This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tort Law: Harassment Act 1997 Essay

2149 words - 9 pages

The main purpose of this Essay is to advise the parties as to any potential liability in tort and under the protection from Harassment Act 1997, also to find out the particulars of the case and list the points that are necessary in order for someone to be found guilty.
In Caroline and Nicole, A minor must be responsible for his or her own torts. However the issue here is whether Nicole’s actions amounted to a battery?
To make a claim, Caroline must establish that Nicole intentionally caused an offensive contact with her. However in (Garratt v. Dailey), Nicole may not be liable for battery because the element of intent is not satisfied as she did not intent to step on Caroline’s foot. On the other hand, Caroline can argue that although it was not intentional but Nicole failure to rectify the situation has rendered it a battery (See: Fagan v Metropolitan Police Commissioner) and Nicole did not consent her as she was a minor (Gillick v West Norfolk & Wisbeck Area Health Authority).
Could Caroline action amount a battery?
To prove tort of battery; Simon must establish that Caroline, Intentionally caused an offensive contact with him, that the force was direct and immediate, and the touching or contact was hostile.
INTENT: Caroline may not have intended to hit Simon with her shoe, although Even if her intention was not to hit Simon the shoe, Caroline may nevertheless have intended a harmful or offensive touching (see Scott v Shepherd). Caroline action alone of not taking a reasonable care of throwing the shoe was foreseeable, as there was possibility that if the shoe did not hit Nicole it would hit somebody (Corn V. Shepard). This is adequate to constitute intent. The facts indicate that Caroline threw off her shoe intending to hit Nicole but missed and hit Simon instead, the doctrine of transferred intent, made the conduct a battery on Caroline (Talmage v Smith) , Simon may also have an action for assault if he saw Caroline shoe coming at him ( R v Lamb).
CONSENT: In most cases, being silence and inaction may patent consent as it is reasonable to assume that a person would act if he objected to the other party actions that is, Simon silence does not mean that he was consented.
Did Simon suffer any harmful or offensive contact?
Harmful contact is usually an objective which a sensible individual might find it destructive or hostile. In this case, it seems probable that being hit by a thrown shoe would be harmful even if it did not cause any serious injury. However, a reasonable person would foresee that being hit by a thrown shoe would be offensive. This means that Caroline caused a harmful contact to Simon.
Furthermore, the law must balance the measures of the risk and the probability of the injury that would have occurred and aligned it with the rate and difficulty of taking precautions. On the other hand, since there was no serious injury, Simon may be entitled to disregard...

Find Another Essay On Tort Law: Harassment Act 1997

How the Civil Law Depends Againist Bullying

1063 words - 5 pages victims may have actions for intentional infliction of emotional distress. That tort responds to “extreme and outrageous conduct” by a defendant who intended to cause, or recklessly caused, the plaintiff’s severe emotional distress (Citron). Bullying is defined as a harmful act against a person, which is also stated under tort law that is considered a civil wrong which unfairly causes someone else to suffer loss or harm resulting in legal

Sexual Harassment Essay

1202 words - 5 pages Opportunity Commission describes sexual harassment as a form of gender discrimination that is in violation of the Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Undesirable sexual advances, request for sexual favors, and further verbal and physical conduct of a sexual nature constitutes sexual harassment, when compliance to or refusal of this behavior explicitly or implicitly affects an individual employment (EEOC). According to a recent study, the

Codes of Conduct and Harassment

2041 words - 8 pages pupils…” This also holds true for any work environment setting, as they have there are laws such as Title VII, California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), Title IX, California Education Code 212.5, Tort Law, and Case Law to address such behavior. The website for the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing (2008) has interesting description about providing protection from harassment or discrimination in employment

Tort Reform

2335 words - 9 pages damages caused to the patient. The tort law is described as disparate from criminal law or contract law because the purpose of a tort case is to find remedies and restore loss or damages through compensation. (Shrager, Spivey and Sachs, 2007)However, some people believe that tort reform is just a waste of time and it has the tendency to describe the plaintiff to be only interested in gaining financially instead of focusing in concerns that are more

General Tort Law

358 words - 2 pages Tort law is, to a great extent, social engineering by the courts. As society evolves, the courts? concept of what interests we have that are worth protecting also evolves. The courts impose duties on us not to injure the protectable interests of others.The leading remedy for accidental injury in this country is the negligence cause of action. Existence of a duty and proximate causation, both of which turn largely on the notion of foreseeability

