Traglear King Lear As An Arthur Miller Tragedy

1216 words - 5 pages

King Lear as an Arthur Miller Tragedy 

 
    If we seek to justify Shakespeare's King Lear as a tragedy by applying Arthur Miller's theory of tragedy and the tragic hero, then we might find Lear is not a great tragedy, and the character Lear is hardly passable for a tragic hero. However, if we take Aristotle's theory of tragedy to examine this play, it would fit much more neatly and easily. This is not because Aristotle prescribes using nobility for the subject of a tragedy, but, more importantly, because he emphasizes the purpose of tragedy -- to arouse pity and fear in the audience, and thus purge them of such emotions.

Arthur Miller, in his famous 1949 essay, "Tragedy and the Common Man," states the following as the nature of the tragic hero:

…The tragic feeling is evoked in us when we are in the presence of a character who is ready to lay down his life, if need be, to secure one thing -- his sense of personal dignity. …The underlying struggle is that of individual attempting to gain his "rightful" position in his society. … Tragedy…is the consequence of a man's total compulsion to evaluate himself justly.

Now some people may find it doubtful whether Lear fits the above description. True, he is displaced from his "rightful position in society," namely, that of a king, but he has brought about displacement by himself. In addition, he shows few signs of struggling to regain that position or striving to "evaluate himself justly."

Lear is not forced, like Richard II is, to give up his crown. Although he is very old, he is not obliged to hand his power over to anyone, let alone divide his kingdom into three. Not only is he not obliged or compelled to do so, Kent even openly warns him against the act in Act I Scene i. Likewise, Lear unnecessarily stages a love-auction with his three daughters, which directly results in his dependence to Goneril and Regan, and the loss of his kingly dignity. Since he himself, not the environment surrounding him, is responsible for his misfortune, there cannot be a struggle between Lear and the society/environment, as Miller describes in his essay.

As for trying to regain his rightful status, King Lear has done little. At first he does not even understand his mistake. In [1.4], when he leaves Goneril because she cut his one hundred knights down to fifty, and then decides to return because Regan will allow only twenty-five [2.2], he is the same foolish Lear in [1.1] who banished Cordelia and believed flowery lies. He has not tried to evaluate himself justly at this point, or even acknowledge his misjudgment.

When he understands his mistake, realizing that Goneril and Regan are both heartless liars, and only Cordelia truly loves him, he starts to go mad. In his better moments he remembers to curse Goneril and Regan and lament his suffering, while in worse moments his utterance hardly make sense. Both are passive reactions to his misfortune, not active struggle for re-establishing his...

Find Another Essay On traglear King Lear as an Arthur Miller Tragedy

A View from the Bridge by Arthur Miller as a Tragedy

2594 words - 10 pages A View from the Bridge by Arthur Miller as a Tragedy A view from the Bridge was written by Arthur Miller in 1955 and set in the 1950's Brooklyn, New York. Most of this area was inhabited by immigrants that arrived from countries such as Italy and Sicily, before the restriction of immigrant's law was passed. Although the law denies people to migrate to the country. Illegal immigrants will often be smuggled in from countries like Sicily

King Lear and the Genre of Tragedy

1299 words - 6 pages A tragedy is a genre typically defined as a play that deals with a series of events that lead to the downfall of the hero. Written between 1604 and 1606, ‘King Lear’ falls into the genre of tragedy, depicting the destruction and downfall of the main character (Abrams). The play centres on Lear, an aging king who, in his retirement, decides to divide his kingdom between his three daughters while retaining the title and privileges of being king

King Lear and the Theme of Tragedy

1175 words - 5 pages A tragedy is a genre typically defined as a play that deals with a series of events that lead to the downfall of the hero. Written between 1604 and 1606, ‘King Lear’ falls into this genre of tragedy, depicting the destruction and demise of the main character (Abrams). The play centres on Lear, an aging king who, in his retirement, decides to divide his kingdom between his three daughters while retaining the title and privileges of being king

The Tragedy of King Lear Analysis

2197 words - 9 pages The Tragedy of King Lear Analysis Lear: By Jupiter, I swear no! Kent: By Juno, I swear ay. In The Tragedy of King Lear, particularly in the first half of the play, Lear continually swears to the gods. He invokes them for mercies and begs them for destruction; he binds both his oaths and his curses with their names. The older characters—Lear and Gloucester—tend view their world as strictly within the moral framework of the pagan

Oedipus the King and The Tragedy of King Lear

1190 words - 5 pages further heightened, by the fact that Teiresias is physically blind and Oedipus is seeing. For an audience these two images would provide an immediate physical difference among the two, that they could easily identify. In The Tragedy of King Lear blindness is an appropriate metaphor, since Lear’s behavior is just like that of a blind man’s. Lear is just as blind to the possible consequences of his rash decisions, as a blind man is to the

