Two Way Billingual Immersion Programs Create Higher Achieving Students

1051 words - 5 pages


Two-way bilingual immersion programs not only create higher achieving students, but also more equipped and confident students. Academically, TWBI students receive higher grades because of the curriculum. Furthermore, 87% to 93% of past TWBI students stated they would not drop out (Lindholm-Leary). Indeed, the knowledge gained allows students to become more resilient, adapting to the new language; independent, figuring out the language themselves; and confident, taking pride in bilingualism. The TWBI program not only teaches another language, but also another culture. One of the programs goals gears students toward culture awareness by exposing other countries’ custom through songs, ...view middle of the document...

Schools should not undermine one language; the encouragement of both will allow students to fully immerse themselves in both languages.The environment and parent demand of school districts determine what other language will take part in the program, choosing from Spanish, Mandarin, Cantonese, Italian, French, Russian, Japanese, Chinese, German, Arabic, Norwegian, etc. The programs should also start from Kindergarten to Eighth grade, so students can not only have sufficient time to become bilingual, but also have the opportunity to either continue that language in advance placement classes in high school or learn another language in their four years of high school. The program will function with at least thirty-percent of one language group with the other language group in the same class room, despite the program’s preference for half and half (Alanís & Rodríguez). There are two different types of two-way immersion to choose: 90:10 and 50:50. 90:10 programs commence with 90% instruction of the foreign language, gradually leveling to 50:50 by fourth grade. In the 50:50 model, both languages receive equal amount of time across all eight years. While both types of programs allow students to perform higher on test than any other program, 90:10 students tend to score higher and be more fully bilingual than students in 50:50 (Lindholm-Leary). Iliana Alanís and Mariela A. Rodríguez also remarks, “the 90/10 model requires an initial emphasis on the minority language because this language is less supported by the broader society.” This signifies that the minority language receives less interaction outside of school, thus justifying the emphasis on the minority language. Opponents of TWBI education claim that affluent neighborhoods and self-selection compromises the studies on two-way immersion. However a study a Cincinnati French Immersion Public school found that underprivileged students benefited from learning two languages, sometimes even surpassing more advantaged children (White). The environment around a TWBI education influences the success of the program (Lindholm-Leary). Six main factors created by Lindholm-Leary play a role which the four schools in the documentary Speaking in Tongues displayed. 1) School environment should encompass a supportive and welcoming atmosphere. This type of...

Find Another Essay On Two-Way Billingual Immersion Programs Create Higher-Achieving Students

How the Federal Bilingual Education Act of 1968 Ended the War on Poverty

1929 words - 8 pages student from learning with his peers (Parkay, 2013). Integrating language minority and language majority students aided to develop dual language proficiency and academic achievement. This study resulted in the “effectiveness in educating nonnative English speaking students,” (Christian, 1994). The two-way programs goals were “proficiency, academic achievement, and positive cross-cultural attitudes and behaviors,” (Christian, 1994). Which allowed

Bilingual Education Essay

876 words - 4 pages spent a year funding bilingual programs. 127.5 million in Boston alone is spent on bilingual education.Statewide academic test scores of California's 1.4 million limited-English immigrant students showed huge gains in the two years since the passage of Proposition 227, the June 1998 ballot initiative that largely replaced bilingual education with English immersion programs. Those school districts that most strictly complied with the terms of

Bilingual Education

1189 words - 5 pages instruction in the majority language. In other words, the native language is maintained and developed, and the second language is acquired and developed. All of the students in these classrooms are second language learners. Dual Language/Dual Immersion/Two-Way Bilingual Education In dual language or dual immersion or two-way bilingual education, language minority and majority students are taught at the same time in the same classroom

The California State Public Education System

2482 words - 10 pages (LMS). The debate over the best way to educate LMS has become increasingly contentious, as their numbers have grown rapidly over the past decade. Sponsors of P-227 rallied support for eliminating bilingual programs among voters concerned about its effectiveness, citing low annual rates of reclassification of students as fluent English speakers, low academic achievement, and high drop-out rates among Hispanic students. More fundamentally, critics of

