Two Ideas: Both Wrong, Both Right

2715 words - 11 pages

Growing up I was a fan of superheroes. On weekends, I would spend endless hours cemented to the television enamored by courageous animations battling their foes in an attempt to save humanity. I was fascinated, not only by their strength and endurance, but also by their overwhelming intelligence. Somehow, they always made the right decision, just in time to rescue the victim and restore the world to its formerly peaceful state. Looking back, it is easy to see why superheroes are not real. While these programs undoubtedly offered me continuous entertainment, they also lulled me into the mindset that in every conflict, there exists only one right and one wrong answer. However, this is a surreal depiction of reality and is not a true representation of the dilemmas we face in our day-to-day lives. Often, there are multiple perspectives on a particular issue or event. A conflict may have more than one solution.
At its most basic level, “The Most Dangerous Beauty”, written by Michael Paterniti, is about the struggle between good and evil. However, this essay tells a story with a much more nuanced conflict rather than the traditional dichotomy between right and wrong. In the essay, David Williams, a professor teaching anatomical illustration, becomes infatuated with Pernkopf’s Atlas, a compendium of anatomical studies produced by Nazis and Nazi supporters. These intricate paintings that portray the human body as examples of the utmost perfection become an obsession for Williams. When allegations are made that the cadavers used to create the Atlas’ illustrations were obtained unethically, both Williams and the document became heavily scrutinized. Through this conflict, Paterniti explores the ethical dilemma of finding beauty in something borne out of evil, while also demonstrating that the values assigned to what is right and what is wrong are dependent upon the assignor.
Additionally, Paterniti credits much of the Atlas’ majesty and brilliance to Pernkopf’s pedantic methodology. Paterniti states that, “All anatomical works before it will seem to be from Kansas, while Pernkopf’s Anatomy will seem to hail from Oz” (Paterniti, 738). The Atlas’ precision and beauty mesmerize Williams. He is entranced by its spell. Williams’ obsession grows as he learns more about the Atlas. He eventually goes to Austria to meet with, and study under the supervision of Franz Batke, the Atlas’ last living artist at the time. Williams spends several months learning many of the artistic techniques exploited on the canvases that encompass Pernkopf’s Atlas. Despite his infatuation with the artistry of the atlas, Williams also has to confront the Atlas’s disturbing past: subjects painted in the atlas were victims of Nazi persecution.
After the allegations about Pernkopf’s Atlas were publicized, Williams came under severe scrutiny. In one particular case, while giving a lecture about the atlas at Cambridge University, he was interrupted by a Jewish woman’s ebullition of...

Find Another Essay On Two Ideas: Both Wrong, Both Right

The two different styles of Quality system -comparing both Western and Japanese ways

3229 words - 13 pages Sigma's systematic problem-solving methodology, identify more business growth opportunities, then you will succeed....6. Conclusion(Evans1993) "Management of both manufacturing and services organization deal with a very critical issue: quality can be the most significant factor in determining the long-run success or failure of any organizations." It can be proved that high quality of goods and services can provide competitive advantages for organizations to increase profits. So quality- first, not profit first concept should be considered by all organizations As all know, Japan and America are the two world lead countries in developing the quality system and tools.

Classical and Operant Conditioning: A Contrast. Clearly explains both forms of conditioning and contrasts the two.

1302 words - 5 pages Though classical conditioning and operant conditioning are both techniques involving learning and the acquisition of behaviors, they have contrasting--but sometimes complementary-- ways of training. However, with pioneers in each conditioning practice believing in the general principle, "Psychology should be based on experimental investigation of behaviors," the two fields often intersect.Classical conditioning was brought to the forefront of

Both sides of the gun control issue -Which Side of the Barrel? The right to bear arms.

976 words - 4 pages statistics to support their argument. From a Mother Jones article, writer Josh Sugarmann makes a compelling argument for gun control in this country, comparing guns to consumer products that need to be regulated. From the National Review, writer John Derbyshire uses recent examples why gun ownership helps to quell criminal activity. These two writers represent both liberal and conservative ideas that can be seen in the two dominate political parties

The work of two management development writers, illustrating both theoretical and practical implications of their work for organisations

3659 words - 15 pages 1. INTRODUCTIONThis report will aim to compare and contrast the work and its implications for organisation of two of the best writers of management ever: Peter F. Drucker and Henry Mintzberg.They based their work on different theories. However, most of Mintzberg's work is focused on Drucker.Peter F. Drucker is a writer, teacher, and consultant specializing in strategy and policy for businesses and social sector organizations. He has consulted

How do both Carhlotte Brontë and Daphne du Maurier explore the dificulties faced by two young women in "Jane Eyre" and "Rebecca"?

