Two Interpretations Of Othello: A Feminist Reading, And A Reading Based On Class And Power

1434 words - 6 pages

Shakespeare's tragedy Othello has been brought to the stage hundreds, thousands of times with many different interpretations and readings due to its vast history of literary debate and analysis. Its thematic concerns are expansive and open to interpretation: they range from tragedy, love, power, jealousy, trust, class and race, and the actions of its characters often provoke controversy and harsh criticism, from Othello's "fatal flaw" of envy, to Desdemona's trivial persistence and Iago's sinister and deadly plotting. Modern audiences, too, have certain expectations and ideas about the play, and it is vital, when producing a play like Othello to take these expectations into consideration. For these reasons, I am proposing two potential readings, or interpretations of the play, a feminist reading and a reading based on the themes of class and power.FEMINIST READINGA feminist reading would give voice to the play's three female characters: Desdemona, Emilia and Bianca (the play's only female survivor), provoking sympathy within the audience for them and portraying them as the true victims of the avoidable tragedy. A feminist reading stems from the fact that in Shakespeare's times, women, whether married or not, fell roughly into two categories: that of a fair, innocent and virgin, or a cuckolding whore. A feminist reading also recognises that it is the men's deplorable attitudes in regard to women and gender that in part caused the tragedy, for instance, Othello's response to Emilia insistence that Desdemona is honest, "She says enough; yet she's a simple bawd/That cannot say as much" (Act 4 Sc 2). The three focus scenes here are Act 1 Scene 3, Act 4 Scene 3 and Act 5 Scene 2. Attention must also be paid to Bianca, who plays an unknowing role in Othello's jealousy. She receives Desdemona's handkerchief from Cassio and gives it back to him when she discovers it is another woman's. Her outburst at Cassio gives the on looking Othello what he thinks is proof of Desdemona's infidelity while displaying her strong character and standing up to a man, behaviour which does not follow the stereotypical expectations of women of the time.Act 1 Scene 1 establishes the context of a patriarchal society, and this is continued in Act 1 Scene 3 with Desdemona summoned to the Senate to defend her new marriage. She clearly outlines the nature of women's status: "You are lord of all my duty, / I am hitherto your daughter. But here's my husband;/ And so much duty as my mother showed/ To you, preferring you before her father, / So much I challenge..." In doing this, Desdemona shows simultaneously her strong will by "challenging" her father, and her reliance on the patriarchal structures inherent in her life. The only way she can gain independence from her father is by submitting to another man, her husband. By doing this, she ultimately pays a price: her life. She, as a woman, is a designated prize or asset to her father (owner), and then husband, as reflected Brabantio's...

Find Another Essay On Two interpretations of Othello: a feminist reading, and a reading based on class and power

A Feminist Reading of John Updike's A&P

1336 words - 5 pages A Feminist Reading of A&P Gone are the days that humans could live impulsively, only taking physical pain and pleasure into account when making decisions. Or so one would like to believe. In a display of sheer innocence and ignorance, Sammy, a grocery clerk at the A & P, managed to revert back to the original behavior patterns of his ape-like ancestors. One cannot possibly predict the future of Sammy, given his own illogical and irrational

A Feminist Reading of The Last of the Mohicans

993 words - 4 pages A Feminist Reading of The Last of the Mohicans   While most often studied as a romance or adventure novel, the most dominant characteristic of The Last of the Mohicans is overlooked: phallicism.  From this phallicism stems Cooper's patriarchal view of society.  In the novel, men are symbolically set apart from women by the possession of weapons (the phallic symbol), and men are separated from one another by the size of their weapons.  The

King Lear: Critical Study of Text (a feminist reading)

1547 words - 6 pages In this production of Shakespeare's King Lear, a feminist reading of the play has been chosen to be presented to the audience. Certain important factors must be taken into consideration as to how this reading will be reflected on stage. Thus, we will examine, in detail, two important scenes: Act I, scene i, and Act IV, scene iv, their impact on the action and main issues of the play (ambition/ greed, power, corruption, appearance versus reality

A Feminist Reading of Buffy the Vampire Slayer

3271 words - 13 pages and to feminist film theory in the Season 3 episode, "Helpless." In "Helpless," Whedon grafts the slasher scenario onto the Buffyverse but makes significant changes, based, I think, both on feminist responses to the genre and also on his own understanding of the show's audience demographics. Though Whedon puts his title character on a continuum with the slasher's female but "boyish" victim-heroes, Buffy becomes a hero with whom her

On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High

965 words - 4 pages On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High In his poem, "On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High", the author, David Chapman Berry, has relied on metaphors and similes to carry out his view of a typical literature class and a teacher's view of teaching. The setting of the poem is in a senior literature class, at South High School. The speaker in this poem is a teacher, who tells the reader about his or her students and about

"The reading aloud system consists of a lexical (dictionary-lookup) and a non-lexical (rule-based) procedure." Evaluate this claim.

