Tv And It’s Effects On Society

998 words - 4 pages

In the two essays, Don’t Blame TV by Jeff Greenfield and Who Us? Stop Blaming Kids and TV by Mike Males, both authors defend the theory that television has little impact on today’s youth and that other significant factors are to blame for the negative changes in society. While the topics may appear similar, there are many differences in how the authors attempt to defend their theses, making one more successful than the other. In any well written argumentative essay there must be a clear thesis, good supporting examples, some objections along with any rebuttals, the writing should be focused with a natural flow.
Firstly, the thesis of Greenfield’s essay is somewhat broad and it is not explicitly stated so the reader can understand the topic. He states in his thesis that TV
has been blamed for the decline of scores on scholastic achievement tests, for the rise in crime, for the decline in voter turnout, for the growth of premarital and extramarital sex, for the supposed collapse of family life and the increase in divorce rate (1).
Further along in the essay he gets to his real thesis with a Latin phrase describing false causation: post hoc, ergo propter hoc (1). In other words, it is incorrect to conclude that since these changes in society followed the rise in television usage, television must be the cause. This thesis is what he attempts to support in his essay, but it is naïve to surmise that the increase in TV and the increase in societies problems are merely coincidental. On the other hand, Males makes his thesis very simple and clear in the first line of his essay by quoting James Baldwin: “Children have never been very good at listening to elders, but they have never failed to imitate them” (qtd. in Males 1). By this reference, he claims that adults are to blame for the increase in violence and drug use among today’s youth.
It is nearly impossible to determine the influence that TV has on SAT scores by interpreting it’s complex trends, yet part of Greenfield’s thesis is that the decline in achievement tests has been falsely blamed on the increase of TV usage among youths. He objects to this by stating that test scores have stopped declining since 1982. It is a bold statement to imply that TV is not to blame for the lowering of scores since there are many other elements that influence the rise and fall of the results. Yet when a closer look is taken at television usage among children a trend seems to evolve. For example, The New York Times published an article stating that a recent “study found that those children with televisions in their bedrooms consistently scored significantly lower on math, reading and language arts tests” (Nagourney).
While Greenfield attempts to prove how TV is not a factor in the dumbing of American youths, Mike Males chooses a different method by showing how the most obvious factor of rising violence is overlooked while TV takes the blame. In a recommendation drafted by the International Association of...

Find Another Essay On TV and It’s Effects on Society

Cellphones and effects on society Essay

1604 words - 6 pages you spend using your phone, and how so often you check it? And without realizing that, most people who own a cell have created a dependency to their device, and sometimes spending too much time on it. Cellphones can have really good assets on society, but there are also some negative effects. Since cellular phones have become such a central part of our lives, it is important to be aware of some of the risks and vulnerabilities associated with

The Effects of TV, JFK and Elvis on America

1610 words - 7 pages studies), and very little women were shown as employed. This set many people’s views on each of the genders, thus sending women, who were rising due to their movement, a step back in the eyes of society. With the change in opinion of others came change in opinion of those watching TV. As it developed the rate of exposure to violence before age 18 raised, due to the police dramas, action films and war movies that now played and not just described the

Contributions of Tv on Society

1001 words - 4 pages . Documentary's and travel shows present viewers with experiences from other cultures as well as taking them to places they may never see otherwise like deserts, jungles and the ocean.T.V can benefit people by widening their experiences, but on the other hand, may also contribute to harmful impressions about the world. Taking you back to the nineteenth century, the government was worried about the effects of media on society which were referred as

Globalisation and the effects on australian society

1663 words - 7 pages What effects has globalisation had on Australian society?Globalisation can many different definitions and is constantly changing, and there does not seem to be a widely accepted definition and will take on different cultural, political, social and other connotations as time goes on . It is indeed an economic phenomenon, involving the increasing interaction, or integration of national economic systems through the growth in international trade

