This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Trotsky And Stalin Essay

1372 words - 5 pages

Trotsky and Stalin

I think that without Trotsky's contribution to the revolution it
wouldn't of been a success I think this because Trotsky was put in
charge of organising the revolution by Lenin and this might show that
Lenin believed that Trotsky could do great things and this also means
Lenin must of trust Trotsky as he picked him very carefully. I also
think as this was a vital job Lenin must of thought that Trotsky was
the best man for the job. Trotsky also had organised the Bolsheviks in
Petrograd. He did this because it was the capital city and it was very
important to take control of the strongest part first this showed
Lenin that Trotsky was very clever.

Before the revolution Trotsky trained Bolshevik agents to go into
factories in Petrograd, Trotsky did this because he wanted to spread
hatred against the provisional government and to tell them how to
prepare for a revolution if it ever happened. He did this in factories
because it was easy to spread hatred to people who were fed up and
tired of slaving away and want an equal country. His proposals
inspired many ordinary people across the country and people started
supporting him he made more and more public speeches to his
supporters.

After Trotsky had gained supporters and respect he helped to build up
the red guard units he did this as he knew that the revolution was to
take place he even had a date set and he knew that he would need some
army groups for taking over Petrograd.

Trotsky got more support for the Bolsheviks by telling the Red Guard
that they were fighting for their family's to get equality for
ordinary people. When the red guards new that they were fighting for
this they gave the Bolsheviks a little bit of respect.

If Trotsky hadn't contributed to the Bolsheviks I don't think that the
revolution would of happened. Trotsky played a vital part in the
revolution and his sneaky plans worked and he had everything planned
secretly from everyone.

B

I think the reason that Stalin and not Trotsky emerged as Lenin's
successor because Stalin was a strong Bolshevik believer from the
beginning unlike Trotsky who was a bit of a glory supporter and only
came onto the Bolsheviks side when he knew that there was going to be
a revolution happening in 1917 that he could be a part of. I think
that if Stalin didn't know that a revolution could take place then he
would of stayed a Menshevik supporter. Stalin also thought that if
they started the revolution in one country (Russia) then they could
get power in that country and then the army would have to join the
Bolsheviks making it bigger to take over one country one by one.
Whereas Trotsky believed that they should take over a few countries at
once this was a very silly idea as they would not be able to pull it
off as they were not quite big enough to...

Find Another Essay On Trotsky and Stalin

Why did Stalin rather than Trotsky emerge as the leader of the USSR after Lenin's death?

1732 words - 7 pages 'In 1293 Stalin had been on the point of political ruin... six years later he would be in unchallenged power' (Conquest). To see how such a dramatic change, and such an unpredictable defeat of Trotsky, happen you have to look at key figure's personalities, political skill, and or mistakes. You will also have to look at the situation each figure is in, the situation of the country and the political scene in general which is holding the 'left

Trotsky's Contribution to the Success of the Bolsheviks Up to 1922

734 words - 3 pages deserved to win more than Stalin, Firstly most of the people of Russia thought that he was the second best leader after Lenin, which is a strong point in favour for Trotsky. Also he was known as a very strong leader already in the military, he organised the Bolshevik takeover in 1917 and he also took control of the red army during the Russian civil war. However, Trotsky also had some points against him which proved to make

Stalin

1216 words - 5 pages Stalin coauthored the book Marxism and the National Question (Chronology of Joseph Stalin 1). The next couple of years was silent for Stalin. In 1917, Stalin advocated Bolshevik co-operation with the establishment of the provincial government of the middle class liberials (Life of Joseph Stalin 3). Stalin continued to play key roles for Lenin but not as noticeable as hischief rival Leon Trotsky (Life of Joseph Stalin 3). Stalin's biggest rise to

Why did Trotsky not become the new leader of the Bolshevik party after Lenin's death?

3990 words - 16 pages When Lenin died on the 21st of January 1924 many thought that Trotsky was his natural successor as the leader of the Bolshevik party. However, even prior to Lenin's death, Stalin was building his power base, which ultimately would allow him lead the Bolshevik party. In October 1927, Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev were expelled from the Central Committee of the Bolshevik party of Soviet Russia. Under pressure from the Central Committee, Zinoviev

Why did Stalin win the struggle for power, 1924-1929?

1623 words - 6 pages which had only a small number of members, around 120, and the people in the section of the party did not need to have a normal job. The highest part of the party was called the Politburo and had the head figures of the likes of Lenin, Stalin, Trotsky, Molotov and others, up to about 10 or 12 people. This part of the party was the most important part and had the most power.Stalin was elected General Secretary in 1922 and from that time he had the

To what extent were the mistakes of Stalin's opponents the main reason why he became leader?

