Traditional Literature: Three Cinderellas Essay

956 words - 4 pages

Most people are familiar with the Cinderella story as told in the translation by Marcia Brown. There are also cultural and parodied versions of this tale. For a cultural version, I will be referring to Sootface, an Ojibwa tale retold by Robert D. San Souci and illustrated by Daniel San Souci (San Souci, 1994). The parody I've chosen is "Cinderumpelstiltskin", found in the book The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales, by Jon Scieszka and illustrated by Lane Smith (Scieszka, 1992). All three renditions are picture storybooks, and have similarities in the cast of characters and in the motifs of transformation and magic, but there are significant differences within those similar themes.
The three stories have honored illustrators in common. Brown's Cinderella earned a Caldecott Medal, while Scieszka's The Stinky Cheese Man won a Caldecott Honor award. Daniel San Souci, the illustrator of Sootface, did not get an award for this book, but has won several awards for his other work. As for the illustrations themselves, they vary widely. Since Brown translated the original from Charles Perrault, she chose to illustrate the story with details from French court life in the late seventeenth century. The pictures are drawn with a light hand, in pen and ink and four color gouache. For Sootface, Daniel San Souci used watercolors in rich forest hues. Like Brown, he researched the setting for the story and included details true to the life of the Ojibwa tribe in the mid eighteenth century. Lane's illustration for "Cinderumpelstiltskin" stands apart from the first two in many ways. There is only one picture for the one-page story. The only common character shown is Cinderella; the author melds Cinderella's story with Jack's (from "Jack's Bean Problem") and Rumpelstiltskin, so those two characters are pictured as well. The picture is done in oil and collage, with dark brown tones, an (Brown, 1954) (San Souci, 1994) (Scieszka, 1992)abstract feel, and little detail beyond the characters. We can tell by looking at the illustration alone that this is no ordinary retelling of the Cinderella story.
A young woman in distress is the common main character, and there are similarities and slight differences in the woman's family, and in the prince figure, as well. The Cinderella figure portrayed by Brown and Scieszka are already beautiful. Poor Sootface's beauty has been scarred by ashes from the fire; her hair is singed. In all three renditions, the mother of the Cinderella figure has died. Both Brown's and Scieszka's Cinderellas have wicked stepmothers and mean stepsisters. Sootface has no stepmother; it's her mean sisters that mock her and make her do their work. The father figures are either absent or powerless to help Cinderella's situation. The father of Brown's Cinderella is "tied hand and foot to his wife's apron strings". Sootface's father...

Find Another Essay On Traditional Literature: Three Cinderellas

Poetry's Role In The Heian Period

1571 words - 6 pages popularity of the two poetry anthologies Man'yōshū and Kokinwakashū, an important element of Heian period literature. The three types of poetry-inspired literature in the Heian period were monogatari(narrative fiction), setsuwa(secular or religious-type stories that were popular from the eighth century to the medieval period), and nikki(poetic diaries, also referred to as utanikki). All of these forms of literature contributed famous works of

Modernism and Dylan Thomas Essay

1781 words - 7 pages (“Modernism”- Literature Periods and Movements). Many writers from this era, called Modernists, were experimenting with their writing by coming up with new ways to explain their thoughts, which made them different from preexisting authors. Dylan Thomas is an example of a Modernist who clearly shows Modernistic characteristics in his work by breaking away from traditional Victorian era proprieties. Unlike many authors predating his time, Dylan Thomas


1476 words - 6 pages tradition, and though many important modernist authors, and critics (such as T.S. Eliot, or Harold Bloom) viewed tradition as an essential part of any literature, most authors wanted to free themselves from the constraints of past writers and traditional literature. Virginia Woolf once wrote that "if a writer were a free man and not a slave, if he could base his work upon his own feeling and not upon convention, there would be no plot, no comedy

The Effect of Cultural and Historical Situations on American Literature

1125 words - 5 pages south was devastated. Nevertheless, the country prospered. America became industrialized and saw innovations such as the railroads, telegraph, telephone, and electricity. Population increased due to immigration. Between the years of 1865 and 1914, American literature was mainly comprised of three writing styles; realism, regionalism, and naturalism. Realism aims to portray life realistically. Though realism’s subject matter concentrated on

