Two Versions Of Christianity In The Grand Inquisite By Dostoevsky

924 words - 4 pages

Two Versions of Christianity in The Grand Inquisite by Dostoevsky

In Dostoevsky's book "The Grand Inquisitor" he develops two versions of
Chrisitianity. One is the Roman catholic version which is represented by the G.I. or Grand
Inquisitor and the other is the Protestant version represented by the Christ-like figure. The
whole dialogue begins when the GI has thrown the Christ-like figure or CLF in prison
after watching him do a few miracles (pg. 24). He then begins to barraage him with
questions that he answers himself. And From this comes the argument of freedom. The GI
then claims that because the CLF refused the 3 temptations (mainly the turning of the stone
into bread) (pg27) he placed the burden of freedom on man. According to the GI if the
CLF had only turned the stone into bread he would have "satisfied the universal and
everlasting craving of humanity--to fing someone to worship"(pg.27). Instead the CLF
rejected it for the sake of freedom. The GI goes on to say that instead of taking mans
freedom from them ("by giving them bread") when you had the chance you instead choose
to make it stronger than ever (pg28). The Gi sees freedom as being the main problem in
man, its almost like a disease. He says that man wants happiness in life not freedom. By
creating this "free" society the CLF has placed the burden of responsibility on man. Now
if you think about it what he says here makes a lot of sense. Because we have the power to
choose, the freedom to choose. We also have to take the responsibility of our choices. We
are forced to deal with the consequences of our actions. Now you might say that's fine just
make good choices and you'll be fine. Well according to the GI men are weak and are
incapable of accepting such a responsibility as the on the CLF has placed on them.
The GI then goes on to tell the CLF that he is no longer needed that he (GI) has
finisehd his (CLF) work. He said that the men have given up their freedom to the church.
And thus the responsibility is not laid on man himself but on the community or church as a
whole. He says that you (CLF) would not give them 'heavenly' bread but I (GI) have
given them 'earthly' bread, which is what they truly want. The Gi believes that man's goal
in life is to pursue happiness and well being. And that if they would give there freedom up
to the church, then they can go on and pursue that.
The main topic here is the struggle for freedom. Christ gave man free-will. To
choose between right and wrong. So man has the right to choose. The GI says that man
can never be free because he is weak corrupt worthless and restless. The GI says that by
giving them freedom ..... you showed that you...

Find Another Essay On Two Versions of Christianity in The Grand Inquisite by Dostoevsky

A Comparison of Two Versions of The Big Sleep

1626 words - 7 pages A Comparison of Two Versions of The Big Sleep The Production Code attempted to censor sex and violence in film of the 1930's and 40's. Instead of impairing, it encouraged directors to use artistic ideas and integrity to surpass the viewers' expectations -- actively involving them in the film despite Hollywood's censorship. Howard Hawks is one such director who used the restrictions of the Production Code to his advantage. His screen

Comparing the Two Versions of To Build a Fire

1094 words - 4 pages Comparing the Two Versions of To Build a Fire   "I am absolutely confident that beyond the motif itself, there is no similarity of treatment whatever" (544). Jack London, writing in December 1908, was responding to an inquiry from the Richard W. Gilder, editor of Century Magazine. Gilder, having just published "To Build a Fire" in his magazine, was worried when he came across another version published 6 years earlier. London's

Consider how the monster is portrayed In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and the Two film versions of Frankenstein

4474 words - 18 pages the error of his ways. At the beginning of the story, Frankenstein begins to advise Walton and he tells him to realise that what he is doing is destroying his crew. By the end, Walton has decided that he cannot go on and he turns back and heads for home, which is exactly what Frankenstein should have done, a long time ago.For this assignment I have been studying Mary Shelley's novel and the two film versions of Frankenstein.This first film in

Contrast of two versions of Macbeth's Beliefs.