983 words - 4 pages Few would doubt Stalin was a strong and effective politician and that that this led to his leadership. How much of this power was due to the mistakes of those who surrounded him rather than Stalin's own ability or luck or the circumstances and structure of power?After Lenin died a collective leadership was introduced: the politburo. At this time Stalin was described as a gray blur opposed to people like Trotsky a charismatic and clever orator

Trotsky's role as a revolutionary between 1917-1940. Discuss Trotsky's role as a revolutionary in the period 1917-1940

2246 words - 9 pages continuation of the NEP. They admitted that Stalin sought nothing less than the dictatorship of the party.The United Opposition criticised the party leadership for abandoning the principles of Leninism.In October 1926 Trotsky expressed his anger at the betrayal of Stalin and his comment as Stalin being a 'grave-digger' of the revolution. For this he was removed from the politburo.Trotsky was seen as a very significant revolutionist to many hence the cult

Stalins Rise To Power

1175 words - 5 pages Stalin politically. When he failed to take advantage of these opportunities, Stalin maneuvered himself into a stronger position within the party by allying with Zinoviev and Kamnev. He manipulated them into crushing Trotsky, thus eliminating the strongest opponent in his path to power. Stalin cleverly avoided potential political diminishment when Lenin formulated his Testament in December 1922. Lenin's Testament2 described what he thought of the

To what extent does history present us with a balanced interpretation of LEON TROTSKY?

727 words - 3 pages was influential in 1905, saying that Trotsky pushed himself to the "forefront of the revolution and gained credibility." Ian Thatcher, however, refuses to take Trotsky's word and argues that firstly, his propaganda wasn't as widespread and influential as Trotsky says.However, Trotsky's involvement in the 1917 is corroborated by many Bolshevik leaders, including Stalin. Trotsky's role in the 1917 October insurrection pushed him into the forefront

Account for Stalin’s rise to power in the period 1922 to 1929

1740 words - 7 pages , Lenin's right-hand man and heir apparent. Among such company Stalin - the bureaucrat from humble origins in the Slavic republic of Georgia - seemed unlikely to fill the political vacuum left by Lenin's death. This essay examines Stalin's rise to power. It argues that a combination of factors, including the disorganised structure of the Communist Party, the deficiencies of his political rivals, particularly those of Trotsky, and Stalin's own

Trotsky

1761 words - 7 pages Russian Jewish Revolutionary leader and Soviet politician, a close friend of Lenin. Trotsky's theory ofpermanent revolution' became unpopular after Stalin had gained power in the Soviet Union. Trotskywas assassinated by one of Stalin's agents. Although Trotsky later condemned the Red Terror, he was, perhaps, one of its first proponents."Things are not going well. The Greek soldiers landed on the shores of Crimea, according to the reports of

Similar Essays

Why Stalin Emerged As The Sole Leader Of The U.S.S.R. And Not Trotsky

754 words - 3 pages Why Stalin Emerged as the Sole Leader of the U.S.S.R. and Not Trotsky Trotsky was a leading Bolshevik and played a pivotal role in the revolution, persuading Lenin to delay the revolution until the Bolshevik’s had a much stronger place in the country. He also was crucial to the civil war, as he organised the troops and motivated them. Stalin on the other hand was in charge of all the dull jobs within the Bolshevik party

Why Did Stalin Take Power And Not Trotsky? The Power Struggle Between The Bolshevik After Lenin's Death

1306 words - 5 pages Why did Stalin take power and not Trotsky?In 1921 Lenin died and a power struggle emerged upon the top members of the Bolshevik party to take over as leader of the Bolshevik party no knowing that in doing so will eventually get themselves exiled out of Russia or Killed by a man largely underestimated and never thought to go to the extremes he did.Lenin had been ill for some time and it was obvious he was not going to live for much longer after

Why Stalin, Not Trotsky, Became Lenin's Successor

613 words - 2 pages the left. This was to gather more support from various other sources.As General Secretary, Stalin issued the letters for Lenin's funeral. To discredit Trotsky, who was seen as Lenin's loyal companion, Stalin told Trotsky the wrong date for the funeral. Many Russians were angered by Trotsky not appearing at their great leader's funeral and Stalin took Trotsky's place at Lenin's side, showing him as the loyal Leninist.Stalin was a manipulator. He

Why Stalin Was Able To Win The Power Struggle With Trotsky

2213 words - 9 pages Why Stalin was Able to Win the Power Struggle with Trotsky The Bolsheviks, the ruling party of the Soviet Union, was lead by the Lenin. When Lenin died in January of 1924, he left behind no clear successor, and vague indications of his intended plans for the Bolshevik party. A power struggle for control of the party ensued, one in which many historical figures arose. Within this plethora of names, two of the most important names in Soviet