This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Torture And National Security: A Moral Question

1662 words - 7 pages

Throughout the semester, we, as freshmen Fellows, have been studying and questioning the existence of morals, why they are important, and to whom or for whom our moral responsibility lends itself. The curriculum is a comprehensive examination of these questions and successfully projects ideas about human morality that, depending on which text, either affirmed or questioned our morality. In addition, we have addressed moral disengagement, a plague that seems to inject every one of us with the ability to ignore or reject situations which call for moral action. While the curriculum does an appropriate job in addresses these questions, there seems to be room for expansion with a type of "gray area" subject. The text that I recommend for inclusion into the Calling and Leadership 102 curriculum is an 1978 entry into the Philosophy and Public Affairs journal simply entitled, "Torture", written by Henry Shue, a Senior Research Fellow and Professor of Politics and International Relations at Oxford University. If included in the curriculum, it would be in the Section 3b, which asks if disobedience or violence is ever moral. This article should be included because of the author's demonstrated expertise in the subject, its alignment and expansion of the section it should be included in, and ability to induce "gray area" type questions about the role of the global community in regards to torture and public safety.
When determining the curriculum for this course, an important aspect of any text that must be examined is the reliability as well as it's appropriateness in context of the general Fellows curriculum. The 1978, "Torture", should be included in because it examines the philosophy of the issue and is not simply a blanket-level assessment. The article will spur a deeper understanding of the issue than one would not get from reading and discussing newspaper article on the same topic. Further demonstrating the appropriateness of the text in the general Fellows curriculum, Dr. Shue discusses Kantian ideas, displaying his desire to understand the philosophy behind the issue (Shue 132). Dr. Shue's renown expertise on the subject of torture as well as the philosophical approach taken in the is just a basic starting point for why it ought to be included in the Calling and Leadership curriculum.
Furthermore, the article, "Torture", should be incorporated in the curriculum because it addresses the questions of Section 3b of the syllabus: "Is disobedience moral?" and "Can violence ever be moral?". The article does not explicitly address the first question, but this text will open discussion about the question of unlawful means of torture in order to protect the innocent. Situations displayed in popular TV shows in which a terrorist knows where a soon-to-be utilized weapon of mass destruction is but won't answer unless tortured and forced to could be discussed. The article more fully addresses the second question, "Can violence ever be moral?" with a...

Find Another Essay On Torture and National Security: A Moral Question

Human Trafficking: Modern Day Slavery that Poses a National and International Security Risk

1967 words - 8 pages -enrichment in which the steady income, low depreciation of human merchandise, and the close to no initial investment fuels the low-risk economic venture. The question now is can Human Trafficking be a National Security Risk to the United States? According to Christine Dolan from the “Terrorism Nexus” seminar the answer is a definite yes.# Terrorist use the trafficking networks already established for the traffickers to move its operative to any

National Security Agency, Privacy and Security for American Citizens

882 words - 4 pages Background The National Security Agency was established in 1952 from the National Security Council for the purposes of intercepting foreign radio communications (Howe, p 11). Since, the NSA has been one of the most secretive institutions within the intelligence community. However, recent events have focused on the NSA’s domestic surveillance, encouraging a debate between security and privacy. In 1978 the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act

Love and a Question

1261 words - 6 pages “Love and a Question” by Robert Frost is trying to get readers to see that love can be strong and change people’s mindset from doing the need or want to help to something that could wait. In this poem Frost uses the ideas of love, decisions and sacrifice to get his point of love and how decisions are made across to the reader. Love is a big part of human life. Love in this poem can be described in two different ways. One way is the love of

National Security Policy: Before and After September 11, 2001

1900 words - 8 pages in its history, geopolitics and the realist paradigm dominated policy-making, and national security moved to “center stage” in American politics (Snow, 2014, p. 66). The result was was the passing of the National Security Act of 1947. From this came the creation of the National Security Council (NSC), comprised of the statutory members of the president, vice-president, and secretaries of state and defense. The purpose of the NCS was to act as a

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

676 words - 3 pages development. Provide rational expectations theories explanatory principle in the central neoclassical economic theory much and I was born in the academic literature and wide . Rational expectations theories are theories experimental human behavior , and as such , does not claim to ideology . However , it is often seen as the presence of traces of the ideological factor of national security . In particular, it addressed the question of " Why should I be

