Two Different Versions Of The Moral Saint

1396 words - 6 pages

Susan Wolf presents two different versions of the Moral Saint in order to show that a perfectly moral person does not live a desirable life. A saint is someone who lives a perfectly moral life according to a given ethical system, and “a necessary condition of moral sainthood would be that one’s life be dominated by a commitment to improving the welfare of others or of society as a whole” (Wolf). Is a Moral Saintliness even a humanly possible? Susan Wolf’s description of a Moral Saint is virtually a fictional being. The requirements, characteristics, and skills she attributes to being a Saint are impossible to obtain without also participating in activities Wolf deems nonmoral or inappropriate for a Saint to engage in. These nonmoral activities are essential building blocks to becoming the Moral Saint that Wolf wishes us to imagine. Human beings have psychological needs that Wolf does not consider or seem to understand. Wolf essentially creates a fallacy and then proceeds to argue against it. When you consider the Moral Saint that Wolf has created, and pair him with the moral dilemma of The Ring of Gyges, you will discover that Wolf’s version of a Moral Saints is not attainable, no matter how innate his moral goodness.
The first Saint she calls the Loving Saint and states that his happiness “would truly lie in the happiness of others, and so he would devote himself to others gladly, and with a whole and open heart” (Wolf). In other words, the Loving Saint does what is right because he truly loves being moral for its intrinsic value. Wolf compares the Loving Saint with the Utilitarian who believes in doing what will make the largest amount of people happy. The Loving Saint is happily moral therefore, will bring bringing happiness to others by his commitment to morality.
The second saint is the Rational Saint who “sacrifices his own interest to the interest of others, and feels the sacrifice as such” (Wolf). In other words, the Rational Saint is not always happy about their sacrifice for others but they do so because it is a moral duty. Wolf believes the Rational Saint is more Kantian, “with his emphasis on reason” (Wolf), meaning the Rational Saint is a person of good will who follows the Categorical Imperative.
Plato uses the fictional story of The Ring of Gyges to prove that the just or moral man is happier than the unjust man (Plato). The Ring of Gyges is a magical ring that when placed on the finger and turned allows the wearer to become invisible, anonymous, and free from consequence. How might these two Saints behave if they were presented with the Ring of Gyges?
In order to consider the behavior of these two Saints when they possessed the Ring of Gyges you must consider whether Susan Wolf’s “Saints” could actually exist. Wolf states right from the beginning of her article, “I don’t know whether there are any moral saints” (Wolf). Wolf’s requirements of both the Loving and Rational Saint seem to defy what is rationally...

Find Another Essay On Two Different Versions of the Moral Saint

Moral Lessons for Children Depicted in Three Versions of the Fairy Tale, The Three Little Pigs

1207 words - 5 pages consequences of laziness of the first two little pigs and the result of evil for the sneakiness of the big bad wolf. The tale does however teach children the benefits of hard-work when at the end the third pig lives happily ever after in his sturdy house made of bricks. Comparing three different versions of The Three Little Pigs succeeds in showing the reader issues surrounding that time in regards to social class and gender. The illustrations of

Contrast of two versions of Macbeth's Beliefs.

1112 words - 4 pages beards forbid me to interpret that you are so." Yet Polanski's in his version believed these witches don't have hairy faces, yet they look like men. So thanks to the two versions we are to believe that the witches have certain characteristics of men.Besides not interacting good with people how does the witches interact with one another. As we read on we find out that the witches besides being weird might not get along with normal people yet the

Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet

3017 words - 12 pages audience to question 'how to deal with the social problems in the world? Furthermore, realising how corrupt our community is…' Luhrmann and Zeffirelli's versions of the film were both outstandingly produced, thus causing my perception of the two films to differ, although the two films remain effective in my psyche but in different ways. Luhrmann's ingenious use of modernisation and vibrant location, (even despite the

Comparing the Text and the Two Filmed Versions of Jane Austen's Emma

2399 words - 10 pages Comparing the Text and the Two Filmed Versions of Jane Austen's Emma   After reading Jane Austen's Emma, then viewing the BBC production and Miramax films based on the novel one can understand why most authors are horrified over the translation of their novels into film.  The two film versions are quite different from one another, but both take such liberties with the original text as to wonder why the film makers of each even bothered with

