Two Troubling Tales And The Power Of Personal Experience

1215 words - 5 pages

The essay, both art form and bane of English students worldwide, originated in France around 1570. Born from the reflections of one man, ultimately inspired by personal reflection, the essay is now a staple of the literary world. As a work of nonfiction, grounded in truth, yet embellished with literary trappings, the essay serves a myriad of purposes. Whether written to inform, persuade, or tell a story, the essay is a form embraced the world over as the original form of non-fiction writing. Long before biographies and creative non-fiction stories, essays dominated the literary non-fiction landscape. In Judith Cofer’s The Myth of the Latin Woman and James Weldon Johnson’s Outcasts in Salt Lake City, we find tales of minorities dealing with the difficulties of growing up in a country not entirely prepared for their existence. Each essay deals with this paradigm in its own way, telling a story of minority difficulties in a unique light. While both prove effective, Johnson’s Outcasts in Salt Lake City more effectively demonstrates the difficulties of growing up different in a society that refuses to accept diversity. Though both essays highlight these difficulties, Johnson more effectively employs the available literary devices in his outstanding work.
In this comparison, both essays tell a story through narrative, imagining again, in story, actual events as remembered by the author. When comparing two narratives, one should consider certain aspects in evaluation of each tale’s effectiveness. Firstly, how true does each story read? Can the reader effectively imagine the scene provided? Second, how powerful is the essay’s overall effect? Does the essay move the reader emotionally? Finally, how effectively does the writer employ the elements of literature in the essay? One must consider each of these questions in evaluation of the effectiveness of the works. In this case, both Cofer’s The Myth of the Latin Woman, and Johnson’s Outcasts in Salt Lake City prove themselves effective employments of the essay. However, Johnson’s Outcasts more effectively utilizes the available literary elements.
Perhaps most effective in both pieces is the intimate voice each author employs in the telling of their story. Both Johnson and Cofer allow the reader into a world they are likely not accustomed to seeing. In both cases here, the author transports white Americans into their world, revealing a darker side of the American subculture not seen by most. To do so, our two authors here range freely through the literary landscape. As T.W. Adorno notes in his work The Essay as Form, “The essay, however, does not permit its domain to be prescribed. Instead of achieving something scientifically, or creating something artistically, the effort of the essay reflects a childlike freedom that catches fire, without scruple, on what others have already done (Adorno, 152).” Both of the essays explored here realize the idea expressed by Adorno above with surprising...

Find Another Essay On Two Troubling Tales and the Power of Personal Experience

The Troubling Future of Our Nation

884 words - 4 pages There are series of issues that are gradually arising from the depth of our nation. Many of the problems root from the decisions and actions made today. One of these problems is the overpopulation that the U.S seems to be heading towards. With the freedom and laws that protect its people today, and the hopes and dreams of the golden tan glossed by the Californian sun, the U.S has been one of the biggest eye-candy for vacationers and

The Power of Personal Relationships Essay

742 words - 3 pages thing to save each of the characters in these two stories. The Women of Brewster Place are faced with prejudice, abandonment, and violence throughout the novel, and The Road characters have to face impending death everyday through possible starvation, dehydration, or torture from a group of cannibals. The only thing that keeps these characters from just giving up is the relationships and strong personal connections they have built. Each relationship reflects the absolute best in every individual, and in these two very depressing stories; relationships serve as the silver lining.

The Power of Personal Goals

2074 words - 8 pages . (For those that were fortunate enough not to have read these novels, one is a hopeless romantic ordeal about a fellow by the name of Heathcliff while the other is a Dickens' work which spans over one thousand pages.) In math, I endured what would amount to six years of courses during my high school tenure. During my sophomore year, I took a class which combined both algebra two and analytic geometry into a single academic year. Many students were

Theory of Multiple Intelligences and Personal Experience

975 words - 4 pages I fleetingly recall being in fourth grade and my teacher, Mr. Pugh, was instructing us how to tell time. The feeling of trying to overcome this hurdle to recognize the “big hand” is for the minutes and the “little hand” correlates with the hours, was such a great feat for a fourth grader. At the time, that felt like such an accomplishment yet there would be many more and greater to come. According to Howard Gardner’s theory of multiple

Truth in the Tales: A Comparison of Two Historically Accurate and Influential Fiction Novels

978 words - 4 pages influence and historical accuracy can create a new subcategory of “historical fiction”. Two exceptional novels by distinguished authors have managed to start this new concept of “historical fiction”. The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Jazz by Toni Morrison are two literary novels that pioneered the movement of historical realism in fiction as well as influenced literary writing styles and United States culture for generations following

