This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tough Love In Mel Gibson's Hamlet And Branagh's Hamlet

781 words - 3 pages

Tough Love in Mel Gibson's Hamlet and Branagh's Hamlet

   One of the most emotional and moving scenes in William Shakespeare's tragedy Hamlet is in Act III, Scene I lines 90-155 in which the title character becomes somewhat abusive toward his once loved girlfriend Ophelia. It is interesting to examine the possible motives behind Hamlet's blatant harshness in this "Get the to a nunnery" scene toward the easily manipulated and mild mannered girl. While watching Kenneth Branagh and Mel Gibson's film adaptations of the play, the audience may recognize two possibilities of the many that may exist which may explain the Prince's contemptible behavior; Kenneth Branaugh seems to suggest that this display of animosity will help the troubled man convince his enemies that he is in fact demented, whereas the Mel Gibson work may infer that Hamlet's repressed anger toward his mother causes him to "vent" his frustrations upon Ophelia, the other female of importance in his life.


Though the reader realizes Hamlet's extreme anger and brooding throughout the entire play, he has no actual confrontation with another character until the aforementioned lines in Act III Scene I. One may notice the Prince's biting tone aimed at Claudius, Polonius or even Gertrude, but until his "Get the to a nunnery!" speech, no outbursts of pure rage in the presence of others can be found. This harshness in relation to Ophelia may be one of Hamlet's first moments of "action." The Prince seems reluctant to act upon any of his emotions toward anyone, though he often does give off an aura of discontentment and sorrow over his father's death. However, in these specific lines the audience sees Hamlet take an active stance in purging this young lady's once precious role from his life.


Kenneth Branagh places emphasis on the fact that Hamlet may be trying to convince his "enemies" that he is certainly mad. Other than the amusing "fishmonger" and "words, words, words" scene, a more serious approach to conveying this insanity could be taken; Hamlet's scurrilous behavior toward the fair Ophelia could be taken as a sure sign of craziness, for Polonius is quite positive that Hamlet is deeply in love with his daughter. By mistreating Ophelia, perchance Hamlet can trick Polonius into believing that he has gone mad; Hamlet's display...

Find Another Essay On Tough Love in Mel Gibson's Hamlet and Branagh's Hamlet

Love in Hamlet Essay

1151 words - 5 pages Relationships are complex. People often say and do things they do not mean, to the people they love. Things are said that can't be taken back and were only thought of after they were said. Every relationship goes through a rough time. No one is perfect and emotions fluctuate. When relationships are going well, it can be like heaven. When relationships aren't going well, tensions get built up and regrettable things can be done. In the play Hamlet

Comparison of Ophelia in Mel Gibson and Brannagh's film depiction of Hamlet

761 words - 3 pages a horribly frightening voice in Branagh's Hamlet. Fear is easily found in the eyes of Winslet as her father pushes her around with forceful hands. Despite her father's lecture on staying away from Hamlet, she continues throughout the conversation to have flashbacks of her and Hamlet making love. Kate plays her character faintly weaker here as she seems terrified at what her father might do next. The flashbacks hint that the single thing that can

Hamlet: Mel Gibson vs Kenneth Branagh

1388 words - 6 pages the tragic heroine. Ophelia’s betrayal in love and the loss of her father makes her the most insane female character in the play. Ophelia in Mel Gibson version was way more dramatic and expressive than the Ophelia from Branagh's version. Laertes in the Mel Gibson version of Hamlet was seen very weak as he did not express enough emotions towards Ophelia therefore we do not see him shed tears or express emotions over her death or her madness

Mel Gibson vs. Kenneth Branaugh as Hamlet

1041 words - 4 pages Mel Gibson vs. Kenneth Branaugh as HamletFirst in an installment looking at the modern film versions of Shakespeare's playsby Lynn Davison Jr., Contributing WriterThe recent "box office rebirth" of England's favorite bard has left Hollywood with much to do about interpreting Shakespeare's classic dramas. The characters of Ophelia, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, the gravedigger, and of course Hamlet himself take new life, as the greatest actors of

Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet

3846 words - 15 pages Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet So exactly why is it that Hamlet is still so popular with our modern day audiences when it was written for the naïve audiences of the 17th century? Personally I believe this is because Hamlet deals with many fresh issues including corruption, love and the supernatural, which still appeal to contemporary audiences. These