Mass Surveillance and Its Role in Promoting National Security

1622 words - 7 pages power to act against foreign threats” (Preface to "Was National Security Agency (NSA) Wiretapping Without Warrants Legal?"). Given the United States’ history with terrorism in cases such as 9/11 and its constant battles with public security, any measures to prevent further attacks should be fully supported by a nation so deeply affected by them in the past. In addition to being supported by the Constitution, mass surveillance is also condoned in

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

964 words - 4 pages provide a “reason” to make agreements that are ideological aspect of national security in some sense: the agreements would result from rational bargaining in any case. Nash and RKS solutions do not necessarily satisfy standard ideological criteria, however, and they can be quite counterintuitive. Also there is no consensus on how to specify or justify a reasonable default position from which to start bargaining. We conclude from all this that the

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

1471 words - 6 pages policies.(95) This brief review suggests a concluding observation about the pattern of theorizing in national security studies. In the case of international relations theorizing, one can discern a dominant arc of research. It starts in the lower-left quadrant with a materialist-rationalist neo-realism, extends to the right along the x-axis in the form of neo-liberal regime theory, which adds more ideological imagery, and moves into the upper-right

The National Security Agency and its Access to Private Information

2417 words - 10 pages By simply looking at a computer screen, it has the ability to track her people’s familial, political, professional, and religious associations. Does this statement sound like a line from a cheap science fiction book written by a paranoid author? Unfortunately, “it” already exists. This entity is the United States Government’s National Security Administration. (Rubenfeld) Through programs codenamed Prism (Edward Snowden), Dishfire, and Prefer

The Catalysts and Images of Terrorism: National Security Threat

3468 words - 14 pages enhancing American national security promoting world peace” (pg. 585). DPT is not only a fallacy, but it does not even begin to understand and contain modern day terrorism. Democratic Peace Theory sounds brilliant on paper, but when closely inspected, its deceptive nature and apparent simplicity becomes evident. One issue that currently divides many experts is the question of defining democracy and liberalism. Furthermore, there is no concise

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security - 1043 words

1043 words - 5 pages and the above axioms, the national security function must be the maximin function. Curiously, however, these premises imply only that welfare function is maximin or maximax (21). The latter maximizes the utility of the best-off actor; that is, . To infer a minimax principle, one must rule out the maximax principle on some other ground. Again the idea of the argument can be conveyed in the two-actors case (22), where separability does not play a

Similar Essays

National Debt, A Threat To National Security?

710 words - 3 pages I don’t agree with the former CJCS, Admiral (R) Mike Mullen’s assessment that the national debt is the greatest threat to National Security. First, the Congressional imposed sequestration cuts in 2011 resulted in the deficit declining over 50 percent from a record $1.43 trillion in 2009 (Dean, Washington Times, Oct 30, 2013). The increase in tax revenues is an indication that businesses and individuals are earning more due to the improving

Free Speech And National Security

1185 words - 5 pages citizens while hunting for evidence against somebody else.” This article brings into question the constitutional rights of the 4th and 9th amendments, of warrants and privacy of citizens: should the government be able to look into private records showing purchases and other private businesses of citizens without a warrant? Adams, Mike. "Big brother u.s. government subpoenaed amazon.com to obtain book purchasing records of customers." Web. A

Cyber Security And The Threat To National Security

1974 words - 8 pages rather a culture that exists in cyberspace and is a compilation of numerous new technologies and capabilities, used by diverse people in diverse real – world locations. Cyberculture, a twentieth century phenomena, has brought challenges unlike any other that the United States has seen in the areas of cyber security and its impact on our most critical institutions. This presentation will focus on the aforementioned three entities where national

National Security Agency And Edward Snowden

1504 words - 6 pages other sorts of data is mined and collected by the government for years now. The first of the leaks happened in June 2013, almost a year ago now. Glenn Greenwald, a journalist for The Guardian, reports that the National Security Agency (NSA) has been collecting millions of Verizon customer’s phone records. This was permitted by a secret court order that allows the government unlimited authority to obtain communication for three months. The next day