This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Torture In The Us Essay

1668 words - 7 pages

Introduction
The United States has been, and may again be, under terrorist threat and attacks or other similar incidents. Torture can be used to prevent these terrible incidents and save the lives of many people. Torture in the United States has been a debatable subject for many years now but after resent tragedies, the idea of torture of many American citizens has changed. It has also been debated over more after the attacks on September 9, 2001 than any other time in American history. Many fight the legalization of torture for moral and civil reasons but the truth is that torture is a lesser evil that can be used for a greater good.
What is Torture?
Torture may have different meanings ...view middle of the document...

S. has a worldwide system of detention centers where prisoners are tortured. Using the “War on Terrorism” (Peterson, Kim), the U.S. has twisted international laws for tis own selfish goal. The government has discarded international protection from war prisoners and made a new designation not provided in international law. By doing so, the U.S has sent a dangerous sign to the rest of the world that it is easy to slip through international laws.
Democracy and life-saving torture have existed side by side for years. Governments usually ignore the interest of its people for the greater good but even if it didn’t, most Americans have supported the use of torture to stop terrorist attacks. Many democratic countries that use torture for a greater good have been stable and not fallen into a barbaric state as many anti-torture supporters say the U.S. will.
Many democratic countries such as France, Britain, and Israel all have used torture under extreme circumstances over the past fifty years and none has sunk into barbarism, or ceased to be a law-government democracy. History of humankind has shown many times that when societies are threatened; they choose the common good over individual interests.
Torture and 911
Before, the U.S. Army Field Manuals used to teach the soldiers the Geneva Conventions and U.S. policies, which prohibited certain acts of violence or intimidation. Any kind of torture threats were not to be used during an interrogation but after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, an argument on how torture should be defined arose after former president George W. Bush’s attempt to fight terrorists by pushing the boundaries of what actions constitute torture. The meaning of torture changed in some aspects after 911. For example, a memo was issued that stated coercive interrogations can actually torture only if suffering equal, in intensity, to pain from serious injuries or even death and is caused intentionally by the Justice Departments Office of Legal Counsel in 2002.

Who Supports Torture
The majority of America, 58%, supports the use of torture to stop and fight terrorism and other crime, under certain circumstances. But, when asked about other Americans being tortured in other countries, all opposed torture. This showed that torture is approved only in rare instances. “When forced to choose between two evils, we always elect for the lesser evil. Notions of individual rights go missing in the process” (Clarke, Bagaric; Mirko; Julie). Poll results raise many questions such as who defines terrorism or, especially, can torture be justified when the terrorists are resisting an illegal invasion. Most poll results have shown support for justifiable torture in rare instances.
Fuzzy Thinking
An example of fuzzy thinking is that it is okay to kill someone to save lives but saying it’s extremely wrong to inflict pain on someone to prevent them or others from doing wrong and possibly saving more lives. Some people believe that torture is...

Find Another Essay On torture in the US

Healthcare in the US Essay

1610 words - 7 pages Canada and the United States of America (US) have two completely different healthcare systems. In the US, healthcare access is limited to those who carry insurance. Healthcare in the US is not centralized, does not offered universal access, and have multiple providers and payers. Canada has a national program for publicly funded healthcare insurance implemented in 1966 under The Canada Health Act (the Act) in all provinces and territories (Shi

Poverty in The US Essay

1647 words - 7 pages for an individual, $8,860. . The number of poor families in America increased by more than 6% in 2001, with 6.8 million families - one out of every ten - living below the poverty line in 2001. In 2002, according to the official measure, 12.1 percent of the total U.S. population lived in poverty .There are many problems connected to the measure of poverty that the US Census Bureau uses. The definition was first calculated in the mid 1960s as three

The US in Libya

2216 words - 9 pages order to do so. One place funding is being reallocated from is the state budgets, and inclusive to the state budgets is funding for the schools system. It should seem clear now that when the United States go to war, it affects us as students in a crucial way, especially when Libya is not the only “war” the United States is fighting. A good example of how exactly the budgets cuts have affected the University students is the threat to eliminate the

Poverty in the US

875 words - 4 pages Insurance and housing subsidies. Without this help, the poverty rate would increase to 25% of the total US population. The biggest portion of people who lived in poverty are children, 22% of children live in poverty, and children make-up 24% of the total US population. The next biggest percentage is taken up by single mothers, with 31.6% of single mothers living in poverty. Single men take up 15.8% and married couples 6.2%. This shows that the US

