Transfer Tax Essay

1830 words - 7 pages

Wealth Transfer: The Irreconcilable Double Standards of Hostility and Envy
Hostility: Emotional Grounds For Transfer Taxes
I have to disclose first that I, throughout personal backgrounds, have a deep-rooted hostility toward the rich or idea of transferring wealth within wealthy people. Thus, my thought is thoroughly biased for the taxation that can limit the transfer of wealth. Oddly, however, I have always envied and admired the rich and their power with a naïve hope that I might be rich someday like them. Thus, I disagree with the taxation, which would be equivalent or amount to the near confiscation of property at death as suggested by Ascher. It is my personal belief that many, if not most, people would have similar irreconcilable thoughts with respect to tax on the transfer of wealth. Therefore, the discussion of transfer taxes (estate taxed supplemented by gift taxes) appears to be disclosing deep-rooted emotional response of individuals of how the playing field and rules of the game must be structured.
The hostility toward the rich and passing all of their wealth to subsequent generations is largely originated from the resistance of the perpetuation of wealth within wealthy families, thereby solidifying the existing social structure. Despite of the danger of over simplification, the wealth has been historically equated with the power and thus the rich, with more resources, exercise some power over others. The wealth and the accompanying power, which allow the rich to enjoy the dominance over others and higher standard of life quality (even if suspicious to call it as higher life quality), are successfully transferred to next generations through the inheritance of the wealth. The idea that the rich class can stay within a socially powerful class through an impenetrable system of wealth transfer, while the underprivileged class is hardly successful to move up to the class despite of the unceasing effort and hard work, even if not impossible, brings the uncomfortable feeling of unfairness or relative deprivation. Even if the poor or relatively underprivileged class is not deprived of anything directly by the rich, the huge discrepancy of the starting lines justifies the feeling of deprivation of equal opportunity to compete.
The underlying rationale of leveling the playfield in the taxing wealth transfer is best described by analogizing to a sports game, such as tracks. A player from underprivileged family does not think that the game is unfair with the reason that other player is born with good body structure and talent as an athlete, is provided with top-rate training with expensive coaches, or is raised with top quality of nutrition. However, a player will think that the game is unfair if the other player starts far ahead of him and the distance of the players is realistically too far to catch up. People have a strong belief or at least they want to believe that, even if they are poorly nurtured and not provided expensive...

Find Another Essay On Transfer Tax


3362 words - 13 pages to collect and manage the property taxes as their own sources of revenue. For this purpose, the transfer for two components of property taxes which are BPHTB and PBB-P2 as local government authority is regulated under Law No.28/2009 on Local Government Tax and Fees. However, this process will not go smoothly as predicted. Both Central and Local Government will face the challenges which can suppress the authority transfer. This paper aims to

Taxation influences multinational companies structure and investment Decisions

992 words - 4 pages . Transfer pricing 5. Royalty payments. In my example later I will also discuss specific strategies used by Google such as the double Irish, Dutch sandwich. 1.) The decision of where a company locates its head office is quite an important one if trying to avoid tax. The importance of the decision is determined by the fact that a company usually has to pay tax in the country in which it is incorporated. So, the choice to locate a company in a high

Canon of Taxation by Adams Smith

2434 words - 10 pages imposed on income, property, company profit and capital gains. While an indirect tax is one whose burden are transferred to other individuals usually the consumer who have purchased a good or service. This form of tax is levied on goods and services, the taxpayer can transfer both the burden and the incidence to the ultimate consumer or user of the goods or services. These could come inform of Value Added Tax, Import Duty or Export Duty. A good tax

Tax Reform

1640 words - 7 pages our economy is the global reach of our businesses, but the way to make sure that happens is not to reward our company for moving jobs off our shores or transfer profits to overseas tax havens." (Ruggeri) Another force trying to keep corporate tax rates high is the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. The OCED is an organization whose mission is to promote policies that will develop the financial and community well being of

Flat taxes in developing and developed nations

2077 words - 9 pages . Understanding Tax Evasion Dynamics. Cambridge, Massachusetts: NBER. Frey, B. S., 2011. Happiness: A Revolution in Economics. Economica, 78(310), pp. 397-399. Fuest, C., Peichl, A. & Schaefer, T., 2005. Dokumentation FiFoSiM: Integriertes Steuer-Transfer-Mikrosimulations- und CGE-Modell. FiFo Discussion Papers - Finanzwissenschaftliche Diskussionsbeiträge. Fuest, C., Peichl, A. & Schaefer, T., 2008. Is a flat tax reform feasible in a grown-up democracy of

