This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Trials Involving Genocide Or Crimes Against Humanity

926 words - 4 pages

‘…it is often argued that trials involving genocide or crimes against humanity are less about judging the person than about establishing the truth of the events.’

‘In nearly all the criminal prosecutions concerned with crimes against humanity committed during or after World War II, some observers have doubted the ability of the criminal law to deal with the events precisely in view of their enormous moral, historical, or political significance.’

Show Trial v. The Need for Justice to be Done in the Public Realm
Hausner's intention was to not only demonstrate Eichmann's guilt but to present material about the entire Holocaust, thus producing a comprehensive record. In addition to ...view middle of the document...

Inherent tension between procedural requirements and didactic intentions
‘…what stood against a trial of the “real” Eichmann was the Israeli government’s intention to use the trial as a stage on which to display a politically usable past.’

‘…in 1961 it would have been possible to conduct a trial reflecting Eichmann’s crimes more accurately.’

“While the prosecution of Eichmann in Jerusalem in 1961, for example, was almost universally held to be necessary, few thought that the necessity lay in the need of punishing Eichmann, the person.”
‘Recording “the truth” and declaring it to the world through the criminal process has been held important for reasons that have little to do with the punishment of the individual. Instead, it has been thought necessary so as to enable the commencement of the healing process in the victim: only when the injustice to which a person has been subjected has been publicly recognised, the conditions for recovering from trauma are present and the dignity of the victim may be restored.’

But, arguably, this healing process had already been allowed to take place. Trials at Nuremberg, subsequent trials by the Allies, etc.

‘…if crimes against humanity really emerge from Kant labelled “radical evil”, an evil that exceeds the bounds of instrumental rationality, that seeks no objective beyond itself, then…’ the deterrent force of international criminal proceedings would be minimal.

‘…fitting crimes against humanity or other massive human rights violations into the deterrence frame requires some rather implausible psychological generalisations. Either the crimes are aspects of political normality – Arendt’s “banality of evil” – in which case there is no mens rea, or they take place in exceptional situations of massive destruction and personal danger when there is little liberty of action.’

‘…legal and historical...

Find Another Essay On trials involving genocide or crimes against humanity

How Japan Committed Crimes Against Humanity in Pursuit of Self-Interest

1480 words - 6 pages crimes against humanity just for the purpose of conquering China. Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941 is another example of its neglecting human rights and committed crimes against humanity. Article 1 of 1907 Hague Convention III clearly prohibited the initiation of hostilities against neutral powers "without previous and explicit warning, in the form either of a reasoned declaration of war or of an ultimatum with conditional declaration of

DNA-Is it fair or unfair to use for or against citizens charged with crimes?

1666 words - 7 pages evidence against the party in question, or release the person from suspicion. Barry Scheck, founder of the Innocence Project, has been a long time advocate of having DNA used as evidence in all criminal court cases.In Spokane, Washington, DNA testing was the key factor in finding a serial killer who had been roaming the streets for nearly 10 years. Robert "Bob" Yates Jr. was convicted of the murder of 8 prostitutes, based upon the semen extracted from

Religion and Genocide in Bosnia

1122 words - 4 pages document, it specified what was considered a crime against humanity, war, and peace. It also stated that “civilian officials” along with “military officers” could both be charged with war crimes. The trials lasted from 1945 to 1949 and were “regarded as a milestone toward the establishment of a permanent international court, and an important precedent for dealing with later instances of genocide and other crimes against humanity.” (History.com) The

Genosides

7167 words - 29 pages of the United Nations and condemned by the civilized world". It declares that genocide has inflicted great losses on humanity at all periods of history, and that international cooperation is required in order "to liberate mankind from such an odious scourge". Article I provides the important clarification that genocide can be committed "in time of peace or in time of war", distinguishing it from crimes against

Genocides

6948 words - 28 pages ". Article I provides the important clarification that genocide can be committed "in time of peace or in time of war", distinguishing it from crimes against humanity, about which there was still, in 1948, much doubt about its application absent an armed conflict. The provision also links the concepts of prevention and punishment. Noting the connection, the International Court of Justice, in the Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and

