Trans Nationalism And Border Crossing Essay

1246 words - 5 pages

From the time of childhood, the world becomes full of imaginary lines. From property borders to adult spaces, people quickly learn that certain spaces denote special uses. This extends to the idea of nationalism in which people who exist in certain spaces are loyal to that space and believe they possess qualities unique from people in other spaces. Nationalism is especially important in post-partition India in which citizens attempted to draw cultural lines between themselves and the West. This can be seen in Amitav Ghosh’s The Shadow Lines in which the Grandma represents cultural nationalism which conflicts with Tridib’s representation of border crossing. This can also be seen in other texts such as Gandhi’s Autobiography and Natyantara Saghal’s Rich Like Us. Both texts examine the relationship between India, the West, and social class while attempting to simultaneously exist in that tension.
First, in Ghosh’s The Shadow Lines the character of the Grandma works to represent the idea of cultural nationalism. The Grandma is deathly afraid of laziness and insists that everyone in her household be in constant motion, never idling or resting. She believes that this is linked to poverty and poverty is the reason that the British can oppress India. This is a representation of cultural nationalism because the Grandma wants India to triumph over their oppressors. This falls in line with Gandhi’s texts in which he confesses he started eating meat in order to grow strong and conquer the British. The idea was that the British can only win as long as they continue to be strong through eating meat which is similar to the Grandma’s idea that the British could overcome India through wealth and hard work. The Grandma also supports Dhaka, an Indian nationalist group that was considered by the government to be terrorists. She says she would have joined the movement if she had not still had schooling left. This contrasts with the way that she believes in order and following the law but in her culturally nationalist ideals it somehow fits. To her, one can be a law-abiding citizen but still support terrorist organizations.
In contrast, Tridib represents border crossing and upholding Western culture in an Indian setting. His education alone separates him from the rest of society, as does his acquaintance with English people. He claims to have been in England for an extended amount of time and likes to brag about that to anyone within earshot. He is also lazy and rarely does much except for occasionally studying for university. The Grandma opposes this because she fells that he is the worst kind of lazy man who will never make anything of himself. However, she still welcomes Tridib into her home because he is the son of rich relatives. Tridib’s border crossing enthralls the narrator and exposes him to an experience beyond the cultural nationalism of his home-life.
Also, the grandmother’s house represents the partition; however, it represents the...

Find Another Essay On Trans-nationalism and Border Crossing

The Kosovo Crisis Essay

2247 words - 9 pages A. Plan of the Investigation What political factors contributed to the idea of Albanian nationalism after the breakup of Yugoslavia that contributed to the Kosovo Crisis of 1999. To determine the political factors that contributed to Albanian nationalism, this investigation will focus on the aftermath of the breakup of Yugoslavia, the social landscape of Kosovo after the breakup and the Kosovo Crisis of 1999. The views of the Albanians and Serbs

Immigration and Border Security Essay

1567 words - 6 pages percent of people crossing illegally” (CQ Researcher). According to the Conservative Caucus, they do not believe the bill will have that much effect when it comes to border security. The U.S has spent a vast amount on border security over the past decades and they have not been able to prevent the large amount of illegal immigration. “S. 744 offers little assurance that illegal immigration will be stopped and no reliable means of obtaining a measure

Illegal Immigrants Entering America

1082 words - 4 pages Mexican immigrants, but permission by Americans, which is not easy. America is nonverbally saying, “If we do not invite you into our country, stay out.” The border obviously denotes a physical barrier between two countries and their association; however, it also symbolizes a metaphorical barrier. This Metaphorical barrier focuses on the struggle of surviving in America. Crossing the physical border is only half the battle, for even after arriving, with

Wall on the American-Mexican Border

752 words - 3 pages Wall on the American-Mexican Border Government officials are planning to build a wall on the American-Mexican border. Building a wall on the American-Mexican border can help and also hurt the citizens in America. Although some officials believe that building a wall on the American-Mexican border can limit the growth of population in America, building a wall can also limit the amount of drugs being smuggled into America and it can keep out

Importance of Border Security

1166 words - 5 pages border there has been less crossing of illegal immigrants and an increase in search and seizure of drugs such as cocaine, marijuana and heroin. This is a memento that effective border security is very important in the prohibition of drugs. Since 9/11, there has been a deficiency in additional terrorist attacks in the U.S. The omnipresence of these new strategies has been successful in protecting the nation’s border. With the on-going dilemma between