Male Representation in the Two Film Versions of the Play Romeo and Juliet

2303 words - 9 pages Male Representation in the Two Film Versions of the Play Romeo and Juliet The Opening The opening of both versions of this piece sets the president for what follows, the Luhrman version perhaps more so than Franco Zefferelli's attempt. They display glimpses of what is to come, drawing the viewer deeper into the story. The amalgamation of multiple 'Big Close Ups' and bird's eye shot, as well as the

The Many Versions of Cinderella

975 words - 4 pages worse. One version will always be better than another, but no matter what version it might be the story will be told. There are many things one has learned from the experience, although the twelve versions of Cinderella are similar to each other but yet in some way they are different, which make it unique. Similar plot and similar circumstances however, different author with different minds. They are portraying with similar knowledge but the way

Is there is any conflict between different versions of Bible?

2542 words - 10 pages different versions can have. Ecclesiastes 11:4, for example reads,"Whoever watches the wind will not plant;Whoever watches the clouds will not reap." (NIV)In the New Living Translation, however, the interpretation makes more sense (especially for those new to the Bible or too young to understand the metaphor presented in the NIV),"If you wait for the prefect conditions, you will never get anything done."All of a sudden, the light switch is thrown

Reflection on Four Different Versions of William Shakesepare's Macbeth

2072 words - 8 pages in the Polanski version aren't as long, and this makes for a different effect and it focuses more on their expressions rather than speech. This is because images can often take the place of words, and be just as effective, if not more so. The two versions are very different mainly because of the media that they have been designed for and also because of the time at which the films were made. 'Macbeth on the Estate

Comparing Different Versions Of Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare

2475 words - 10 pages Comparing Different Versions Of Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare I am going to compare different versions of Shakespeare's Twelfth Night. There have been many cinematic and theatre adaptations of Twelfth Night through out the years, but I am going to just compare two. A performance of it I went to see at the Globe theatre in London, and the 1999 film version starring Helena Bonham Carter. The theatre version was

Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet

1115 words - 4 pages Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet Shakespeare’s play ‘Romeo and Juliet’ was made into a film by two different directors. Baz Luhrmann’s to Franco Zeffirelli’s interpretation of Romeo and Juliet were very distinct and they both appeal to different age group audiences. Franco Zeffirelli’s version was the first film of Romeo and Juliet. It was produced in 1968 and it was quiet typical, exactly what

Two Film Versions of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

1334 words - 5 pages of portraying Romeo and Juliet, and the two most popular film versions portray two very different styles of this one play. Zeferelli's Romeo and Juliet was made in the 1970s, and is the film version most commonly shown in high school classrooms. The newest film version of this play is Baz Luhrmanns Romeo and Juliet. This version sets the classic story in a modern day setting. Both versions, while different stylistically, hold true to the basic

Similar Essays

Two Versions Of The Song Roxanne

949 words - 4 pages Many say that music has evolved over the years. This essay shall explore the elements of two versions of one song. It shall discuss the correlations and disparities of these songs and confer how it has been revolutionised to entertain the audiences of today. The two songs which shall be scrutinized shall be Roxanne. Originally released in 1978, it was performed by ‘The Police’. The cover version El Tango de Roxanne was rearranged by Mariano

A Comparison Of Two Versions Of The Big Sleep

1626 words - 7 pages A Comparison of Two Versions of The Big Sleep The Production Code attempted to censor sex and violence in film of the 1930's and 40's. Instead of impairing, it encouraged directors to use artistic ideas and integrity to surpass the viewers' expectations -- actively involving them in the film despite Hollywood's censorship. Howard Hawks is one such director who used the restrictions of the Production Code to his advantage. His screen

Comparing The Two Versions Of To Build A Fire

1094 words - 4 pages two versions of "To Build a Fire." Although they differ in their treatment of the motif, they both follow his philosophy well. In both stories, the basic moral is "Never travel alone." Jack London doesn't just tell us that and leave it at that. He has his main character express this idea through his actions, and in the later version, ultimately through his death. London certainly succeeds in giving his stories "breadth and thickness" (531

Two Versions Of Christianity In The Grand Inquisite By Dostoevsky

924 words - 4 pages Two Versions of Christianity in The Grand Inquisite by Dostoevsky In Dostoevsky's book "The Grand Inquisitor" he develops two versions of Chrisitianity. One is the Roman catholic version which is represented by the G.I. or Grand Inquisitor and the other is the Protestant version represented by the Christ-like figure. The whole dialogue begins when the GI has thrown the Christ-like figure or CLF in prison after watching him do a few