Is the Genocide Convention a Meaningless Document

3490 words - 14 pages of the GC is in its definition of genocide, which is ambiguous thereby, weakening the convention in action. Moore Rebecca argues that definitions of the term is highly contested hence what qualifies as “genocide” remains controversial. This is however problematic in averting conflict and stopping crimes against humanity as witnessed in Darfur. Clearly, there was a lack of agreement on what did or did not constitute genocide in Darfur with the

The Holocaust

1215 words - 5 pages for their involvement in these crimes against humanity; however the Nuremberg trials were the best solution for justice, as they showed ignorance and duty were no longer viable excuses for crimes, and they set a precedent for future trials by demonstrating a strong intolerance for genocide. Before the trials began, the Allied forces debated on whether it was necessary to try these men, or if it would be best to simply execute them without trial

International Criminal Law: A Fallacy or Reality?

763 words - 4 pages the United Nations in 1946 announced genocide a crime under international law and to be condemned by the civilized world, regardless if those who perpetrate the atrocity are “private individuals, public officials, or statesmen.” And as per the Conventions on Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, held in 1951, 120 countries have ratified an international law prohibiting such acts. Crimes against humanity are considered acts committed

Rwandan Genocide

1125 words - 5 pages , there were over 100,000 genocide suspects awaiting trial. In 2001, the government began enforcing a participatory justice system, known as Gacaca to take care of the enormous amounts of cases. Judges are elected by the community to hear the trials of genocide suspects accused of all crimes except for the planning of genocide or rape, the national systems handles these cases under the normal penal and do not offer provisional release for genocide

Nuremberg Trials

1584 words - 6 pages is capable of and the weakness of the human psyche. Even the most seemingly normal person can be corrupted and manipulated by their thirst for power or their obedience to the status quo. Though the Trials showed the world that the establishment of a permanent international court with common laws was necessary, they are sometimes criticized because they accused people of war crimes and crimes against humanity before this legal commonality between

The Value of Humanity

1777 words - 7 pages people about it. A lot of people don’t know what genocide is, and why it is so bad. Then, these people might go on to commit a genocide, or have a part in one. Humanity is threatened when atrocities or crimes against humanity happen. It is important for people to be educated about genocide, because crimes such as this threaten humanity. The numbers concerning genocide are so large, and this proves that genocide is a real, and very grave problem in

Similar Essays

Crimes Against Humanity Essay

960 words - 4 pages Crimes against humanity are felonies, such as genocide, targeting many people because of their race, religion, or other beliefs. They are spread throughout history from Biblical times to the 90’s. They have also been all over the world. Crimes against humanity begin with racism, hatred, discrimination, and intolerance. These crimes can be explained through their roots, examples, and the survivors. Discrimination, “the practice of unfairly

North Korea's Actions Are Crimes Against Humanity

1396 words - 6 pages Debates have been swirling around the international community over North Korea’s recent actions considered to be “Crimes against humanity” (Pearson, Hanna, and Park). When did North Korea start to have these issues and who is behind the crimes arguably equal to that of Nazi Germany? Was it during the reign of Kim ll-sung or Kim Jong-il? Arguments can be made that the crimes did start under the reign of these two leaders, but the real culprit

The Commissioner Of The Most Brutal Crimes Against Humanity

1583 words - 7 pages thousands of people’s lives by administering some of the most brutal crimes against humanity. Though Mengele devoted the majority of his life to medical research and the military, there was a time when none of that existed in his life. On March 16, 1911 Mengele was born in Günzburg, Germany. He was the oldest son of Karl and Walburga Mengele. He had two younger brothers, Karl Jr. and Alois. Together the family lived in a rural area where they

Rudolf Hoess: Crimes Against Humanity Essay

2250 words - 9 pages ). This quote demonstrated how different Hoess was when he was at home and at work It is difficult to imagine that the history's greatest mass murderer's playing games with his five children or kissing his wife after killing numerous innocent children and women at work, but despite that fact, he was definitely a loving father and a devoted husband. He cared for his children and spent time with them. He helped his wife with ghe education of their