Acid Rain and its effects on society

2086 words - 8 pages through the ground, it affects a variety of plants and animals. The strength of the effects depend on many factors, including how acidic the water is, the chemistry and buffering capacity of the soils involved, and the types of fish, trees, and other living things that rely on the water.Dry deposition refers to acidic gases and particles. About half of the acidity in the atmosphere falls back to earth through dry deposition. The wind blows these

America’s Prisons and Their Effects On Society

2066 words - 8 pages Every civilization in history has had rules, and citizens who break them. To this day governments struggle to figure out the best way to deal with their criminals in ways that help both society and those that commit the crimes. Imprisonment has historically been the popular solution. However, there are many instances in which people are sent to prison that would be better served for community service, rehab, or some other form of

Effects of TV Violence on Children

3359 words - 13 pages When did teaching kids to kill become associated with a person's first amendment rights? In the wake of school shootings and concealed weapons being carried by students, many government agencies have begun to study the effects of violence on television as a prominent variable in childhood and adolescent aggressiveness. The prevalence of violence in television is rampant. It is as addictive as a drug to the children and adolescents

Religious Effects on Society

1928 words - 8 pages have someone to turn to they begin to question things and it can cause them to be sad and depressed and it can make life hard on them. Religion has a great influence on the decisions people make in their lives. “Religion has a huge impact on daily life of almost everybody, far bigger than most people realize. Our society is built on religion so even if you are not a believer yourself the fact remains that most of the way that society works is

Children and Violence on TV

1082 words - 4 pages Children and Violence on TV In the past twenty years, violence on TV has become more common and more acceptable in society. This generation is growing up in an increasingly cruel world – where children are exposed to violence, murders and bullying on TV. Guidelines have been put in place – but are they really enough? In this essay I shall be discussing the positive and negative effects of violence on TV and ask if

Violence on tv and children

9978 words - 40 pages crisis of children having children has been eclipsed by the greater tragedy of children killing children" (The National Forum On Television Literacy, video #3).While media professionals would rather believe that television has no effects other than those intended, thousands of studies have pointed to a causal relationship between TV violence and real life crime. In the mid 1980's, FBI reports showed that crimes committed by children, the poor, and

Sex And Violence On Tv

1908 words - 8 pages in front of the television for hours on end. What are the effects of all this television watching? "The key outcomes of excessive TV watching are inactivity/obesity, violence, and poor academic performance" (Wansbrough 35). Over excessive television viewing can lead to bad habits for children. Television does not affect just young children. "Televised violence affects the behavior of children of different ages. This includes imitation of

Similar Essays

The Native American Mascot Issue And It’s Effects On The Growing Sensitivity On Society

1713 words - 7 pages American culture and society are the catalysts for racism? Some sports teams are accused of having derogatory names that are offensive to Native Americans. Examples of these offensive names are the Indians, Chiefs, Braves, Redskins, Illini, Savages, and Redmen. Additionally, the mascots that represent these teams are also seen as offensive by their mockery of Native American Traditions. Some people take this theory of ruining our youth through

Tv Effects On Children Essay

1239 words - 5 pages Saturday mornings than any other time. The cartoons aimed at little children influence youngsters to mimic violent acts because their parents do not fully explain the effects of the stunts. It is pathetic that in such a technology based society, such a simple thing as television can have a negative effect on people.Before Television, Americans followed simple laws, believed heavily in God, were honest, and never locked their doors because they felt

Software Piracy And It’s Effects Essay

1033 words - 4 pages Identification and Description of the IssueCopyright law are perhaps those laws which are breached the most by individual on a daily bases. This is because one might not know be informed about these law or because not much is done to enforce these law. Also some countries of the world have no Copyright laws.Software Piracy is a breach of a copyright law as one copies data contained on the medium on to another medium without the consent of the

Malaria And Ddt, It’s Effects Essay

870 words - 4 pages article even further and found out that once exposed to DDT it can survive in the tissues of animals and humans for up to 20 years. DDT is used outside in the hot and humid temperatures. In an article about the effects of DDT on the environment from the internet contributed by Richard Posner a senior lecturer and co-author of Becker-Posner Blog from the University of Chicago Law School that part of the wildlife is dying and up to 10 000 species