This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

True Or False: Corrective Justice Is The Most Important Form Of Justice

1028 words - 5 pages

Essentially, “justice is the quality of being impartial, fair, and just” (Pollsky, 2012, p.53). Furthermore, the act of being just is derived from the latin word “jus” which translates to matters involving laws or rules (Pollsky, 2012, p.53). There are three types of justice and they each differ in matters of circumstance: firstly, distributive justice attempts to provide equality for each individual; corrective justice attempts to reverse an unfair advantage, provide a remedy to the problem, and show equality within the population; lastly, reciprocal justice provides the notion of equality amongst freely exchanged goods amongst individuals.
According to Aristotle, distributive justice incorporates the allocation of resources amongst society(Aristotle, trans W.d Ross, 1994). These resources can include education, profession, honor, status, money, or property (Pollsky, 2012, p. 54). There are a variety of theories that describe various methods of carrying out distributive justice including ideas of need, merit, and entitlement. These ideas work in order to bring the goal of justice which is equality and fairness within society. However, the reason that this is not the most important form of justice is that it is too narrow in scope.
A quick look in history can provide many examples of unfair and unjust treatment with distributive ideals. Even today, in our own country, we can see many perceived flaws with this type of justice. Occupy Wall Street started as a protest movement that sought to provide equality in pay for all citizens not just those fortunate enough to be born or rose to the one-percent. The common adage that is used very frequently is “the rich get richer and the poor get poorer”. This very well could be perceived as unfair as those that are born into wealth seem to have to easier to become wealthier based on their status. This could be thought of as unjust as someone who is not well off has completely different struggles than those that are well off. Thus, if the goal of justice is create a fair, impartial, and just society where everyone has the same chance to succeed, then the distributive form of justice stands as a mecca of dissent with hopes of only altering the status quo so that there is uniform sense of fairness. To create an overwhelming sense of fairness with distributive justice is a treacherous, icy, uphill battle as there are many dissenters who believe CEO’s, lawyers, and doctors are overpaid and that minimum wage should be $15.00 an hour. There is always someone who is going feel that they never got a fair shake.
The word “fair” can be a very ambiguous term. In any situation, one person may feel that the outcome was totally just and fair while the other may complain that they were slighted or a bias existed. A fair situation is fair until it is not anymore. In this day and age, fairness and unfairness, I believe, straddle a very legal oriented line. If you lose your job, you can collect unemployment until you find...

Find Another Essay On True or False: Corrective Justice is the Most Important Form of Justice

The Difference between Juvenile and Criminal Justice Why is Juvenile Justice Important?

1176 words - 5 pages Criminal and Juvenile system can be complex for many people who do not understand how the system can work. Juvenile Justice would be concentered an important aspect to the American system. The system is in place to ensure or deter delinquencies from entering the adult structure. This paper examines the criminal justice system throughout history, juvenile versus criminal system, transition from juvenile to criminal justice, and the effectiveness

Christianity: True Justice Essay

1532 words - 7 pages fighting and arguing around the world but execute true justice through love. Additionally, through this it will explain how the United Nations is one of the best organizations to execute justice around the world, BRIC nations is the second most important area to promote justice and finally the Globalized world is the least best tool to promote justice around the world. What i will start with is how the United Nations is the best organization to execute

Failure of the Australian Legal System to Provide True Justice

2711 words - 11 pages Failure of the Australian Legal System to Provide True Justice The Australian legal system uses the adversary system in solving legal disputes. The adversary system is a judicial process where an independent and impartial judge administers justice in courts and two opposing parties present allegations and counter allegations regarding a legal dispute placed before the court by one or both parties. (B.Bash, 2001, Legal

'The First World War was the most important cause of the Russian Revolution'.- How true is this claim?

1562 words - 6 pages the way for industrial development. Many of the Asiatic peoples in East were semi-nomads, and most of the European Russian population were peasants. After abolition, they were able to hold more than half the arable land in the country, either as individual owners or through their village organization. Despite this, they remained largely illiterate and uneducated, and were regarded by the landed aristocracy as an inferior class. Emancipation also

Film as the Most Important Art Form of the Twentieth Century

1903 words - 8 pages Film as the Most Important Art Form of the Twentieth Century The use of film and its explorations have progressed steadily since the 1800’s and as our title suggests, it has become an important art form and a huge influence on society today. Influencing the way we live, the way we speak, the way we act and more. There isn’t an art form closer to representing ‘reality’; this is why film has such an affect on all of us