Kafka - "The Metamorphosis" and personal experience comparison

677 words - 3 pages , this is true; however, in most situations, people adapt to new life changes and discover new and other ways to make themselves valuable and loved by their families.My experience of alienation does not compare at all with Kafka's "Metamorphosis" due to the fact that his idea and feeling of being unwanted and alienated by his family was actually true. He actually heard his family conversing about getting rid of this creature that replaced their

Power and Corruption in The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer

2205 words - 9 pages the Parson’s Tale, and the level of power within the Church structure. These are two of the stories of the many that are in The Canterbury Tales. Chaucer uses the Pardoner as a high level leader who is corrupt and yet enables him to convert the sinners even if he does it for personal gain. While the Parson is of lower standing in the Church, he is not corrupt, and gives the message to the pilgrims so that they might be forgiven. The Church in

Two Tales of Secret Sin

911 words - 4 pages the most often reoccurring themes in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s works is the idea of secret sin. The short stories “The Minister’s Black Veil” and “Young Goodman Brown” are no exception to this common motif; despite the differences in the way sin is presented in both of these tales. The symbol of secret sin is represented both spiritually and physically in Hawthorne’s works allowing for his distaste of human hypocrisy to become evident. One of

Personal Experience Of Science

2358 words - 9 pages Personal Experience Of Science Born as I was into the immediate post-war generation, my thinking on science parallels in many ways the generation as a whole. We came along in the aftermath of the first scientific war – fought between countries with, in many ways, highly-developed technologies, which served to both fuel and end the conflict (Brehm, Kassin, & Fein, 1999, cited in Schneider, Grunman & Coutts, 2005). But then came the first

Compare and contrast the process and experience of decolonisation in two countries in Africa

1523 words - 6 pages facilitated the development of new trade networks to offload the surplus of production and to procure rights of access to raw resources. The availability of cheap labour was exploited, strategic land and maritime locations were acquired and the national prestige of the imperial power became elevated. The rhetoric to ‘stamp out the evil’ of slavery and slave-trading and the mantra proclaiming a ‘civilising mission’ on the ‘Dark Continent’ were

The Effects of Death, Personal Experience and the Supernatural Element in Sylvia Plath's Poetry

1568 words - 6 pages These five poems by Sylvia Plath are all connected by the theme of death, self-loathing, and by the presence of historical, even mythological, concepts. Sylvia Plath uses very powerfully charged imagery of controversial and emotional topics in order to best describe her own life. Most of the poems reflect her own personal life, including the events that she has experienced and, more appropriately, the relationships and emotions that she has felt

Similar Essays

Two Diary Entries (Journal) Of A Voyager's Journey Being A Hudson Bay Company's Fur Trader And His Personal Experience And Views

634 words - 3 pages My DiaryJune 15th, 1805I have learnt a French song today. I have found singing is a great way to be entertained and escape reality while traveling the long tedious roads of our journey. With over two months left of our trading trip I already miss my family tremendously. I asked the other members how they cope with missing their families. They simply said: "You'll get used to it. Just make yourself really busy everyday and you won't even have

The Good, The Bad And The Troubling

959 words - 4 pages that “no one” was killed, ignoring that a black person was killed and she quickly moves on from the story of the danger Huck could have been in. Sally goes on to tell a story of much more importance to herself.  She describes a boat that also had a cylinder-head blown out two years ago that injured a white, Christian man.  Sally is sad for the man who was injured but still does not care at all that a black person died on the same boat Huck traveled

Personal Experience And The Heroic Influences Of The Submarine Community

1033 words - 5 pages our nation, yet few people understand or know the tasks they carry out on a daily basis. As a First Class Midshipman on the verge of entering the community, I cannot even being to grasp the extent to which my career will unfold. Yet, if submarines are anything like real life, there is much more to them than simply words on paper. ISR, Power Projection, Sea Control Mine Warfare, Deterrence and Special Operations are certainly core mission areas

The Troubling History Of Dictyota J.V. Lamouroux

888 words - 4 pages Atlantic Ocean, was shown to consist of a complex of predominantly range-restricted species. Tronholm et al. (2012) concluded that genuine D. crenulata is confined to the Central American eastern Pacific shores, while the Atlantic species segregate into the amphi-Atlanic D. jamaicensis W. R. Taylor, D. canariensis (Grunow) Tronholm and D. pleiacantha Tronholm, the latter two species apparently being confined to Macaronesia. Dictyota canariensis has so