Tragedy Versus Comedy Essay

1189 words - 5 pages

Emotion. Aside from the occasional exception, one could correctly assume the definite ability of emotional perception humans have. Depending upon the goal of a play, or other literary work, the plot of the aforementioned work is designed to evoke a specific, or a range of emotions. The manner in which the literary work in question, achieves a certain emotional response can be characterized by the specific literary elements the work contains. For example, two of the most popular literary styles are tragedies and comedies. The two evoke different responses, and each style can be distinguished by its specific attributes. One could argue that a comedy is the complete opposite of a tragedy, and vice versa, since the two tend to have stark differences. The key differences between a tragedy and a comedy are the character of the protagonist,the struggle of the protagonist, and the conclusion.

In every society ever molded by the hands of man, an unquestionable though sometimes overlooked fact of such societies is the distinction between groups of individuals based upon their perceived worth. This distinction is a fundamental difference between a tragedy and a comedy. In a tragedy, a protagonist is "a prominent and powerful hero,(1),a king, or even a god (4). The hero tends to be stubborn, traditional, and experiences emotions strongly (2). The probability of an audience member having the ability to empathize with such an esteemed character, is low. A comedic protagonist tends to be quite the opposite. The protagonist of a comedy must display at least the minimum amount of personal charm to gain the audience's basic approval and support (1). The protagonist also tend to be more adaptable (2) than a tragic protagonist. The comedic protagonist has morals that are "average to below average" (1). Respect for authority or individuals in a position of authority, tends be less in a comedic play (2). Essentially, a protagonist from a tragedy and a protagonist from a comedy are found on different ends of a spectrum. A tragic protagonist values tradition, and the concept of throwing all of one's self into any given emotion or action. A comedic protagonist is more adaptable and is more focused on adjusting to circumstances through luck or will.

The circumstances surrounding any individual at any given point in their lives is unique for every individual. Whilst the same concept applies to both tragedies and comedies, there is a general struggle that pertains specifically to a tragedy, and in a distinctively different way to a comedy. In a tragedy, the protagonist has a struggle between man and fate/destiny (3), or in some cases, a struggle against social forces that are beyond man's control (2).Their struggle is dominated by fate or necessity (3). The struggle they face, is tantamount to, or even surpasses the aesthetic worth of the protagonist. Their struggle results in actions that will lead to certain and occasionally peculiar outcomes. In the beginning, the...

Find Another Essay On Tragedy versus Comedy

Analyzing the Contrast Of Romeo and Juliet

1719 words - 7 pages Analyzing the Contrast Of Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet is one of Shakespeare's greatest and most popular plays, a romantic tragedy written in about 1593. An underlying feature running throughout the play is Shakespeare's use of contrast, love/hate, young/old, life/death, light/dark, tragedy/comedy and real/unreal. Shakespeare draws out, illustrates and emphasises those contrasts by clever use of language,...

Compare and contrast: The Canterbury Tales

3366 words - 13 pages A COMPARISON AND CONTRAST:THE KNIGHT'S AND MILLER'S TALES REVISITEDThe Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer is a classic piece wherein pilgrims tell tales during their journey to a holy shrine in Canterbury. A Knight and Miller are two of the pilgrims. Chaucer gives personality to each character wherein a drunken Miller can tell a tale that is full of brilliant characterization and also have nicely balanced action, and a tough...

The transformation of Hamlet into Rosencrantz and Guilden are Dead and themes that were explored by both plays.

966 words - 4 pages Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are dead is a play written in 1967 by Tom Stoppard. He took two...

Classicism Versus Romanticism in Tom Stoppard's Arcadia

2536 words - 10 pages Tom Stoppard is one of the finest playwrights of the modern age. Some of his well-known plays are Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, The Coast of Utopia, Every Good Boy Deserves Favour, Professional Foul, The Real Thingand many more.The finest of all his plays is Arcadia.The literary meaning of the term “Arcadia” inspired Tom Stoppard to write his play Arcadia. It was titled “Et in Arcadia ego”. “Arcadia” actually means a vision of...

