Two Different Views Of American History

2370 words - 9 pages

Fredrick Jackson Turner and Reginald Horsman present us with two very different views of American History. Turner views the American period of expansionism across the North American continent as if this were a natural phenomenon. In contrast, Horsman begs us to consider such a perception—very seriously. Where Turner sees something like a sprit of freedom and independence driving the course of American history into the western frontier—and (coincidentally) over the peoples already living there—Horsman reveals how such a view of the American people’s ‘nature’ is constructed, ultimately to justify such expansion.
Where Turner limits their view of American history to simply what the colonists did to take over the continent, viewing their history in isolation, Horsman tries to go beyond this, showing some of the history—and racially-based ideology—which in turn influences Turner’s view of history. Let us consider these differences further, beginning with how Turner presents the expansion of the American peoples across the North American continent.
We should take careful notice of how Turner describes the role of native tribes in American history. The reason for this is that it proves to be very insightful into the kind of historical narrative that Turner presents to describe the ‘real reasons’ for why American’s expanded into the Western frontiers.
In a sense, Turner presents a kind of social-historical blindness, if not white-European- privileging bias in their analysis. One gets the impression from Turner’s analysis that the native tribes (which we refer to today as Native Americans) indeed existed. Indeed, they played an important role in American history. And yet, in reading Turner’s view, one discovers that at the same, the natives are curiously absent. At best, they are treated as subordinate actors in the history of the United States.
In the best light, Turner treats the native tribes as those who, through trade, through teaching the settler how to survive. The natives “pioneered the way for civilization (Turner, 7).” In other words, without their traded goods, without their teaching the colonists the lay of the land, how to farm and hunt upon it, or where to travel, American expansionism over the North American continent might not have been possible.
But in a nutshell, this is really the most positive light in which Turner presents the native tribes. Turner provides a small, simple, brief recognition in the supportive role of native tribes the expansion of America into the western frontiers. Turner recognizes the native tribes as pioneering the way for civilization—which presumes the natives didn’t have such a thing, anyway. But beyond this, everything Turner has to say about the native tribes casts them in a subordinate or adversarial role to the expansion of the United States.
Beyond this, “the Indian was a common danger, demanding united action (Turner, 7),” and the “management of these tribes became an object...

Find Another Essay On Two Different Views of American History

Two Views of Affirmative Action Essay

1490 words - 6 pages Two Views of Affirmative Action "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal…." Even before it became a nation, America was heralded as a land of equality. Thomas Jefferson's statement begs more than a few questions, one of which is: "How can we ensure equality to everyone?" Beginning in the late 1960s, the federal government provided an answer to this question in the form of affirmative action. In recent years

Two Views of Capital Punishment Essay

1355 words - 5 pages punishment. “ What comparison can there really be, in point of severity, between consigning a man to the short pang of a rapid death, and immuring him in a living tomb, there to linger out what may be a long life in the hardest and most monotonous toil, without any of its alleviations or rewards” (Mill 66). He is contradicting himself when making these two points. According to Kant, a person is the subject whose actions can be imputed to him. “Only a

Societal Views on Interracialism Throughout American History

6704 words - 27 pages the potential to incite savage racial discrimination, loathing, and violence. Indeed, even in today’s significantly more enlightened and politically correct views on race, interracial relationships and individuals still possess the potential to make many uncomfortable. Two historical periods in which racial topics, including interracialism, were the source of much social unrest are the eras of the pre-Civil War and the Harlem

This essay is about racial profiling. I am comparing two different essays written by two authors and there views on racial profiling.

540 words - 2 pages profiling. When you step on an airplane there are other people on that plane with you. It is the airlines job to protect the people from a terrorist attack. If that means you have to check the people that look suspicious or only people of Muslim descent then so be it. Kahn argues that it is not fair for people that look a certain way to be checked. He says just because someone skin is a certain color it doesn't give them the right to just check

Different Views of War in Poets

1842 words - 7 pages Different Views of War in Poets I will explain the different view of war I have, from the poems written by 4 different poets. The poems I will be writing about are "INTO BATTLE, WHO'S FOR THE GAME, PEACE AND SPRING OFFENSIVE AND FUTILITY". All these poems are based on the 1st World War. "Into Battle by Julian Grenfell. This poem was written at the start of the war, hence the title Into Battle. It