Language Intuition in English Language Teaching

1507 words - 6 pages exams than students who receive traditional grammar teaching. 2) Fostering language intuition could substitute traditional grammar teaching in English language teaching in secondary school of China. Meanwhile, three research questions would be addressed as following: 1) What are the most common ways to nurture language intuition in the secondary school of China? 2) Could fostering language intuition substitute traditional grammar teaching in

A Modern Female Image in A Woman on a Roof

1317 words - 5 pages pivotal works of fiction speaking for women, Lessing demonstrates an unnamed woman bathing sunshine on the roof in the middle of summer in London, who has fortune, leisure and taste to enjoy herself under sunshine while three male workers make all efforts to approach her. No matter what method they try, the woman pays no attention to them with dignity.The image of this woman on the roof rebels against the traditional female image. In tradition

Lady Mary Wortley Montague's The Lover: A Ballad

2073 words - 8 pages (Damrosch, 2558). Nevertheless, by going against the traditional form of ballads, she shows that women were not going to define themselves by traditional stereotypes or try to fit into an image of what women were supposed to be. Montagu’s own frustration directed at an era in literature and time that depicts women passively can be felt by the reader by underlying tones of aggression from being held down by societal stereotypes and values

Traditional Ecological Knowledge

2254 words - 9 pages tamed by science. Throughout history in North America, the indigenous peoples culture, tradition and religion have always differed from the western way of life. In this essay, I will explore three views of nature-indigenous people’s view of nature, western science view and the economist view. Second, I will take a look out how a more ecocentric view can be formed by amalgamating western science with traditional ecological view of nature. I

George Orwell: Contentious Socialist Advocate

1667 words - 7 pages George Orwell, a politically distinguished novelist from Britain, was a primary source of scrutiny throughout his life; spanning from 1903 to 1950. Developing a broad separation between himself and fellow writers, Orwell stretched boundaries as brilliantly and gracefully as a ballerina extends through each outermost extremity. Producing timeless literature that relates to each successive generation, his novels will remain among the noted

Impact of World War One on American Literature

1943 words - 8 pages literature, America looked to her mother England for guidance. The very traditional literature that resulted had a strong emphasis on religion, family, and country. In early literature it was scandalous to question God; the family was only to be portrayed as a supportive, loving community; and dying for one's country was the ultimate act of bravery and honor. This glorification of war in early American literature and attitude created unrealistic

Gender Issues in Children's Literature: Then and Now

3491 words - 14 pages Gender Issues in Children's Literature: Then and Now Charlotte's Web, Anne of Green Gables, Treasure Island, Cinderella and Grimm's Brothers fairy tales, have all been treasures of society's basic children's literature. They covered their share of beauties, villains, conflicts and happy-endings that many of us remember till this day. But were we as society's children aware of the impact these stories made on our views of men and women

Similar Essays

Art, Literature, And The Carriers Of Civilization

1289 words - 5 pages . Reading their great works gives us a vivid image of what literature, writing, and reading is. The works of these three authors, when explored chronologically, poses a series of questions: What IS literature? What makes a great reader? How can I apply this to my writings? Literature, with all its intangibilities, opens a gateway to the genius of reading and writing.In essence, literature is a domain of many diverse outputs. Literature cannot be simply

Little Souna: Building A Sense Of National Identity

1715 words - 7 pages “Little Souna” in nourishing children’s initial sense of national identity can make sense. There are three major parts of analyses on the “Little Souna” in the essay below: the first part concerns with the linguistics, where the function of language, sound and words will be examined; the second part is related to the traditional culture such as traditional music, traditional literature and traditional morality; the third part is a case study of

Modernism, Modernists In American Literature, Robert Frost, Wallace Stevens, Ezra Pound, And T.S Eliot.

1313 words - 5 pages something which is enough. He talks about very different ideas for modern literature. He says society is broken down, we can't repeat things that described and he also says that we have to forget our past; we have to give up traditional. We must find the new context; it must be new poetry and new idea. Stevens was also called Supreme Fiction because he was thinking that poetry as a way of understanding reality.Ezra Pound is the most important writer

Postmodernism In The Theatre Essay

942 words - 4 pages were occurring during the 19th and 20th century, in which the modernist artists used as a model of change from traditional forms. The postmodernist movement questions such acceptance of change as truth and is characterized by the rejection of any absolute truth, the idea that facts are not always true, the idea that all religions should be recognized as legitimate, rationalization, and equality. Three theorists that we have studied this semester