The Effects of Colors on Mood

1949 words - 8 pages Over the years, researchers have been studying the power of colors to influence every aspect of our life. Furthermore, color has been also employed to describe mood. Some frequently expressions employed when a person is feeling sad is to describe it as “feeling blue” or when a person falls in love is common to hear that this person view the world through “rose-colored glasses.” To be “green with envy” refers to a very jealous person or to “be...

Film Comparative: City of God and Sexy Beast

2295 words - 9 pages The films City of God and Sexy Beast are both crime films that share many similarities such as narrative shape, light, and in both films the narrative unravels in foreign countries. The on difference they have is the classification of crime genre. City of God 2002, directed by Fernando Meirelles depicts the Rocket’s past, how he became a photographer, and how he got out of the slums in a chilling sequence of flashbacks to the people he knew and...

Literary Love

1451 words - 6 pages Love - possibly the most powerful four-letter word known to man. A feeling and emotion so strong that it makes it nearly impossible to put its meaning into words. However, it is also one of the most explored subjects in the world of literature. Whether in a comedy or a tragedy, the theme of love is very often expressed. This theme can be expressed in many different ways, for example, positively causing everyone to live happily ever after in a...

The War Experience in Italian Film

3169 words - 13 pages The War Experience in Italian Film The experience of war as it is presented throughout the history of Italian cinema is a uniquely composite display of historical reverence and cultural consecration. An analysis of this experience in all of its manifestations can be discerned from the evaluation of one or several works from the post-World War II period within the corpus of the Italian cultural signification. It follows from this...

hypocrisy and vanity in joseph andrews

6817 words - 27 pages Hypocrisy and Vanity in Joseph AndrewsBy Caylen-Grasz | October 2013Page 1 of 2In his novel,...

Clockwork Orange

2301 words - 9 pages Clockwork Orange In all of my reading, I have come to the conclusion that Anthony Burgess is one of the greatest literary genius’s of the twentieth century. His masterpiece, A Clockwork Orange, is unrivaled in obvious depth, insight, and innovation. The novel is a work of such quality, such perfection, that it seems to be genuinely written by a literary demigod. The novel's main theme deals with free choice and spiritual freedom....

Gilgamesh, Achilles and the Human Condition

3848 words - 15 pages Gilgamesh, Achilles and the Human Condition Gilgamesh and Achilles, each heroes of their respective epic tales, embody the whole array of typical heroic attributes. They stand above. They are men set apart. They operate somehow in that area that lies between average mortals and the gods themselves. They are stronger, faster, more wily than those they face in battle. They overcome. They are men who stand alone in their various strengths. ...

Similar Essays

Tragedy And Comedy Essay

1007 words - 4 pages Some of the earliest traces of tragedy and comedy date back to Greek festivals honoring their gods. Among all the gods, Dionysus was honored with a festival called City Dionysia. This festival took place in Athens which was a preeminent core of theatrical performances at the time. The dithyramb, an ancient Greek hymn, was sung in honor of this god. In fact, tragedy and comedy almost originated as one. John Morreall of State University of New...

Comparing The Play Versus The Film Of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

884 words - 4 pages Comparing the Play versus the Film of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing ?Much Ado About Nothing'' is a postwar love story. Its principal subject is that of romance that may settle over the land after soldiers come home. I noticed that Much Ado is actually two love stories. One concerns sweetly innocent lovers who are driven apart by the plotting of enemies. The other involves very sarcastic lovers who are swept into each...

The Relationship Between Warm Colors And Positive Mood

1163 words - 5 pages This research is important because every day we have to make choices that include choosing a color when for example we decide what shade of makeup to use, what color of clothes to buy or decide what color to paint a wall. Even it has been proved that people often associate their mood with a specific color. Some frequently responses when a person is feeling sad is to describe it as “feeling blue” or when a person fall in love is common to hear...

"Twelfth Night" A Tragic Comedy

1214 words - 5 pages Shakespeare’s comedies have always had a distinct subtext of tragedy as shown in Twelfth Night. It teeters on the brink of tragedian literature similar to his tragedies, such as Hamlet, through the ambiguity of the main characters and unfinished resolutions. Comedies are generally morally clear- the villains and heroes are clearly defined. Twelfth Night’s characters have a layer of ambiguity stemming from their use of illusion in the...