1280 words - 5 pages explore these hindrances and how the young women confront and behave towards them.In many ways, the two characters, Jane and Mrs De Winter, are noticeably similar. There is one primary factor that stands out from all others; they are both considerably young. Jane is only a child when orphaned into the house of her Aunt Reed; she experiences cruel discrimination for the first time and is 'humbled by the consciousness of her physical inferiority

Which epic has most relevance to a twenty first century reader, Virgil's 'Aeneid' or Homer's 'Odyssey'? Examines themes in both epics (from the english translations) and compares the two.

1969 words - 8 pages 'plan a'!In 'The Aeneid', the theme of appearance and reality, deception and trust is also present. Virgil heavily emphasises the treachery of the Greeks in his description of the story of the Trojan horse in Book Two by describing how flawlessly they were deceived, and how they were wrong to trust such barbarians. This also provokes some questions about racism, obviously a particularly contemporary issue. The themes of loyalty, sincerity, deception

Compare and contrast the role that women played in both world war one and world war two. To what extent did women expand their role in society between the wars?

1299 words - 5 pages Women's Support Roles in the World Wars Right up to the outbreak of World War I, feminists on both sides pledged themselves to peace, in transnational women's solidarity. Within months of the war's outbreak, however, "all the major feminist groups of the belligerents had given a new pledge - to support their respective governments." Suddenly, campaigners for women's suffrage became avid patriots and organizers of women in support of the war

1993 Although New England and the Chesapeake region were both settled largely by people of English origin, by 1700 the regions had evolved into two distinct societies. Why did this difference in...

1082 words - 4 pages Isabel Olivas Eliason AP U.S. History 6 September 2014 The New World was a marvel and a chance to make it big in the 1600s. England took its gamble at building colonies in the unsettled region of what is now the east coast. It then was separated into two regions, New England and the Chesapeake. Even though they were both founded by the English, their differences in religion, unity, and motives evolved their societies into polar opposites. In New

DBQ 1993 Although New England and the Chesapeake region were both settled largely by people of English origin, by 1700 the regions had evolved into two distinct societies. Why did this difference in...

1082 words - 4 pages Isabel Olivas Eliason AP U.S. History 6 September 2014 The New World was a marvel and a chance to make it big in the 1600s. England took its gamble at building colonies in the unsettled region of what is now the east coast. It then was separated into two regions, New England and the Chesapeake. Even though they were both founded by the English, their differences in religion, unity, and motives evolved their societies into polar opposites. In New

This paper deals with two articles, one viewing the death penalty as wrong and one viewing it as right.

725 words - 3 pages that it takes a psychiatrist five years to figure out "why a guy wants to stop for two drinks after work and won't quit smoking," so why would they want to sit for even more years and listen to "Willie the Wolfman describe his ax murders." Next, the writer talks about how people want to know what right society has "to take a life if an individual can't." He responds by saying "the individuals who make up a society give it that right" because the

Exploring Morality in Measure for Measure

754 words - 3 pages able to have his audience look at the situation in two different ways, and, in the end, make a decision for themselves.   In Measure for Measure, Shakespeare uses the audience's general conceptions of right and wrong to make them consider how they arrived at their ideas. By portraying a person that a majority of people would find immoral on face as a comical character, Shakespeare challenges people's general preconception about

Similar Essays

Title: Two Theories Of Right And Wrong

1284 words - 5 pages Two Theories of Right and WrongJohn Stuart Mill, author of the essay entitled Utilitarianism, gave an in depth theory of right and wrong commonly referred to as utility or the utilitarian view of morality. Utility claims thatactions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure and the absence of pain; by unhappiness pain and privation of

How Both "Vendetta" And "The School Teacher's Guest" Deal With Ideas Of Justice And Revenge.

955 words - 4 pages Both stories explore the strong maternal bonds between a mother and son. They are both based strongly on justice, murder and revenge; which places emphasis on the personal and cultural forces in both of the short stories.The main character in the story “Vendetta” is the Widow Saverini; her emotions are emblazoned across the story “Never fear, never fear, you shall be avenged my son…and pressed her cold lip to the dead lips of

The Transformation From Regional To World Powers In Both Han And Rome Was Inspired By The Customs And Ideas Of Previous Cultures In This Essay, A Comparison Of The Two Areas Can Be Found.

1955 words - 8 pages The transformation from regional to world powers in both Han and Rome was inspired by the customs and ideas of previous cultures - the Han forming its powerful empire on the ancient Qin dynasty's institutional ways along with Confucius' intellectual power and Rome on Mediterranean predecessors. Although these empires had no real contact with each other, they had much in common. The Roman and Han empires had many similarities including rule

Pierre Bourdieu And Plato: Both Proclaim The Truth Is The Right Approach To Life.

2233 words - 9 pages The truth is a basis by which we should base our lives. Both Bourdieu and Plato, two great philosophers, are simply restating a fact that should be already known by all. You can always get caught in a lie; however, you can never be tripped up by the truth. By living lives filled with truth, we can affect many other areas, such as democracy and morality, in a positive manner.From a moral standpoint, living a life of truth is on in which there are