2429 words - 10 pages that non-words are read aloud by some form of analogy process. Involving a non-word activating the lexical entries for words that are orthographically similar to it, and so non-word reading is non-lexical and is not based on explicit rules.It is hard to challenge the dual route model as none of the other models were explicitly formulated, whereas the dual-route theorists have been open about the structure of their model. Thus making it

A Naive Opinion on the Nation's Economic Health (Based off of Reading Naked Economics)

584 words - 2 pages generally bad (and that scary word, economy, is on there every once in awhile); (2) I don't know what the main economic issues are; and (3) I better get started on that summer reading if I want to understand this class. My assumption that the US economy is in such bad shape, is solely based on the fact that I hear more complaints than praises of the system. It seems that people assume the economy should be working perfectly at all times--so when it

Death of a Salesman Pre- Reading In-Class Essay: Homes

1019 words - 5 pages consists of a red brick two-story townhouse that is equipped with a dark and chilly basement, part of which my parents have converted to a movie theater. Connected by a set of creaky wooden stairs, the teal paint on which has mostly peeled off, to said basement lies the main floor on which we have our living room, where we have our 21-inch black television, couches, one chocolate brown and one sandy in colour, and wooden shelves filled with both

An essay on shopping malls and the power struggles going on within them: A critical analysis of Fiske's "Shopping for Pleasure", from "Reading The Popular".

1533 words - 6 pages An essay on shopping malls and the power struggles going on within them.In this essay, I have given a critical analysis of Fiske's "Shopping for Pleasure", from"Reading The Popular". In this analysis, I will be examining the main points in this chapter and discussing Fiske's explanation for including each one. I will also be examining counter arguments from other sources on his theories.There are five distinctive sections within this chapter

Feminist Reading of Thomas Gray's Elegy (Eulogy) Written in a Country Churchyard

586 words - 2 pages Feminist Reading of Thomas Gray's Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard   While Thomas Gray's "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard" overtly deals with the distinction between social class and the opportunity for greatness, the poem also contains a subtle yet strong message against the dominant role of men over women in society. Gray's tone throughout the poem is permeated with regret and a sense of something lost, voicing his opinions

Is Erasmus a Faithful Roman Catholic of his days based on the reading of The Praise of Folly?, and include a statement as to what you mean by "Faithful".

1291 words - 5 pages realize that this book would have a great influence on splitting the Christian Church in two, it innately did. By doing this, Erasmus would have been considered not a faithful catholic.But how can one be considered to be a direct defiant to the church if he just believes that some of the minor teaching of the church was wrong. Erasmus never stated anywhere in his writings that Jesus was not God, and that he felt that the Christian faithwas wrong

Similar Essays

A Feminist Reading Of Othello Essay

1151 words - 5 pages Question: Why is Othello relevant today?Othello is relevant today because of its ability to be interpreted from different perspectives and have different readings applied to it. One such reading is the Feminist reading.The opening scenes of Othello establish firm Gender identities, and a patriarchal context for the play. The Gender identities are established in the way Othello's speaks about of his wooing of Desdemona, where he says,"...her

A Feminist Reading Of Galatea 2.2

877 words - 4 pages A Feminist Reading of Galatea 2.2 There is one common thread linking all novels written by males; their female characters are always depicted as the stereotypical female: weak, indecisive and emotionally unstable. The feminist approach to analyzing literature provides an explanation for this phenomenon. In this patriarchal society, women are viewed as the weaker sex, inferior. This can be the result of socialization or some negative

A Feminist Reading Of Sophocles' Antigone

1784 words - 7 pages       While researchers disagree over when the feminist movement began, most agree that it was sometime in the past two centuries. The feminist movement has generally, and often successfully, sought equality between sexes. For example, the womens' movement has won women the right to vote, moved women "out of the kitchen," and, in many ways, made women socioeconomically competitive with men. Nonetheless, all such gains, and the womens' (or

Appropriation Of The Old Grimm Fairy Tale Florinda And Yoringal, In A Feminist Reading

1162 words - 5 pages Woods often had company in her cosy cottage and she taught her skills and knowledge of herbs to a great number of young girls from the surrounding villages.Her best apprentice was a maiden named Jacinta; who had a passion for helping others. She was not only beautiful and kind but also very intelligent and courageous, an independent young woman who was sure of herself and concentrated whole-heartedly on her pursuit of learning the skill of healing