1217 words - 5 pages law, so the possibility of bad people getting through is mitigated.This new Smart Border concept will attempt to prevent criminals from crossing, than apprehend them once they do cross. The concept will use the already existing law within and throughout the country, not just at the border.The technocrats hope their opposition, the law enforcements view, implies tight controls that are intolerable, expensive and probably ineffective. In short, it

Globalisation And Its Effects On Australian National Identity And Democracy

1088 words - 5 pages Paul Keating put it; "at the arse end of the world" "the nexus between nation state and national identity is breaking down under the pressures of economic and cultural globalisation." As Alan Asher of the ACCC put it "if you look at the huge proportion of our lives, that is inherently trans-border, whether its culture, the economy, the environment, law enforcement, even the weather and so for people who want to cling to a notion of national

The North American Free Trade Agreement

3714 words - 15 pages . from Mexico. Traffic through Texas has increased 19% since 1994, to a level of 17,582 trucks per day. Since NAFTA was enacted, the number of trucks crossing California's San Diego Otay Mesa border has more than doubled, from 450,000 to 1,000,000. The EPA has suggested that border-area residents are exposed to health-threatening levels of air pollutants, including carbon monoxide [particulate], and now the following border areas exceed ambient air

The Influence of Joan of Arc in French History

1798 words - 7 pages . France was already in a dire situation when Joan of Arc was born to Jacques D'Arc and Isabelle Romée in January 1412, during the reign of Charles VI in France and the near the end of the peaceful period brought by the Truce of Leulinghen between France and the English-Burgundian alliance, into the farming village of Domremy, near the border between area controlled by France and the area taken by England and Burgundy. Joan's voices, from the

Adjusting To Terrorism

709 words - 3 pages the job done -- except here, on America's own borders. Why is that? Every year, our border crisis worsens. First, it was drugs. Then disease. Then, it was illegal aliens, crossing by the hundreds and then by the millions. And now, terrorists are crossing our borders, determined to rain more death and destruction down upon us. If there were ever a time for the United States to put troops on the border, this is it!" ( own troops at

The Border Fence: Consequences

1253 words - 5 pages There has always been controversy in immigrants crossing over to the US-Mexico border illegally.Our government has turned to a border fence as the solution. As US citizens we should see that building the fence will have a huge impact on our people and country.The fence can do good in so many ways such as creating jobs in construction, also giving the national security more power of the regions along the border, and decreasing the amount of

Similar Essays

The Isolation, Exploitation, And Discrimination Of Border Crossing

1863 words - 7 pages When humans interact through the crossing borders and migration into new regions, the residents and immigrants are faced with the problems of racism, segregation, misinterpretation, and even exploitation of others. The Spaniards explored the New World in the 15th and 16th centuries and they saw a land full of economic opportunities. The native residents had no idea of what the European's intentions were with their exploration efforts. Central

Drawing Lines And Crossing Them: A Look At The Complexities Of The Us Mexico Border

983 words - 4 pages Drawing Lines and Crossing Them: A Look at the Complexities of the US-Mexico Border American writer/reporter, Walter Lippmann, once said, “The great social adventure of America is no longer the conquest of the wilderness, but the absorption of fifty different peoples.” Over the course of its history, the United States has evolved into the country of all countries – in more ways than one. Not only is the US comprised of an array of people from

To Fence Or Not To Fence

875 words - 4 pages Although the United States has stopped building the fences along the Arizona border, it is clear by the statistics that the fences that are built along the Arizona border has significantly help deter and curtail some illegal immigrants from crossing those parts of border, so why stop building the fences along Arizona’s border? Some people are against the fences because of the danger of people crossing into other isolated parts of the desert

The European Union As A Model For Globalization

1899 words - 8 pages “unsparing social programs” (Kirby, 2011, para. 5) and more recent bank bail outs the European monetary system is stretched to its limits which could arguably “lead to the collapse of the euro currency zone” (Kirby, 2011, para. 4). Another sign of trouble for the EU is that “the borders of EU member states are effectively coming back to life” (Kupchan, 2010, para. 14). Border crossing checks are once again being conducted in some parts of Germany