The Crucible by Arthur Miller is a Greek Tragedy

1173 words - 5 pages for all times.  The play is also his greatest tragedy because of the strict adherence to the form of classical tragedy as outlined by Aristotle. Works Cited American Writers. Ed. Leonard Unger. Vol. III. New York: Scribner’s, 1974. 145-169. Bigsby, Christopher. Introduction. The Crucible. By Arthur Miller. New York: Penguin Books, 1995. Matlaw, Marion. Modern World Drama: An Encyclopedia. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co

Tragedy Defined By Arthur Miller: Othello And Willy Loman

627 words - 3 pages "Tragedy and the Common Man" written by Arthur Miller defines what he feels is a tragedy. There are several different characteristics that Miller feels defines a tragic figure. One is that the main character does whatever he has to do to secure his personal sense of dignity. Another key part of a tragedy is the "tragic flaw" that the main character has. When the character recognizes his tragic flaw, he tries to overcome it, and fails in the

Tragedy and the Common Man by Arthur Miller

1843 words - 7 pages with the same core, and this gives people the power to influence the actions of those around them. In “Tragedy and the Common Man,” Arthur Miller discusses the role that tragedy plays in life. He talks about how many choose to believe that tragedy only affects those in a higher position, but Miller points out that all humans are the same and we all experience tragedy at some point. Miller states that tragedy is a part of life. All of us must face

All My Sons by Arthur Miller: A Modern American Tragedy

991 words - 4 pages All My Sons by Arthur Miller produced by Scrappy Coco Productions, is based on the t modern representation of an American tragedy about the Keller family in 2010. Family man Joe Keller, a middle-aged, successful entrepreneur makes a decision which leads to tragic outcome. Under government contract he was to produce a fleet of Toyotas for members of the military. Joe approves the use of faulty parts on a production of these automobile’s resulting

king lear and the tragedy within king lear - english 12 - essay

857 words - 4 pages Calum Nieass 26th September 2017 English 12 Block 1 King Lear essay: Shakespeare’s King Lear is all about a family tragedy, which makes the play that much more relatable because one has at least some sort of family even if they are not blood-related. One is stuck with a family forever, one has no choice in this. If this eternal relationship turns for the worst, that means that the outcome of an immoral action is going to be more severe than it

Conventions of Tragedy in A View From The Bridge By Arthur Miller

1731 words - 7 pages the uncompromising role of fate. 'I knew, I knew then and there - I could have finished the whole story that afternoon.' 'I knew where he was going to end.' Fate is a compulsory convention of a modern tragedy, perhaps the most important one. Fate decides our destiny and fate decides when our terminal existence will come to an end. Arthur Miller uses literary devices such as imagery also to help establish the fact

Similar Essays

Traglear King Lear As A Bradley Tragedy

1330 words - 5 pages King Lear as a Bradley Tragedy      King Lear meets all the requirements of a tragedy as defined by Andrew Cecil Bradley.  Bradley states that a Shakespearean tragedy has to be the story of the hero and there is exceptional suffering and calamity slowly being worn in.  Also, the current time must be contrasted to happier times.  The play also depicts the troubled parts in the hero’s life and eventually he dies instantaneously because of

Traglear Tragic Character In King Lear

945 words - 4 pages serious mental and physical dilemmas. And although the two characters are very similar, the story of King Lear is tragic, and Gloucester’s is not. Lear’s tragedy is a result of bringing fate upon himself, which in turn stripes Lear of everything, and only in his final moments does Lear resolve some of his problems with a catharsis. To ensure that Lear’s story is indeed tragic while Gloucester’s is not, an examination of tragedy is necessary. Also

Traglear Tragic Hero In King Lear

1606 words - 6 pages main character in King Lear was affirmed as the tragic hero because the play meets all the requirements of a tragedy.   In order for a character to be qualified as a tragic hero, he must be in a high status on the social chain and the hero also possesses a tragic flaw that initiates the tragedy.  The fall of the hero is not felt by him alone but creates a chain reaction that affects everyone around him.  The hero should

The Tragedy Of King Lear Essay

1029 words - 5 pages Gonorill. Regan. Cordelia. Those names should ring a bell if you have ever read or seen “The Tragedy of King Lear.” The plot behind this play revolves around King Lear’s relationships with each of these three characters; his daughters. King Lear has a different relationship with each of them. Gonorill, Regan and Cordelia all have very distinct personalities. In this play, King Lear decided it was time to give up and divide his kingdom amongst