Transfer Pricing In Brazil

1860 words - 7 pages General Overview of Brazilian Transfer Pricing Control Rules by Lionel Nobre - Pontifical University of Sao Paulo Following the globalization trend present in the world nowadays initially triggered by Law nr. 9.249, of December 26th, 1995, and later complemented by further laws, Brazil in the late nineties adopted once and for all a more international approach to taxation.Brazil can now boast having truly international mechanisms for tax

Municipal Budgeting and Revenue

2493 words - 10 pages Taxes – This initiative passed in 1986 amended the government code in relation to general and special taxes. In order to raise local general taxes an ordinance that states the type of tax, tax rate, and method of collection must be approved by 2/3 of the governing body. Special taxes must receive approval of 2/3 of the popular vote prior to being enacted. Proposition 90 – Property Tax: Transfer of Base Year Home Value for Seniors – This

Tax Havens

1081 words - 4 pages States taxes. (Ruggeri) He has faced criticisms. 83 of the largest 100 companies in the United States use overseas tax havens. Some critics argue that the rules will make companies less internationally competitive. Obama argues "One of the strengths of our economy is the global reach of our businesses, but the way to make sure that happens is not to reward our company for moving jobs off our shores or transfer profits to overseas tax havens

Corporation Tax and the Harberger General Equilibrium Model

937 words - 4 pages easily transfer their share of ownership through the exchanges in the financial markets. The tax on a company’s profits which is the difference between the company’s gross income and its business costs is thus called the corporation tax. Now it may appear that as the tax is on the profits of the company and so the company must pay the tax, however there are many individuals such as the employees, consumers and owners on whom the corporation tax

Tax Legislation in Mauritus

1587 words - 7 pages . • Profitable firms are required either to spend 2% of their profits on government-approved Corporate Social Responsibility schemes, or to transfer these funds directly to the government to be used in the fight against poverty. Branch or subsidiary: Branches and resident subsidiary companies pay tax in Mauritius on the same basis; dividends (for the subsidiary) and net profits (for the branch) can both be remitted abroad without deduction of withholding

Tax planning and Tax Avoidance Analysis

2668 words - 11 pages BEPS of multinationals from countries in which they were created originally to other countries as a measure of cutting down on tax liability. Further, one international framework in applying taxes in different countries has the benefit of implementing transfer pricing system. Advantage of transfer pricing system is that it ensures that governments that have multinational companies operating in their territories are taxed on profits that are

Similar Essays

Generation Skipping Tax Essay

1331 words - 6 pages Generation Skipping Transfer Tax INTRODUCTION AND ISSUE The United States generation skipping transfer tax imposes a tax on gifts and transfers to people more than one generation younger than the donor. An example is a grandparent giving a gift to a grandchild, in turn skipping their own child. Grandparents would give a gift to their grandchildren to avoid or defer federal gift taxes, but this is now subject to a generation skipping tax

Retrospective Taxation Proposed By Financial Bill. 2012

594 words - 3 pages . Vodafone content was that the provisions were not applicable as the primary obligation to discharge the tax was with the payee that is HTIL. Moreover withholding tax provisions cannot have extra territorial application and is applied to companies of Indian residence only. Treatment of Capital Gains on extra territorial Transaction According to section of the Income Tax Act, where a non resident earns any income by the transfer of capital

Taxation System In Bhutan. Good Or Bad?

1693 words - 7 pages transparency. BIT and CIT were fixed on 30% on net profit. PIT was based on income slabs, for example: People earning below Nu. 100,000 per year were exempted from tax; property transfer tax was 5%; and land tax, cattle tax and house tax were categorized under rural tax. Tax has contributed in revenue generation, which is one of the largest contributors for country’s developmental activities. The fiscal year 2012- 2013 revenue reports shows that, 73

Tax Evasion Or Tax Avoidance: Is Starbucks` Tax Planning And Practice Setting A Bad Precedent?

1949 words - 8 pages , etc. All of these latter may attract penalties upon assessment and are offences which are open to prosecution. The ordering of one’s affairs, referred to above, is permissible unless it falls within the terms of the specific anti-avoidance sections. In my opinion the Starbucks scenario, transfer pricing and tax avoidance feature prominently as opposed to tax evasion. This is because Starbucks may have undertaken an intentional plan to transfer