Torturing For A Confession Essay

1176 words - 5 pages

Torture has been a practice used to inflict severe pain in the victim as a way of punishment, revenge, cruelty towards heretics or to get a confession. It is prohibited all over the world by law and it is a violation of the human rights, in other words torturing is seen as unacceptable and barbaric. This represents a problem in our modern society because in extreme cases where a confession could save thousands of lives and the only way to get it is by torturing the perpetrator, is seen as a violation of the human rights. Another speculation is that torture is morally wrong and does not comply with the ethics that our parents taught us as children. Also, it is difficult to resolve this dilemma since it affects us in many ways. It is left to the public to decide whether it is the right thing to do in life or death situations.
Throughout history, torture has been present since the second century but it was only used on slaves until then. It has been mainly applied as a way of punishment towards those who committed a crime, during the medieval times, and specially heretics and witches during the inquisition. Initiated by the Catholic Church, the inquisition is perhaps the most salient piece of history involving torture as a method of interrogation and ecclesiastical imprisonment. But in the modern world things have not changed significantly, torture is still practiced, possibly with the same purposes from the past even though numerous laws were passed to prohibit it. We might not know about the cases but when it comes to saving the citizens from a terrorist attack, where a bomb has been hidden and he will not confess where it is, the only way of obtaining an answer would be torturing him. The methods used are depriving the victim from their clothes since being naked means vulnerability, this adds shame and helplessness. Part of the psychological abuse is immobilizing the victim to create fear and desperation, impotence. Then interrogation proceeds and burning, cutting, striking, degrading, mutilating or executing occurs. During prisoner interrogations it is avoided the use of methods that could leave marks or evidence of injuries. This is only done to prevent future attacks but some people see it as a violation of the human rights, because even though terrorists are criminals, they still have rights as any other person. But the argument is only based in a black and white view of the things because it is more logical to sacrifice a life to save thousands of them than to have a massacre.
As children we are taught the principles of knowing the distinction of right and wrong by our parents which it is known as “train morality” because we instinctively follow the same path our parents did. This becomes a general idea of what is good and bad and if anyone begs to differ then they are not accepted by the community or they get judged. To some people torture is morally wrong due to the fact that is inhumane and it goes against the moral code, even when...

Find Another Essay On Torturing For a Confession

"The Salem Witch Trials", heavily citing examples from "The Crucible".

979 words - 4 pages credibility, and she too was to be tried for witchcraft. However, Ann Putnam's accusations did not end with Martha Corey. She then accused Rebecca Nurse, a popular 71 year old woman who frequently attended church, of practicing witchcraft. Ann and several of the young girls claimed Martha's spirit would "float into their rooms at night, pinching and torturing them" (2). The convincing testimonies put forth by the Putnam's and the young girls led

The Long Walk By: Slavomir Rawicz

1006 words - 4 pages Prison. Rawicz is forced to sign a document stating that he is a Polish spy plotting against the motherland of Russia (USSR at the time). His sentence to the "confession" is twenty-five years minimum to serve as a slave for Camp 303 located south of Yakutsk, Siberia. The long trek there took two weeks by train and fifty days by foot through the snow bearing lands. Frostbite and death were common among the prisoners. When Slavomir reaches the camp, he

Michel Foucault's claim that "Western man has become a confessing animal".

1325 words - 5 pages seen as an art, a unique experience and not something dirty or prohibited. Therefore, sex loses both its pleasure, and power, if talked about. The other procedure for constructing the truth of sex is Scientia sexualis, which derives truth of sex strictly from a knowledge-power relationship. As one can plainly see, these two procedures appear to be in direct opposition to one another.In our culture, we rely on the act of 'confession' as a ritual for

The Arizona v. Fulminante Case

1769 words - 7 pages , the Supreme Court voted 5 to 4 to uphold the Arizona Supreme Court’s decision: Fulminante would receive a new trial and the confession would not be allowed; this would be for future law reference. The Supreme Court, profoundly, ruled that a coerced confession could not account as evidence against the person being tried (“Arizona v. Fulminante”. Lawschool). Arizona v. Fulminante was one of the few cases in law history with justices shifting from