Applying Showalter’s Idea’s to Branagh's Film of Hamlet

2058 words - 8 pages Applying Showalter’s Idea’s to Branagh's Film Version of Hamlet       Elaine Showalter begins her essay, Representing Ophelia: Women, Madness, and the Responsibilities of Feminist Criticism, by criticizing analyses of Shakespeare's Hamlet that have virtually ignored the character of Ophelia in the past. The feminist critic argues that Ophelia is an important character in her own right, not just a foil to Hamlet. Further, she says that

The Effects of Love in Hamlet

1337 words - 5 pages Love is found everywhere in both fiction and reality and comes in many different forms. Love is no less common in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, and comes in no fewer forms. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, love is exceedingly important, whether it be romantic, taboo, or friendly, because it gives the reader an insightful way to analyze the reasons behind characters’ actions toward others. Romantic love is often considered the most sacred of all the different

The Effects of Love in Hamlet

923 words - 4 pages Love is easy to find in both fiction and reality and comes in many different forms. Love is no less common in Shakespeare’s Hamlet. More Intro. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, love is very important, whether it be romantic, incestuous or taboo, or friendly, because it gives the reader an insightful way to analyze the reasons behind characters’ actions toward others. Romantic love is often considered the most sacred of all the different types of love

The theme of familial love in Hamlet

2268 words - 9 pages a sense of duty to unconditionally love their family members, these parties would not even dream of taking revenge on those who dishonoured and hurt their parents, the way that Hamlet and Laertes did in Hamlet. Taking revenge for a family member's death, in this case a parent's, is no longer a natural occurrence like it was in Hamlet's time. Today, people leave this so-called revenge up to the courts and are usually satisfied with that, not

Hamlet and Gertrude, love or hate

941 words - 4 pages Imagine it, while away at college you receive word that your beloved father who had seemed in good health only a short while ago has died leaving your mother and yourself. This situation would be enough to bring great depression to even the strongest of souls but for Hamlet, the fictional prince of Denmark in Shakespeare's play of the same name, this is not his imagination but cruel reality. Not only has his father passed but, as if to mock the

Love in the Two Tragedies: William Shakespeare's Romeo & Juliet and Hamlet

4913 words - 20 pages Two among the famous works of Shakespeare are Romeo and Juliet and Hamlet. And in both of these works, love is portrayed in different ways. Romeo and Juliet disregarded their obstacles and pursued their love until their death while Hamlet and Ophelia allowed family circumstances to affect their relationship.Both couples encountered problems that involved each one's family affecting each couple's relationship. In Romeo and Juliet, even before the

Similar Essays

Hamlet: Branagh's Ophelia And Showalter's Representing Ophelia

2060 words - 8 pages Hamlet: Branagh's Ophelia and Showalter's Representing Ophelia       Ophelia falls to the floor, her screams contrasting eerily with the song pieces she uses as her speech.  In an instant she is writhing and thrusting her pelvis in such a gross sexual manner that it becomes clear that, in his film interpretation of William Shakespeare's Hamlet, Kenneth Branagh wants to imply a strong relationship between female insanity and female

Love And Sexuality In Hamlet Essay

2146 words - 9 pages The aim of this paper is to analyze the themes of love and sexuality in one of Shakespeare's most famous plays, Hamlet. As a playwright, Shakespeare depicted human nature profoundly, therefore, in Hamlet we may find as many kinds of love as the number of relationships that are described and intermingled. There is romantic love, paternal and maternal love, and friendship, which is love among people of the same rank, class or sex. The love present

Inaccessible Oedipus: Comparing Olivier's And Branagh's Women (An Contrast Between Gertrude And Ophelia In Lawrence Olivier's Hamlet And Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet)

1153 words - 5 pages young boy falls in love with his mother and may even develop sexual feelings towards her. The boy sees his father as a rival for his mother’s love, and the child often develops aggression or even jealously towards his father (Coleman) The problem with using the Oedipus complex in describing Hamlet is that the Oedipus complex peaks between ages 3 and 6. While parents of young children may readily identify with the concept as seen in their

Comparison Of Ethan Hawke And Kenneth Branagh's Versions Of Hamlet

1057 words - 4 pages Comparison of Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh's Versions of Hamlet Modern day directors use a variety of methods to hold ones interest. Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh’s created versions of Hamlet that shared some similarities, but ultimately had many differences in respects to an audience’s appeal. An appealing movie is one that has an alluring ambiance and an intellectual stimulus. With these two movie versions, a setting and a mood forced