them, skip also had dramas during his life.Skip Duncan at the start of a Bridge to Wiseman's Cove is a very judgemental man. Skip Duncan hates Carl because Carls Grandpa played a trick on skip Duncan and had hurt his leg, and so skip then had to

Carl Matt is the only character that changes throughout the novel, "A Bridge to Wiseman's COve" by James Moloney, do you agree? (DRAFT 3)

1039 words - 4 pages completely. Skip helped him by giving him a job on the barge. Justine also helped him, by making him more open to everyone. Carl opened up more, by standing up to Beryl .He made everyone know that his not like every other Matt in his family. Not only did Carl change in this novel, other people did as well.Skip was an aggressive man and very rude to people. He exploded at Joy for bringing a Matt onto his barge. “MATT! The word exploded… is

Similar Essays

"Gattaca" Shows That Even If Your Resume Is In Your Genes, What You Make Of Your Life Is Up To You. Do You Agree?

775 words - 3 pages opportunity and this shows that genes do not determine everything, as it was Eugene's choice to fail and surrender.Anton Freeman, Vincent's brother, also belongs to the higher class group of the genetically elite. Anton has the genetic resume to choose whatever profession he possibly could, however he chooses to become a detective (hoover), which is not necessarily the greatest profession according to his ability. From a young age, Anton sees himself

The Optional Protocol To The Iccpr Immeasurably Improved Its Enforcement. Do You Agree?

4159 words - 17 pages domestically.' The heterogeneity of legal and political cultures presents the Committee with a huge challenge, one that is next to impossible to overcome in any real terms. The nature of the violations which the State must deal with also has a bearing on how effective it is. The European Court of Human Rights is often held up as a shining example of an effective, supra-national supervisory body. However, the effectiveness of the ECHR owes itself, in some

Question: 'a Free Market System Is The Best Way To Organize The Economy.' Do You Agree With The Statement? Explain Your Answer

879 words - 4 pages these disadvantages is the unequal distribution of wealth. Hypothetically, a free market system allows everyone an equal opportunity to succeed. In practice however, this is a fallacy. Opportunity is dependant on the labour market, academic qualifications, inborn abilities, gender, race and culture; just to name a few. Research conducted by the London School of Economics showed that even after taking account of differences in their academic

Do You Agree With The Contention That The Mixed Ec

832 words - 3 pages capitalism and the command economies. The capitalism is an economic system characterized by private ownership of resources and markets. It is also known as the ?free enterprise system?. Capitalism is determined by two characteristics that are private ownership of resources and decentralized decision-making. Among the key strength of the capitalism economy system is its capacity in achieving economic efficiency. This is because the competition and