Booker T Washington vs. W.E.B Dubois, Two Different Styles of African American Leadership

1731 words - 7 pages In the early history of the civil rights movement two prominent African American leaders, Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois arose to accomplish one goal, education for all African Americans. During the turn of the century, between the years 1895 and 1915 there were many theories on how African Americans were going to achieve first-class citizenship. With two separate views on how to accomplish this goal, the African American community was

Two different countries in two different continents. One of them

1340 words - 5 pages Two different countries in two different continents. One of them is considered as Third World Country, the third world countries are generally undeveloped countries. Congo, is one of these countries which can not develop itself for years. The other one of these two countries, Turkey. It is located at the centre of three old continents which are Europe, Asia, and Africa. As it is seen it has geopolitical importance because of its location

Popper and Kuhn: Two Views of Science

1430 words - 6 pages Popper and Kuhn: Two Views of Science In this essay I attempt to answer the following two questions: What is Karl Popper’s view of science? Do I feel that Thomas Kuhn makes important points against it? The two articles that I make reference to are "Science: Conjectures and Refutations" by Karl Popper and "Logic of Discovery or Psychology of Research?" by Thomas Kuhn. In the article, "Science: Conjectures and Refutations", Karl Popper

Alternative Views of Origin Of Life (Different cultures)

528 words - 2 pages •Discuss the ways in which developments in scientific knowledge may conflict with the ideas about the origins of life developed by different cultures:Different cultures and religious in the world have their own ideas about life, it maybe quite different to the scientific evidenceIn biblical creationism different organisms were made for specialised environments at the same time, the organisms that were created have not changed nor are they

Analysis Of Advertisements For Two Different Things

1124 words - 4 pages Analysis of Advertisements for Two Different Things      In order for advertisements to succesfully portray a product, they must be directed to the appropriate intended audience. Magazines, in general, are usually geared towards a specific audience with distinct interests. Therefore, the `ads' need to be carefully designed to attract the attentions of the magazine reader. This very concept is well displayed in the two

A Comparison of Two Different Newspapers

1802 words - 7 pages A Comparison of Two Different Newspapers In the following essay, I intend to compare the differences and similarities in which two different newspapers - a tabloid (The Mirror) and a broadsheet (The Times) report the same story. I will be looking at the presentation and the use of language as well as the basics of how the story is put forward and told. Both papers are reporting the same story in which Prince Philip

Similar Essays

Different Views Of History Essay

854 words - 3 pages on the bomb came slowly" (332) We can see clearly that both these models will yield diverse results. Which model a historian leans toward and how they relate these events will influence our individual interpretations of history. Davidson and Lytle have demonstrated throughout the book is that by using various tools of investigation, we will continue to find different ways of looking at events that have taken place in history. The authors have clearly communicated their opinion that history is what you make of it.

Different Views Of The American Dream

1017 words - 5 pages , or social status.  The American Dream, although not easily acquired, is achievable through hard work and dedication. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s speech, “I Have a Dream”, and John Steinbeck's novella, Of Mice and Men, exemplify their personal views on this ambiguous subject. My concept and Martin Luther King, Jr.'s concept of the American dream entail equality, but do not share the same concept in terms of property distribution. In Martin

Two Views Of Slavery Essay

1342 words - 6 pages Two Views of Slavery During the time prior to the twentieth century our world accepted slavery as a normal part of life. Aphra Behn and Phillis Wheatley, both female authors born about 100 years apart, had their own views of slavery and wrote poems and stories about the subject. These women were physically different, Aphra was a Caucasian, and Phillis was an African American, and their lives were rather different as well. Aphra was a spy and

Views Of American Culture Essay

2188 words - 9 pages -one. Is it so bad that people lose control of things occasionally under stress? In viewing similarities and differences in Lindsay Lohan and Elizabeth Taylor it is obvious to say that American culture as a whole is very judgemental towards people in the limelight. Egoism and relativism are both factors in pop culture. Simply defined egoism is An ethical theory that treats self-interest as the foundation of mortality. “The focus of ethical egoism