Tort Law for Damages Practiced in Civil Law

1517 words - 7 pages Tort Law Tort Law has been a Civic Law practiced and used since the beginning of Law, after mankind first discovered what was right and what was wrong. It is a private or civil wrong for which damages may be removed and involves; falls at work, work vehicles, and nuisances. It’s a civil law that can be recognized for a law suit. It has a wide range of provisions and can range from negligence, purposeful, and ethics. Among the types of damages

Tort Reform

1377 words - 6 pages normally run if they were not afraid of being sued and sending patients to specialists for basic care, such as pap smears and mole removals. Proponents of tort reform also believe that tort reform will lower the cost of medical malpractice insurance in the state of Texas and increase the number of doctors willing to practice medicine in Texas.What is a tort reform? Prosser and Keeton on Torts text book defines, a tort as a "civil crime; an act that

Sexual Harassment

1075 words - 4 pages sexual harassment may occur without economic injury to or discharge of the victim.The harasser's conduct must be unwelcome" (Facts About Sexual Harassment, 1997 & 2000).Types of Sexual Harassment & Related CasesFederal law recognizes two different forms of claiming sexual harassment under Title VII. The first is quid pro quo. Under the quid pro quo form of harassment, a person in authority, usually a supervisor demands sexual favors of a

Sexual Harassment Laws

972 words - 4 pages legislation will be raised and evaluated. As such, a conclusion will be established as to whether current legislation is adequate or inadequate, and if so what improvements can be made. The Queensland Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 was enacted to promote fair treatment and equality of opportunity by making unfair discrimination and all forms of sexual harassment against the law. It gives all of us the right to be

Tort Laws and Ethics

1324 words - 5 pages . Conclusion There are laws that are set in place to govern the ethical standards of care that health professionals must abide. When these standards are deviated from and an act of negligence against a person occurs that results in the harm against a person, effects, or character, the result is often a tort claim or malpractice suit. The tort law most directly impacts the habits, standards, and ethical issues that health care professionals face. Laws

Sexual Harassment In the Workplace: a formal report for a sexual harassment policy for a mock-company, Sound and Vision Inc., SVI

2872 words - 11 pages ;>.Kantrowitz, Barbara. "Striking a Nerve." Newsweek 21 Oct. 1991: 17-21.Levin, Joseph. "Investigative Report on Sexual Harassment." SVI Formal Report 24 July 2001.Petrocelli, William, Kate Repa, Barbara. Sexual Harassment on the Job. 4th ed. Nolo: Berkeley, 1999."Sample Sexual Harassment Policy." Personnel Dynamics 11 July 2001 .Wyatt, Nancy. "Information on Sexual Harassment." 11 July 2001. Penn State University. .Zimmer, Michael J., Charles A. Sullivan, Richard F. Richards, Deborah A. Calloway. Cases and Materials on Employment Discrimination. 4th ed. New York: Aspen Law & Business, 1997.

Similar Essays

Gender Differences: Perceptions Of Sexual Harassment

1766 words - 7 pages against sexual harassment. However, first and foremost, educating employees about what constitutes harassment and its effects is vital, because there is considerable uncertainty and disagreement about what harassment is. Common law tort lawsuits, such as intentional infliction of emotional distress and assault and battery, provide a remedy in certain types of sexual harassment cases that is totally dependent of any of the statutes and governmental

Harassment An Employment Law Paper By Holly Outland

1181 words - 5 pages companies with 15 or more employees. (1997)The Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 safeguards people who are 40 years and older from employment discriminati0on based on age. The ADEA gives sanctuary to both employees and job applicants. Under this act it is against the law to discriminate against a person because of age in regards to ant term, condition, or benefit of employment. This includes some of the same items from the American with

The Purpose Of Tort Law In The Irish Legal System

3219 words - 13 pages both criminal law and contract law, I will now focus in on some of the theories of what the intended purpose of tort law is. As I have outlined above, tort law could not fall under criminal law because its sole purpose is not to punish those for criminal actions. Not all torts fall under the descriptive category of a criminal act. Similarly, tort law could not be seen as contract law for similar reasons. Tort actions do in fact sometimes

Sexual Harassment In The Workplace Essay

1267 words - 5 pages issue can result not only in costly lawsuits, but also in a loss of employee morale, decline in productivity, and an erosion of a company's public image. To act wisely, companies need to understand the whole issue of sexual harassment. They need to consider the disturbing statistics behind an often hidden problem, the legal grounds available to victims, the current trends in the law, and the ways that companies can protect themselves