This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Transfer To Adult Criminal Court Essay

1025 words - 5 pages

There are times where a juvenile may be eligible for transfer to adult criminal court. There are certain criteria that must be met for this to happen, and there is a strong belief that juveniles who commit serious offenses would be more appropriately dealt with by criminal (or adult) courts (Elrod & Ryder, 2011). Juveniles are capable of committing the same serious offenses that adults do. Therefore, with the requirements of a transfer being met, there are times that juveniles should be placed in the adult criminal court system and tried through here, rather than the juvenile court system. The juvenile court system may not have the same consequences or sentencing guidelines as the adult ...view middle of the document...

Studies have shown how waiving a juvenile to the adult criminal court system may act as a deterrent towards juveniles. Some juveniles who were transferred to the adult criminal court system were not violent offenders; they were repeat offenders for property crimes (Urbina & White, 2009). With this message directed towards juveniles, as well as the likely chance that juveniles whom are transferred to the adult criminal court system will result in some type of incarceration, this may lead to a deterrence of violent or misbehaved actions committed by juveniles in an attempt to avoid these prosecutions. These statements conducted by Urbina and White (2009), are statements to consider on the issue of a juveniles transfer to adult criminal court. Although there are strong facts to support this type of transfer for juveniles, Urbina and White (2009) also found that this might not be the best option in some cases. There have been studies that showed juveniles whom were transferred to the adult criminal court system and sent to adult jails were more likely to re-offend and with more serious crimes than did their juvenile counterparts (Urbina & White, 2009). With this study that was conducted, it adds doubt to the fact that juveniles should be transferred to the adult criminal court system. Although, at times, this may be the best option for serious and violent repeated offenders, it is not likely that this process will have a positive affect on the juvenile or the community. Urbina and White (2009) continue to lack strong argumentative evidence to show the exact times that transferring a juvenile to the adult criminal court system is the best option.
It is important to consider every fact of a case and the details of a juvenile before considering them for transfer to the adult criminal court system. If a juvenile is likely to repeat offending and has continued to show up in the juvenile court system, it may be appropriate to transfer them to the adult criminal court for harsher and more appropriate sentences. It is important to consider the safety and...

Find Another Essay On Transfer to Adult Criminal Court

'Consider what you think are the key aims of a criminal trial and explain, with reasons, the extent to which you think the Crown Court or magistrates’

1689 words - 7 pages Within criminal court proceedings, there are two key aims that need to be upheld. Firstly, the trial should be fair, most importantly with respect to the consistency of judgments that are given for comparable offences; additionally, judges and juries must fully consider each case individually. Secondly, a judgment ought to come from a body that is representative of the local population; those making judgments should be without any prejudices

WAIVER TO ADULT COURTS IMPACT FOR JUVENILE OFFENDERS

1266 words - 6 pages laws allow the juvenile to be prosecuted in criminal court by the order of the judge. Prior to a juvenile’s judges decision to waive the case, a formal hearing is conducted. During this hearing based off of the evidence and the charges a judge can approve the waiver for transfer to adult court. According to Fagan (2008) the right for juveniles to receive a formal hearing prior to the waiver decision was decided following Kent v. United States

Arguments For and against Waiver

1080 words - 4 pages decision on waiving a case. There are other factors that affect the judge’s final decision. Aspects like the criminal history of the offender or the severity of the crime are crucial for the waiver to take place. Statutory Exclusion is when certain offenses are barred. By 1997, 28 states had statutory exclusions (Juvenile "waiver" (transfer to adult court)). Offenses commonly excluded are first degree murder, or any other felony. Similar to

Youths and the Law

589 words - 2 pages ) The Youth Justice Act will be watched closely in hopes of helping youths who may be endangering our society as well as sentencing the ones who already have.Two factors determine how a detained youth will be dealt with in the justice system: the type of offence and the age of the offender. The Youth Criminal Offences Act determines that crimes that deal with the Criminal Code of Canada are federal jurisdiction and violations against provincial laws and statutes (ie, traffic offences) are provincial jurisdiction. There can be no transfer of the youth to adult court, though he may be tried with adult law.

