Treating Or Terminating: The Dilemma Of Impaired Infants And The Right To Be Human

1514 words - 6 pages

Aiding the death of infants is a much disputed controversy in healthcare. H. Tristram Engelhardt Jr. provides an ethical view that there is a moral duty not to treat an impaired infant when this will only prolong a painful life or would only lead to a painful death. It is these individuals, like Engelhardt, who must defend this position against groups who consider that we have the ability to prolong the lives of impaired infants, thus we are obligated to do so.
Infanticide is associated with aiding the death of an infant and infant euthanasia. Jim Holt, contributing author for the New York Times, writes that, “Infanticide is the deliberate killing of newborns with the consent of the parents and society. This concept has been common throughout most of history. In some cultures it served as a form of birth control when food supplies were limited. In others, it was a way of getting rid of malformed offspring. Judaism, Christianity and Islam all condemned infanticide as murder holding that only God has the right to take innocent human life. Consequently, the practice has long been outlawed in every Western nation.” (Euthanasia).
The case study from “Mercy Killing in the Newborn Nursery,” Sara T. Fry and Robert M. Veatch provide an example of a situation where the duty not to treat is evident:
…The infant had been born with anencephaly, or lack of cranial development. The infant’s skull was an open sore that the nurses packed and layered with gauze to give his face a round appearance. Because of lack of cerebral hemispheres, the infant was incapable of any conscious activity. After his birth, the infant was admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit and placed in a bassinet. He was reported to be kicking and breathing, and his heart was beating. The hospital issued him a live birth certificate… (182)
This case is not unlike many of the births every year in the United States. Approximately 1 in 68,000 births result in anencephaly annually. About 25% of anencephalic babies die at birth; those who survive have a life expectancy of a few hours or days (Jaquier 2006).
There are methods in the justification of aiding in the death of an impaired infant. Engelhardt outlines that there is a distinction between aiding the death of adult and children. The question of status is also explored to determine that children are neither self-possessed nor responsible. The concept of Injury of Continued Existence is given to look at the potential person the infant might become if allowed to exist. These examples are provided to give a thorough evaluation of a child before the decision is made whether or not to prolong life.
Is there a difference when evaluating the life of a child versus an adult when considering aiding in their death? Engelhardt determines that yes, there is a distinction. He convincingly notes that “the difference lies in the somewhat obvious fact that infants and young children are not able to decide about their own futures and this are...

Find Another Essay On Treating or Terminating: The Dilemma of Impaired Infants and the Right to Be Human

Letter to the general public concerning the lack of morality in our society due to men treating women as means and women not asking to be treated

1555 words - 7 pages , and to improve, just like a man can; there is nothing different about the character or soul of a man that women lack so as to let only men accomplish moral virtue. Yet in our society, men treat women as toys, a mere tool for pleasure, and leave them no option to become anything more. Women in our society therefore are just not considered human beings. According to the principles of morality outlined by Kant, men’s treating us like a means to

The Puritan Dilemma Responds to questions: According to Edmund Morgan, what was the "Puritan dilemma?" How did the Puritans and/or Winthrop address this dilemma?

1306 words - 5 pages standing in the way of his ultimate two-fold purpose. As Edmund Morgan's work shows, by his life's end, Winthrop had created in himself a powerful example of how to address the central "Puritan dilemma:" how a righteous man does right in a world that does wrong (182).According to Puritan belief, every member bore responsibility for the Church of England's behavior, and all would be held accountable to God for its sinfulness (16). For this reason

Is it the government's job or duty to guarantee you the right to be happy?

710 words - 3 pages people with an environment in which it is possible for them to be happy. It is up to the people whether, or not to take advantage of the resources and opportunities available to them. People have a right to be happy within the limits of laws, but cannot expect a government to guarantee them to be happy. In drafting the Declaration of IndependenceThomas Jefferson hoped that in this country people would be free to pursue whatever happiness they

The Benefits of Advances in Communication for the Visual or Hearing Impaired

2771 words - 11 pages The Benefits of Advances in Communication for the Visual or Hearing Impaired Language is a means of communication that people use to interact with others in society. Generally, language comprises vocal sounds to which meanings have been assigned by cultural convention and often supplemented by various gestures. (Sharma, 30) For any 'normal' person, language is no longer viewed as a tool to acquire: language is placed as a standard and

Benefits and Accomodations for the Visually Impaired

2738 words - 11 pages visually impaired a way to be mobile.Long canes were developed for visually impaired travel. The canes used are slender, lightweight aluminum or fiberglass, and white with a red tip. Long canes are longer than orthopedic canes, so the tip is able to touch the ground about a step and a half in front of the user. The cane is moved in an arc motion, to probe the ground and determine what is in front of each foot. The use of the long canes, developed

: Should freedom of movement outside the home-country be accepted as the basic human right?