Marriage As A Form Of Justice In Measure For Measure

1505 words - 6 pages it may not be conventional according to Shakespeare's standards, it does make sense. However, the marriage of the Duke and Isabella does not appear to satisfy any form of justice and is thus inconsistent with the others. Is this another problem in a problem comedy? Perhaps we should take a closer look at these relationships.Claudio and Julietta, who are clearly the couple whose relationship most closely resembles that of a romance, appear to have

Capital Punishment Essay - True Justice Through Application of the Death Penalty

1104 words - 4 pages True Justice Through Application of the Death Penalty       The death penalty, as administered by states based on their individual laws, is considered capital punishment, the purpose of which is to penalize criminals convicted of murder or other heinous crimes (Fabian).  The death penalty issue has been the focus of much controversy in recent years, even though capital punishment has been a part of our country's history since the beginning

John Marshall: The Most Influential Chief Justice of the Supreme Court

682 words - 3 pages . Through its next legislature, it cancelled the transaction due to public objection. The Supreme Court ruled that the grant was a contract and that it could not be overruled or impaired. This case ruled in favor of all property right holders against popular pressures and clarified the meanings of grants and contracts for future rulings. Marshall’s next case was one of the most important during his term, as it has remained lucid ever since

The criminal justice system has been important in defining, explaining and controlling behaviors understood as deviant. Discuss two sociological responses to concepts of criminal deviance

645 words - 3 pages within an appropriate societal context and values framework (L. DeFleur M. et al., Sociology: Human Society, 1973).Merton's Anomie of Strain theory devised in 1938 hypothesized that deviant behavior is the result of a "disjunction between culturally defined goals to which most members of society aspire, and.....legitimate means for achieving the goals". Thus socially provoked tensions causes deviant behavior (Social Structure and Anomie, 1957

Is It True That Justice Is A Good ? And If So, Does It Mean That We Have Good Reasons To Act Justly?

2228 words - 9 pages And if so, does it mean that we have good reasons to act justly? In formulating your answer, you should consider Thrasymachus's argument in Book I, and the story of Gyges's ring in Book II.BEING JUST OR UNJUSTJustice is one of the most important concept in people's life. It has been argued by many people and philosophers but however it is not exactly clear that what justice is and what the reality of injustice demand of us. Besides, In ''the

Honour and justice are two very important issues in the play "A View From the Bridge" by Arthur Miller, how does the author present these issues through the characters and action in the play?

893 words - 4 pages Wikipedia says honour is “the concept of a direct relation between one's virtues (or "values") and their status within society” and that justice is “the ideal, morally correct state of things and persons”. Honour and justice are in fact the two main issues surrounding Arthur Miller’s “A View from the Bridge”. We can see these two elements right at the start of the play, with the story of Vinny Bolzano: the boy

Similar Essays

Arguments Over The Most Desirable Form Of Justice

2384 words - 10 pages Golden Rule). However, in recent years two opposing, philosophically based groups have rallied their proverbial troops and taken part in verbal wars over the most desirable form of justice. These groups are specifically those that subscribe to the tenants of retributive justice, and restorative justice. This argument is far reaching, and is a basic conversation focused on what is and is not ethical in relation to the treatment of offenses and

The True Heroes Of Justice Essay

1661 words - 7 pages ( eg. Power, Wealth). Racial and gender injustices can be equated with the same framework ,but the consequences of each injustice varies dramatically. Racial and gender injustices are clearly related, but they are also qualitatively and emphatically different. The similarity between them entwine on the fact that both sides had prominent non-violence leaders who intellectually stood for justice. Racial injustice had spurred from the aftermath

Social Justice In The Form Of Art

753 words - 4 pages one of the dancers portraying a bully and the bully just pushes her away, as if the bully doesn’t want to be seen with someone like her. It is amazing how much one look or the way a dancer moves can make such a big impact on the viewers. The most inspirational part of the dance for me was when the dancers who are getting bullied dance as if an invisible wall is crashing down on them and it is taking all of their effort to keep it from falling

Artistotle's Use Of Distributive, Corrective, And Reciprocal Justice,

2251 words - 9 pages their race, sexual orientation, religion, or gender should have equal rights under the law. Fear, ignorance, and religion are not reasons to condemn homosexuals the right to marry. Most religions do not condemn homosexuality, the verses of the bible of any religion is typically misinterpreted and not challenged. It is not wrong to love another person. Everyone should embrace a society that is equal, and just for everyone.Same Sex Marriage Should