The Juvenile Court System is Distinct from Adult Courts

2010 words - 8 pages adjudicated to criminal court. Once adjudicated to criminal court, juveniles’ rights may increase but transfer to adult courts has multiple disadvantages. Policy Changes Have Expanded How Juveniles Are Transferred to Adult Court Although historically, juvenile courts were established to rehabilitate delinquent youth, once adjudicated to criminal courts, juveniles face harsh consequences. Juveniles, in the United States, can be

Juveniles in the News Report

1682 words - 7 pages . It declares that the court may transfer a juvenile from criminal prosecution to juvenile court if the defendant proves by a preponderance of the evidence that it is in the best interest of the public for the juvenile to be disposed in juvenile court. However, once a case has been transferred to juvenile court, it can’t be transferred back to adult court (OJJPD, 2014). This can be related to Hribal’s case, as his lawyer stated he would file for a

Juveniles Tried In an Adult Court

1651 words - 7 pages judge decides whether to transfer the case or not. The prosecutorial-discretionary is when the prosecutor uses his discretion to decide whether to file a case in a criminal court. Most states will have at least two or three of these transfer laws in their system. One of the advantages of trying a juvenile in an adult court is that the sentencing may sometimes vary. It has been found that most cases end up on probation, rather than serving

Youth and the Law

1080 words - 5 pages prevent crimes by young persons. One way the YOA attempts to ensure society’s protection is through a provision permitting a young offender aged 14 years or older to be transferred to adult court. In the transfer to adult court the young offender is tried under the same rules as an adult, and faces the same penalties upon conviction3. When a young person pleads guilty or is found guilty of a criminal offence, the youth court must determine the

Juvenile and Adult Courts - A Comparative Analysis

1522 words - 6 pages is a reverse waiver "where a criminal court judge can waive a case to juvenile court based on various characteristics of the offender and the offense" (Steinberg, 2000). In some states like New York, juveniles who are age 16 or 17 will automatically be tried in a criminal court because the juvenile court jurisdiction ends at age 15, and this is not considered a transfer. More cases are being transferred to adult courts because the list of cases

Automatic Transfer Law: An Effective Policy?

1388 words - 6 pages of a sixteen year old male juvenile who committed a serious offense and to help the judge there was also a psychological report on the Kent concepts. For this juvenile, his level of dangerousness and sophistication-maturity were low but his amenability to treatment level was high. The judges were given a scale of one to five for how useful the Kent concepts when determining whether to transfer a juvenile to adult court. This procedure was based

How might the changing demographics and diversity of the U.S. population affect the operation of juvenile and criminal courts?

803 words - 3 pages would constitute a crime if it were committed by an adult, the district attorney may petition the juvenile court to transfer the youth to the adult court for criminal prosecution.When a petition for transfer is filed, the juvenile court conducts a hearing to determine whether it is in the best interest of the youth or the public to grant a motion to transfer. If, after hearing all the evidence, the court finds that there are reasonable grounds to

Similar Essays

The United States Lends Credibility To The International Criminal Court

1683 words - 7 pages The International Criminal Court (ICC), created in 1998 (Thayer and Ibryamova 2010), is responsible for investigating and prosecuting the most extreme cases, including crimes against humanity, aggressive crimes, war crimes, and genocide. The credibility of this institution, however, has been compromised due to the United States revocation of support and membership. Initially it is important to recognize the arguments against the United States

The United States Lends Credibility To The International Criminal Court

1607 words - 6 pages The International Criminal Court (ICC), created in 1998 (Thayer and Ibryamova 2010), is responsible for investigating and prosecuting the most extreme cases, including crimes against humanity, aggressive crimes, war crimes, and genocide. The credibility of this institution, however, has been compromised due to the United States revocation of support and membership. Initially it is important to recognize the arguments against the United States

Certiorari To The Court Of Criminal Appeals Of Texas

3619 words - 15 pages Smith v. Texas CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS Mark Anthony Bolden Jr. 2nd Period I Introduction LaRoyce Lathair Smith was convicted of capital murder and after some time being in court he was sentenced to death by a jury in Dallas County, Texas (Kennedy). This case deals with whether or not the death penalty should be nullified due to the jury’s improper instruction, how weak the two special issues are in

Subject: Negotiations Title: The Us Opposition To The Establishment Of International Criminal Court

2345 words - 9 pages IntroductionThe International Criminal Court is the very important institution, which should become the mean of struggling with such crimes as genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, and many countries supported that idea, but the US took position against it. The aim of this paper is the application of several concepts from the course of the negotiation to the situation with the establishment of the International Criminal Court and the