This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tort Of Negligent Investigation Essay

1182 words - 5 pages

As police officers own right to carry out an investigation on the suspect, public arise concerning on negligent investigation. In the Hill v. Hamiton-Wentworth case, Mr. Hill was accused robbery and then was proved innocent. Mr. Hill filled a lawsuit against police officers on the tort of negligent investigation, and the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed Hill’s appeal. Moreover, a majority of the court recognizes there is a tort of negligent investigation in Canada, but Mr. Hill was investigated under code of care and no tort of negligent investigation during his investigation. While the argument of minority believes the tort of negligent investigation should be recognized in Canada, and the police had been negligent, the argument of minority is more compelling than majority.
Tort of Negligent Investigation
General speaking, a tort of negligence is a failure of someone or one party to follow a standard of care which means failed to do what a reasonable person do or do what a reasonable personal would not do. From the interest perspective, the tort of negligent investigation is an offence against private interest of an individual, corporation or government due to the negligent investigation. Whether a tort of negligent investigation exists in Canada is related to whether investigators owe a duty of care to person being investigated and what is the standard of care. Finally, a tort of negligent investigation only exist when there is a loss or injury to the suspect and the loss or injury was caused by the negligent investigation.
While the police officers have rights to investigate suspect, the duty of care of the officers to suspect exist and the officers were under a legal obligation to exercise care for Mr. Hill. The case indicated that there is a particular relationship between the police and a suspect under investigation, reasonable foreseeability is clearly made out because a negligent investigation may cause harm to the suspect (Hill v Hamilton, 2007). Police officers, who have authority to investigate crime suspect can easily foresee the harm caused to the suspect would be imprisoned and even more serious penalties as a result of the negligent conduct of an investigation. The minority believe that the tort of negligent investigation should not be recognized as there is a duty of care to public to ensure public safety and avoid further crime. Therefore, the duty of care to public and duty of care to suspect is conflict. First of all, the arrested suspects were not criminal during the investigation procedure, so they were part of the public as well. Secondly, negligent investigation might cause innocent people were went to jail and convicted criminal were free to commit another crime. Last but not least, the duty of care to suspect is not necessary overarching the duty of care to public.
After approved that police officers owe a duty of care to suspect, the next requirement for tort of negligent investigation is the standard...

Find Another Essay On tort of negligent investigation

Tort law in Canada and what this area of law is all about

1111 words - 4 pages be a detriment to society.Tort law is used in society as an advantage by helping the victim receive damages from the person who caused the injury or damage. Tort law is great when it is used properly. If you get injured due to the negligence of another person it is not right. Tort law is a benefit because the victim will receive compensation for the mistakes of the person who was negligent. As an example of a real case; John Doe is suing Thomas

Essay on tort law history, in particular looking at the British and Australian tort law development through the 19th century

1396 words - 6 pages there is little correlation between negligent law in the nineteenth century with any law preceding this, as it was a completely new area of law sparked by the unique situations that industrialization created. Therefore the old law could not be overthrown as it never had to deal with tort cases of this nature. The new doctrines arose not as a result of ambition in the powerful segments of society but rather as a result of change. Furthermore, it would

A report outlining the legal implications of undertaking the of acquisition a country house and converting it into a hotel

1400 words - 6 pages construction decisions in particular reference amongst other matters, to tort, land law, company, employment and consumer and planning law.Setting up the companyHotels possess a dual nature as they can be seen both as business and as real estate. It is therefore of great importance to have the advice of professionals who are familiar with the hotel industry. It is important to assemble a team of seven professionals who help to carry out an overall


1048 words - 4 pages crime is considered a public wrong, which is punishable by the state. In tort law, there are three different kinds of torts, including intentional, negligent, and strict liability. An intentional tort requires that the defendant meant to do a certain action, but not necessarily to harm a person or thing. Negligence is a situation in which harm is caused by accident, and strict liability is where harm is done, but one is responsible without proof

Torts versus Crimes

1549 words - 6 pages to meet a standard of conduct for care that is professionally recognized and because of the negligence a client or patient is injured or something is damaged because of an error. A tort of negligence consists of lack of duty or breach of duty for due care, a connection between the cause and the injury, and actual damage or lass has occurred because of negligence. People and businesses can still be held liable for the negligent actions even