1767 words - 8 pages asylum versus an exotic cultural experience). The author will survey the main theories and studies behind freedom of movement and as well as raise the ethical issue on if migration restrictions violate basic human rights. 2. Should freedom of movement across borders be considered as human basic right One of the most significant questions for stable developed democratic countries is if they do have the strict moral obligations to admit

The Right to Bear Arms is a Human Right

760 words - 4 pages Michael Bross 28 May 2014 American Government John Burton Dangerous Freedom or Peaceful Slavery? “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the securing of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” Those are the words of the seconds amendment to the Constitution of the United States. These words were written by the man who laid the foundation of our government today. As a constitutional right our

The Right to Live or Die

1939 words - 8 pages asks for PAS and, of those, only 10% actually take the lethal dose prescribed--were legal; 17% of patients chose euthanasia whereas 3% chose PAS" (Zucker 703). Nevertheless, there are no moral or legal obligations for a physician to comply with a patient's request for a doctor's assistance to commit suicide. However, "While there is a focus on the right to life, there is also what is considered to be a 'negative right,' which is the right not to

Google, The Human Resources Dilemma

1927 words - 8 pages strictly structured. Organisational management structure isa basic element in planning and decision-making. An unclear definition of management structure can lead to organisational conflict.Knowledge, skills, and abilities that include job-related information and the necessary human abilities to perform certain job activities should be considered by Google HR team rather than academic proficiency alone. Meaning that the current recruitment

Ethics in Business Ethics and Human Resources Ethics commonly refer to the rules or principles that define right and wrong conduct

1968 words - 8 pages , especially when no one is looking. It is up to HR to train, educate and communicate with employees on rights and wrongs in the workplace. After all, ethics is one topic that begins and ends with people and you cannot separate standards of behavior from HR. Human Resources and ethics are linked and must be integrated. In today's high-pressured environment, HR must spell out for employees that ethics come before deadlines or bottom lines. It's a message

The Difficulties of Treating MRSA

801 words - 3 pages The Difficulties of Treating MRSA MRSA is difficult to treat because of it's resistance. Acquired immune processes include the body's adaptive response to antibiotics. ie when given the body makes specific antibodies to combat MRSA by destroying it's outer membrane. Antibiotics can be given orally or through injections. The main antibiotics used are vancomycin and rifampicin and they are most effective when used in

Similar Essays

Whether Or Not Taiwan Has The Right To Be Autonomous

1535 words - 7 pages , while the Chinese government says that Taiwan is still an inseparable part of China and should maintain unified. Many of us are concerned whether Russia has the right to claim Crimea as one of its lands, and the problem between China and Taiwan is similar. There have been discussions in Asia about whether Taiwan has the right to be independent, which is to gain political independence from China, but settling this complicated dispute is not easy

Whether Or Not Taiwan Has The Right To Be Autonomous

1310 words - 6 pages elites will rise and benefit the future of the country. Many cities in China have developed into very civilized places and there are many highly educated people in China. With all these bright minds, there should definitely be a solution to the problems of China and Taiwan, and thus Taiwan should remain under the ruling China and not separating itself. Taiwan has the right to become autonomous, but should remain the current status with China because

Do Infants Have An Innate Ability To Recognise The Human Face And Imitate Facial Expressions?

1664 words - 7 pages abilities has not been resolved, but by looking at research conducted into imitation with neonates Meltzoff and Moore (1977, 1983) and by considering possible functions of imitation is it possible to draw some conclusions. Similarly, it is not known whether or not infants recognise the human face innately or if it is knowledge acquired over time. Morton and Johnson suggest infants may be born with CONSPEC a mechanism which enables them to learn, and

Cloning: Right Or Wrong? Should Cloning Be Legal? What Are The Pros And Cons Of Cloning? What Can Cloning Lead To? What Should Be Done?

563 words - 2 pages clones will behave like any other human being would behave as it will have all the characteristics of a normal human being, as long as the individual who was cloned had human characteristics, it wont really matter.In conclusion I would like to say that, as you've seen above, cloning could be used in various ways to benefit the lives of humans .It is inevitable that cloning, at some stage, will play an important, if not vital, part in our lives therefore it is about time that society accepts this fact and lifts all constraints upon cloning so that more research can be carried out and help eliminate any risks associated with cloning.