The Salem Witch Trials

981 words - 4 pages heresy. Accusing an individual of Witchcraft was often seen as a tool to get rid of one’s enemies; the community would purge itself. The catch to this act was that concrete evidence must be provided; as addressed later, concrete evidence eventually fell away from trials. It was often said that torture was good for confession and this was justified by the law because witchcraft offended the church and the state. Not only was witchcraft an act of

The Changing of Chillingworth throughout The Scarlet Letter

1158 words - 5 pages neither one truly wanted to be around the other. The tone of conversations between Chillingworth and Hester are cold, and they never try to work out any differences they had in order to ignite a love again that probably never existed in the first place. In the first interaction between Chillingworth and Hester, Chillingworth is the doctor for both Hester and Pearl. Hester is dubious of Chillingworth's motives for helping them, and with good

Anatomy of a False Confession

1613 words - 6 pages truthful information. However, there are times when the interrogation tactics used by law enforcement officers are so persuasive as to obtain a confession from an innocent suspect. The police may outright lie to the suspect, stating incriminating evidence was found, convincing the suspect to confess. For example, after ten to twenty hours of interrogation, a police officer may tell the suspect that his fingerprint or blood was found at the scene of

Revenge

1223 words - 5 pages was done so that he would have better chances to discover the man by means of trickery, which this played a key part in him finding out that Arthur Dimmesdale, was the man who wronged him. Once Chillingworth positions himself within the knowledgeable officials of the town, he quickly gleams the minister Dimmesdale holds a secret. Chillingworth then devotes himself to coercing the secret out of the minister by torturing him mentally for many years

What Comes Around Goes Around

1043 words - 4 pages . Ryan was a woman who was most likely a sister, since she wore a black cloak and bonnet. She would go to Jackie's school everyday to prepare the students for confession and communion. Ryan frequently spoke of hell, barely mentioning heaven; and if she did it was probably by accident, "for hell had the first place in her heart" (361). Jackie described an incident where she would light a candle, taking out a half-crown (British money), and offer it

Character Summary Proctor

623 words - 2 pages crucial information. When this attempt failed John finally comes out with a full confession of his adultery. Calling Abigail a "whore" and telling everybody that he was guilty of adultery. But it's too late. Abigail caused so much trouble that John Proctors confession can't even save him. His confession only leads to his arrest and conviction as a witch. What a terrible twist in a terrible tragedy for John Proctor. In the end Proctor does

scarlet letter

1014 words - 5 pages sinner but views Chillingsworth at the worst sinner of all. Dimmsdale says "old man's revenge has been blacker then my sin."(chapter 17) Dimmsdale believes Chillingsworth torturing him is worse the committing the sin of lust. Dimmsdale views Chillingsworth as a monster for trying to ruin any chance of him and Hester having a happy life together. Dimmsdale seeks justice for himself by trying to confess his sins to society before he dies. In Dimmsdale

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Hanged Man's Bride, The Trial For Murder And Confession Found In A Prison

3638 words - 15 pages Analysis of The Hanged Man's Bride, The Trial for Murder and Confession Found in a Prison Introduction Based on my study of Charles Dickens, I have decided to focus upon three short stories to write about in detail. These are: The Hanged Man's Bride, written in 1860, The Trial For Murder, written in 1865 and Confession Found in a Prison, written in 1842. To enable me to understand the stories better and also Dicken's

Frank O'connor's The First Confession Essay

926 words - 4 pages could from the grandma. She would pick on Jackie for her own entertainment. When it was her turn for confession, she was in and out in a matter of seconds. "Her eyes were lowered, her head was bowed, and her hands were joined very low down on her stomach, and she walked up the aisle to the side altar looking like a saint." (333). All before this confession, Nora was torturing Jackie on the walk in. She was very devious. She went from one

The Misuse Of Torture In Rendition

1371 words - 5 pages , no, no, no. Wait! Wait! He contacted me a year ago, (…) Rashid called me on my cell phone, (…) he wanted information on how chemical composition can increase explosive power (SubZin, 38).” Chief Fawal immediately replies, “ Names, names, give me names (SubZin, 39). ” A person who is tortured will eventually say anything to make it stop. This exemplifies how torturing a person cannot secure a legitimate confession. Douglas Freeman is suspicious

Dfaff Essay

623 words - 3 pages threaten to use torture is the same as actually torturing, both legally and morally. Torture as defined under the United Nations Torture Convention of 1984 as: Any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having