902 words - 4 pages The tort of negligent statement was established in 1964 and before that date, the cases relied upon contract law or considered as the tort of deceit, as judges were hostile to allow compensation for pure economic loss (Turner, 2010). The consequence of negligent misstatement is pure economic loss, which in early decades was concerned to compensate only for physical damage (Cooke, 2011). Deceit is a fraudulent misrepresented made knowingly or

Intentional Torts in Professional Sports

2027 words - 9 pages tort is a legal wrong against another. Torts are civil wrongs and thus are the grounds for a lawsuit. There are many ways to organize torts since there can be many different types some even overlapping a bit with each other. More or less there are three different categories within tort law: negligent torts, strict liability torts, and intentional torts. Negligent torts are a cause of action leading to the actual damages. Moreover, it is “The

The Burden of Proof in the Case of Darling vs. Charleston Community Memorial Hospital

866 words - 4 pages award to plaintiff. Legalities of Medical Malpractice The system of law governing the resolution of civil disputes between parties in the United States is referred to as the adversarial system, where respective advocates for each side in a dispute skillfully present arguments before an impartial party, such as jury or judge. The adversarial system is used in common law countries to resolve disputes related to negligent conduct, whether medical

Commercial law essay

696 words - 3 pages Civil obligations to not injure our neighbours in New Zealand are dealt with by the use of tort law (textbook). Negligence is the most significant of all tort law and is the relevant tort I will be using to examine this case. This case involves David who is felling trees on a property, on the last tree he was felling he careless and hurried to fell the last tree. As a result the tree fell on the neighbouring property, demolishing the boundary

Ethical Employer Dilemm

983 words - 4 pages of the employee’s criminal record increases the employer’s risk in a potential lawsuit of negligent hiring. A criminal history is used against the employer to exemplify that the employer did not use reasonable care in hiring an ex-offender (Camacho 1993). Negligent hiring liability can be avoided if the employer screen applicants cautiously and conduct a complete background check. Also, the background investigation should be more extensive as the

Alumina Simulation

2170 words - 9 pages statement about "skeletons in the closet" is insinuating that Alumina is hiding something.•The proposed investigation of a private citizen with the intent to find something that a company can use against them is unethical and illegal.•Negligence Tort: Heavy traffic has caused pollutants to contaminate the water, and the PAH levels are 100 times greater than before urbanization.•An injunction could possibly force Alumina to stop doing

Similar Essays

The Purpose Of Tort Law In The Irish Legal System

3219 words - 13 pages intentional tort. Another type of tort is negligence. This includes careless conduct that causes damages to another as a result. For example, accidentally striking someone would be deemed as a negligent act but is still regarded as a tort. Both intentional torts and negligence are the two most common types of tort. However, liability can also be imposed on a defendant in situations where they did not intentionally or accidentally cause harm

Malpractice Insurance: What Price Can Be Put On Safety?

825 words - 3 pages with a vengeance (7). "September was a disaster for insurance companies, but every day since has been a blessing" (11). Mismanagement and fraud are also somewhat to blame. St. Paul, the leading malpractice insurer, pulled out of the business because of "lawsuit risks." After investigation, the determining factor in St. Paul's downfall was mismanagement and fraud (9).Congress has proposed one solution, tort reform. However, the mistake of enacting

Tort Laws And Ethics Essay

1324 words - 5 pages receive jail time and/or malpractice claims if found guilty of such negligence as described in the tort claim. According the Congressional Budget Office (2006), “The system has twin objectives: deterring negligent behavior on the part of providers and compensating claimants for losses (including medical costs, lost wages, and pain and suffering) they incur as the result of an injury that occurs because of negligence” (

Alumina Tort Liability Essay

1218 words - 5 pages Running Head: Alumina Tort LiabilityAlumina Tort LiabilityRita Ben-CherquiJohn MartoranaBusiness LawUniversity of PhoenixMarch 3, 2009Alumina Inc. is a company facing a lot of opponents other then Kelly Bates. In today's society there is a conscience of extremely environmentally people. With the polluting of Lake Dira there are many allegations being considered that are facing the environment and other items. In many business regulations there