Tragedy In Drama Essay

1706 words - 7 pages

Tragedy and Drama

In a range of dramatic works from Agamemnon to Hamlet, one sees the range of development of the tragic form, from the earliest Greek to the later Shakespearean tragedies. There are two basic concepts of tragedy: the concept introduced by Aristotle in his Poetics, and the concept developed by Frederick Nietzsche in his "The Birth of Tragedy." Many dramas can be reviewed to reveal the contrast between these two concepts of tragedy, and demonstrate the development of the tragic form over time.

The idea of Greek tragedy stems from Aristotle’s definition of a tragic hero. In Aristotle’s definition, the tragic hero must be a person of high standing so their fall from glory will be all the more horrible. The hero’s story must evoke pity for the hero and fear of his fall, so the hero cannot be completely evil. Also, the hero must have a tragic flaw, a characteristic that, in excess, causes him to bring some disaster upon himself, and because of this, he cannot be completely good either. It is important to note that the root of the term tragic flaw is the Greek word “hamartia”, which is actually better translated as an error in judgement. Often this flaw or error has to do with fate ­ a character tempts fate, thinks he can change fate or doesn't realize what fate has in store for him. In Agamemnon, the classic Greek drama, Aeschylus demonstrates the concept of the tragic flaw in the character of Agamemnon. While on his journey to the battle at Troy, Agamemnon has to make the choice to sacrifice his daughter for the sake of his fleet. It is this choice that begins the cycle of tragedy. Agamemnon’s wife, Clytemnestra, sees her husband’s act as unforgivable, and upon his return from battle, she murders him in an act of vengeance.

However, this is not the only revenge taking place. Clytemnestra’s lover, whose father Thyestes was tricked by Agamemnon into devouring his own children, also justifies Agamemnon’s murder as revenge for the acts committed against his family. So while Agamemnon is heralded as a hero in the battle of Troy, his less admirable side is also revealed. In keeping with the Aristotelian concept of tragedy, Agamemnon is seen as neither entirely good nor entirely bad, thus invoking pity. But his decision to sacrifice his daughter for the good of his fleet and his acts against Thyestes demonstrates the fatal error in judgement that would lead to his fall.

Oedipus Rex is considered by most as the source for Aristotle’s ideas about tragedy, as it is a classic example of a hero with a tragic flaw that brings about his downfall. Again, we have a person of high standing in Oedipus, who is neither entirely good nor entirely bad. However, it is Oedipus’ pride that pervades as his tragic flaw throughout the play. It is pride that causes Oedipus to believe the rumor of his questionable parentage and further, to go to the oracle. It is again pride that causes him to leave Corinth in attempt to defy the prophecy of the...

Find Another Essay On Tragedy In Drama

The History of Drama from the Romantic Period to Modern Times.

544 words - 2 pages involved major innovations in technology as photographically accurate scene pictures could be mounted on stage. Also, the events of the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars greatly impacted drama. Playwrights of the mid-nineteenth century focused on "uniting long lost relatives, exposing a villain's true motives that would end in true love and virtue" (Evans 143). These themes set the stage for modern play developments. Many playwrights of today

Aristotle’s Poetics through Oedipus Rex Essay

1221 words - 5 pages Tragedy is a form of drama based on human suffering that is often described as bad things happening to good people. Many appeal to tragedy because they feel good that they feel dolorous for the person suffering. Greek playwrights used it entrance the emotions of the audience. Oedipus Rex, written by Sophocles, is a great example of a Greek tragedy. Around this time of Greek theatre, Aristotle wrote the Poetics, which analyzed tragic drama and

Eva Luna

918 words - 4 pages the events that happened in “The Legend of Sleepy Hallow” like the headless horseman, are part of the genre magical realism, which is another thing you cannot see in a performance. There are many other aspects other than drama, comedy, tragedy, and magical realism that you can see in storytelling other than what you can find in a theatrical performance.

Othello, The Moor of Venice

1322 words - 5 pages . William Shakespeare fulfills Aristotle’s requirements in this famous play. Aristotle the famous philosopher outlined several requirements in which a play or piece of drama is to follow. The first rule that is met in Shakespeare’s play is that Othello is considered tragic hero, which every tragedy must contain. According to Aristotle, the tragic hero must be a man in a position of power who is a good person and makes a mistake during the

Tragedy: Fact or Fiction?