Multiculturalism in the US

866 words - 3 pages people are Americans, people born and raised in the US. These citizens might not seem to be Americans, but they are as American as any American.         Ronald Takaki in his essay, "An Educated and Cultural Literate Person Must Study America's Multicultural Reality", gives an excellent example of what I meant when I said that some citizens might not seem to be American. Takaki was born in Hawaii, one of the 50 states. After graduating from

Unemployment in the US

4009 words - 16 pages Unemployment in the US Why I Chose These Indicators I chose these indicators because all are something that ordinary people deal with every day. All of us have control over our own spending and how far into debt we go. If we are not making the salary we want then we are free to look for a new job or an additional job. There is also the possibility of going back to school to raise your educational level in order to get a better job

The Animal in Us

1102 words - 5 pages using organs from animals genetically more similar to us reduce the problem of rejection," (Cooper 44) is the pig better suited for transplant rather than a chimpanzee or baboon? Several factors need consideration when selecting a potential donor animal. The environment in which the animals live in and the availability of the animals are two of the most important factors. Because the apes are an endangered species, they are off-limits to any

christianity in the us

2096 words - 9 pages no prompting of the conscience. Without God, we're mired in the material, that flat world that tells us only what the senses perceive. Without God, there is a coarsening of the society. And without God, democracy will not and cannot long endure. If we ever forget that we're one nation under God, then we will be a nation gone under.” Reagan was a great president because he truly believed that our country would only be successful if God was the

George Orr's Torture by His Dreams in The Lathe of Heaven

1611 words - 6 pages George Orr's Torture by His Dreams in The Lathe of Heaven George Orr is tortured by his dreams because sometimes they come true. The world he wakes up to has changed into the world that he dreamed, sometimes radically, sometimes violently. As a teenager he dreams the death of his aunt and he awakens to finds that she was killed in a car accident six weeks before. He is horrified, and attempts to control his dreaming, but over the years some

The Imp in Us All

2846 words - 11 pages The Imp in Us All "The Imp is taken to be a self destructive force present in all of us but with important difference in each person according to the power of will and morality". (Edwards 162) Those important differences both connect and individualize the works of Edgar Allan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne. The Imp of the Perverse, The Tell Tale Heart, and William Wilson all demonstrate Poe's fascination and exploration with inner conflict

Chinese Christians in the US

2249 words - 9 pages Chinese Christians in the US are a minority group which has been assimilated into the cultural diversity of America. This group depicts the integration of various groups into the American community and dominant way of life. This group has shown high levels of adaptation as shown by their operations in the US. Though the Chinese living in China were poorly informed on Christianity, they adopted Christian as their religion which differentiated

Similar Essays

Torture In The Middle Ages Essay

2139 words - 9 pages as much pain as possible before dying. For example, when using saws torturers would have their victim upside down which slowed down the loss of blood and therefore the victim would have to endure the pain of being sawed in half for a longer time. Compared to the torture of Medieval Times, the torture used today is generally less severe and used to cause psychological or emotional distress with limited physical hardship. In the US torture is

The Torture In Force Feeding Essay

839 words - 4 pages Guantanamo Bay. This article was not convincing at all and I believe force-feeding is torture. In the article it talks about Natalie’s story on how its so easy to be force feed. I think that once someone is on a hunger strike and is rejecting the treatment but still being given the procedure, the procedure may be given wrong, or in a harmful way. In the article it talks about 345,000 Americans using feeding tubes and receiving no health problems

Limiting The Use Of Torture In America

618 words - 2 pages ) how do we find the victims and such? The usage of torture on individuals that have a reasonable doubt of committed a heinous crime should not happen. Though torture itself in the United States is not allowed. But should torture be allowed, it should only be used on those that committed crimes that can put you on death row or life in prison. Such as in Oklahoma where if “a capital offense sex crimes against a child under 14 years of

The Misuse Of Torture In Rendition

1371 words - 5 pages ... and you're not. We can torture one, and save 7000. Those are ‘good’ statistics.” Under these circumstances where torturing one man can result in saving 7,000 people, this seems really good, but how can one be sure that the information told to us is 100% accurate? What if hostages learn to say anything in order to save their own life? In the movie, Rendition, it raises the issue of ends justifying the means, but it does not develop it