1112 words - 4 pages beards forbid me to interpret that you are so." Yet Polanski's in his version believed these witches don't have hairy faces, yet they look like men. So thanks to the two versions we are to believe that the witches have certain characteristics of men.Besides not interacting good with people how does the witches interact with one another. As we read on we find out that the witches besides being weird might not get along with normal people yet the

A Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet by Zefferelli and Luhrmann

3385 words - 14 pages A Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet by Zefferelli and Luhrmann One is by the more authentic director Franco Zefferelli and one is by the more modern money-seeking director Baz Lurmann. The major differences between the two movies Romeo and Juliet who were made by Franco Zefferelli in 1968 and

Comparing Two Film Versions of A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare

1390 words - 6 pages Comparing Two Film Versions of A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare Introduction The two films we have been asked to compare are both different versions of 'A Midsummer Night's Dream'. The first was a big screen movie, by Michael Hoffman and made in 1998. This film was set in the 19th Century in the fictional city of Monte Athena and starred major actors and actresses such as Sophie Marceau

Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet

3017 words - 12 pages . Luhrmann and Zeffirelli are considered to be 'both alike in dignity'; they are both well-known directors of their era. Although well established, their styles fluctuate dramatically. Their many similarities consist of not being afraid to be unconventional. Zeffirelli astonished his mainstream audience by casting two unidentified actors to play the roles Romeo and Juliet: Olivia Hussey and Leonard Whiting. In a similar vein

Comparing the Text and the Two Filmed Versions of Jane Austen's Emma

2399 words - 10 pages best of the fish and the chicken, but leave him to chuse [sic] his own wife.  Depend upon it, a man of six or seven-and-twenty can take care of himself" (Austen  11).  We can see the extreme significance in the changes made by the BBC film as opposed to this ending.  However, in both film versions the ending is changed significantly.   The Miramax version also changes the ending.  Instead of Knightley saying this final comment to end the first

Security in The Grand Inquisitor

1415 words - 6 pages damnation later. “Make us your slave, but feed us” (Dostoevsky, 26). This statement by the Grand Inquisitor portrays how man would rather have security than freedom. You cannot obtain both because the two are inconceivable together. Humanity wants to escape the “terrible gift” of freedom. Only the church can take away this freedom and provide happiness and security. The Grand Inquisitor is convinced that man is weak, vicious, worthless, and

The Many Versions of Cinderella

975 words - 4 pages worries of the middle-class while Grimm’s version focus on harsh realities of life associated with the peasant culture. Also, Grimm’s version the help that Cinderella gets do not come from the fairy god-mother but the wishing tree that grows on her mother grave; stepsisters try to trick the prince by cutting off parts of their feet in order to get the slippers and not like other versions by just simply trying the shoe on. Another is the prince is

Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet

1115 words - 4 pages Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet Shakespeare’s play ‘Romeo and Juliet’ was made into a film by two different directors. Baz Luhrmann’s to Franco Zeffirelli’s interpretation of Romeo and Juliet were very distinct and they both appeal to different age group audiences. Franco Zeffirelli’s version was the first film of Romeo and Juliet. It was produced in 1968 and it was quiet typical, exactly what

Similar Essays

A Discussion Of The Grand Inquisitor From 'the Brothers Karamazov' By Fyodor Dostoevsky

686 words - 3 pages The Grand Inquisitor is an adaptation from The Brothers Karamazov, a novel written by Fyodor Dostoevsky. It is a Russian novel, set in 19th century Russia. The Inquisitor, the part of the story that we are dealing with, is a discussion between two of four brothers, Ivan and Alyosha.Alyosha is the youngest brother, of about twenty years of age. He is preparing to become a monk in the Eastern Orthodox Church. Ivan is older, about thirty years of

Two Versions Of The Song Roxanne

949 words - 4 pages Many say that music has evolved over the years. This essay shall explore the elements of two versions of one song. It shall discuss the correlations and disparities of these songs and confer how it has been revolutionised to entertain the audiences of today. The two songs which shall be scrutinized shall be Roxanne. Originally released in 1978, it was performed by ‘The Police’. The cover version El Tango de Roxanne was rearranged by Mariano

Two Different Versions Of The Moral Saint

1396 words - 6 pages Susan Wolf presents two different versions of the Moral Saint in order to show that a perfectly moral person does not live a desirable life. A saint is someone who lives a perfectly moral life according to a given ethical system, and “a necessary condition of moral sainthood would be that one’s life be dominated by a commitment to improving the welfare of others or of society as a whole” (Wolf). Is a Moral Saintliness even a humanly possible

Male Representation In The Two Film Versions Of The Play Romeo And Juliet

2303 words - 9 pages Male Representation in the Two Film Versions of the Play Romeo and Juliet The Opening The opening of both versions of this piece sets the president for what follows, the Luhrman version perhaps more so than Franco Zefferelli's attempt. They display glimpses of what is to come, drawing the viewer deeper into the story. The amalgamation of multiple 'Big Close Ups' and bird's eye shot, as well as the