2269 words - 9 pages Throughout time theatre has evolved and underwent so many metamorphosis that it is almost impossible to compare and discuss Tragedy as a theatre form in one essay. I have chosen to compare 20th Century Tragedy with Elizabethan Tragedy and how they vary from each other and even where they are the same in some areas.Renaissance drama developed in England during the reign of Elizabeth I in the latter part of the 16th century. Some academic

Othello: The Tragedy of an Aristotelian Tragic Hero

1677 words - 7 pages had a musical element that “Othello, the Moor of Venice” lacked. Works Cited Aristotle. Poetics. 350 B.C. Goode, William J. Marraige among the English Nobility in the 16th and 17th Centuries. Vol. 3. Cambdrige University Press, n.d. 2 vols. Kelly, H. A. Ideas And Forms Of Tragedy From Aristotle To The Middle Ages. Cambridge University Press, 1993. Kennedy, X.J. and Dana Gioia. Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, Drama, and

classic tragedy in modern perspective

6078 words - 24 pages . However, in the late 19th century, dramatists such as Ibsen and Chekhov, who truly conceived that it was no longer possible to write tragedies based on the classical conventions, helped develop a new form of tragedy which was totally in line with the modern consciousness and spirit and, at the same time, captured the depth and power of the ancient tragedies. Ibsen's The Wild Duck With Ibsen drama turned more to human soul and character, to

The Marxist Hamlet

884 words - 4 pages The Marxist Hamlet In his article "'Funeral Bak'd Meats:'  Carnival and the Carnivalesque in Hamlet," Michael D. Bristol mingles Marxism and Bakhtin's notion of double discoursed textuality into an unique reading of Shakespeare's drama as a struggle between opposing economic classes.  Bristol opens with a two paragraph preface on Marxism, highlighting Marx's own abnegation of Marxism:  "Marx is famous for the paradoxical claim that he was

Aristole

1607 words - 7 pages allowed for an audience of thousands to observe the theatrics and watch as the actors vie to win the drama competition. In addition, ancient Greek theater used dramas to relay moral and political messages to their communities. There are two different categories of drama: comedy and tragedy. Greek theater used two masks known as Thalia (comedy mask) and Melpomene (tragedy mask) to symbolize these two types. In a general sense comedy and tragedy

Macbeth's Downfall

961 words - 4 pages Macbeth’s Downfall Shakespeare created a character in Macbeth who is strongly influenced in his decision making throughout the drama of The Tragedy of Macbeth. This drama is a Tragedy, hence the title, and has a hero, in Macbeth, who has a downfall. Readers become aware of the aspects that lead up to this predicament. Macbeth’s downfall was contributed equally from Lady Macbeth, the three weird sisters, and Macbeth’s ambition. In the beginning

A brief history of drama

699 words - 3 pages language, strong plots, realistic settings and social critique. In realistic plays such as Henrik Ibsen's A Doll House, a very common situation involving an everyday married couple is reviewed and critiqued. In the naturalistic play Miss Julie by Swedish playwright August Strindberg, a naturalistic tragedy develops as the characters find themselves trapped in an odd love triangle. Both Naturalism and Realism were monumental to drama because they

Similar Essays

Essay On The Origins Of Greek Drama

607 words - 2 pages The history of Greek Drama:The origins of Greek drama are obscure, but it is known from Early Greek tradition that tragedy, drama, and comedy has evolved from dithyramb, the songs and for the Greek God Dionysus. It is important to understand that drama began in the Greek world as a form of religious ritual, which later became a form of entertainment for the Athenians, from there it evolved. ¹Greek drama and theater are theatrical traditions

Definition Of Tragedy According To Aristotle's "Poetics".

792 words - 3 pages elevated. The Greek root for Tragedy is tragoidia, which means something serious, but not necessarily a drama with an unhappy ending. Plato has called Homer's Odyssey a Tragedy, though it is not drama. Seriousness of subject is what really matters.Tragedy, F. L. Lucas maintains, had three different meanings in the three periods of literary history. In ancient times, a Tragedy meant a serious drama; in medieval times, a Tragedy meant a story with an

Oedipus As An Epic Poem By Ari

614 words - 2 pages Oedipus as a Tragedy by Aristotle's Definition A tragedy by definition is "a drama which recounts an important and casually related series of events in the life of a person of significance, such events culminating in an unhappy catastrophe, the whole treated with great dignity and seriousness". The Greek tragedies are plays based on myths which were well known and enjoyed by audiences. Most of the plays encompassed certain elements that

Robert Frost And Poetry Essay

3601 words - 14 pages drama in all degrees from general awareness to conscious imitation. Yet there has been no recreation or reproduction of Greek tragedy because its uniqueness is genuine, and in important ways not transferable. Even in itself, Greek Tragedy is resistant to any kind of systematization: there are intractable differences between the three major tragedians. The reason is that the three issues of tragedy i.e. Fate, Necessity and the nature of the Gods