Decolonization For All: Mi'kmaw and Mainstream Education in Nova Scotia

1059 words - 5 pages The Mi’kmaq Education Agreement allowed for the creation of the corporation, Mi’kmaw Kina’matnewey (MK), which acts as the administrating body of resources transferred from AANDC as well as over see’s education programs services administered to the participating Mi’kmaq communities. However, it is with the individual bands to create jurisdictional education laws, not MK. As opposed to provincial school which are accountable to the school

Resurgence of the Hawaiian Language

1078 words - 5 pages higher levels of achievement as their English-only counterparts. There is also evidence in the visible ability of these same students, their parents, teachers, and other prominent speakers of ʻōlelo Hawaiʻi, to speak, write, read, work, learn and live in the society opponents say they are not capable of living in. Opponents might say that there aren’t enough materials or immersion resources available to make the transition. This may be true

Bilingual Education: Building Bridges

2151 words - 9 pages language speakers to learn the English language. I am in favor of the two-way immersion method as a bilingual education application in the classroom. According to Hadi-Tabassum, “Two-way immersion (TWI) bilingual education is an integrated language immersion program in which students who speak a majority language, such as English, study and learn together in the same classroom with students who speak a minority language….Both the language majority and

Bilingual Education

2022 words - 8 pages -way immersion (TWI) bilingual education is an integrated language immersion program in which students who speak a majority language, such as English, study and learn together in the same classroom with students who speak a minority language….Both the language majority and language minority students learn the two languages simultaneously and acquire academic content knowledge through both L1 (English) and L2 (Spanish, Korean, etc.). Dual immersion

Linguistic Diversity

634 words - 3 pages are grouped according to their first language. Teachers in the immersion classrooms will be fluent in both languages. With this program, instruction in language arts is taught in their first language, with all other areas of curriculum being taught in the second language (Otto, 2010)." Variations of the immersion program are; two way immersion programs in which students would be learning in more than one language within the class, for instance

How to Give American Students a Billingual Education

1426 words - 6 pages . Bilingual education in today’s United States remains inadequate as most students might have the chance to learn a second language for only one or two years in high school, depending on if the school provides such programs. However, many states have taken interest to improve bilingual education and overcome the financial issues. Two-way bilingual immersion(TWBI), a program teaching students a native language and a foreign, provides the best option

U.S. Bilingual Education Viewed From Abroad

4510 words - 18 pages immersion model, but from the United States, models such as mainstreaming (submersion), transitional bilingual�education, and dual-language�education�(two-way immersion) have been publicized internationally. However, the United States has since the late 1990s received worldwide attention for its politicization of bilingual�education�and for moving to an increasingly subtractive, assimi-lationist form of�education�for immigrant children. In short, more

Similar Essays

An Overview Of Bilingual Education Essay

5396 words - 22 pages speakers who are learning a second language (majority students,) students who speak a foreign language and are learning English (minority students,) and a two-way bilingual immersion program which has both majority and minority students in one classroom (Genesee, 1998). In the first two programs, the children are taught in one language, but are aiming for full bilingualism in both languages (Walker, 2000). The two-way immersion program will be

Dual Language Programs Essay

965 words - 4 pages , 2010). The school district has over 210,000 students consisting of 54% of Hispanics, 33% of African Americans, and 10% of Euro-Americans. There are over 20 students per grade level that are English language learners. These students are accommodated by attending one way (labeled developmental bilingual - 50:50) and two way (labeled bilingual immersion - 90:10) bilingual programs to learn English as their second language (Kohner, 2010). The state

Leveraging Technology To Support Students With Written Expression Difficulties In French Immersion

2109 words - 9 pages and planning is another low-tech option. A mid range tech-tool to consider in the French immersion setting is a voice recorder as it allows students to record their ideas and then listen to them as many times as needed during the writing process. Some higher tech programs such as MindView (MatchWare, n.d.) and Inspiration (Inspiration Software Inc., n.d.) also support the planning and organizing stage of writing. MindView (MatchWare, n.d.) is

The Debate Over Bilingual Education And Immersion Programs

3838 words - 15 pages immerse LEP students in the English language, seem to have the right idea. Students need to start their study of English in the primary grades, not later on, the way many bilingual education programs are set up to do. Disadvantages of the ESOL Program There are, of course, concerns about English language immersion programs (such as ESOL) as well. For example, these classes do not build on the students’ native language(s) in academic